scieee Open visual document viewer

Observations on the ontogenetic and intraspecificchanges in the radula of Polycera aurantiomarginataGarcía and Bobo, 1984 (Gastropoda: Opistobranchia)from Southern Spain

Martínez Pita, Inés; Guerra García, José Manuel; Sánchez España, Ana I.; García, Francisco J.

Abstract

Polycera aurantiomarginataGarcía and Bobo 1984 has a stable population in the intertidal area of El Portil beach(Huelva, SW Spain). This fact allowed specimens of different sizes to be collected from March 2001 to December 2003. In thispaper, the ontogenetic variations of the radula of P. aurantiomarginataare studied. The radulae of 141 specimens were exam-ined, 138 from El Portil and 3 from La Herradura (Granada, SE Spain). Specimens of 1.5-2 mm in length lack the typical radu-la described for P. aurantiomarginata. They have the so called pre-radula whose teeth are different in size and shape from thetypical radula of the adults. In the specimens of 3 and 4 mm the pre-radula coexists with the characteristic radula, which is thesingle structure present in the specimens larger than 4 mm. The following features of the radula are included in this study: radu-lar length, number of teeth rows and length of the outer lateral teeth. According to the three measured variables, the affinitiesamong specimens without a pre-radula were established through cluster analysis, which defined three different groups (4-10 mm,11-22 mm and 23-48 mm). Correlations between specimen length and radula length, number of rows and mean length of outerlateral teeth were significant. Feeding strategies could be related to the different morphology of the radula established by theCluster analysis.

Full text

SCIENTIA MARINA 70 (2) June 2006, 227-234, Ba celona (Spain) ISSN: 0214-8358 Obse a ions on he on ogene ic and in aspeci ic changes in he adula o Polyce a au an ioma gina a Ga cía and Bobo, 1984 (Gas opoda: Opis ob anchia) om Sou he n Spain INES MARTÍNEZ-PITA, JOSE M. GUERRA-GARCÍA, ANA I. SÁNCHEZ-ESPAÑA and FRANCISCO J. GARCÍA Labo a o io de Biología Ma ina, Depa amen o de Fisiología y Zoología, Facul ad de Biología, Uni e sidad de Se illa, A da. Reina Me cedes 6, 41012 Se illa, Spain. E-mail: [email p o ec ed] SUMMARY: Polyce a au an ioma gina a Ga cía and Bobo 1984 has a s able popula ion in he in e idal a ea o El Po il beach (Huel a, SW Spain). This ac allowed specimens o di e en sizes o be collec ed om Ma ch 2001 o Decembe 2003. In his pape , he on ogene ic a ia ions o he adula o P. au an ioma gina a a e s udied. The adulae o 141 specimens we e exam- ined, 138 om El Po il and 3 om La He adu a (G anada, SE Spain). Specimens o 1.5-2 mm in leng h lack he ypical adu- la desc ibed o P. au an ioma gina a. They ha e he so called p e- adula whose ee h a e di e en in size and shape om he ypical adula o he adul s. In he specimens o 3 and 4 mm he p e- adula coexis s wi h he cha ac e is ic adula, which is he single s uc u e p esen in he specimens la ge han 4 mm. The ollowing ea u es o he adula a e included in his s udy: adu- la leng h, numbe o ee h ows and leng h o he ou e la e al ee h. Acco ding o he h ee measu ed a iables, he a ini ies among specimens wi hou a p e- adula we e es ablished h ough clus e analysis, which de ined h ee di e en g oups (4-10 mm, 11-22 mm and 23-48 mm). Co ela ions be ween specimen leng h and adula leng h, numbe o ows and mean leng h o ou e la e al ee h we e signi ican . Feeding s a egies could be ela ed o he di e en mo phology o he adula es ablished by he Clus e analysis. Keywo ds:Polyce a au an ioma gina a, Opis hob anchia, Gas opoda, adula, on ogene ic a ia ion. RESUMEN: CAMBIOS ONTOGENÉTICOS E INTRAESPECÍFICOS OBSERVADOS EN LA RÁDULA DE POLYCERA AURANTIOMARGINATA GARCÍA AND BOBO, 1984 (GASTROPODA OPISTHOBRANCHIA). – Polyce a au an ioma gina a Ga cía y Bobo, 1984 mues a una población es able y en la localidad de El Po il (Huel a, SW de España), lo que ha pe mi ido la ecolección, desde ma zo de 2001 has a diciemb e de 2003, de un al o núme o de ejempla es de odos los amaños. En el p esen e es udio se ha ex aído la ádula de 141 animales, 138 ecogidos en la zona in e ma eal de El Po il y 3 en La He adu a (G anada). Los amaños de los animales han osci- lado en e 1.5 mm y 48 mm. Se ha podido obse a en los indi iduos de en e 1.5 y 2 mm la exis encia de una p e- ádula cuyos dien es son mo ológicamen e di e en es a los de la ádula de los indi iduos mayo es; sin emba go, en los ejempla es de 3 y 4 mm es a p e- ádula coexis e con la ádula ípica, siendo es a es uc u a la única p esen e en indi iduos de longi ud igual o mayo a 4 mm. A cada una de las ádulas ex aídas, an o con p e- ádula o sin ella, se le ha medido la longi ud o al de la cin a, la lon- gi ud del dien e la e al ex e no y el núme o de ilas de dien es. Conside ando los es pa áme os medidos, las a inidades en e los ejempla es sin p e- ádula se es ablecie on a pa i de análisis de Clus e , que de inie on es g upos dis in os (4-10 mm, 11-22 mm y 23-48 mm). Las co elaciones exis en es en e la longi ud de los indi iduos y la longi ud de la ádula, el núme o de ilas y la longi ud media de los dien es ue on signi ica i as. Las di e encias mo ológicas econocidas en los g upos conside ados pod í- an es a elacionadas con dis in as es a egias alimen a ias. Palab as cla e:Polyce a au an ioma gina a, Opis hob anchia, Gas opoda, ádula, a iación on ogené ica. sm70n2227-2025 25/5/06 16:02 Página 227 INTRODUCTION The mo phology o he adula ee h, including aspec s such as he numbe o ee h ows and ee h pe hal - ow, has o en been used o di e en ia e species o opis hob anchs. Ne e heless, he in aspeci ic and on ogene ic adula a ia ions in he opis hob anchs ha e been p o ed in some species. Bleakney (1989) e ealed a mo phological a ia ion o he adula o Placida dend i ica (Alde and Hancock, 1843), compa ing popula ions om he Paci ic and A lan ic. Be sch (1976, 1978a, 1978b) s udied he adulae o Discodo is e elinae Ma cus, 1955 and se e al gene a o Ch omo- do ididae, concluding ha he e is a mo phological a ia ion be ween he newly o med ee h, si ua ed in he newe ows, and he o he ee h, si ua ed in olde ows. Fu he mo e, he numbe o ee h ows inc eases wi h he leng h o he animal. P u o -Fol (1926) desc ibed he p esence o a “p e- adula” o dis inguish he i s ee h ows om he emaining ows, du ing he ju enile s age o he police id nudib anch Polyce a quad ilinea a (Mülle , 1776). Focusing on he amily Polyce a idae, Fe ei a (1977) epo ed di e en adula pa e ns be ween ju enile and adul s in species o he genus T iopha Be gh, 1880. Recen ly, Ocaña e al. (2004) p o ided da a on he on ogene - ic a ia ion in numbe and mo phology o adula ee h in se e al species o genus Tambja Bu n, 1962, compa ing ju enile and adul s ages. This pape examines in aspeci ic adula a ia- ions o Polyce a au an ioma gina a Ga cía and Bobo, 1984 om sou he n Spain, and p o ides da a on he a ia ion in numbe and mo phology o ee h ows in specimens a di e en s ages, be ween 1.5 and 48 mm in leng h. MATERIAL AND METHODS The p esen s udy was conduc ed using speci- mens om El Po il beach (Huel a, SW Spain) (37º12´40´´N, 7º7´50´´W) and La He adu a (G anada, SE Spain) (36º44´N, 3º43´W) (Fig. 1). Th ee animals we e collec ed in La He adu a and 138 o hem in El Po il om Ma ch 2001 o Decembe 2003. The specimens we e ca ied ali e o he labo a o y, whe e hey we e measu ed and ixed in 4% o malin. The adulae o all he specimens we e s udied by using op ic mic oscopy and hose o he ju eniles we e also pho og aphed using SEM. The leng h o he adula, he numbe o ows and he leng h o he ou e la e al oo h we e measu ed wi h a mic ome e ocula . To de e mine he size o he adula ee h we conside ed he leng h o he ou e la e al oo h, om he apical cusp o he base (Fig. 2). The a ini ies among specimens acco ding o he h ee measu ed a iables ( adula leng h, numbe o ows and he mean alues o oo h leng h) we e es ab- lished h ough Clus e analysis using he UPGMA me hod (Unweigh ed Pai G oup Me hod using A i hme ic a e ages) (Snea h and Sokal, 1973), based on Euclidean dis ance. Fo hese analyses he ou specimens wi h a p e- adula we e no included. Once he g oups o specimens we e es ablished h ough he Clus e analysis, he possible di e ences o he h ee SCI. MAR., 70(2), June 2006, 227-234. ISSN: 0214-8358 228 • I. MARTÍNEZ-PITA e al. IBERIAN PENINSULA EL PORTIL LA HERRADURA FIG. 1. – Map o Spain showing he sampling loca ions. FIG. 2. – Ou e la e al oo h. The ba shows he measu ed leng h o de e mine he size o he ee h. sm70n2227-2025 25/5/06 16:02 Página 228 measu ed a iables be ween g oups we e es ed using he non-pa ame ic K uskal-Wallis es , a e es ing he da a o no mali y using he Kolmogo o - Smi no es and Le ene’s es o homogenei y o a iances. Mul i a ia e analyses (clus e ) we e ca - ied ou using he PRIMER package (Cla ke and Go ley, 2001) and o uni a ia e analyses (mean com- pa ison h ough K uskal Wallis) he BMDP was used (Dixon, 1983). RESULTS Mo phological a ia ion o he adula ee h The adula o P. au an ioma gina a is de ined as ha ing he o mula 8-15 x 4.2.0.2.4 (Figs. 3E, F). The ou ma ginal ee h a e quad angula , wi hou cusps and he size dec eases ou wa ds (Fig. 3F; Fig. 4C). The wo in e nal ee h a e hama e, as he inne SCI. MAR., 70(2), June 2006, 227-234. ISSN: 0214-8358 ONTOGENETIC AND INTRASPECIFIC RADULAR CHANGES OF P. AURANTIOMARGINATA • 229 FIG. 3. – SEM pho og aphs o he adula and p e- adula in di e en specimens o P.au an ioma gina a. A. Olde po ion o he adula in an indi idual 1.5 mm long. B. De ail o a bi id oo h in he adula o an indi idual 1.5 mm long. C. Radula and p e- adula o a specimen 4 mm in leng h. D. De ail o he p e- adula po ion om a ju enile 4 mm in leng h. E-F. Adul adula. sm70n2227-2025 25/5/06 16:02 Página 229 oo h is smalle and hinne han he second one; hey ha e an apical cusp and a spu app oxima ely in he middle o he oo h (Figs. 3E, F; Figs. 4G, J). The e is no achidian oo h. This adula pa e n, conside ed as he adul ype o he species, appea s in almos all he specimens s udied. Howe e , some mo phological di e ences a e seen in specimens smalle han 4 mm in leng h. Specimens o 3-4 mm in leng h ha e he adula di ided in o wo po ions, wi h mo phological a i- a ions o he ee h. The an e io ee h ows, which a e he oldes , ha e he ma ginal ee h p o ided by an enla ged basal pa and a ilamen ous cusp (Fig. 3D; Fig. 4B); he la e al ee h ha e he adul mo - phology, al hough he spu s a e e y small (Figs. 4E, I). The newe ows ha e he adul pa e n desc ibed be o e (Fig. 3C; Figs. 4F, J). In his si ua ion, he an e io po ion o he adula is conside ed as a p e- adula, acco ding o P u o -Fol (1926). Specimens smalle han 3 mm lack he adul adula pa e n (Fig. 3A), o i only appea s in he las ows o he ibbon. The ma ginal ee h a e ilamen ous, lacking SCI. MAR., 70(2), June 2006, 227-234. ISSN: 0214-8358 230 • I. MARTÍNEZ-PITA e al. FIG. 4. – On ogene ic a ia ions in he adula and p e- adula. A, B and C, a ia ion o he ma ginal ee h in animals smalle han 3 mm (A), 3-4 mm in leng h (B) and bigge han 4 mm (C). D, E, F and G, a ia ion in he ou e la e al oo h in animals smalle han 3 mm (D), 3-4 mm in leng h in he p e- adula po ion (E) and adula po ion (F) and indi iduals bigge han 4 mm (G). H, I and J, a ia ion o he inne la e al oo h in animals smalle han 3 mm (H), 3-4 mm in leng h (I) and indi iduals bigge han 4 mm (J). The alue o he scale ba s a e 10mm in H, 20mm in A, B, D, E and I, 100mm in F and 200mm in C, G and J. sm70n2227-2025 25/5/06 16:02 Página 230 he basal enla ged po ion; some ma ginal ee h ha e he ip bi id (Figs. 3A, B; Fig. 4A). The ou e la e - al ee h lack he spu and he cusp is p o ided by a longi udinal u ow (Fig. 4D). The inne la e al ee h ha e he adul mo phology, bu he spu s a e e y small (Fig. 4H). Rela ion be ween he leng h o he animal and he size o he adula and ee h Figu e 5 shows he ela ion be ween he leng h o he animals and he leng h o he adula. The ela ion be ween he leng h o he specimens and he mean alue leng h o he ee h is shown in Figu e 6. Bo h g aphs show a s a is ically signi ican posi i e co e- la ion. The leng h o he adula inc eases wi h he g ea e leng h o he animal (Fig. 5). This line is desc ibed by he equa ion Y = 0.69 + 0.04x, wi h he coe icien o co ela ion ( ) equal o 0.91 (n = 141, P <0.001). The leng h o he ou e la e al oo h (con- side ed he mean alue leng h o all ows o each spec- imen) inc eases as he leng h o he animal inc eases (Fig. 6). The eg ession line is Y = 154.36 + 5.99x; = 0.92 (n =137, P <0.001). Va ia ion o oo h size along he adula wi h p e- adula Besides he on ogene ic mo phological a ia ion, he ee h o he p e- adula pa di e in size om he adul pa . Figu e 7 shows he size o he ou e la e al ee h along he adula ibbon in specimens up o 4 mm in leng h. The ee h along he p e- adu- la ows a e no ably smalle han he ee h p esen in adul ows. Specimens wi h only p e- adula ee h ha e all he ou e la e al ee h clea ly smalle han hose ani- mals wi h adul ee h. In specimens wi h p e- adula and adul adula ows, he size o he ee h inc eas- es quickly om he olde ows (p e- adula po ion) o he newe ows (wi h adul ee h pa e n). In ani- mals 4 mm in leng h he p e- adula may be p esen o absen . When only adul ee h ows a e p esen , he size o he ee h coincides wi h hose o la ge specimens. Radula di e ences be ween he numbe o ows and he leng h o he specimens Figu e 8 shows he ela ion be ween he numbe o ows and he leng h o he animals. In his g aph- ic i is possible o see ha specimens smalle han 4 mm ha e mo e ee h ows han la ge specimens. SCI. MAR., 70(2), June 2006, 227-234. ISSN: 0214-8358 ONTOGENETIC AND INTRASPECIFIC RADULAR CHANGES OF P. AURANTIOMARGINATA • 231 Animal leng h (mm) 0 102030405060 Radula leng h (mm) 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 Y=0.69+0.04X FIG. 5. – Rela ion be ween he animal’s leng h and he leng h o he adula. Animal leng h (mm) 0 102030405060 Mean ee h leng h (µm) 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 Y=154.36+5.99X FIG. 6. – Rela ion be ween he animal’s leng h and he mean leng h o he ou e la e al oo h. Row 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 Tee h leng h (µm) 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 1.5 mm 2 mm 3 mm 4 mm 4 mm´ 4 mm´´ FIG. 7. – Size o he ou e la e al oo h in each ow o he adula ib- bon in specimens up o 4 mm in leng h. The a ow indica es he beginning o he adula pa . Indi iduals 4 mm in leng h wi hou a p e- adula a e included. sm70n2227-2025 25/5/06 16:02 Página 231 The e is a signi ican dec ease in he numbe o ows in specimens la ge han 4 mm, and a e his, he numbe o ows inc eases e y slowly wi h inc eas- ing animal size. The sudden dec ease coincides wi h he disappea ance o he p e- adula in he animal. On ogene ic a ia ion o he adula in P. au an ioma gina a Figu e 9 shows he esul o clus e ing he speci- mens using he UPGMA me hod and Euclidean dis- ance. The h ee measu ed a iables ( adula leng h, numbe o ows and he mean alues o oo h leng h) we e used o es ablish he a ini ies among speci- mens. Animals wi h a p e- adula we e no included in his analysis. Clus e analysis dis inguished h ee g oups, which ep esen h ee animal sizes: 4-10 mm, 11-22 mm and 23-48 mm in leng h. The non- pa ame ic K uskal-Wallis es showed s a is ically signi ican di e ences among he h ee g oups o he h ee measu ed a iables (Table 1). Figu e 10 shows ha he mean alues o he ou e la e al oo h o each adula ow e eal ha he h ee g oups ha e di e en in e al sizes, which a e la g- SCI. MAR., 70(2), June 2006, 227-234. ISSN: 0214-8358 232 • I. MARTÍNEZ-PITA e al. Adul leng h (mm) 1 10 100 Row numbe 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 Row 0123456789101112 Tee h leng h (µm) 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 4-10 mm 11-22 mm 23-48 mm FIG. 8. – Rela ion be ween he leng h o he animal and he numbe o ows p esen in he ibbon, he loga i hmic scale has been used o he leng h o he animal. 0 1 2 3 4 5 4 -10 mm Euclidean dis ance 11 - 22 mm 23 - 48 mm FIG. 9. – The h ee di e en g oups esul ing om he clus e ing using he UPGMA me hod and he Euclidean dis ance. Animals wi h a p e- adula a e no included. FIG. 10. – Mean alues o he ou e la e al ee h wi h he s anda d e o o he mean in each adula ow along he ibbon in he h ee di e en g oups. sm70n2227-2025 25/5/06 16:02 Página 232 e in he animals 23-48 mm in leng h. Howe e , he size cu es along he ibbon a e simila o he h ee g oups. Thus, he oldes ee h a e smalle because o wea ; he size o he ee h inc eases owa ds he newe ows, wi h a maximum leng h in he six h o eigh h ows. The las ows o he adula (which a e he mos ecen ly o med) ha e smalle ee h, which a e s ill de eloping. DISCUSSION Al hough he opis hob anchs ha e a ce ain wide ange in he numbe o ee h pe ow, his pa ame e is equen ly used as a diagnos ic ea u e a a speci ic le el. Some a icles ha e been published ha aim o examine he in aspeci ic a iabili y ela ed o he adula o mula (i.e. Beeman, 1963; Be sch, 1976; Fe ei a, 1977). All o hem desc ibed a di ec co e- la ion be ween he size o he body and he numbe o adula ows. Howe e , we ha e ound in P. au an- ioma gina a ha he co ela ion is no obse ed i specimens smalle han 4 mm a e conside ed, because in animals up o 3-4 mm he numbe o adula ows is no ably highe han ha o specimens la ge han 4 mm. Simila si ua ions we e desc ibed in he species o Polyce a idae T iopha ca alinae (Coope , 1863), T. macula a MacFa land, 1905, Tambja ceu ae Ga cía- Gómez and O ea (1988) and T. ma bellensis Schick and Ce e a, 1998 (Fe ei a, 1977; Ocaña e al., 2004). Fo bo h species o T iopha, Fe ei a (1977) desc ibed he p esence o a di ec unc ion be ween he size o he adul specimens and he numbe o ows. Howe e , his au ho indica ed ha e y small specimens (smalle han 10 mm in leng h) ha e a much g ea e numbe o ows han he adulae o ma u e indi iduals (Fe ei a, 1977). In Tambja ceu ae and T. ma bellensis he numbe o adula ows is also highe in specimens smalle han 10 mm long (Ocaña e al., 2004). P u o -Fol (1926) desc ibed he p esence o he so called p e- adula o dis inguish he i s ee h ows o Polyce a quad ilinea a om he es o he ows de eloped du ing he ju enile s age. The shape o he ee h o he p e- adula is di e en om he adul ee h o he adula ibbon.The species o Tambja s udied by Ocaña e al. (2004) also show some changes which coincide wi h he idea o he p esence o a di e en de elopmen al pa e n o he adula in ela ion o he size (o age) o he speci- mens. Du ing he de elopmen o animals om he ju enile o adul s ages he adula changes in he numbe o ows and he shape o he ee h, inde- penden ly o he species. This pa e n o adula wi h p e- adula, coincides wi h ha ound in P. au an- ioma gina a. Acco ding o he idea o P u o -Fol (1926), who desc ibes a p e- adula in Polyce a quad ilinea a, he obse a ions o Fe ei a (1977) and Ocaña e al. (2004) in he T iopha, and Tambja species espec i ely, and in P. au an ioma gina a (p esen pape ), i is possible o suppose ha in Polyce a idae he e is a ansi ion in adula mo - phology om young o adul animals ha akes place apidly. This a ia ion could be ela ed o a change o die no con i med ye by analysis o s omach con en s. Finally, based on ou s udy he ollowing conclu- sions can be made abou P. au an ioma gina a: 1) The leng h o he adula inc eases wi h he leng h o he specimen. 2) The leng h o ou e la e al ee h inc eases wi h he leng h o he animal. Fu he mo e, he ee h along he p e- adula ows a e clea ly smalle han adul ee h. 3) Specimens smalle han 4 mm wi h a p e- adu- la ha e mo e ee h ows han hose la ge han 4 mm. 4) In specimens wi hou a p e- adula, he numbe o ee h ows inc eases as he leng h o he animal inc eases. 5) Acco ding o he on ogene ic a ia ions obse ed in he adula o P. au an ioma gina a, ou g oups o specimens a e dis inguished, which ep e- sen di e en animal sizes: smalle han 4 mm wi h a p e- adula, 4-10 mm, 11-22 mm and 23-48 mm. SCI. MAR., 70(2), June 2006, 227-234. ISSN: 0214-8358 ONTOGENETIC AND INTRASPECIFIC RADULAR CHANGES OF P. AURANTIOMARGINATA • 233 TABLE 1. – Resul s o he K uskal Wallis es o he h ee measu ed a iables: he adula leng h, numbe o ows and mean leng h o he ee h in he h ee g oups es ablished h ough he Clus e analysis. Mean ± S anda d de ia ion K uskal Wallis 4-10 mm 11-22 mm 23-48 mm (S a is ic) Radula leng h 0.94 ± 0.16 1.46 ± 0.22 2.00 ± 0.27 805.8*** Numbe o ows 8.93 ± 0.77 10.00 ± 0.96 11.20 ± 1.27 45.1*** Mean leng h o he ee h 178.55 ± 36.69 261.49 ± 26.88 333.61 ± 26.08 104.9*** *** p<0.001 sm70n2227-2025 25/5/06 16:02 Página 233 The e is no clea eason o explain he clus e sepa- a ion o he di e en g oups; howe e , ou own obse a ion leads us o hink ha his sepa a ion could be ela ed o eeding s a egies o ood ype. P obably, he e is a change in die in P. au an- ioma gina a du ing i s g ow h, which would be ela ed o he ype o adula ee h p esen . The smalles specimens (1.5 o 4 mm in leng h) we e ound on he b yozoan Sessibugula ba osoi López de la Cuad a and Ga cía-Gómez, 1994 (pe s. obs.), which leads us o hink ha his species could be i s p ey die . Howe e , he la ge specimens (which include he h ee emaining clus e g oups) we e ound ea ing he b yozoan Bugula ne i ina (Linnaeus, 1758) and T icella ia occiden alis (T ask, 1857). ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We wish o exp ess ou g a i ude o Au o a Mon e o who helped us o ex ac mos o he adu- lae. We also hank D . Sánchez Tocino and D . Ocaña o p o iding he specimens om La He adu a and SEM pho og aphs. REFERENCES Beeman, R.D. – 1963. Va ia ion and synonymy o Phyllaplysia in he No heas e n Paci ic (Mollusca: Opis hob anchia). Velige , 6(1): 43-46. Be sch, H. – 1976. In aspeci ic and on ogene ic adula a ia ion in opis hob anch sys ema ics (Mollusca: Gas opoda). Sys . Zool., 25: 117-122. Be sch, H. – 1978a. The Ch omodo idinae nudib anchs om he Paci ic coas o Ame ica. – Pa II. The genus Ch omodo is. Velige , 20(4): 307-327. Be sch, H. – 1978b. The Ch omodo idinae nudib anchs om he Paci ic coas o Ame ica. – Pa III. The gene a Ch omolaichma and Mexich omis. Velige , 21(1): 70-86. Bleakney, J.S. – 1989. Mo phological a ia ion in he adula o Placida dend i ica (Alde and Hancock, 1843) (Opis hob anchia: Ascoglossa/Sacoglossa) om A lan ic and Paci ic popula ions. Velige , 32(2): 171-181. Cla ke, K.R. and R.N. Go ley. – 2001. P ime (Plymou h Rou ines In Mul i a ia e Ecological Resea ch) 5: Use Manual/Tu o ial. PRIMER-E L d, Plymou h. Dixon, W.J. – 1983. BMDP S a is ical So wa e. Uni e si y Cali o nia P ess, Be keley. Fe ei a, A.J. – 1977. A e iew o he genus T iopha (Mollusca: Nudib anchia). Velige , 19(4): 387-402. Ocaña, A., L. Sánchez-Tocino and F.J. Ga cía. – 2004. On ogene ic adula a ia ion in species o Tambja Bu n, 1962 (Gas opoda, Opis hob anchia, Polyce a idae), om he eas e n A lan ic Ocean and Medi e anean Sea. Sci. Ma ., 68(2): 205-210. P u o -Fol, A. – 1926. Le bulbe buccal e la symé ie des Mollusques: I. La Radula. A ch. de Zool. Exp. e Gén., 65(5): 209-343, pl. 4-7. Snea h, P.H.A. and R.R. Sokal. – 1973 Nume ical axonomy. The p inciples and p ac ique o nume ical classi ica ion. WWH F eeman and Company, San F ancisco. Scien . ed.: J.D. Ros Recei ed No embe 9, 2004. Accep ed No embe 4, 2005. SCI. MAR., 70(2), June 2006, 227-234. ISSN: 0214-8358 234 • I. MARTÍNEZ-PITA e al. sm70n2227-2025 25/5/06 16:02 Página 234