Final pre-40s maturation depends on the functional integrity of the 60s subunit ribosomal protein l3

Final Pre-40S Maturation Depends on the Functional Integrity of the 60S Subunit Ribosomal Protein L3 Juan J. Garcı ´a-Go ´mez 1 , Antonio Ferna ´ndez-Pevida 1. , Simon Lebaron 2. ,Iva ´n V. Rosado 1 , David Tollervey 2 , Dieter Kressler 3 , Jesu ´s de la Cruz 1 * 1Departamento de Gene ´tica, Universidad de Sevilla, and Instituto de Biomedicina de Sevilla, Hospital Universitario Virgen del Rocı ´o/CSIC/Universidad de Sevilla, Seville, Spain, 2Wellcome Trust Centre for Cell Biology, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom, 3Unit of Biochemistry, Department of Biology, University of Fribourg, Fribourg, Switzerland Abstract Ribosomal protein L3 is an evolutionarily conserved protein that participates in the assembly of early pre-60S particles. We report that the rpl3[W255C] allele, which affects the affinity and function of translation elongation factors, impairs cytoplasmic maturation of 20S pre-rRNA. This was not seen for other mutations in or depletion of L3 or other 60S ribosomal proteins. Surprisingly, pre-40S particles containing 20S pre-rRNA form translation-competent 80S ribosomes, and translation inhibition partially suppresses 20S pre-rRNA accumulation. The GTP-dependent translation initiation factor Fun12 (yeast eIF5B) shows similar in vivo binding to ribosomal particles from wild-type and rpl3[W255C] cells. However, the GTPase activity of eIF5B failed to stimulate processing of 20S pre-rRNA when assayed with ribosomal particles purified from rpl3[W255C] cells. We conclude that L3 plays an important role in the function of eIF5B in stimulating 39end processing of 18S rRNA in the context of 80S ribosomes that have not yet engaged in translation. These findings indicate that the correct conformation of the GTPase activation region is assessed in a quality control step during maturation of cytoplasmic preribosomal particles. Citation: Garcı ´a-Go ´mez JJ, Ferna ´ndez-Pevida A, Lebaron S, Rosado IV, Tollervey D, et al. (2014) Final Pre-40S Maturation Depends on the Functional Integrity of the 60S Subunit Ribosomal Protein L3. PLoS Genet 10(3): e1004205. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1004205 Editor: Jonathan Warner, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, United States of America Received June 4, 2013; Accepted January 13, 2014; Published March 6, 2014 Copyright: ß2014 Garcı ´a-Go ´mez et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. Funding: This work was supported by grants from the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (MICINN) and FEDER (BFU2010-15690) and the Andalusian Government (CVI-271, P08-CVI-03508) to JdlC, from the Wellcome Trust (077248) to DT and the Swiss National Science Foundation (PP00P3_123341) to DK. JJGG is a recipient of a FPI fellowship from the MICINN. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist. * E-mail: [email protected] .These authors contributed equally to this work. Introduction Ribosomes are very intricate ribonucleoprotein particles that catalyse protein synthesis. In all organisms, ribosomes are composed of two ribosomal subunits (r-subunits), the large one (60S, LSU) being about twice the size of the small one (40S, SSU) [1,2]. In eukaryotes, synthesis of ribosomes is a multicomponent, multistep process that is highly compartmentalised (for reviews, see [3–5]). Most ribosome maturation reactions take place in the nucleolus, but later steps occur in the nucleoplasm and cytoplasm [6–8]. Although evolutionary conserved throughout eukaryotes, ribosome biogenesis has been best studied in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. In the yeast nucleolus, the mature 18S, 5.8S and 25S rRNAs are transcribed as a single large precursor rRNA (prerRNA) that undergoes both co-transcriptional and post-transcriptional processing [9]. Concomitant with processing, the pre-RNAs undergo RNA modification and folding, association with transacting factors, and assembly with 5S rRNA and most ribosomal proteins (r-proteins) to form pre-ribosomal particles. The yeast pre-rRNA processing pathway is well-characterised [10] (see Figure S1). Among the pre-rRNA processing reactions, cleavage at site A 2 is special since it separates the intermediates on the LSU and SSU synthesis pathway, which apparently follow independent nuclear maturation. Correct nuclear maturation of pre-ribosomal particles leads to the recruitment of export factors and acquisition of export competence. Incorrectly assembled pre-ribosomal particles are strongly retained in the nucle(ol)us and are targeted to degradation (for examples, see [11,12] and references therein). Cytoplasmic pre-ribosomal particles undergo final maturation before becoming translationally active [8,13]. Cytoplasmic maturation of pre-60S particles involves pre-rRNA processing of the 6S pre-rRNA to mature 5.8S rRNA [6] and the dissociation and recycling of several export and assembly factors by an ordered series of linked ATPaseand GTPase-dependent steps [8,14]. Among these factors are Tif6 and Nmd3, which are proposed to impede joining of pre-60S with mature 40S r-subunits [15,16]; thus, they should be removed before mature 60S r-subunits enter translation. Concomitant with this, the assembly of several rproteins occurs, amongst them P0 (also P0 in the new proposed nomenclature of r-proteins [17]), L10 (L16), L24 (L24e) and L40 (L40e). During cytoplasmic maturation of pre-40S particles, Dim1 dimethylates two consecutive, conserved adenines at the 39end of the 18S rRNA [18], followed by Nob1-dependent cleavage of the 20S pre-rRNA at site D to produce the mature 18S rRNA 39end [7,19]. Late-acting factors associated with the cytoplasmic pre-40S particles may prevent premature association with translation PLOS Genetics | www.plosgenetics.org 1 March 2014 | Volume 10 | Issue 3 | e1004205 initiation factors, mRNA, initiator tRNA, and mature 60S rsubunits [20]. Only a few 40S r-proteins are thought to stably assemble in the cytoplasm, and these are likely to include S3 (S3), S10 (S10e) and S26 (S26e) [21]. We are interested in understanding the contribution of specific 60S r-proteins to ribosome biogenesis. L3 is an evolutionarily conserved protein that contains two tightly packed globular domains bound on the solvent side of the LSU, close to the binding region for GTP-dependent translation factors. Moreover, L3 contains two extensions that enter deep into the central core of the LSU and are very close to the peptidyl transferase center (PTC) (Figure S2) [2,17]. Dinman and coworkers have extensively studied the role of yeast L3 in ribosome function and revealed that it modulates translation elongation by coordinating both the accommodation of charged tRNAs and the binding of elongation factor 2 (eEF2) (e.g. [22,23]). We have previously undertaken the analysis of L3 in yeast ribosome synthesis. Our results indicate that L3 has an essential role in the formation of early pre-60S rparticles [24]. To further study the role of L3 in ribosome synthesis, we have analysed the phenotypic effects of a collection of viable rpl3 point mutants. Herein, we show that, unexpectedly, the rpl3[W255C] mutation leads to the accumulation of translationcompetent cytoplasmic pre-40S r-particles containing the 20S prerRNA. These in vivo results unequivocally demonstrate the requirement of the 60S r-subunit for efficient 20S pre-rRNA processing. Two recent studies have revealed that 20S pre-rRNA cleavage to mature 18S rRNA might require the association of pre-40S r-particles with the yeast translation initiation factor eIF5B/Fun12 and the 60S r-subunit to form an 80S-like complex [25,26]. In agreement with these reports, our results demonstrate that despite the fact that in vivo yeast eIF5B associates with similar efficiency to wild-type and L3[W255C] containing ribosomes, its GTPase activity is unable to stimulate processing of 20S pre-rRNA in rpl3[W255C] cells. Taking into account that the L3[W255C] mutant protein alters the structure of the 60S r-subunits [27] and the in vitro affinity of ribosomes for the elongation factors eEF1 and eEF2 [23], we postulate that the correct conformation of the binding site of ribosome-dependent GTPases is used as a quality control step to ensure proper maturation of cytoplasmic preribosomal particles. Results The rpl3[W255C] mutation impairs processing of 20S prerRNA into mature 18S rRNA To define better the role of L3 in the normal accumulation of 60S r-subunits, we studied the phenotypes of selected rpl3 point mutations (Figure S2A). The rpl3[K30E] and rpl3[Q371H] mutations were found to be synthetically lethal with mutants of genes encoding components of the Dpb6-containing subcomplex [28,29]. The rpl3[W255C], rpl3[P257T], rpl3[I282T] and rpl3[W255C, P257T] mutations have been reported to affect different translation properties [22,23,30]. All these mutant proteins support growth as the sole source of L3, although not at wild-type levels, and are recessive (Figure S3, and data not shown). We next examined the polysome profiles of the different mutants grown at 23uC relative to an isogenic wild-type strain. As shown in Figure 1, the rpl3[K30E], rpl3[Q371H] and rpl3[P257T] mutants clearly displayed profiles consistent with a deficit of 60S rsubunits. Notably is the appearance of polysome halfmers (indicated with arrows in Figure 1), which reflect formation of 43S pre-initiation complexes that are not bound by 60S r-subunits. Moreover, the rpl3[I282T] mutant apparently has a mild translation initiation defect. Unexpectedly, both the single rpl3[W255C] and the double rpl3[W255C, P257T] mutants displayed a clear deficit in free 40S relative to 60S r-subunits. This finding was not previously reported for the original mak8-1 mutant, which consists of the double rpl3 mutation W255C P257T [31]. Northern analyses were used to determine whether the polysome profiles obtained for the rpl3[W255C] and the rpl3[W255C, P257T] mutants correlated with defects in prerRNA processing or rRNA accumulation. Comparison of total RNA isolated from the rpl3 mutants and the isogenic wild-type strain revealed only slight differences in the levels of most prerRNAs in rpl3 mutants (Figure 2). The exception was a dramatic accumulation of 20S pre-rRNA in the rpl3[W255C] and rpl3[W255C, P257T] mutants, accompanied by modest reductions in mature 18S rRNA accumulation. These phenotypes were similar to those observed in the previously characterised rps14A[R136A] mutant, which served as a positive control for 20S pre-rRNA accumulation [32]. We conclude that, unexpectedly for a specific mutation in a 60S r-subunit protein, the mutation rpl3[W255C] leads to a 40S r-subunit biogenesis deficit due to a defect in 20S pre-rRNA processing. The rpl3[W255C] mutant accumulates 20S pre-rRNA in the cytoplasm Processing of the 20S pre-rRNA occurs in the cytoplasm [7], so a defect in 20S pre-rRNA processing might result from either reduced export of pre-40S particles or impaired cleavage of cytoplasmic 20S pre-rRNA. To assess pre-40S export, we analysed the subcellular localisation of the 40S r-subunit reporter S2-eGFP in wild-type and rpl3[W255C] cells. As shown in Figure 3A and Figure S4, both S2-eGFP and the 60S r-subunit reporter L25eGFP were almost exclusively cytoplasmic in both wild-type and rpl3[W255C] cells. We also visualised the 20S pre-rRNA and its precursors by FISH using a probe complementary to the 59region of ITS1. In the wild-type strain, the FISH signal was predominantly nucleolar with a faint cytoplasmic signal (Figure 3B). This Author Summary Recent progress has provided us with detailed knowledge of the structure and function of eukaryotic ribosomes. However, our understanding of the intricate processes of pre-ribosome assembly and the transition to translationcompetent ribosomal subunits remains incomplete. The early and intermediate steps of ribosome assembly occur successively in the nucleolus and nucleoplasm. The preribosomal subunits are then exported to the cytoplasm where final maturation steps, notably including D site cleavage of the 20S pre-rRNA to mature 18S rRNA, confer subunit joining and translation competence. Recent evidence indicates that pre-40S subunits are subject to a quality control step involving the GTP-dependent translation initiation factor eIF5B/Fun12, in the context of 80S-like ribosomes. Here, we demonstrate the involvement of 60S subunits in promoting 20S pre-rRNA cleavage. In particular, we show that a specific point mutation in the 60S subunit ribosomal protein L3 (rpl3[W255C]) leads to the accumulation of pre-40S particles that contain the 20S prerRNA but are translation-competent. Notably, this mutation prevents the stimulation of the GTPase activity of eIF5B/Fun12, which is also required for site D cleavage. We conclude that L3 plays an important role in regulating the function of eIF5B/Fun12 during 39end processing of 18S rRNA at site D, in the context of 80S ribosomes that have not yet engaged in translation. 40S Maturation Requires the 60S Ribosomal Subunit PLOS Genetics | www.plosgenetics.org 2 March 2014 | Volume 10 | Issue 3 | e1004205 was expected, since the 20S pre-rRNA is rapidly converted to mature 18S rRNA following export of pre-40S particles to the cytoplasm. However, in the rpl3[W255C] mutant, the signal was substantially stronger and predominantly cytoplasmic, indicating that the unprocessed 20S pre-rRNA accumulated in the cytoplasm of rpl3[W255C] cells. The 20S pre-rRNA is dimethylated at the 39 end of 18S rRNA by Dim1 following export and prior to cleavage [33]. Primer-extension is blocked by the presence of the dimethylation, which was clearly present in 20S pre-rRNA of rpl3[W255C] cells (Figure 3C), confirming that the block in maturation occurs following export. We conclude that the 20S pre-rRNA is exported from the nucleus but fails to be efficiently processed in the cytoplasm in rpl3[W255C] cells. Identical results were obtained in analyses of rpl3[W255C] yeast strains derived from W303 or BY4741, showing our findings to be independent of genetic background and any secondary mutation(s) (data not shown). The accumulated 20S pre-rRNA gets incorporated into translating ribosomes We previously reported that pre-40S r-particles containing the 20S pre-rRNA could be efficiently incorporated into translating ribosomes in ubi3Dub mutant cells [34]. In contrast, pre-40S rparticles are not found in polysomes in wild-type cells or in most mutants that accumulate cytoplasmic 20S pre-rRNA [25,32,35,36]. Interestingly, pre-40S r-particles can engage with mRNAs and 60S subunits but are unable to efficiently elongate in cells depleted of Rio1 or Nob1, or expressing S14A[R136A] [25,36,37]. To assess whether the pre-40S r-particles accumulated in rpl3[W255C] cells engage in translation, the distribution of the 20S pre-rRNA in polysome gradients was determined by northern blotting and compared to the wild type and cells expressing L3[Q371H] or S14A[R136A] (Figure 4). In wild-type and rpl3[Q371H] mutant cells, 20S pre-rRNA co-migrated with the 40S r-subunit peak. In rps14A[R136A] cells, the 20S pre-rRNA accumulated in the 80S peak, whereas the rpl3[W255C] mutant showed 20S pre-rRNA in complexes of high molecular weight that co-sedimented with polysomes. To confirm that the slowly sedimenting 20S pre-rRNA containing particles were not simply aggregates, cell extracts were prepared under polysome run-off conditions (omission of cycloheximide) either in standard buffer or in a buffer lacking MgCl 2 (which causes dissociation of 80S couples into 40S and 60S r-subunits). In the absence of cycloheximide, the 20S pre-rRNA was shifted from the high molecular weight fractions to the 80S fractions in the presence of MgCl 2 or to 40S fractions in the absence of MgCl 2 (Figure S5). Moreover, quantification of the 20S/18S and 20S/25S ratios showed similar values for each polysomal fraction in Figure 4, indicating that the accumulated, 20S pre-rRNA containing pre-40S r-particles are competent for both translation initiation and elongation (data not shown). We conclude that the presence of L3[W255C] in the 60S r-subunits leads to the accumulation of pre-40S particles that assemble into 80S ribosomes and are competent for translation elongation. Translation modulates the accumulation of 20S pre-rRNA in rpl3[W255C] cells We assessed whether translation influences the accumulation of pre-40S r-particles in the rpl3[W255C] mutant (Figure 5). Protein synthesis was inhibited by treatment of wild-type and rpl3[W255C] strains with 0.8 mg/ml cycloheximide (the lowest concentration that arrested growth). As shown in Figure 5A, cycloheximide treatment for 6 h did not significantly affect steady-state levels of mature 25S and 18S rRNA in the wild-type or the rpl3[W255C] strain and resulted in only a minor accumulation of 35S pre-rRNA in wild-type cells. Cycloheximide also had little effect on 20S pre-rRNA levels in the wild-type strain, whereas a 2-fold reduction Figure 1. The rpl3 [W255C] mutation results in a deficit in 40S ribosomal subunits. Strain JDY319 (rpl3::HIS3MX6) expressing either wildtype RPL3 or the indicated rpl3 alleles, harboured on the plasmid YCplac111, were grown in YPD at 23uC to exponential phase. Cell extracts were prepared and 10 A 260 of each extract were resolved on 7–50% sucrose gradients. The A 254 was continuously measured. Sedimentation is from left to right. The peaks of 40S, 60S, 80S and polysomes are indicated. Half-mers are labelled by arrows. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1004205.g001 40S Maturation Requires the 60S Ribosomal Subunit PLOS Genetics | www.plosgenetics.org 3 March 2014 | Volume 10 | Issue 3 | e1004205 was already observed 1 h after cycloheximide addition to rpl3[W255C] cells. To discard any indirect effect of the cycloheximide treatment, we blocked translation initiation by using a cdc33– 42 mutant, in which Cdc33/eIF4E is defective in recognition of the cap structure of mRNAs during translation initiation [38]. As shown in Figure 5B, in the cdc33–42 rpl3[W255C] double mutant, the 20S pre-rRNA levels again decreased about 3-fold in comparison to those from an isogenic rpl3[W255C] single mutant, while the 20S pre-rRNA levels in the cdc33–42 single mutant were similar to those of the wild type strain. The fraction of ribosomes engaged in translation is much lower in slow-growing than in fast-growing cells [39]. Consistently, when wild-type and rpl3[W255C] cells were cultivated in different media, we found a clear correlation between the measured doubling times and the levels of accumulation of 20S pre-rRNA in the rpl3[W255C] strain (Figure 5C and Table S4). Thus, fast-growing cells accumulated about 4-fold more 20S prerRNA than slow-growing cells. These data indicate that 20S prerRNA accumulation in rpl3[W255C] cells is promoted by active translation, suggesting that 20S pre-rRNA processing and/or decay is prevented in pre-40S r-particles engaged in translation. Fun12/eIF5B bound to 60S subunits containing L3[W255C] does not stimulate 20S pre-rRNA processing in vitro Fun12 (the yeast homologue of eIF5B) is a GTPase required for binding of initiator tRNA and r-subunit joining during translation initiation [40]. In addition, Fun12/eIF5B is required for efficient 20S pre-rRNA processing [26,41], which requires binding of Fun12/eIF5B to pre-40S r-particles and mature 60S r-subunits [25,26]. To assess binding of Fun12 to 60S r-subunits containing L3[W255C], we expressed a fully functional genomically integrated Fun12-TAP construct [42] in wild-type and rpl3[W255C] cells and performed immunoprecipitation experiments with IgGSepharose. As shown in Figure 6A, western blot analysis indicated that Fun12-TAP co-precipitates Nob1 and r-proteins from both rsubunits to the same extent in both strains. Furthermore, Northern hybridisation showed that Fun12-TAP co-precipitated similar levels of 20S pre-rRNA and mature 25S rRNAs relative to the levels of their respective inputs in cells of both strains (Figure 6B). As previously reported [26], Fun12 also co-precipitated nuclear 35S, 32S and 27S pre-rRNAs. The significance of this is unclear, but more efficient association with these species was observed in wild-type compared to rpl3[W255C] cells. Since Fun12/eIF5B coprecipitates several pre-rRNAs, we studied the association of TAPtagged Fun12/eIF5B with pre-ribosomal particles by sucrose gradient analysis. As shown in Figure S6A, Fun12-TAP is enriched in the low-molecular-mass fractions, in free 40S r-subunits, 80S and polysomes. In agreement with our previous results, the sedimentation pattern of Fun12-TAP was similar in cell extracts of wild-type and rpl3[W255C] cells. Likewise, analysis of the sedimentation pattern of fully functional N-terminal PTH-tagged Nob1 in sucrose gradients showed that PTH-Nob1 is enriched in Figure 2. The rpl3 [W255C] mutant accumulates 20S pre-rRNA. The wild-type and the rpl3 mutants described in the Figure 1 and the rps14A[R136A] strain were exponentially grown in YPD medium at 23uC. Total RNA was prepared and equal amounts of RNA (5 mg) were subjected to Northern blot hydridisation. A. Northern blot analysis of high-molecular weight preand mature rRNAs. Note that two exposure times are shown to better visualize differences in 20S pre-rRNA levels. B. Northern blot analysis of low-molecular weight preand mature rRNAs. Signal intensities were measured by phosphorimager scanning; values (indicated below each panel) were normalized to those obtained for the wild-type control, arbitrarily set at 1.0. Probes, between parentheses, are described in Figure S1A and Table S3. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1004205.g002 40S Maturation Requires the 60S Ribosomal Subunit PLOS Genetics | www.plosgenetics.org 4 March 2014 | Volume 10 | Issue 3 | e1004205 Figure 3. The 20S pre-rRNA accumulates in the cytoplasm of rpl3 [W255C] cells. A. Wild-type and rpl3[W255C] cells expressing either L25-eGFP or S2-eGFP were exponentially grown in SD-Ura at 23uC. The GFP signal was analysed by fluorescence microscopy. B. Wild-type and rpl3[W255C] cells were grown in YPD at 23uC. Cells were fixed with formaldehyde, spheroblasted, and subjected to FISH using a Cy3-labelled probe complementary to the D/A 2 segment of ITS1 (Table S3). DAPI staining visualises the nucleoplasm. C. Levels of dimethylated 20S pre-rRNA in the wildtype strain and the rpl3[W255C] and rpl3[Q371H] mutants. RNA was extracted from cells of these strains following exponential growth in YPD at 23uC and analysed by primer extension with probe c (Figure S1 and Table S3). The position of the primer extension stops due to the presence of the modifications is indicated. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1004205.g003 Figure 4. 20S pre-rRNA containing 40S subunits get incorporated into polysomes in rpl3 [W255C] cells. The wild-type strain and the rpl3[W255C], rpl3[Q371H] and rps14A[R136A] mutants were grown in YPD at 23uC. Cell extracts were prepared and 8 A 260 units of each extract were resolved in 7–50% sucrose gradients and fractionated. RNA was extracted from each fraction and analysed by Northern blotting using probes c, h and b, which reveal 20S pre-rRNA and mature 25S and 18S rRNAs, respectively. The position of free 40S and 60S ribosomal subunits, 80S ribosomes and polysomes are shown. T stands for RNA from total extract. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1004205.g004 40S Maturation Requires the 60S Ribosomal Subunit PLOS Genetics | www.plosgenetics.org 5 March 2014 | Volume 10 | Issue 3 | e1004205 the low-molecular-mass region and free 40S r-subunit fractions of the gradient with a weaker peak around 80S to 90S in wild-type cells. This sedimentation pattern was also similar for wild-type and rpl3[W255C] cells (Figure S6B). We conclude that the binding of Fun12/eIF5B and Nob1 to 80S-like r-particles is not significantly altered in rpl3[W255C] cells. In vitro cleavage of 20S pre-rRNA by the endonuclease Nob1 is stimulated by addition of ATP or GTP, and Fun12/eIF5B was identified as the relevant GTPase [26]. We used this assay to determine whether L3 directly contributes to 20S pre-rRNA cleavage. To this end, we purified pre-ribosomal particles from cells expressing L3 or L3[W255C] via N-terminally PTH-tagged Nob1, which co-purifies both free pre-40S r-particles and pre-40S60S complexes [26]. The stimulation of 20S pre-rRNA processing upon addition of ATP or GTP was assessed by primer extension (Figure 7). As controls, pre-ribosomes were also purified from cells expressing L3[K30E] and rsa3Dcells; both mutations reduce 60S r-subunit accumulation to a similar extent, but do not lead to 20S pre-rRNA accumulation ([29], and Figure 2). Nob1, like other PIN-domain nucleases, requires Mn 2+ for efficient in vitro cleavage (see ref. [19] and references therein). During the incubations required for purification of the pre-ribosomes, cleavage is inhibited by the use of buffers containing only Mg 2+ . Cleavage is then activated at time 0 by addition of Mn 2+ plus the relevant nucleotide. However, Nob1 inhibition in the absence of added Mn 2+ is not complete, so the 0 min time point contains some level of pre-rRNA that has been cleaved at site D [26]. Thus, in our assays, the efficiency of cleavage was quantified relative to the signal at time 0. Moreover, the amount of 20S pre-rRNA that is recovered and available for cleavage is not the same for different mutants. In particular, the in vivo 20S pre-rRNA processing defect shown by rpl3[W255C] strains results in substantially higher recovery, as shown by the stronger primer extension stop at the 18S rRNA dimethylation sites at A 1781/1782 and the increased signal at site D at time 0. Since only a small fraction of the total 20S pre-rRNA is cleaved, even under optimal conditions, the primer extension stop at A 1781/1782 was used as a control for input to normalize between the different time points for each strain. Comparison of primer extension stops at site D and at A 1781/1782 in the 0 min samples, indicated that the fraction of the 20S prerRNA that was cleaved during pre-ribosome purification was similar in each sample (Figure S7). As shown in Figures 7A and 7B, addition of Mn 2+ plus ATP to pre-ribosomes purified from the wild-type cells increased the level of cleaved 20S pre-rRNA about 3.5-fold after 30 min incubation. Cleavage of 20S pre-rRNA in the presence of ATP was mildly reduced when r-particles were purified from rpl3[K30E], rpl3[W255C] or rsa3Dcells (only 2.5-fold stimulation at 30 min) probably reflecting the deficit in 60S r-subunit levels. In contrast, when cleavage was activated by addition of Mn 2+ plus GTP, the level of 20S pre-rRNA cleaved at site D was elevated around 2.5 fold in pre-ribosomes purified from the wild-type, rpl3[K30E], or rsa3Dstrains, whereas substantially less cleavage was observed for pre-ribosomes recovered form rpl3[W255C] cells (less than 1.5fold stimulation at 30 min) (Figures 7C and 7D). We conclude that impairment of 20S pre-rRNA processing in rpl3[W255C] cells is, at least, partially due to the inability of the GTP-dependent activity of Fun12/eIF5B to stimulate the Nob1 cleavage activity at site D. Since L3[W255C] protein is a component of 60S r-subunits, these data demonstrate that 20S pre-rRNA processing could occur in particles formed by pre-40S and pre-60S or mature 60S r-subunits. Figure 5. Translation rate modulates the levels of 20S pre-rRNA in rpl3 [W255C] cells. A. Inhibition of translation by cycloheximide treatment partially suppresses the 20S pre-rRNA processing defect of the rpl3[W255C] mutant. The wild-type strain and the rpl3[W255C] mutant were exponentially grown in YPD at 23uC. Cycloheximide (final concentration, 0.8 mg/ml) was added to the cultures and cells were harvested at the indicated times after the addition. B. Inhibition of translation initiation partially suppresses the 20S pre-rRNA processing defect of the rpl3[W255C] mutant. The indicated strains were grown exponentially in YPD medium at 30uC. C. The levels of 20S pre-rRNA are reduced in slowly growing rpl3[W255C] cells. The wild-type strain and the rpl3[W255C] mutant were grown at 23uC in either rich medium containing glucose (YPD), rich medium containing galactose (YPGal), minimal medium containing glucose (SD) or minimal medium containing glycerol and lactate as carbon source (SGly). In all cases, RNA was extracted and equal amounts of RNA (5 mg) subjected to Northern blot hybridisation as described in the legend of Figure 2. To quantify the relative amounts of pre-40S r-particles in the different conditions and mutants, the signal intensities for 20S pre-rRNA and 25S rRNA were measured by phosphorimager scanning. The 20S/25S ratios calculated were calculated and normalised to that obtained for the wild-type strain under the same conditions. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1004205.g005 40S Maturation Requires the 60S Ribosomal Subunit PLOS Genetics | www.plosgenetics.org 6 March 2014 | Volume 10 | Issue 3 | e1004205 The NOB1-TAP allele synthetically enhances the slowgrowth phenotype of the rpl3[W255C] mutant To test for functional interactions between L3 and Nob1, we combined the rpl3[W255C] mutation with the NOB1-TAP allele, which expresses Nob1 fused at its C-terminus with a TAP-tag. This nob1 allele also leads to a mild 20S pre-rRNA accumulation, in contrast to the PTH-NOB1 construct, which behaves like the wild type protein ([26], and data not shown). As shown in Figure 8, the NOB1-TAP allele specifically exacerbated the growth defect of the rpl3[W255C] mutant at both 23uCor30uC. Taken together with the results of the previous section, these data strongly suggest that the conformational changes of 60S r-subunits caused by the W255C mutation in L3 negatively affect the functionality of the Dsite endonuclease Nob1. Discussion Multiple steps in the translation cycle are mediated by ribosome-associated GTPases, including eIF5B/Fun12 (r-subunit joining), eEF1 and eEF2 (translation elongation), eEF3 (translation termination) and even Hbs1 (release of stalled ribosomes and NGD) (reviewed in [43]). Each of these associates with a common binding site in the 60S r-subunit, which is referred to as the GTPase-associated center. Recent reports have proposed that final maturation of cytoplasmic pre-40S r-particles is stimulated by association with Fun12 and mature 60S r-subunits [25,26]. Here, we demonstrate a functional link between formation of the correct structure in the GTPase-associated center region of 60S r-subunits and the stimulation of 20S pre-rRNA cleavage. L3 has been described as the ‘‘gatekeeper to the A-site’’ [23] and the L3[W255C] protein alters the structure of the 60S r-subunits [27] and the binding in vitro of elongation factors [23]. These results strongly suggest that the correct conformation of the domain forming the binding site for the ribosome-dependent GTPases is a prerequisite for final 40S r-subunit maturation. This model is outlined in Figure 9. Examination of the L3 structure within the 60S r-subunit (see Figure S2B) reveals that W255 is located at the tip of the internal ‘‘finger’’ that extends through the A-site to the PTC. Indeed, this residue makes the closest approach of any amino acid to the PTC site. Residue P257 induces a bend in the finger that helps position W255 [17,22,23,27]. Biochemical and molecular analyses show that L3 functions in binding of aminoacylated tRNAs and eEF2. Moreover, mutations in L3 affect peptidyl-transferase activity, antibiotic sensitivity and translation of RNA derived from the ‘‘killer’’ dsRNA virus (see [22,23] and references therein). The rpl3[W255C] allele was found to be functionally important as this mutation conferred resistance to anisomycin, decreased peptidyltransfer rate and increased programmed 21 r-frameshifting (21 PRF), leading to loss of the killer virus. All these phenotypes appear to result from increased affinity of ribosomes containing L3[W255C] for the eEF1-GTP-aminoacylated tRNA ternary complex and decreased affinity for eEF2 [22,23]. In the 80S ribosome structure, the W255 residue is about 12 nm away from the 39end of the 18S rRNA, making it unlikely to directly contact the 20S pre-rRNA processing machinery (see Figure S2B). It also appears unlikely that the reduced 20S cleavage in rpl3[W255C] strains is an indirect effect of reduced translation of (a) 20S prerRNA processing factor(s), since other rpl3 alleles (e.g. rpl3[P257T] and rpl3[I282T]) also result in strong anisomycin resistance, peptidyl-transferase inhibition and stimulation of 21 PRF [30] but do not impair 20S pre-rRNA processing or turnover (Figures 1 and 2). Therefore, the observed 20S pre-rRNA processing impairment in rpl3[W255C] cells is likely caused by the loss of proper interaction and/or function of a distinct trans-acting factor that stimulates the activity of the D-site endonuclease Nob1. In line with such a scenario, we observed that only the rpl3[W255C] mutation exacerbates the mild slow-growth phenotype of a NOB1TAP allele, which expresses a C-terminally TAP-tagged Nob1 protein (Figure 8). The observation that ribosomes containing L3[W255C] show alterations in the affinity and function of elongation factors eEF1 and eEF2 [22,23], suggested that functional interactions with Fun12/eIF5B might also be impaired. The structural homology between the eIF5B G-domains of Fun12/eIF5B, eEF1 and eEF2 Figure 6. The rpl3 [W255C] mutation does not significantly impair the association of Fun12 to pre-40S ribosomal particles and mature 60S ribosomal subunits. Immunoprecipitation was carried out using IgG-Sepharose in isogenic W303-1A strain (Fun12 Wild type), DY121 (Fun12-TAP Wild type) and JDY1025 (Fun12-TAP W255C). Cells were grown at 23uC in YPD to mid-log phase, lysed and total extracts were subjected to immunoprecipitation. A. Protein corresponding to 0.1% of each total extract (lanes T) and 1% of the immunoprecipitates (lanes IP) were subjected to SDS-PAGE and then analysed by Western blotting using specific antibodies. B. RNA was also extracted and 1% of each total extract (T) and 45% of the immunoprecipitates (IP) were subjected to Northern analysis. Pre-rRNAs and mature rRNAs were analysed by Northern blot hybridisation as described in the legend of Figure 2. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1004205.g006 40S Maturation Requires the 60S Ribosomal Subunit PLOS Genetics | www.plosgenetics.org 7 March 2014 | Volume 10 | Issue 3 | e1004205 Figure 7. In vitro processing of 20S pre-rRNA is impaired in the rpl3 [W255C] mutant. In vitro cleavage assays were performed with preribosomal particles purified via PTH-tagged Nob1 from different strains: wild-type (blue, circle), rpl3[W255C] (red, square), rpl3[K30E] (green, square) and rsa3D(purple, triangle). Purified particles were incubated in reaction buffer containing 1 mM ATP (A and B) or 1 mM GTP (C and D) for the indicated times (0, 2, 5, 10 and 30 min). RNA was extracted and cleavage at site D was analysed by primer extension with probe c’ (Figure S1 and Table S3). Representative primer extension analyses are shown (A and C). The strong upper stops result from termination at sites of 18S rRNA basedimethylation at A 1781 and A 1782 . These modifications precede site D cleavage in vivo. The black arrow indicates site D. Filled and empty dots indicate non-relevant primer extensions stops that were observed in some experiments (for further discussion, see [26]). Signal intensities were measured by phosphoimager scanning; values were corrected for RNA loading using the dimethylation signals as internal standards, normalised to the sample at the zero time-point, arbitrarily set at 1.0, and plotted (B and D). The average of 2 (B) and 4 (D) independent experiments is shown; the error bars indicate the standard deviation. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1004205.g007 Figure 8. Synthetic enhancement of the slow-growth phenotype of the rpl3 [W255C] mutant by the NOB1 -TAP allele. The strains YKL207 (NOB1) and YKL233 (NOB1-TAP) harbour the rpl3 null allele complemented by the pHT4467D-RPL3 plasmid and a wild-type NOB1 or NOB1TAP allele, respectively. The NOB1-TAP allele expresses a C-terminally TAP-tagged Nob1 protein. These strains were transformed with YCplac111 plasmids that carry either the wild-type RPL3 or the indicated mutant rpl3 alleles. After 5-FOA shuffling, cells were spotted in 10-fold serial dilution steps onto YPD plates, which were incubated for 2 days at 30uC or 3 days at 23uC. Note that the NOB1-TAP allele specifically synthetically enhances the growth defect of the rpl3[W255C] mutant. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1004205.g008 40S Maturation Requires the 60S Ribosomal Subunit PLOS Genetics | www.plosgenetics.org 8 March 2014 | Volume 10 | Issue 3 | e1004205 strongly indicates that these proteins interact similarly with the ribosome ([44], reviewed in [43,45]). The GTPase activity of Fun12 promotes r-subunit joining [40,46] and stimulates in vitro Nob1-dependent 20S pre-rRNA cleavage in purified pre-40S rparticles in conjunction with mature 60S r-subunits [26]. Stimulation of 20S pre-rRNA cleavage by GTP is lost in pre40S r-particles that were associated with 60S particles containing L3[W255C] (Figures 7C and 7D). Since Fun12 is responsible for GTP-mediated stimulation of 20S pre-rRNA cleavage in vitro [26], we conclude that Fun12 function (i.e. its GTP-hydrolysis dependent conformational change) is practically impaired in ribosomes containing L3[W255C]. This does not appear to be due to strongly reduced binding of Fun12 to 80S particles, since Fun12-TAP co-precipitated in vivo particles containing 20S prerRNA and 25S rRNA with similar efficiencies from wild-type and rpl3[W255C] cells (Figure 6). Fun12-TAP also co-precipitated 35S, 32S and 27S pre-rRNA species, and maturation of both 35S and 27S pre-rRNAs is delayed in a fun12Dstrain [26,41]. The rpl3[W255C] allele did not clearly alter 35S or 27S pre-rRNA processing (see Figure 2), but strongly reduced association of these pre-rRNA species with Fun12-TAP (Figure 6). The significance of the association of Fun12 with nuclear and nucleolar pre-ribosomes remains to be determined. In vitro, cleavage of 20S pre-rRNA in purified pre-40S r-particles is also activated by an ATP-binding Figure 9. Model for the conversion of 20S pre-rRNA into mature 18S rRNA within cytoplasmic pre-40S r-particles. A. In wild-type cells, immature pre-40S and pre-60S r-particles are transported through the channel of nuclear pore complexes to the cytoplasm. L3, which is incorporated into early pre-ribosomal particles in the nucleolus, is highlighted in pre-60S particles. Few assembly factors (AFs) remain associated with the particles as they enter the cytoplasm (e.g. Tif6 and Nob1). The release and recycling of these factors is concomitant to the assembly of a few remaining rproteins (RPs). The translation initiation factor eIF5B/Fun12 binds pre-40S r-particles and stimulates joining of the 60S r-subunits. Formation of the resulting 80S-like particle triggers Fun12 to hydrolyse its bound GTP, thereby presumably promoting its dissociation. We assume that GTP hydrolysis by Fun12 generates a relative movement of the head to the body of pre-40S r-particles that triggers the activation of Nob1 and, thus, the endonucleolytic cleavage of ITS1 at site D (discussed in [26]). Nob1 activity is also stimulated by a still unknown ATPase [26]. Wild-type 80S-like particles are not competent for translation; thus, the alternative fate to maturation is degradation. Final maturation of pre-60S r-particles includes 6S pre-rRNA processing to mature 5.8S rRNA (not shown). Note that the precise timing of most of the events shown in this cartoon has not yet been defined. B. In rpl3[W255C] cells, the conformational changes caused by the mutation W255C in L3 (white dot on the L3 drawing) might impair the GTP-dependent stimulation of 20S pre-rRNA processing exerted by Fun12/eIF5B within 80S-like particles. Our data also show that the 80S-like rparticles containing the L3[W255C] protein efficiently translate, thereby preventing their degradation. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1004205.g009 40S Maturation Requires the 60S Ribosomal Subunit PLOS Genetics | www.plosgenetics.org 9 March 2014 | Volume 10 | Issue 3 | e1004205