Clinical S udy
A P ospec i e, Double-Blind, Randomized, Con olled
Clinical T ial in he Gingi i is P e en ion wi h an Oligome ic
P oan hocyanidin Nu i ional Supplemen
R. M. Díaz Sánchez, G. Cas illo-Dalí, A. Fe nández-Ola a ía, R. Mosque a-Pé ez,
J. M. Delgado-Muñoz, J. L. Gu ié ez-Pé ez, and D. To es-Laga es
O al Su ge y Depa men , Den al School, Uni e si y o Se ille, Se ille, Spain
Co espondence should be add essed o D. To es-Laga es; [email p o ec ed]
Recei ed 20 Ma ch 2017; Re ised 10 Augus 2017; Accep ed 13 Sep embe 2017; Published 10 Decembe 2017
Academic Edi o : Giuseppe Valacchi
Copy igh © 2017 R. M. Díaz Sánchez e al. This is an open access a icle dis ibu ed unde he C ea i e Commons A ibu ion
License, which pe mi s un es ic ed use, dis ibu ion, and ep oduc ion in any medium, p o ided he o iginal wo k is
p ope ly ci ed.
Aim. To e alua e he effec i eness on issue esponse o he new nu i ional supplemen made o oligome ic p oan hocyanidins in
induced gingi i is a e 21 days o use. Ma e ial and Me hods. A p ospec i e, double-blind, andomized, con olled clinical ial was
ca ied ou on 20 pa ien s; i is di ided in o an expe imen al g oup and a con ol g oup a e ulfilling he selec ion c i e ia. Pa ien s
had o come 4 imes du ing he s udy o egis e he Silness and Löe index, he gingi al bleeding index, he plaque index, he
inflamma o y c e icula fluid s udy (IL6), and he changes in he b igh ness o he gingi a. No complemen a y hygiene me hods
we e allowed du ing he 21 days. Resul s. The Silness and Löe index was highe in he con ol g oup han in he expe imen al
g oup, eaching a wo old diffe ence be ween he g oups (p<00001). The gingi al bleeding index also suppo s his ac , since
he bleeding was lowe in he expe imen al g oup (p<0005). Howe e , he den al plaque on he oo h su ace acco ding o he
plaque index was 33% highe in he expe imen al g oup (p<0006). Some diffe ences in he IL-6 we e ound in he c e icula
fluid (p<00001). Conclusion. Oligome ic p oan hocyanidins ha e an effec on he pe iodon al issue’s heal h. No effec s on he
accumula ion o plaque on he oo h su ace we e ound, so u he s udies a e needed o de e mine he na u e o he plaque.
1. In oduc ion
Gingi i is is an inflamma o y disease o den al issue sup-
po ha in he fi s ins ance affec s he gingi a. Gingi i is
could mo e on o mo e ad anced s ages, leading o he
de elopmen o pe iodon i is, in which he inflamma ion
and bac e ial in ec ion can p oduce he des uc ion o he
suppo ing issues o he ee h, gingi a, pe iodon al ligamen ,
and al eola bone [1–5].
Gingi i is is due o he long- e m effec s o plaque
deposi s on he ee h, which is composed o bac e ia, loca ed
on he su aces o he ee h and in he gingi al sulcus. I pla-
que is no p e en ed o emo ed, i u ns in o a ha d deposi
called a a (o calculus) ha becomes apped a he base o
he oo h. Plaque and calculus i i a e and p oduce gingi al
swelling. Bac e ia and he oxins p oduce in ec ion and mo e
swelling gingi a [1–5].
C e icula fluid is no mal plasma exuded flowing
h ough he gingi al sulcus. A pa ien wi h gingi i is de elops
an inflamma o y esponse wi h a la ge numbe o media o s
in ol ed, such as he cy okines IL-6 and IL-8 [1–6].
In e leukin 6 (IL-6) is a mul i unc ional cy okine ha is
p oduced by a ange o cells, and i is in ol ed in he B-cell
diffe en ia ion, p oli e a ion, and diffe en ia ion o T cells;
in he immunoglobulin, s imula ion by he B-cell sec e ion
[7] can also induce bone eabso p ion [8]. IL6 is a use ul
diagnos ic indica o o de e mine he p og ession o he gin-
gi i is o a pe iodon al disease [9].
The ea men goal o gingi i is is o educe inflamma ion
by cleaning he ee h, using diffe en ins umen s o emo e
he den al plaque deposi s acco ding o he case [6]. I is
impo an o educa e he pa ien and p esc ibe special oo h-
pas e, mou hwash, gel, and so o h which con ain a wide
spec um o an isep ic and an i-inflamma o y p ope ies.
Hindawi
Media o s o Inflamma ion
Volume 2017, A icle ID 7460780, 7 pages
h ps://doi.o g/10.1155/2017/7460780
Howe e , he den is has he esponsibili y o explain he co -
ec oo h b ushing echnique o achie e good esul s [2, 3].
The oligome ic p oan hocyanidins (OPCs) a e one o he
mos abundan polyphenolic subs ances in he plan king-
dom. These subs ances exhibi a ange o a he su p ising
physical and chemical p ope ies which, once applied o li -
ing o ganisms, a e ansla ed in o a mul i ude o biological
ac i i ies [10]. The OPCs ha e been ecen ly in es iga ed,
and, apa om i s powe ul an ioxidan ac i i y, hey ha e
been shown o ha e an icance , an i-inflamma o y, an imi-
c obial, and asodila o y p ope ies, e ealing o be a po en-
ially aluable he apeu ic ool o he ea men o many
illnesses [11–15].
The a ailable esea ch has demons a ed ha he acidic
en i onmen o he human s omach does no easily deg ade
he p oan hocyanidins; he e o e, he a es o abso p ion in
he uppe gas oin es inal ac a e no high [16].
Howe e , i seems ha e en he low le els obse ed in
u ine a e an o al dose (gene ally less han 250/0 o doses/
o iginal) a e sufficien o significan ly inc ease he an ioxi-
dan capaci y in plasma/se um. When OPCs each he colon,
hey suffe an ex ensi e deg ada ion due o colonic flo a [16].
The me aboli es and biological p ope ies o his p ocess
ha e no been in es iga ed ye ; i has been sugges ed ha hey
may ha e p o ec i e effec s on he an ioxidan and sys emic
illness [11–16].
Rega ding he o he componen included in he OPCs,
i amin C, we know ha i is a good associa i e op ion o bil-
be y. Vi amin C gene ally p o ides p ope ies ha con ib-
u e o he o ma ion o collagen, which helps o main ain
unc ionali y o ee h and gums and o he p ope ies such
as ein o cemen o he immune sys em and po en an ioxi-
dan opposi ion o oxida i e s ess [17–21].
Al hough in i o s udies published abou he in e ac-
ion be ween he OPCs and pa hogens in he o al ca i y
ha e had e y good esul s, he e a e no publica ions wi h
he app op ia e design o assess he clinical efficacy o
OPCs in gingi al disease in human, excep an a icle pub-
lished in 2015 compa ing he chlo hexidine and he c an-
be y mou hwash [22–25].
The aim o his s udy is o e alua e he effec i eness o he
new nu i ional supplemen made o oligome ic p oan ho-
cyanidins (OPCs) on issue esponse o p e en gingi i is.
We hypo hesise a heal hy s a e o he pe iodon al issue in
he s udy g oup e sus gingi i is in he con ol g oup.
2. Ma e ial and Me hods
2.1. S udy Design and Popula ion. A andomized, double-
blind, placebo-con olled, clinical ial o 21 days o du a ion
was conduc ed among 20 olun ee s uden s o he School o
Den is y o he Uni e si y o Se ille. The du a ion o 21 days
was chosen as ha ime allows he pa ame e s udy on he
gingi a and was enough o s udy he inflamma ion o he gin-
gi a wi hou causing any i e e sible p oblem in i . No p e i-
ous s udies ha e been ound in he li e a u e, so 20 subjec s
we e de e mined o he pilo s udy o es ou hypo hesis.
The E hics Commi ee o he Uni e si y o Se ille
app o ed he s udy p o ocol. P io o pa icipa ion, he
pu pose and p ocedu es we e ully explained o all heal hy
olun ee s and all pa icipan s ga e w i en in o med con-
sen in acco dance wi h he Decla a ion o Helsinki. The
s udy was designed, conduc ed, analyzed, and epo ed
acco ding o he guidelines o Good Clinical P ac ice.
The s udy was app o ed by he h p://ClinicalT ials.go
P o ocol Regis a ion and Resul s Sys em wi h he numbe
NCT02515929. The p o ocol can be accessed i necessa y
in h p://ClinicalT ials.go .
The s udy was ca ied ou be ween Sep embe 2013 and
Janua y 2014. The ec ui men s a ed in Sep embe , and
he baseline s age ook place in Oc obe 2013. A e he
21-day ollow-up da a was ea ed ob aining he esul s
in Janua y 2014.
The medical and den al his o ies we e done a he p e-
sc eening isi , and we selec ed he 21 pa icipan s based
on he inclusion and exclusion c i e ia. The inclusion c i-
e ia we e he ollowing: subjec s olde han 18 yea s old,
male o emale, good o e all heal h, and a minimum o
20 ee h ( ee h wi h big ca ies we e c owned o ex ensi ely
es o ed, and ee h ha we e o hodon ic banded, abu men s,
o hi d mola s we e no included in he oo h coun ); he
olun ee s signed he w i en consen be o e he ini ia ion
o he s udy.
The exclusion c i e ia we e he ollowing: pe iodon al
disease (defined as 4mm and/o posi i e bleeding when
p obing), p egnan o b eas eeding, subjec s wi h fixed o
emo able p os hesis, umou pa hology in o al ca i y, use
o an ibio ics du ing a 2-mon h pe iod p io o he s a o
he ial, hype sensi i i y o ed ui s in gene al, xe os omy,
ac i e smoke , con agious-in ec ious pa hologies, pa hology
wi h se e e sys emic epe cussions, any o he judgmen ha
makes he in es iga o belie e o endange o isk he subjec
pa icipan , subjec s wi h phenylke onu ia o alle gy o
aspa ame, and he use o any o al hygiene p oduc du ing
he s udy.
A single examine p e iously calib a ed de e mined
assessmen o pa ien eligibili y o he s udy and en olmen
o pa ien s in o ial. Pa ien s eligible o he s udy we e indi-
idually andomly assigned o oligome ic p oan hocyanidins
nu i ional supplemen ea men o placebo g oups by an
in o ma ics p og amme by LACER S.A.
The s udy was double-blind. The examine and he
pa ien did no know in o which g oup hey we e assigned.
The esul s we e ea ed by ano he examine who knew
which pa ien s belonged o he expe imen al o placebo
g oup. The masking p ocess was es ablished by a numbe
assigna ion o each pa ien in he s udy, and he ea men
was he same bo h o he pa ien and he examine who we e
no allowed o know o which g oup hey belonged.
Pa ien s had o ake he expe imen al o placebo ea -
men each nigh a e dinne and a e a inse wi h wa e .
The pill was main ained in he mou h un il comple e dissolu-
ion. Nei he d inking no ea ing was allowed du ing 30
minu es a e aking he ea men . The expe imen al ea -
men consis ed o 90 mg exocian c an 408 (equi alen o
36mg OPCs) and 120mg o i amin C, while he placebo
g oup was composed o he same o ganolep ic subs ance
bu ee o ac i e ing edien s.
2 Media o s o Inflamma ion
Bo h we e simila in appea ance. No complemen a y
hygiene me hods we e allowed du ing he 21 days ( oo h
b ushing, inses o i iga ion wi h any p oduc , o flossing),
which could cons i u e a bias o he s udy.
A he ial baseline s age, a a a emo al was ca ied
ou in each pa ien o egula ize he ini ial si ua ion; a pa ien
dia y, enough medica ion o he en i e s udy, and ins uc-
ions we e gi en o i s co ec ulfillmen . The inflamma ion
o he c e icula fluid (IL6) and he b igh ness o he gingi a
we e egis e ed.
Two e alua ion isi s we e pe o med on days 14 and 21
o he s udy o an o al clinical examina ion and o egis e
he Silness and Löe index, he gingi al bleeding index, he
Tu esky plaque index, he inflamma o y c e icula fluid
s udy (IL6), and changes in he b igh ness o he gingi a.
2.2. Silness and Löe Index [26, 27]. Six ee h we e examined
acco ding o Ram jo d c i e ia (16-21-24-36-41-44). Fou
su aces o each oo h we e examined, making a o al o 24
measu emen s. These measu emen s we e pe o med wi h a
pe iodon al p obe by he same examine .
2.3. Gingi al Bleeding Index [28]. A pe iodon al p obe was
used o ake his index. The alues es ablished o his exam-
ina ion a e 0—absence o inflamma ion; 1—mild inflamma-
ion, sligh change in colo , no gingi al edema, and no
bleeding on p obing; 2—mode a e inflamma ion, edness,
edema, and gingi al hype ophy, and bleeds o p obe
(a e 10 seconds); 3—se e e inflamma ion, ma ked ed-
ness, and hype ophy. The e may be ulce a ions; he gingi a
ends o be spon aneous in bleeding.
2.4. Tu esky Plaque Index [29, 30]. The buccal su aces o he
an e io ee h we e examined using a mou hwash o basic
uchsine as de eloping agen plaque, and he ollowing
nume ical sco ing sys em om 0 o 5 was es ablished:
0— he e is no plaque; 1—independen s eaks o plaque in
he ce ical ma gin o he oo h; 2—a hin con inuous band
o plaque (up o 1 mm) a he ce ical ma gin; 3—a band
g ea e han one millime e wide, bu co e s less han
one- hi d o he c own; 4— he plaque co e s a hi d, bu
no mo e han wo- hi ds o he c own; 5— he plaque co e s
wo- hi ds o mo e o he c own.
2.5. Inflamma o y C e icula Fluid S udy (IL6) [7–9]. C e-
icula fluid samples we e collec ed om in e den al a eas
(lingual, buccal, mesial, and dis al) o six ee h dis ibu ed in
he ou quad an s (16, 21, 24, 36, 41, and 44) using fi e s ips
o p essed pape ha we e 2cm long, especially o c e icula
fluid. The imp egna ion ime o each pa ien was 5 seconds,
and he s ips we e immedia ely inse ed in o mic o ubes
ha con ained 0.5 ml o Eppendo wi h 50 μl saline a 4
°
C
o p ese a ion. The samples we e hen anspo ed o he
biological labo a o y in a e ige a o and we e s o ed ozen
a −80
°
C a he labo a o y un il hey we e p ocessed.
Then, we p oceeded o analyze he concen a ion (pg/ml)
o in e leukin 6 p esen in each sample using panels 96-well
bioplex b and Luminex®.
2.6. B igh ness o he Gingi a. The b igh ness o he gingi a
was aken o iden i y possible changes in he gingi al colo .
The eddening o he gingi a accompanies he inflamma ion
o he issue, which is a ac o ha may help o diffe en ia e
inflamma o y changes a his le el.
The luminosi y o he gingi a was egis e ed wi h Mic o
Spec oShade™MHT Op ic Resea ch AG. This ins umen
is designed o ake den al colo . Howe e , besides including
colo guides, he Spec oShade has he abili y o measu e
he b igh ness o any colo , no jus shades o whi e. The
change o colo o he gingi a was obse ed in each pa ien ,
and he colo e e ence was measu ed in he same poin in
each e alua ion isi , which helped us compa e he change
in he colo a ion o he same poin .
2.7. S a is ical Analysis. The managemen o he da a was
pe o med using he SPSS s a is ical p og am. A simila
da abase o No ebook Da a Collec ion was c ea ed. The e
a e a minimum ange and a maximum ange o each a i-
able, and he name o he a iable and i s alues we e defined.
The da a a e p esen ed as he mean ±s anda d de ia ion o
he measu emen s, and a p alue less han 0.05 was consid-
e ed s a is ically significan .
Chi-squa e es was pe o med o quali a i e a iable
and S uden ’s - es o he quan i a i e a iable, a e he
Kolmogo o -Smi no o assu e he no mali y.
The E hical Commi ee app o ed his s udy, and all
examina ions and ea men s we e pe o med wi h he con-
sen o he subjec s and acco ding o he guidelines o he
Decla a ion o Helsinki.
3. Resul s
A s a is ical analysis be ween he wo s udy g oups, 10
pa ien s in each g oup, in e ms o sex, age (yea s), weigh
(kg), heigh (cm), obacco use, alcohol, and use o concomi-
an medica ion, was ca ied ou o ensu e he eliabili y o
he esul s. We ound no significan diffe ences be ween he
s udy g oup and he con ol g oup, so we can say ha he
homogenei y be ween he g oups was achie ed (Table 1).
Table 1: G oups cha ac e is ics.
Expe imen al
(n=10)
Con ol
(n=10)p
Sex Men 2 5 0.674
Women 8 5
Yea s 24.6 ±4.27 23.5 ±1.64 0.525
Weigh (Kg) 57.04 ±9.33 66.6 ±16.43 0.420
Heigh (cm) 164.7 ±8.02 169.3 ±8.59 0.325
Smoke Yes 0 0 1.000
No 10 10
Alcohol Yes 1 1 1.000
No 9 9
Medical
ea men
Yes 1 (ACO) 0 0.875
No 9 10
3Media o s o Inflamma ion
The medica ion pe cep ion o bo h g oups, as he ini ial
fla ou , he p oduc du abili y, he appea ance, size, and effi-
ciency, was he same; he e we e no s a is ically significan
diffe ences be ween he da a ob ained (Table 1). No ad e se
e en s we e no ified du ing he s udy.
Once he s udy g oups we e analysed, he da a p ocessing
was conduc ed depending on he diffe en iews held.
3.1. Pe iodon al Index o 15 Days o T ea men (In e media e
Visi ). The Silness and Löe gingi al index (o 0–3 om
leas o g ea es gingi al inflamma ion) (Table 2) was
highe in he con ol g oup han in he expe imen al
g oup, eaching a wo old diffe ence be ween he wo g oups
(p<00001). The gingi al bleeding index also co obo a es
his ac , as he bleeding was lowe in he expe imen al g oup
e sus he con ol g oup (p<0005) (Table 2).
In con as o he alues ob ained in he Silness and
Löe and gingi al bleeding indexes, he amoun o den al
plaque deposi ed on he su ace o he pa ien s acco ding o
he Tu esky index plaque was sligh ly highe (33%) in he
expe imen al g oup e sus in he con ol g oup (p<0006)
(Table 2).
3.2. Pe iodon al Index o 21 Days o T ea men (Final Visi ).
The esul s ob ained 21 days a e s a ing he ea men
showed he endency obse ed in he in e media e isi ,
inc easing he diffe ence be ween he s udy g oups.
Silness and Löe index was highe in he con ol g oup
compa ed o he expe imen al g oup, wi h a diffe ence o
50% be ween he s udy g oups (p<00001). The gingi al
bleeding index, which showed bleeding in he con ol g oup,
was highe in he expe imen al g oup (p<00001).
Howe e , he plaque deposi ion was highe in he expe -
imen al g oup han in he con ol g oup acco ding o he
Tu esky plaque index ha ing plaque deposi doubled in he
pa ien s in he expe imen al g oup (p<00001) (Table 2).
3.3. Gingi al B igh ness. The gingi al b igh ness was aken in
each pa ien using he Mic o Spec oShade Op ic Resea ch
MHT AG. This alue was aken a he beginning, middle
isi , and in he final isi . The da a ob ained om hese h ee
measu emen s in each pa ien showed no s a is ically signifi-
can diffe ences (p alues om 0.351 o 0.545) (Table 3).
3.4. Inflamma o y C e icula Fluid S udy (IL6). S a is ically
significan diffe ences we e ound a he baseline be ween
he expe imen al g oup and he con ol g oup and in he sub-
sequen isi s. No s a is ically significan diffe ences be ween
he fi s isi and he second isi , and he fi s and hi d isi s
we e ound, al hough i was significan be ween he second
isi and he hi d isi (Table 4).
4. Discussion
Gingi i is is caused by deposi ion o plaque on he oo h su -
ace; his deposi ion cons i u es an i i an ha igge s he
gingi al inflamma ion and bleeding. Gingi i is could be
e e sible i he pa ien has a cons an and good hygiene.
These measu es could be ca ied ou by a p ope b ushing
echnique [1–5].
The d ug used in he cu en s udy is a nu i ional
supplemen based on bluebe y and ed ui ich in oligo-
me ic p oan hocyanidins (OPCs) [7]. P oan hocyanidins
ha e been ecen ly in es iga ed, as we sugges ed in he in o-
duc ion, due o hei powe ul an ioxidan and an icance
ac i i ies and due o hei an i-inflamma o y, an imic obial,
and asodila o sys emical p ope ies. The beneficial effec
o p oan hocyanidins is a ibu ed o i s abili y o educe oxi-
da i e s ess, lipid pe oxida ion, ee adical gene a ion, and
LDL oxida ion [11].
Mohana e al. published a s udy in 2015 abou he effec
o he OPCs in he p e en ion and ea men o a he oscle o-
sis. Oxida ion o low-densi y lipop o eins (OxLDL) has been
s ongly sugges ed as a key ac o in he pa hogenesis o
a he oscle osis [11]. Due o he an ioxidan ac ion o he
Table 2: Silness and Löe, gingi al bleeding, and plaque index.
Tes E alua ion isi s Expe imen al Con ol p
Silness and Löe index Day 14 0.65 ±0.58 1.24 ±0.66 0.0001
Day 21 0.97 ±0.54 1.48 ±0.60 0.0001
Gingi al bleeding index Day 14 0.91 ±0.84 1.33 ±0.75 0.005
Day 21 0.98 ±0.67 1.61 ±0.66 0.0001
Plaque index Day 14 1.68 ±0.79 1.25 ±0.91 0.006
Day 21 3.35 ±1.59 1.68 ±1.43 0.0001
Table 3: B igh ness o he gingi a.
B igh ness o he gingi a Expe imen al Con ol p
Baseline 30.75 ±4.19 31.37 ±3.55 0.351
Day 14 32.70 ±3.48 31.50 ±3.10 0.480
Day 21 32.57 ±4.72 31.22 ±2.52 0.425
Di (day 21 and day 14) −0.12 ±1.85 −0.28 ±1.92 0.545
Table 4: IL-6 in he c e icula fluid (pg/ml).
IL-6 in he c e icula
fluid (pg/ml) Expe imen al Con ol p
Baseline 62.85 ±45.8 126.60 ±54.03 0.011
Day 14 17.95 ±13.02 47.40 ±33.61 0.019
Day 21 22.15 ±15.14 69.40 ±50.10 0.011
Di (day 14—baseline) 44.90 ±44.05 79.20 ±64.54 0.095
Di (day 21—baseline) −40.70 ±45.02 −56.70 ±70.63 0.245
Di (day 21 and day 14) −4.20 ±3.21 −22.00 ±21.03 0.016
4 Media o s o Inflamma ion
p oan hocyanidins and he modula ion o mac ophage di -
e en ia ion, Mohana e al. epo ed he benefi o he p oduc
as p e en ion and ea men o he a he oscle osis [11].
Wang e al. ha e also es ed he an i-inflamma o y mech-
anisms o OPCs [12]. They designed an in i o s udy in
mouse models o in es iga e he p o ec i e effec o OPCs
agains alcohol-induced li e s ea osis and inju y. The esul s
showed ha OPC significan ly imp o ed alcohol-induced
dyslipidemia and alle ia ed li e s ea osis by educing
le els o se um alanine amino ans e ase (ALT), aspa a e
amino ans e ase (AST), o al iglyce ide (TG), o al cho-
les e ol (TC), low-densi y choles e ol (LDL-c), and li e
malondialdehyde (MDA) and inc easing le els o se um
high-densi y lipop o ein (HDL-c) and li e supe oxide
dismu ase (SOD). Fu he in es iga ion indica ed ha OPC
ma kedly dec eased he exp essions o lipid syn hesis genes
and inflamma ion genes such as s e ol egula o y elemen
binding p o ein-1c (S ebp-1c), p o ein-2 (S ebp2), in e leu-
kins IL-1b and IL-6, and TNF-α10.
These s udies sugges ed ha an effec in he inflamma-
ion genes and media o s could be modified by he OPCs,
educing he inflamma ion ob ained [11, 12]. Ou esul s
do no show significan diffe ences in he IL-6 be ween he
baseline and he second isi and be ween he baseline and
he hi d isi . Significan diffe ences we e ound be ween
he 14 h and 21s days and be ween g oups in each isi ,
including in he baseline s age, so he g oups we e no simila
a he beginning o he s udy, which could be a bias in he
esul s. Tha eason o ces us o no conside significan ly
he esul s ob ained. Howe e , he da a is lowe in he
expe imen al g oup in each isi and his ac sugges s
ha an effec could be in he IL-6, bu we canno assu e
his like in o he s udies because o ou diffe ence in he
baseline g oup. Howe e , he clinical pa ame e s, he Löe
and Silness index and gingi al bleeding index, showed us
ha he clinical inflamma ion was highe in he con ol
g oup han in he expe imen al g oup, finding s a is ically
significan diffe ences.
Du ing he s udy, we obse ed ha he deposi ion o pla-
que, Löe and Silness index, gingi al bleeding index, and he
b igh ness o he gingi a, inc eased sequen ially, so he
inflamma o y ac o s mus ha e also inc eased due o he
esul s ob ained in each pa ame e , al hough he e we e no
diffe ences be ween he s udy g oups in he b igh ness o
he gingi a. We a ibu e his ac o he mechanical i i an
ha he plaque cons i u es i sel , wi hou aking in o accoun
i s na u e.
Besides he an i-inflamma o y effec , OPCs ha e shown
an imic obial effec , epo ed by u he s udies [10–16, 23,
25]. This p ope y also jus ifies es ing he effec i eness o
he OPCs in pe iodon al disease. A e pe o ming he cu -
en s udy, we can affi m ha he OPCs ha e an effec in
he heal h o he pe iodon al issues, as we could see
h ough he Silness and Löe and gingi al bleeding indexes,
which we e significan ly lowe in he expe imen al g oup
han in he con ol g oup, al hough i was no co obo a ed
by he Tu esky plaque index, whe e he p esence o plaque
was pa adoxically highe by 33% in he s udy g oup han in
he con ol g oup (Table 1).
These esul s lead us o suspec ha his supplemen
ce ainly has an imic obial effec , since he gingi al bleed-
ing index and Silness and Löe index we e lowe e en in
he p esence o mo e den al plaque, so he na u e o he
plaque mus be modified, possibly because o a change in
he pH o by a diffe en bac e ial composi ion. In Ma ch
2015, Mahesh e al. published in he Con empo a y Clinical
Den is y a andomized pa allel clinical ial compa ing a
0.2% chlo hexidine glucona e mou hwash e sus a 0.6%
c anbe y mou hwash on S ep ococcus mu ans in 50 sub-
jec s, ob aining simila esul s in he colonisa ion o his
bac e ia in he plaque [25]. This s udy confi ms he esul s
ob ained in ou clinical ial, in which we hypo hesised
ha he plaque could be diffe en because o he mino
inflamma ion o he pe iodon al issue.
Un il his momen , only one s udy has been published
abou he use o c anbe y mou hwash (a componen o
OPCs) in pe iodon al disease in humans [25]. Howe e , in
2011, Löh e al. published an in i o s udy abou he an imi-
c obial effec o he OPCs ac ing in he adhesion o Po phy -
omonas gingi alis o KB cells [23]. They pos ula ed ha he
OPCs had an an iadhesi e effec agains P. gingi alis in he
KB cells. The esul s o his s udy showed ha OPCs exe
an iadhesi e effec s agains P. gingi alis, concluding ha
OPCs may be use ul o he p e en ion o P. gingi alis-asso-
cia ed pe iodon al diseases [23]. Ou s udy does no include
bac e ial analysis, bu ou esul s suppo i due o he ac
ha in he expe imen al g oup he pa ame e s showed less
inflamma ion and less cell esponse o he plaque, which
could be a ibu ed o i s na u e.
Due o he p e ious s udy [23], we suspec ha he an i-
adhesion effec modified he plaque o he subjec s in he
expe imen al g oup, making he inflamma ion lowe . Lö h
e al. showed ha polyphenols in e ac wi h p o ein su ace
(e.g., gingipains, p edominan ly because o i s ac i i y agains
A g-gingipain) and change he unc ionali y and eac i i y.
Thus, OPCs mainly in e ac wi h he ini ial adhesion p ocess
o he bac e ia o he cell memb ane. This p ocess could be
ex apola ed o ou s udy, gi ing us an explica ion o ou
esul s. IL-6 has no shown significan diffe ences, bu a eal
effec in he inflamma ion o he gingi a ook place in ou
pa ien s; hus, he Löe and Silness index and gingi al bleeding
index we e lowe in he expe imen al g oup.
5. Conclusion
The nu i ional supplemen made o oligome ic p oan ho-
cyanidins (c anbe y and i amin C) induces an imp o emen
in he heal h o he pe iodon al issues, since he Silness and
Löe index and gingi al bleeding index we e ma kedly lowe
in he expe imen al g oup, al hough ha supplemen has
no been shown o ha e effec s on he accumula ion o plaque
on he oo h su ace. Fu he s udies a e needed o de e mine
he na u e o he plaque.
Disclosu e
The abs ac was p esen ed as a pos e in he Jou nal o
Clinical Pe iodon ology, in he special issue Abs ac s o
5Media o s o Inflamma ion

Eu oPe io8, London, UK, 3–6 June as pe he below
URL (page 48, D056): h p://onlinelib a y.wiley.com/doi/
10.1111/jcpe.12398/epd .
Con lic s o In e es
The au ho s decla e ha he e a e no conflic s o in e es in
his s udy.
Acknowledgmen s
The au ho s hank M . Modes o Ca ballo om he Biology
Depa men o CITIUS (Uni e si y o Se ille). LACER S.A.
financed he p esen s udy.
Re e ences
[1] D. D. Bossha d and K. A. Sel ig, “Den al cemen um: he
dynamic issue co e ing o he oo ,”Pe iodon ology 2000,
ol. 13, no. 1, pp. 41–75, 1997.
[2] B. Synde gaa d, M. Al-Sabbagh, R. J. K yscio e al., “Sali a y
bioma ke s associa ed wi h gingi i is and esponse o he -
apy,”Jou nal o Pe iodon ology, ol. 85, no. 8, pp. e295–e303,
2014.
[3] T. Mo elli, M. S ella, S. P. Ba os e al., “Sali a y bioma ke s in
a biofilm o e g ow h model,”Jou nal o Pe iodon ology,
ol. 85, no. 12, pp. 1770–1778, 2014.
[4] P. Gümüş, Ö. Özçaka, B. Ceyhan-Öz ü k, A. Akcali, D. F.
Lappin, and N. Buduneli, “E alua ion o biochemical pa am-
e e s and local and sys emic le els o os eoac i e and B-cell
s imula o y ac o s in ges a ional diabe es in he p esence o
absence o gingi i is,”Jou nal o Pe iodon ology, ol. 86,
no. 3, pp. 387–397, 2015.
[5] M. Bo ona -Ca alá, M. Ca alá-Piza o, and J. V. Bagán
Sebas ián, “Sali a y and c e icula fluid in e leukins in gingi-
i is,”Jou nal o Clinical and Expe imen al Den is y, ol. 6,
no. 2, pp. e175–e179, 2014.
[6] P. Pozo, M. A. Valenzuela, C. Melej e al., “Longi udinal
analysis o me allop o einases, issue inhibi o s o me allo-
p o einases and clinical pa ame e s in gingi al c e icula
fluid om pe iodon i is-affec ed pa ien s,”Jou nal o Pe i-
odon al Resea ch, ol. 40, no. 3, pp. 199–207, 2005.
[7] T. Hi ano, S. Aki a, T. Taga, and T. Kishimo o, “Biological and
clinical aspec s o in e leukin 6,”Immunology Today, ol. 11,
no. 12, pp. 443–449, 1990.
[8] Y. Ishimi, C. Miyau a, C. H. Jin e al., “IL-6 is p oduced
by os eoblas s and induces bone eso p ion,”The Jou nal
o Immunology, ol. 145, pp. 3297–3303, 1990.
[9] T. Kobayashi, K. Ishida, and H. Yoshie, “Inc eased exp ession
o in e leukin-6 (IL-6) gene ansc ip in ela ion o IL-6 p o-
mo e hypome hyla ion in gingi al issue om pa ien s wi h
ch onic pe iodon i is,”A chi es o O al Biology, ol. 69,
pp. 89–94, 2016.
[10] Z. Xu, P. Du, P. Meise , and C. Jacob, “P oan hocyanidins:
oligome ic s uc u es wi h unique biochemical p ope ies
and g ea he apeu ic p omise,”Na u al P oduc Communica-
ions, ol. 7, no. 3, pp. 381–388, 2012.
[11] T. Mohana, A. V. Na in, S. Jamuna, M. S. Sakeena Sadullah,
and S. Ni anjali De a aj, “Inhibi ion o diffe en ia ion o
monocy e o mac ophages in a he oscle osis by oligome ic
p oan hocyanidins –In- i o and in- i o s udy,”Food and
Chemical Toxicology, ol. 82, pp. 96–105, 2015.
[12] Z. Wang, B. Su, S. Fan, H. Fei, and W. Zhao, “P o ec i e
effec o oligome ic p oan hocyanidins agains alcohol-
induced li e s ea osis and inju y in mice,”Biochemical
and Biophysical Resea ch Communica ions, ol. 458, no. 4,
pp. 757–762, 2015.
[13] S. Jin, Ee dunbayae , A. Doi e al., “Polyphenolic cons i uen s
o Cynomo ium songa icum Rup . and an ibac e ial effec o
polyme ic p oan hocyanidin on me hicillin- esis an S aphy-
lococcus au eus,”Jou nal o Ag icul u al and Food Chemis y,
ol. 60, no. 29, pp. 7297–7305, 2012.
[14] M. Miyake, K. Ide, K. Sasaki, Y. Ma suku a, K. Shijima,
and D. Fujiwa a, “O al adminis a ion o highly oligome ic
p ocyanidins o Ja oba educes he se e i y o collagen-
induced a h i is,”Bioscience, Bio echnology, and Biochemis-
y, ol. 72, no. 7, pp. 1781–1788, 2008.
[15] E. M. Kimmel, M. Je ome, J. Holde ness e al., “Oligome ic
p ocyanidins s imula e inna e an i i al immuni y in dengue
i us in ec ed human PBMCs,”An i i al Resea ch, ol. 90,
no. 1, pp. 80–86, 2011.
[16] E. M. Va oni, G. Lodi, A. Sa della, A. Ca assi, and M. I i i,
“Plan polyphenols and o al heal h: old phy ochemicals o
new fields,”Cu en Medicinal Chemis y, ol. 19, no. 11,
pp. 1706–1720, 2012.
[17] N. H. Gokhale, A. B. Acha ya, V. S. Pa il, D. J. T i edi, and S. L.
Thaku , “A sho - e m e alua ion o he ela ionship be ween
plasma asco bic acid le els and pe iodon al disease in sys em-
ically heal hy and ype 2 diabe es melli us subjec s,”Jou nal o
Die a y Supplemen s, ol. 10, no. 2, pp. 93–104, 2013.
[18] P. Lings om, S. Fu e, B. Dinilzen, C. F i zne, C. Kle bom, and
D. Bi khed, “The elease o i amin C om chewing gum and
i s effec s on sup agingi al calculus o ma ion,”Eu opean
Jou nal o O al Sciences, ol. 113, no. 1, pp. 20–27, 2005.
[19] M. Nishida, S. G. G ossi, R. G. Dun o d, A. W. Ho,
M. T e isan, and R. J. Genco, “Die a y i amin C and he isk
o pe iodon al disease,”Jou nal o Pe iodon ology, ol. 71,
no. 8, pp. 1215–1223, 2000.
[20] L. Boni ai and D. G enie , “C anbe y polyphenols: po en ial
benefi s o den al ca ies and pe iodon al disease,”Jou nal o
he Canadian Den al Associa ion, ol. 76, a icle a130, 2010.
[21] P. J. Leggo , P. B. Robe lson, R. A. Jacob, J. J. Zambon,
M. Walsh, and G. C. A mi age, “Effec s o asco bic acid deple-
ion and supplemen a ion on pe iodon al heal h and subgingi-
al mic oflo a in humans,”Jou nal o Den al Resea ch, ol. 70,
no. 12, pp. 1531–1536, 1991.
[22] M. K. Vaananen, H. A. Ma kkanen, V. J. Tuo inen, A. M.
Kullaa, A. M. Ka inpaa, and E. A. Kumpusalo, “Pe iodon al
heal h ela ed o plasma asco bic acid,”P oceedings o he
Finnish Den al Socie y, ol. 89, no. 1-2, pp. 51–59, 1993.
[23] G. Löh , T. Beikle , A. Podbielski, K. S anda , S. Redanz, and
A. Hensel, “Polyphenols om My o hamnus flabelli olia
Welw. inhibi in i o adhesion o Po phy omonas gingi alis
and exe an i-inflamma o y cy op o ec i e effec s in KB cells,”
Jou nal o Clinical Pe iodon ology, ol. 38, no. 5, pp. 457–469,
2011.
[24] J. Go inda aj, P. Emmadi, Deepalakshmi, V. Raja am,
G. P akash, and R. Pu anak ishnan, “P o ec i e effec o
p oan hocyanidins on endo oxin induced expe imen al pe i-
odon i is in a s,”Indian Jou nal o Expe imen al Biology,
ol. 48, no. 2, pp. 133–142, 2010.
6 Media o s o Inflamma ion
[25] R. Mahesh, M. Khai na , G. N. Ka ibasappa e al., “Compa a-
i e assessmen o c anbe y and chlo hexidine mou hwash on
s ep ococcal coloniza ion among den al s uden s: a andom-
ized pa allel clinical ial,”Con empo a y Clinical Den is y,
ol. 6, no. 1, pp. 35–39, 2015.
[26] J. Silness and H. Loe, “Pe iodon al disease in p egnancy II.
Co ela ion be ween o al hygiene and pe iodon al condi ion,”
Ac a Odon ologica Scandina ica, ol. 22, no. 1, pp. 121–135,
1964.
[27] H. Loe, “The gingi al index, he plaque index and he e en-
ion index sys ems,”Jou nal o Pe iodon ology, ol. 38, no. 6,
Pa II, pp. 610–616, 1967.
[28] H. G. Ca e and G. P. Ba nes, “The gingi al bleeding index,”
Jou nal o Pe iodon ology, ol. 45, no. 11, pp. 801–805, 1974.
[29] S. Tu esky, N. D. Gilmo e, and I. Glickman, “Reduced plaque
o ma ion by he chlo ome hyl analogue o ic amine C,”Jou -
nal o Pe iodon ology, ol. 41, no. 1, pp. 41–43, 1970.
[30] G. A. Quigley and J. W. Hein, “Compa a i e cleansing effi-
ciency o manual and powe b ushing,”The Jou nal o he
Ame ican Den al Associa ion, ol. 65, no. 1, pp. 26–29, 1962.
7Media o s o Inflamma ion