scieee Open visual document viewer

Adaptive Robust Efficient Methods for Periodic Signal Processing Observed with Colours Noises

Pchelintsev, Evgeny

Abstract

In this paper, we consider the problem of robust adaptive efficient estimating a periodic signal observed in the transmission channel with the dependent noise defined by non-Gaussian Ornstein-Uhlenbeck processes with unknown correlation properties. Adaptive model selection procedures, based on the shrinkage weighted least squares estimates, are proposed. The comparison between shrinkage and least squares methods is studied and the advantages of the shrinkage methods are analyzed. Estimation properties for proposed statistical algorithms are studied on the basis of the robust mean square accuracy defined as the maximum mean square estimation error over all possible values of unknown noise parameters. Sharp oracle inequalities for the robust risks have been obtained. The robust efficiency of the model selection procedure has been established.

Full text

INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIES AND SERVICES VOLUME: 17 |NUMBER: 3 |2019 |SEPTEMBER Adap i e Robus E icien Me hods o Pe iodic Signal P ocessing Obse ed wi h Colou s Noises E geny PCHELINTSEV 1,2, Se guei PERGAMENSHCHIKOV 3,4, Ma iana MARCOKOVA5,6 1Depa men o Ma hema ical Analysis and Theo y o Func ions, Facul y o Mechanics and Ma hema ics, Tomsk S a e Uni e si y, Lenin A enue 36, 634050 Tomsk, Russia 2In e na ional Labo a o y o S a is ics o S ochas ic P ocesses and Quan i a i e Finance, Tomsk S a e Uni e si y, Lenin A enue 36, 634050 Tomsk, Russia 3Labo a o y o Ma hema ics Raphael Salem, Uni e si y o Rouen No mandie, A enue de l’Uni e si e 12, 76801 Sain E ienne du Rou ay, F ance 4In e na ional Labo a o y o S a is ics o S ochas ic P ocesses and Quan i a i e Finance, Tomsk S a e Uni e si y, Lenin A enue 36, 634050 Tomsk, Russia 5Depa men o S uc u al Mechanics and Applied Ma hema ics, Facul y o Ci il Enginee ing, Uni e si y o Zilina, Uni e zi na 8215/1, 010 26 Zilina, Slo ak Republic 6Depa men o Elec onics and Nanoelec onics, Na ional Resea ch Uni e si y "Moscow Powe Enginee ing Ins i u e", K asnokaza mennaya 14, 111250 Moscow, Russia e gen-pch@yandex. u, se ge.pe gamench chik[email p o ec ed], ma iana.ma coko a@ s a .uniza.sk DOI: 10.15598/aeee. 17i3.3132 Abs ac . In his pape , we conside he p oblem o obus adap i e e icien es ima ing a pe iodic sig- nal obse ed in he ansmission channel wi h he dependen noise de ined by non-Gaussian O ns ein- Uhlenbeck p ocesses wi h unknown co ela ion p ope - ies. Adap i e model selec ion p ocedu es, based on he sh inkage weigh ed leas squa es es ima es, a e p o- posed. The compa ison be ween sh inkage and leas squa es me hods is s udied and he ad an ages o he sh inkage me hods a e analyzed. Es ima ion p ope ies o p oposed s a is ical algo i hms a e s udied on he basis o he obus mean squa e accu acy de ined as he maximum mean squa e es ima ion e o o e all pos- sible alues o unknown noise pa ame e s. Sha p o a- cle inequali ies o he obus isks ha e been ob ained. The obus e iciency o he model selec ion p ocedu e has been es ablished. Keywo ds Asymp o ic e iciency, model selec ion, non- pa ame ic eg ession, O ns ein-Uhlenbeck p o- cess, pe iodic signals, obus quad a ic isk, sha p o acle inequali y, sh inkage es ima ion, weigh ed leas squa es es ima es. 1. In oduc ion In his pape , we conside he es ima ion p oblem o he 1-pe iodic signal S( )on he basis o obse a ions (y )0≤ ≤ngi en by he s ochas ic di e en ial equa ion: dy =S( )d +dξ ,0≤ ≤n, (1) whe e nis he du a ion o obse a ion and (ξ )0≤ ≤n is unobse ed colou noise. No e ha i (ξ )0≤ ≤nis B ownian mo ion, hen we ob ain he well-known "sig- nal + whi e noise" model which is e y popula in s a- is ical adio-physics (see, o example, [1], [2] and [3]). In his pape , we assume ha he use ul signal Sis dis o ed by he impulse low desc ibed by he non- Gaussian O ns ein-Uhlenbeck p ocesses, which allows s udying he signal es ima ion p oblems wi h depen- den pulse noises, i.e. we assume ha he noise p ocess (ξ )0≤ ≤nobeys he equa ion: dξ =aξ d +du ,(2) u = ´n1w + ´n2z and z =x∗(µ−˜µ) , whe e a,´n1and ´n2a e some unknown cons an s, (w ) ≥0is he s anda d B ownian mo ion, µ(ds dx) is he jump measu e wi h de e minis ic compensa o ˜µ(ds dx) = dsΠ (dx),Π(·)is he Le y measu e, i.e. some posi i e measu e on R∗=R {0}, such ha Πx2= 1 and Πx6<∞. He e we use he no- a ion Π (|x|m) = RR∗|y|mΠ (dy). No e ha he Le y c 2019 ADVANCES IN ELECTRICAL AND ELECTRONIC ENGINEERING 270 INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIES AND SERVICES VOLUME: 17 |NUMBER: 3 |2019 |SEPTEMBER measu e Π (R∗)could be equal o +∞. We use ∗ o he s ochas ic in eg als wi h espec o andom measu es (see [4], Chap e s 2 and 3), i.e.: x∗(µ−˜µ) = Z 0Z R∗ y(µ−˜µ) (ds, dy).(3) I should be no ed ha i a= 0, hen we ob ain he Le y eg ession model conside ed in [5]. In he case when Π (·) = 0 we ob ain he well-known Gaussian O ns ein-Uhlenbeck eg ession model in oduced in [6] and [7]. The model in he Eq. (1) and Eq. (2) in which he jump p ocess (z ) ≥0is de ined by he compound Poisson p ocess was s udied in [8] and [9]. Howe e , he compound Poisson p ocesses can desc ibe only he la ge noise impulses o small ixed equency, bu he elecommunica ion and loca ion sys ems may ha e he impulse noises wi h any equency wi hou any condi- ion. We no e ha in he pape s [8] and [9] he p o- posed s a is ical p ocedu es a e based on he classical weigh ed leas squa es es ima o s. The main goal o his pape is o de elop a new imp o ed adap i e obus e icien signal es ima ion me hods o he non-Gaussian O ns ein-Uhlenbeck noise (ξ )0≤ ≤nbased on he gene al Le y p ocesses wi h unknown dis ibu ion Q. We assume ha his dis ibu ion belongs o he class Q∗ nde ined as a am- ily o all hese dis ibu ions o which he pa ame e s −a∗≤a < 0,´n1≥ξ∗and ´n2 1+ ´n2 2≤ξ∗, whe e a∗, ξ∗and ξ∗a e some ixed posi i e bounds. The quali y o an es ima e ˆ Sno he unknown signal S, i.e. some unc ion o (y )0≤ ≤n, will be measu ed wi h he obus quad a ic isk: R∗ˆ Sn, S= sup Q∈Q∗ n RQˆ Sn, S,(4) whe e RQˆ Sn, S:=EQ,S    ˆ Sn−S   2 and (5) kSk2= 1 Z 0 S2( )d . He e EQ,S is he expec a ion wi h espec o he dis i- bu ion PQ,S o he p ocess in he Eq. (1) wi h a ixed dis ibu ion Qo he noise (ξ )0≤ ≤nand a gi en unc- ion S. 2. Sh inkage Es ima ion Me hods Le (φj)j≥1be a igonome ic basis in L2[0,1]. We ex end hese unc ions by he pe iodic way on Ri.e. φj( ) = φj( + 1) o any ∈R. Fo es ima ing he unknown unc ion Sin he Eq. (1), we conside i s Fou ie expansion: S( ) = ∞ X j=1 θjφj( ) and (6) θj= (S, φj) = 1 Z 0 S( )φj( )d . The Fou ie coe icien s θjcan be es ima ed as: ˆ θj,n =1 n n Z 0 φj( )dy .(7) We de ine a class o weigh ed leas squa es es ima es o S( )as: ˆ Sλ= n X j=1 λ(j)ˆ θj,nφj,(8) whe e he weigh s λ∈Rnbelong o some ini e se Λ om [0,1]n. Now, o he i s d≤nFou ie coe icien s in Eq. (6), we use he imp o ed es ima ion me hod p o- posed o pa ame ic models in [10] and [11]. To his end we se ˜ θn=ˆ θj,n1≤j≤d. In he sequel, we will use he no m |x|2 d= d P j=1 x2 j o any ec o x= (xj)1≤j≤d om Rn. Now we de ine he sh inkage es ima o s as: θ∗ j,n = (1 −g(j)) ˆ θj,n,(9) whe e g(j) = cn |˜ θn|d 1{1≤j≤d},1Ais he indica o o he se Aand cnis some known pa ame e such ha cn≈d nas n→ ∞. Now we in oduce a class o sh ink- age weigh ed leas squa es es ima es o Sas: S∗ λ= n X j=1 λ(j)θ∗ j,nφj.(10) We deno e he di e ence o quad a ic isks o he es i- ma es in Eq. (10) and Eq. (8) as ∆Q(S):=RQ(S∗ λ, S)− RQˆ Sλ, S. Now o his de ia ion, we ob ain he ol- lowing esul . Theo em 1 Assume ha o any ec o λ∈Λ he e exis s some ixed in ege d=d(λ)such ha hei i s dcomponen s equal o one. Then o any n≥1and > 0: sup Q∈Qn sup kSk≤ ∆Q(S)<−c2 n.(11) The inequali y in Eq. (11) means ha non- asymp o ically, i.e. o any n≥1 he es ima e in he c 2019 ADVANCES IN ELECTRICAL AND ELECTRONIC ENGINEERING 271 INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIES AND SERVICES VOLUME: 17 |NUMBER: 3 |2019 |SEPTEMBER Eq. (10) ou pe o ms in mean squa e accu acy he es- ima e in he Eq. (8). Mo eo e , as we will see below, ncn→ ∞ as n→ ∞. This means ha he imp o e- men e ec in he nonpa ame ic case is mo e signi i- can han o pa ame ic eg ession [11]. 3. Model Selec ion P ocedu e This Sec ion gi es he cons uc ion o a model selec ion p ocedu e o es ima ing a unc ion Sin he Eq. (1) on he basis o imp o ed weigh ed leas squa es es ima es and s a es he sha p o acle inequali y o he obus isk o he p oposed p ocedu e. The model selec ion p ocedu e o he unknown unc- ion Sin he Eq. (1) will be cons uc ed on he basis o a amily o es ima es (S∗ λ)λ∈Λ. The pe o mance o any es ima e S∗ λwill be measu ed by he empi ical squa ed e o : E n(λ) = kS∗ λ−Sk2.(12) In o de o ob ain a good es ima e, we ha e o w i e a ule o choose a weigh ec o λ∈Λin he Eq. (6). I is ob ious ha he bes app oach is o minimize he empi ical squa ed e o wi h espec o λ. Making use he es ima e de ini ion in he Eq. (6) and he Fou ie ans o ma ion o Simplies: E n(λ) = n X j=1 λ2(j)θ∗ j,n2−2 n X j=1 λ(j)θ∗ j,nθj+ n X j=1 θ2 j. (13) Since he Fou ie coe icien s (θj)j≥1a e unknown, he weigh coe icien s (λj)j≥1canno be ound by mini- mizing his quan i y. To ci cum en his di icul y one needs o eplace he e ms θ∗ j,nθjby hei es ima o s ˜ θj,n. We se : ˜ θj,n =θ∗ j,n ˆ θj,n −ˆσn n,(14) whe e ˆσnis he es ima e o he noise a iance o σQ=EQξ2 j,n which we choose in he ollowing o m: ˆσn= n X j=[√n]+1 ˆ 2 j,n and ˆ j,n =1 n n Z 0 φj( )dy .(15) Fo his change in he empi ical squa ed e o , one has o pay some penal y. Thus, one comes o he cos unc- ion o he o m: Jn(λ) = n X j=1 λ2(j)θ∗ j,n2−2 n X j=1 λ(j)˜ θj,n +δˆ Pn(λ), (16) whe e δis some posi i e cons an and ˆ Pn(λ)is he penal y e m de ined as: ˆ Pn(λ) = ˆσn|λ|2 n n.(17) Subs i u ing he weigh coe icien s, minimizing he cos unc ion: λ∗= a gmin λ∈Λ Jn(λ)(18) in he Eq. (10) leads o he imp o ed model selec ion p ocedu e: S∗=S∗ λ∗.(19) I will be no ed ha λ∗exis s because Λis a ini e se . I he minimizing sequence in he Eq. (18) λ∗is no unique, one can ake any minimize . In he case, when he alue o σQis known, one can ake ˆσn=σQand Pn(λ) = σQ|λ|2 nn−1. Theo em 2 Fo any n≥2and 0< δ < 1 2, he obus isks de ined in he Eq. (4) o es ima e in he Eq. (19) o con inuously di e en iable unc ion Ssa is ies he o acle inequali y: R∗(S∗ λ∗, S)≤1+5δ 1−δmin λ∈ΛR∗(S∗ λ, S) + B∗ n nδ ,(20) whe e he e m B∗ nis independen o Sand such ha B∗ nn−→0as n→ ∞ o any  > 0. The inequali y in Eq. (20) allows us o es ablish ha he p ocedu e in he Eq. (19) is op imal in he o acle inequali ies sense. This p ope y enables o p o ide asymp o ic e iciency in he adap i e se ing, i.e. when in o ma ion abou he signal egula i y is unknown. 4. Asymp o ic E iciency In o de o s udy he asymp o ic e iciency, we de ine he ollowing unc ional Sobole ball: Wk, =( ∈Ck p[0,1] : k X i=0    (i)   2≤ ),(21) whe e > 0and k≥1a e some unknown pa ame e s, Ck p[0,1] is he space o k imes di e en iable 1-pe iodic unc ions such ha o any 0≤i≤k−1 : (i)(0) = (i)(1). In o de o o mula e ou asymp o ic esul s we se : n=n ξ∗, lk( ) = ((2k+ 1) )1 (2k+1) k π(k+ 1)2k (2k+1) (22) and we deno e by Σno all es ima es ˆ Sno Smea- su able wi h espec o he σ-algeb a gene a ed by he p ocess in he Eq. (1). Theo em 3 The obus isk de ined in he Eq. (4) ad- mi s he ollowing asymp o ic lowe bound: lim in n→∞ in ˆ Sn∈Σn 2k/(2k+1) nsup S∈Wk, R∗ˆ Sn, S≥lk( ). (23) c 2019 ADVANCES IN ELECTRICAL AND ELECTRONIC ENGINEERING 272 INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIES AND SERVICES VOLUME: 17 |NUMBER: 3 |2019 |SEPTEMBER This lowe bound is sha p in he ollowing sense. Theo em 4 The obus isk de ined in he Eq. (4) o he es ima ing p ocedu e in he Eq. (19) has he ollow- ing asymp o ic uppe bound: lim sup n→∞ 2k/(2k+1) nsup S∈Wk, R∗(S∗, S)≤lk( ).(24) Theo em 3 and Thm. 4 imply ha he model selec ion p ocedu e S∗is e icien and he pa ame e lk( )de- ined in he Eq. (22) is he Pinske cons an in his case [3]. 5. Mon e Ca lo Simula ions In his sec ion, we epo he esul s o a Mon e Ca lo expe imen o assess he pe o mance o he p oposed model selec ion p ocedu e in he Eq. (19). In he Eq. (1) we choose 1-pe iodic unc ion Swhich is de ined as S( ) = sin(2π ) + 2(1 − ) cos(2π ), o 0≤ ≤1. We simula e he Eq. (1) wi h he noise p ocess de ined as: dξ =−ξ d + 0.5dw + 0.5dz ,(25) whe e z = N P j=1 Yj,N is a Poisson p ocess wi h he in ensi y λ= 1 and (Yj)j≥1is i.i.d. Gaussian (0,1). We use he model selec ion p ocedu e de ined in he Eq. (19) wi h he weigh s p oposed in [8]: k∗= 100 + √ln n,=1 ln nand m=1 2. We used he cos unc ion wi h δ= (3 + ln n)−2. We de ine he em- pi ical isk as ¯ R˜ S, S=1 p p P j=1 ˆ E˜ Sn( j)−S( j)2 and ˆ E˜ Sn(·)−S(·)2=1 N N P l=1 ˜ Sl n(·)−S(·)2wi h he equency o obse a ions p= 100001 and numbe s o eplica ions N= 10000. Table 1 gi es he alues o he sample isks o di - e en numbe s o obse a ion pe iod n. Tab. 1: Empi ical isks. n¯ R˜ S, S¯ R(S∗, S)¯ R˜ S, S/¯ R(S∗, S) 100 0.0457 0.0289 1.6 200 0.0216 0.0089 2.4 500 0.0133 0.0021 6.3 1000 0.098 0.0011 8.9 6. Conclusion In his pape , we conside ed he p oblem o nonpa a- me ic signal p ocessing on he basis o he obse a- ions wi h he dependen non-Gaussian impulse noises. We de eloped adap i e e icien s a is ical model selec- ion p ocedu es based on he sh inkage me hods and we ha e shown ha he sh inkage es ima ion me hods con- side ably imp o e he non-asymp o ic es ima ion accu- acy. The ob ained heo e ical esul s a e con i med by he nume ical simula ion. I u ns ou ha nume ically he imp o emen e ec may inc ease 10 imes. Nex , o he de eloped s a is ical me hods we ob ained he adap i e e iciency p ope y, which means ha we p o- ide he bes mean squa es accu acy wi hou using he smoo hness in o ma ion abou he o m o unknown signal. Mo eo e , in his pape , we s udied he accu- acy p ope ies o he p oposed me hods on he basis o he obus app oach, i.e. uni o mly o e all possible unknown noise dis ibu ions. This allows us o syn- hesize he s a is ical algo i hms possessing he high noise immuni y p ope ies. The esul s ( hei sa is ac- o y conco dance wi h he co esponding expe imen al da a) can be used o he es ima ion o he signals. Such p oblems a e o a g ea impo ance in he ields o adio-and-hyd oacous ic communica ions and posi- ioning, adio-and-hyd oloca ion, e c. (see [12] and e - e ences he ein). Acknowledgmen The esul s o his wo k a e suppo ed by he Min- is y o Science and Highe Educa ion o he Russian Fede a ion in he amewo k o he esea ch p ojec no. 2.3208.2017/4.6. The second au ho is pa ially suppo ed by he Russian Fede al P o esso P og am, p ojec no. 1.472.2016/1.4 (Minis y o Science and Highe Educa ion o he Russian Fede a ion) and by he p ojec X e M-Fede , Uni e si y o Rouen. The esul s o Sec. 4. and Sec. 5. a e suppo ed by he RSF g an numbe 17-11-01049. Re e ences [1] IBRAGIMOV, I. A. and R. Z. KHASMINSKII. S a is ical Es ima ion: Asymp o ic Theo y. 1s ed. New Yo k: Sp inge , 1981. ISBN 978-1-4899-0027- 2. [2] KASSAM, S. A. Signal De ec ion in Non- Gaussian Noise. 1s ed. New Yo k: Sp inge , 1988. ISBN 978-1-4612-3834-8. [3] CHERNOYAROV, O. V., M. VACULIK, A. SHIRIKYAN and A. V. SALNIKOVA. S a is- ical Analysis o Fas Fluc ua ing Random Signals wi h A bi a y - Func ion En elope and Unknown Pa ame e s. Communica ions - Scien i ic Le e s o he Uni e si y o Zilina. 2015, ol. 17, no. 1a, pp. 35–43. ISSN 1335-4205. c 2019 ADVANCES IN ELECTRICAL AND ELECTRONIC ENGINEERING 273 INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIES AND SERVICES VOLUME: 17 |NUMBER: 3 |2019 |SEPTEMBER [4] CONT, R. and P. TANKOV. Financial Modelling wi h Jump P ocesses. 1s ed. Boca Ra on: Chap- man & Hall, 2003. ISBN 1-58488-413-4. [5] PCHELINTSEV, E., V. PCHELINTSEV and S. PERGAMENSHCHIKOV. Non asymp o ic sha p o acle inequali ies o he imp o ed model selec ion p ocedu es o he adap i e nonpa ame - ic signal es ima ion p oblem. Communica ions - Scien i ic Le e s o he Uni e si y o Zilina. 2018, ol. 20, no. 1, pp. 72–76. ISSN 1335-4205. [6] HOPFNER, R. and Y. A. KUTOYANTS. On LAN o pa ame ized con inuous pe iodic sig- nals in a ime-inhomogeneous di usion. S a is i- cal Decisions. 2009, ol. 27, iss. 4, pp. 309–326. ISSN 0721-2631. DOI: 10.1524/s nd.2009.1064. [7] HOPFNER, R. and Y. A. KUTOYANTS. Es i- ma ing discon inuous pe iodic signals in a ime- inhomogeneous di usion. S a is ical In e ence o S ochas ic P ocesses. 2010, ol. 13, iss. 3, pp. 193– 230. ISSN 1387-0874. DOI: 10.1007/s11203-010- 9046-7. [8] KONEV, V. V. and S. PERGAMENSHCHIKOV. E icien obus nonpa ame ic es ima ion in a semima ingale eg ession model. Annales de l’Ins i u Hen i Poinca e (B) P obabili y and S a is ics. 2012, ol. 48, no. 4, pp. 1217–1244. ISSN 0246-0203. DOI: 10.1214/12-AIHP488. [9] KONEV, V. V. and S. PERGAMENSHCHIKOV. Robus model selec ion o a semima ingale con inuous ime eg ession om disc e e da a. S ochas ic P ocesses and hei Applica ions. 2015, ol. 125, iss. 1, pp. 294-326. ISSN 0304-4149. DOI: 10.1016/j.spa.2014.08.003. [10] KONEV, V. V., S. PERGAMENSHCHIKOV and E. PCHELINTSEV. Es ima ion o a eg ession wi h he pulse ype noise om disc e e da a. Theo y o P obabili y and I s Applica ions. 2014, ol. 58, iss. 3, pp. 442–457. ISSN 0040-585X. DOI: 10.1137/S0040585X9798662X. [11] PCHELINTSEV, E. Imp o ed es ima ion in a non-Gaussian pa ame ic eg ession. S a- is ical In e ence o S ochas ic P ocesses. 2013, ol. 16, iss. 1, pp. 15–28. ISSN 1387-0874. DOI: 10.1007/s11203-013-9075-0. [12] CHERNOYAROV, O. V., Y. A. KUTOYANTS and M. MARCOKOVA. On equency es ima ion o pa ially obse ed sys em wi h small noises in s a e and obse a ion equa ions. Communica ions - Scien i ic Le e s o he Uni e si y o Zilina. 2018, ol. 20, no. 1, pp. 66–71. ISSN 1335-4205. Abou Au ho s E geny PCHELINTSEV was bo n in Alma y, Kazakhs an. He ecei ed his M.Sc. in Ma hema ics om Tomsk S a e Uni e si y in 2009, Ph.D. in Applied Ma hema ics and S a is ics om Tomsk S a e Uni e si y and Rouen Uni e si y in 2012. His esea ch in e es s include s a is ical modelling and iden i ica ion o s ochas ic dynamic sys ems, so compu ing, and simula ion. Se guei PERGAMENSHCHIKOV was bo n in Tomsk, Russia. He ecei ed his M.Sc. om Tomsk S a e Uni e si y in 1980, Ph.D. in P obabili y Theo y and S a is ics om Tomsk S a e Uni e si y in 1986, Doc o o Sciences in Ma hema ics om Cen al Economics and Ma hema ics Ins i u e o RAS in 1994. His esea ch in e es s include s a is ical modelling and iden i ica ion o s ochas ic dynamic sys ems, s ochas ic di e en ial equa ions, op imiza ion, and con ol. Ma iana MARCOKOVA was bo n in T en- cianska Tepla, Slo ak Republic. She ecei ed he Mas e deg ee in eache aining o ma hema ics and physics a Comenius Uni e si y in B a isla a, Slo ak Republic in 1970. Since 1970 she wo ked as a eache o ma hema ics a se e al ma hema ical depa men s a Uni e si y o Zilina, Slo ak Republic ( o me he Uni e si y o T anspo in Zilina), in he las 25 yea s as an associa e p o esso o ma hema ics and in he las 5 yea s also as he associa e p o esso a Moscow Powe Enginee ing Ins i u e, Russia. A e doc o al s udies in ma hema ical analysis a Palacky Uni e si y in Olomouc, Czech Republic, she ob ained he deg ees: RND . and CSc. He esea ch in e es s include special unc ions, o hogonal polynomials, and applied ma hema ics. c 2019 ADVANCES IN ELECTRICAL AND ELECTRONIC ENGINEERING 274