Polyethylene Nail Brace for Ingrown Toenails Treatment: A Randomized Clinical Trial

International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health Article Polyethylene Nail Brace for Ingrown Toenails Treatment: A Randomized Clinical Trial Salvador Márquez-Reina 1, Inmaculada Palomo-Toucedo 2, María Reina-Bueno 2, JoséManuel Castillo-López 2, Javier Ramos Ortega 2, César Calvo-Lobo 3, Daniel López-López 4,* and Gabriel Domínguez-Maldonado 2 1Nuestra Señora de la Oliva Foot Clinic, Bda. Ntra. Sra. de la Oliva Bq. 24, Bajo B, 41013 Sevilla, Spain; [email protected] 2Departamento de Podologia, Universidad de Sevilla, Calle Avicena, s/n, 41009 Sevilla, Spain; [email protected] (I.P.-T.); [email protected] (M.R.-B.); [email protected] (J.M.C.-L.); jr[email protected] (J.R.O.); [email protected] (G.D.-M.) 3 School of Nursing, Physiotherapy and Podiatry, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, 28040 Madrid, Spain; [email protected] 4Research, Health and Podiatry Group, Department of Health Sciences, Faculty of Nursing and Podiatry, Universidade da Coruña, 15403 Ferrol, Spain *Correspondence: [email protected]; Tel.: +34-981-16-70-00 (ext. 3546) Received: 17 September 2020; Accepted: 22 October 2020; Published: 23 October 2020   Abstract: Background: Onychocryptosis is one of the most prevailing onychopathies and one of the usual reasons for visiting podiatry clinics. In this research, we aim to evaluate the effectiveness of a procedure of nail reeducation technique via a strip of polyethylene in subjects with stage I or IIa onychocryptosis, in which pathological toenail curves are present. Methods: This research was a randomized clinical trial (ACTRN12615000834550). The sample was made up of 94 cases of stage I or IIa onychocryptosis, according to the Mozena classification. Briefly, 46 cases were treated with the combination of a spicule technique and nail brace with a polyethylene plastic strip, and 48 were only treated with the spicule technique. Results: The combination of the spicule technique and the nail brace technique with a strip of polyethylene had a significantly lower recurrence rate compared to that achieved with just the spicule technique, twelve months after the beginning of the study (N.S. =0.000 for α =0.05). The change in the nail width achieved with the nail brace technique, twelve months after the beginning of the study, was statistically significant (N.S. =0.000 for α =0.05). Conclusions: The recurrence rate of the spicule technique alone was significantly higher than the combined technique of spicule with nail brace. A nail brace with a strip of polyethylene reduces the recurrence rate of onychocryptosis. Keywords: onychocryptosis; nail curves; nail brace; orthonyxia; spicule 1. Introduction Of all the onychopathies described, onychocryptosis is undoubtedly one of the most prevailing conditions and one of the usual reasons for visits to podiatry clinics. It was defined for the first time in 1845 as “a nail which grows towards the inside of the flesh” as a consequence of an excessive curvature, which causes pain and inflammation of the surrounding tissues. It has a prevalence of 20% of the patients who visit for a foot pathology [ 1 ]. In a study carried out with 10,900 podiatry patients, it was indicated that 61% of them (6754) presented symptomatic nail conditions. There is a predilection for the first toe of the foot and its peroneal edge (with a proportion of 2–5:1) [ 2 ], although it can affect any toe and either of the two edges [3,4]. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020,17, 7741; doi:10.3390/ijerph17217741 www.mdpi.com/journal/ijerph Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020,17, 7741 2 of 13 In 2002, Mozena [ 5 ] classified this pathology into four stages: stage I or inflammatory, stage II or abscess, which is divided into two substages, stage IIa and stage IIb, and stage III. In the initial stages of the onychocryptosis (stages I and IIa), conservative treatments are efficient in reducing painful processes, solving a great number of cases, which is why they are considered first-choice treatments [ 6 ]. Nail reeducation techniques can be varied: applying cotton impregnated with alcohol below the nail edges, plugging with gauze, applying plastic cannulas, applying dental floss, acrylic resin nails, metallic nail braces, or plastic nail braces. In this study, we investigate the effectiveness of a procedure of nail reeducation in subjects with onychocryptosis at stages I or IIa, who present pathological nail curves, using a nail brace technique carried out with a strip of polyethylene (polyethylene orthonyxia) stuck to the nail with cyanoacrylate. 2. Materials and Methods 2.1. Design and Sample We have carried out an ongoing, phase IV, blinded parallel-group, randomized clinical trial with an endpoint classification of efficacy study 1:1 allocation ratio conducted at an only-podiatry medical center. No changes were made in the proposed methodology because the original protocol was not altered. Furthermore, the Consolidated Statement for Reporting Trials (CONSORT) statement and checklist were considered. The study factor was the type of treatment, which had two values: one of which was the combination of the spicule technique and the nail brace technique with a strip of polyethylene (experimental group), and the other just the spicule technique (control group). The assignation of each subject to the randomized clinical trial was computer-generated by the statistic software Epidat version 4.2 (Conseller í a de Sanidade, Xunta de Galicia, España; Organizaci ó n Panamericana de la salud (OPS-OMS); Universidad CES, Colombia). 2.2. Subjects The sample was made up of 94 cases of mild pincer toenail onychocryptosis at stages I and IIa, according to Mozena’s classification [ 5 ]. Sixty-four people took part: 17 men and 47 women. Forty-six cases made up the experimental group and 48 cases the control group. The mean age was 54.9 years old for the experimental group and 57.96 years old for the control group. 2.3. Ethics Considerations This randomized clinical trial was approved by the local Experimental and Ethics Committee of the University of Seville, in Seville, Spain, with 20 February 2012 as the date of signing, and it was recorded in the Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry (ACTRN12615000834550). All voluntary patients provided their written consent form before the randomized clinical trial started. Human research ethical standards, according to the Helsinki Declaration, the human rights and biomedicine statements regarding the Convention of the Council of Europe, as well as the human genome and rights considered by the UNESCO Universal Declaration and other appropriate national or institutional organizations, were respected. 2.4. Sample Size G*Power version 3.1.9.7 statistics power tool software was used to analyze and establish the sample size; a 90% confidence level, with 0.95 power and a 0.05 alpha level, was utilized. Additionally, a 15% sample loss was also adivsed. This procedure was stipulated based on the experience of previous studies carried out by the authors. Finally, the necessary sample size obtained was thirty cases each for the control and experimental groups, making a total of sixty cases, although more cases were recruited due to the estimated magnitude of data loss. One hundred cases were randomly separated into two groups of fifty cases, in which six cases were discarded from the study due to experimental death; of these, four were from the study group and two from the control group. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020,17, 7741 3 of 13 2.5. Procedures Having obtained the patients’ informed consent, which fulfilled the inclusion criteria, a complete clinical history was carried out. Next, a straight nail cut was done at the hyponychium level. Later, the width of the nail was measured. Nail hyponychium was taken as a reference to affect the measurement of the nail width, as it is a fixed point of reference in all people. A caliber was used for the measurement. Later, the spicule technique of the nail edge or edges affected by onychocryptosis was carried out. The nail portion that injures the periungual soft tissues, causing onychocryptosis, is called a spicule. We now describe the technique of cutting the nail spicule [ 7 , 8 ]. After disinfecting the area, the edge of the nail is milled in order to weaken the sheet and facilitate cutting. A first oblique cut is made with a nail clipper and finished with a number 15 scalpel, pointing dorsally. The spicule is cut to the back of the affected area and extracted with the help of fine forceps, ensuring that the end of the cut does not form an angle that could create a harpoon. This treatment was performed at least once in all the subjects belonging to the study, both in the study group and in the control group. Local cures with povidone–iodine were indicated once a day for a week. In the experimental group, in addition to the previous treatment, a nail brace was applied to correct the nail layer. The polyethylene nail brace consisted of applying a flat strip of this type of plastic between the free edge and the middle area of the nail, which, being stuck on the nail with cyanoacrylate and having elastic memory toward the horizontality, tends to modify its curvature. The principles of action are based on the tensile forces exercised by the plastic strips, which act directly on the proximity of the nail matrix and will accompany the growth of the nail, affecting traction in its more distal zones. The nail brace technique, with a plastic strip, is bloodless, painless, and enables carrying out any kind of movement and using any type of footwear; it is easy to apply and of little economic cost [9]. The strips of polyethylene were obtained from 0.5 mm thick polyethylene sheets. It was necessary to measure the width of the nail strip with a tape measure to adjust the size of the nail brace to the needs of each case (Figure 1). The length of the polyethylene strip was 2 mm less than the length of the nail from one side to the other, 1 mm less for each end. The width with which the plastic strip was cut was a third of the measure of the nail from the eponychium to the free edge. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020, 17, x 3 of 12 randomly separated into two groups of fifty cases, in which six cases were discarded from the study due to experimental death; of these, four were from the study group and two from the control group. 2.5. Procedures Having obtained the patients’ informed consent, which fulfilled the inclusion criteria, a complete clinical history was carried out. Next, a straight nail cut was done at the hyponychium level. Later, the width of the nail was measured. Nail hyponychium was taken as a reference to affect the measurement of the nail width, as it is a fixed point of reference in all people. A caliber was used for the measurement. Later, the spicule technique of the nail edge or edges affected by onychocryptosis was carried out. The nail portion that injures the periungual soft tissues, causing onychocryptosis, is called a spicule. We now describe the technique of cutting the nail spicule [7,8]. After disinfecting the area, the edge of the nail is milled in order to weaken the sheet and facilitate cutting. A first oblique cut is made with a nail clipper and finished with a number 15 scalpel, pointing dorsally. The spicule is cut to the back of the affected area and extracted with the help of fine forceps, ensuring that the end of the cut does not form an angle that could create a harpoon. This treatment was performed at least once in all the subjects belonging to the study, both in the study group and in the control group. Local cures with povidone–iodine were indicated once a day for a week. In the experimental group, in addition to the previous treatment, a nail brace was applied to correct the nail layer. The polyethylene nail brace consisted of applying a flat strip of this type of plastic between the free edge and the middle area of the nail, which, being stuck on the nail with cyanoacrylate and having elastic memory toward the horizontality, tends to modify its curvature. The principles of action are based on the tensile forces exercised by the plastic strips, which act directly on the proximity of the nail matrix and will accompany the growth of the nail, affecting traction in its more distal zones. The nail brace technique, with a plastic strip, is bloodless, painless, and enables carrying out any kind of movement and using any type of footwear; it is easy to apply and of little economic cost [9]. The strips of polyethylene were obtained from 0.5 mm thick polyethylene sheets. It was necessary to measure the width of the nail strip with a tape measure to adjust the size of the nail brace to the needs of each case (Figure 1). The length of the polyethylene strip was 2 mm less than the length of the nail from one side to the other, 1 mm less for each end. The width with which the plastic strip was cut was a third of the measure of the nail from the eponychium to the free edge. Figure 1. Strip of polyethylene treatment in ingrown toenails. The growth time of the toenails from the matrix to the free edge can be 12–18 months, depending on the location. The modification of the curvature of the nail from the eponychium to the free edge was observed, measuring the modification of the nail curvature at the level of the hyponychium. We have followed the same treatment time as a similar investigation of nail reeducation with plastic sheet orthonyxia, which was 6 months [9]. All the subjects who made up the experimental group were Figure 1. Strip of polyethylene treatment in ingrown toenails. The growth time of the toenails from the matrix to the free edge can be 12–18 months, depending on the location. The modification of the curvature of the nail from the eponychium to the free edge was observed, measuring the modification of the nail curvature at the level of the hyponychium. We have followed the same treatment time as a similar investigation of nail reeducation with plastic sheet orthonyxia, which was 6 months [ 9 ]. All the subjects who made up the experimental group were given a minimum of three nail braces. The first when starting the study, then another after two months, and, lastly, the third after four months. In the event of an accidental detachment, a new strip Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020,17, 7741 4 of 13 of polyethylene was put into place, and, in this case, the subject undertook to notify us when this happened. We considered the follow-up period to start once the treatment period had ended since the treatment was carried out over 6 months. The follow-up period was another 6 months. This follow-up period is also that of diverse authors consulted in the bibliography [ 10 – 15 ]. All the study subjects were given a check-up appointment every 2 months during a year. At these check-ups, the evolution was confirmed, and the nail width was measured in the study group’s subjects after 2, 4, 6, and 12 months (Figures 2–4). Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020, 17, x 4 of 12 given a minimum of three nail braces. The first when starting the study, then another after two months, and, lastly, the third after four months. In the event of an accidental detachment, a new strip of polyethylene was put into place, and, in this case, the subject undertook to notify us when this happened. We considered the follow-up period to start once the treatment period had ended since the treatment was carried out over 6 months. The follow-up period was another 6 months. This follow-up period is also that of diverse authors consulted in the bibliography [10–15]. All the study subjects were given a check-up appointment every 2 months during a year. At these check-ups, the evolution was confirmed, and the nail width was measured in the study group’s subjects after 2, 4, 6, and 12 months (Figures 2–4). At these check-ups, the subjects who made up the control group only had the nail cut done at the level of the hyponychium, without spicule treatment, if they did not present recurrences. Figure 2. Initial appearance of the 1st toenail. Figure 3. Appearance at 6 months. Figure 4. Appearance at 12 months. Figure 2. Initial appearance of the 1st toenail. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020, 17, x 4 of 12 given a minimum of three nail braces. The first when starting the study, then another after two months, and, lastly, the third after four months. In the event of an accidental detachment, a new strip of polyethylene was put into place, and, in this case, the subject undertook to notify us when this happened. We considered the follow-up period to start once the treatment period had ended since the treatment was carried out over 6 months. The follow-up period was another 6 months. This follow-up period is also that of diverse authors consulted in the bibliography [10–15]. All the study subjects were given a check-up appointment every 2 months during a year. At these check-ups, the evolution was confirmed, and the nail width was measured in the study group’s subjects after 2, 4, 6, and 12 months (Figures 2–4). At these check-ups, the subjects who made up the control group only had the nail cut done at the level of the hyponychium, without spicule treatment, if they did not present recurrences. Figure 2. Initial appearance of the 1st toenail. Figure 3. Appearance at 6 months. Figure 4. Appearance at 12 months. Figure 3. Appearance at 6 months. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020, 17, x 4 of 12 given a minimum of three nail braces. The first when starting the study, then another after two months, and, lastly, the third after four months. In the event of an accidental detachment, a new strip of polyethylene was put into place, and, in this case, the subject undertook to notify us when this happened. We considered the follow-up period to start once the treatment period had ended since the treatment was carried out over 6 months. The follow-up period was another 6 months. This follow-up period is also that of diverse authors consulted in the bibliography [10–15]. All the study subjects were given a check-up appointment every 2 months during a year. At these check-ups, the evolution was confirmed, and the nail width was measured in the study group’s subjects after 2, 4, 6, and 12 months (Figures 2–4). At these check-ups, the subjects who made up the control group only had the nail cut done at the level of the hyponychium, without spicule treatment, if they did not present recurrences. Figure 2. Initial appearance of the 1st toenail. Figure 3. Appearance at 6 months. Figure 4. Appearance at 12 months. Figure 4. Appearance at 12 months. At these check-ups, the subjects who made up the control group only had the nail cut done at the level of the hyponychium, without spicule treatment, if they did not present recurrences. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020,17, 7741 5 of 13 2.6. Data Collection and Analysis The data were analyzed with the SPSS ® computer pack, version 17.0 for Windows ® (SPSS Science, Chicago, IL, USA). The Kolmogorov–Smirnov test was used to determine the normality of certain variables. The Mann–Whitney U-test and the Wilcoxon t-test were used. The Pearson correlation test was employed for the study of measurement reliability. Its reliability has been assessed, repeating the measurement process with the aim of analyzing the concordance between the different measures. We studied different aspects of reliability: intraobserver concordance and interobserver concordance. 3. Results Table 1shows the recurrence values during the period of treatment and follow-up, respectively, in the two study groups. Table 1. Recurrence data of ingrown toenails in both groups. Treatment Period Follow-Up Period No Recurrence Recurrence No Recurrence Recurrence Experimental Group 33 (71.74%) 13 (28.26%) 36 (78.26%) 10 (21.74%) Control Group 2 (4.17%) 46 (95.83%) 4 (8.33%) 44 (91.67%) During the treatment period, in the experimental group, there were only 13 cases with some recurrences. On the other hand, in the control group, almost all subjects had at least one recurrence. Only 10 cases of the experimental group had any recurrence during the follow-up period (Table 1). Taking into account the follow-up period after treatment, in the group with the nail brace, it was noted that 56.52% of the sample did not repeat any symptomology during that year. On the other hand, with only the spicule treatment, 95.83% had to revisit the podiatrist for treatment. This meant that not applying the nail brace after spicule treatment led to 11.22 times more recurrences in the control group than in the study group, beyond even the phase of treatment, taking measures throughout all of a year. The Mann–Whitney U-test showed significance values of less than 0.001 when compared to the number of recurrences in both groups, both considering and not considering the follow-up period. With respect to the measuring of the nail width, Table 2shows the values of nail widths recorded in the study group during the treatment and the follow-up. It can be noted, descriptively, that there was an increase in this width during the period of treatment. Table 2. Descriptive parameters of the nail width measurements in the experimental group. Initial Nail Width Nail Width after 2 Months Nail Width after 4 Months Nail Width after 6 Months Nail Width after 12 Months Mean 12.86 ±2.70 13.88 ±2.55 14.41 ±2.57 15.01 ±2.67 14.03 ±2.57 Minimum 4.83 6.20 6.88 7.04 5.49 Maximum 16.78 17.60 17.98 18.25 17.52 All measurements are in millimeters. The measurements of nail width in all the assessments carried out during the application of the treatment (up to 6 months), as well as the comparison of the nail width 6 months after finishing the treatment (follow-up period), showed significant differences with respect to the initial width (<0.001) using the Wilcoxon test. A progressive increase can be noted in the nail width during the treatment period, which is related to a change in the nail’s morphology, reducing its curve. However, 6 months after applying the treatment, this value decreases. That is to say, the nail layer shows a tendency to Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020,17, 7741 6 of 13 partially recover its initial curve, showing values very similar to those achieved after 2 months of treatment. However, despite this, the percentage of recurrence of pain symptoms did not increase at the end of the follow-up period. We plan to extend the follow-up period in future studies to be able to check if the tendency of the nail over time is to equal the initial width and if there are recurrences of the symptoms. Forthestudyofthe reliability ofthe measurements, we carriedout fivemeasurementsof 10different nails at three different moments—the first measurement after a week and then after two weeks—in such a way that we could verify an index of intrasubject reliability. Likewise, a second examiner did the same measurements to value intersubject reliability. We studied the Pearson correlation index, which showed values of between 0.99 and 1 for all the measurements studied, both for the intraobserver measurements and the interobserver measurements. This guaranteed the reliability of the measurement technique used. 4. Discussion Among the studies that have carried out on nail reeducation techniques with a plastic strip, according to Effendy et al. [ 16 ], the effectiveness rate obtained was 100% during a follow-up that went from 3 to 6 months. However, it has to be taken into account that this was a study done with a sample of 3 cases, and the application time of the treatment was not specified. On the other hand, Di Chiacchio et al. [ 9 ], with a sample of 25 cases and 6 months of treatment, established an effectiveness rate of 100% during a follow-up period that went from 3 to 6 months. In both studies, the follow-up period was not exactly the same as in this study as they indicated that it went from 3 to 6 months, while in this study, it was 6 months in all cases. Additionally, our sample size differed quite a lot from the two previous studies. Nor was the stage of the onychocryptosis of the subjects included in the sample specified. Studies that have evaluated the effectiveness of other nail brace techniques and nail reeducation techniques are referenced to be able to make comparisons with this study (Table 3). Most of these studies did not have a research method similar to this study. Many had a fundamentally descriptive aim, showing the results obtained with a specific technique or with various techniques at the same time in the same study; a study group that was compared with a control group was lacking. It was thus difficult to interpret their results. Other publications that were found were based purely on empirical data and, therefore, did not offer scientific data on the results or the recurrence rates. As to the effectiveness rate of the spicule technique alone, few studies have been published (Table 4). When analyzing the nail width variable, it has been noted that an average difference of 1.8798 mm was obtained after 6 months and 0.8185 mm after 12 months. We compared the nail width measurements of the subjects of the study group after 6 months and 12 months and we noted descriptively that there was a decrease of this width, the average decrease being − 1.0613 mm. This is the period in which the subjects did not have the nail brace in place. That is to say, it seems that the nails treated have a certain capacity of memory and tend to curve slightly with the passing of time. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020,17, 7741 7 of 13 Table 3. Studies of the effectiveness of other nail brace techniques and nail reeducation techniques. Nail Brace Techniques Studies Year Nº Cases Treatment Time Follow-Up Time Effectiveness Rate Van Oirschot et al. [17] 1994 85 Average 9 sessions - 76.5% * Kim and Sim [13] 2003 14 1 month 12 months 100% Harrer et al. [11] 2005 21 - 6–12 months 81% * Erdogan [18] 2008 7 - 6 months 100% Iribarren and Delgado [19] 2006 10 - - 100% Cabo and Macián [20] 2007 - 141 days - 82% * Erdogan and Erdogan [21] 2006 21 4.1 ±2.36 months 2 years 71.4% * Kruijffet al. [10] 2008 47 - 12 months 82.98% * Ishibashi et al. [22] 2008 14 - 3 months 100% Kim and Park [23] 2009 31 3 weeks 13.3 ±4.9 months 93.55% Moriue et al. [24] 2008 5 - >6 months 100% Matsumoto et al. [25] 2010 61 9.3 months 10 months 91.8% Erdogan [26] 2011 21 6–10 months - 100% Okada and Okada [15] 2012 106 ≥5 days 4.6 months (range 2–12 months) 92.45% Moon et al. [27] 2013 15 - 9 months (range 5–12 months) 86.67% Tseng et al. [28] 2013 43 2–3 months 6 months 95.35% Kim et al. [29] 2013 21 2–3 weeks Foreseen: 12 weeks Later: 37.9 ±21.3 weeks (range 16–84 weeks) 90.5% (12 weeks) 57.14% (range 16 to 84 weeks) Park et al. [30] 2014 31 From 2–3 weeks or more (41 days) 161 days 77.4% * Guler et al. [31] 2015 74 Until cure and correction nail curve 12.7 ±3.9 months 91.9% Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020,17, 7741 8 of 13 Table 3. Cont. Nail Brace Techniques Studies Year Nº Cases Treatment Time Follow-Up Time Effectiveness Rate Arik et al. [32] 2016 41 4–6 weeks Range 6–12 months (8.6 ± 2.1 months) 80.5% * This study 46 6 months 6 months 78.26% * Nail reeducation techniques Lloyd-Davies and Brill [1] 1963 100 - 2 years 60% * Wallace et al. [12] 1979 Study 1 (retrospective): 25. Study 2 (prospective): 36 6 weeks10–12 weeks 6 months 52% (retrospective study) * 56% (rrospective study) * Cameron [33] 1981 100 3.5–4 months 6 months 61% * Senapati [34] 1986 25 - 2–56 weeks (of 23.7 ±14.3 weeks) 79% * Connolly and Fitzgerald [35] 1988 61 - 2.5 years 72% * Reijnen y Goris [36] 1989 Stage I: 20 Stage II: 47 Stage III: 52 Total: 119 From 2 weeks until pain disappeared 2 years 96% (stage I and II) * 38% (stage III) * Ilfeld [37] 1991 43 - - 97.68% * Salasche et al. [38] 1998 62 - 2 years 100% * Lazar et al. [39] 1999 20 3–9 weeks - 95% * You et al. [40] 2001 27 - 6 months 37% * Gupta et al. [41] 2001 39 - 6 months 79.5% * Abby et al. [42] 2002 28 - 4 months 71.4% * Kim et al. [43] 2003 Group 1: 28 Group 2: 29 Group 1: 3 days Group 2: 2 weeks 1 year 92.8% (treatment of 3 days) * 89.7% (treatment of 2 weeks) * Ozawa et al. [44] 2005 9 2 weeks 6–37 months (average 17.7 months) 89.89% * Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020,17, 7741 9 of 13 Table 3. Cont. Nail Brace Techniques Studies Year Nº Cases Treatment Time Follow-Up Time Effectiveness Rate Nazari [45] 2006 32 7–15 days 6 months 93.75% * Lee et al. [46] 2011 30 - Average 8.42 months 60% * Do˘gan et al. [47] 2013 16 2 weeks 6 months 100% * Ceren et al. [48] 2013 57 15 days 6 months 87.8% * AlGhamdi and Khurram [49] 2014 23 1 months 6 months 80% * Taheri et al. [50] 2014 11 ≥4 weeks 5 months 81.82% * Gutiérrez-Mendoza et al. [51] 2015 10 2 months 2 months 80% * This study 46 6 months 6 months 78.26% * Note: * The results of this study and those that are close to it.