Full text
Assessing managemen s a egies o ca bon s o age in Medi e anean soils:
Double-c opping, no- illage, and ni ogen e iliza ion educ ion
Jesús Fe n´
andez-O ega
a,*
, Jo ge ´
Al a o-Fuen es
b
, An onio Delgado
c
,
Ana Ma ía Ga cía-L´
opez
c
, Ca los Can e o-Ma ínez
a
a
Ag icul u al and Fo es Science and Enginee ing Dp . Uni e si y o Lleida - Ag o ecnio CERCA Cen e , A . Alcalde Ro i a Rou e, 191, Lleida 25198, Spain
b
Soil and Wa e Dp ., Es aci´
on Expe imen al de Aula Dei (EEAD), Spanish Na ional Resea ch Council (CSIC), A d. de Mon a˜
nana, 1005, Za agoza 50059, Spain
c
Depa men o Ag onomy, Uni e si y o Se ille, C a. U e a km 1, Se ille 41013, Spain
ARTICLE INFO
Keywo ds:
Double-c opping sys em
Legume
Maize
No- illage
N e iliza ion
Soil o ganic ca bon
ABSTRACT
In Medi e anean condi ions, he his o ical use o adi ional ag icul u al p ac ices has led o a signi ican loss o
soil o ganic ca bon (SOC) and he associa ed bene i s i p o ides. Consequen ly, i becomes impe a i e o explo e
e ec i e s a egies ha p omo e he p ese a ion and enhancemen o SOC. Some p omising p ac ices o inc ease
SOC a e he use o double-c opping, conse a ion illage, and educed N e iliza ion. The aim o his s udy was o
e alua e he combined e ec s o in oducing a legume p io o maize, oge he wi h di e en illage sys ems and
mine al N e iliza ion a es on SOC and ela ed ac ions (pa icula e o ganic ma e ca bon, POM-C; mine al-
associa ed o ganic ma e ca bon, Min-C; and pe mangana e-oxidizable o ganic ca bon, POxC). Addi ionally, he
s udy aimed o in es iga e enzyma ic ac i i ies associa ed wi h he ca bon cycle. The s udy compa ed mono-
c opping maize (MC) e sus legume-maize double-c opping (DC) wi h wo illage sys ems (con en ional illage,
CT; no- illage, NT), and h ee mine al N e iliza ion a es (ze o, medium and high). The legumes employed we e
pea o g ain (2019), e ch o g een manu e (2020), and e ch o o age (2021). The DC inc eased he SOC le el
by 10.6 % compa ed o he use o MC, wi h POM-C as he main ac ion in ol ed in his change. Thus, he
employmen o DC allowed o he main enance o SOC le els, while he use o MC esul ed in hei educ ion
compa ed o he le els obse ed a he beginning o he expe imen . NT exhibi ed highe alues o SOC and i s
ac ions POM-C and Min-C. These di e ences we e obse ed only in he 0–10 cm dep h laye s. The use o NT
enabled he main enance o SOC compa ed o he ini ial s udied pe iod, while CT educed SOC. The ea men s
wi h N e iliza ion achie ed highe alues o SOC and all he s udied ac ions compa ed o he un e ilized
ea men . Howe e , a he end o he expe imen , i was ound ha he applica ion o N e iliza ion, especially
a high a es, led o a dec ease in SOC. Addi ionally, i was obse ed ha he employmen o DC and NT inc eased
he enzyma ic ac i i ies o dehyd ogenase and β-glucosidase. The esul s o his s udy indica e ha he u iliza ion
o legume-maize DC, as well as he implemen a ion o NT and educed N e iliza ion, a e use ul s a egies o
main ain SOC le els and imp o ing he biological quali y o he soil unde Medi e anean i iga ed condi ions.
1. In oduc ion
Soils a e he la ges s o e o e es ial o ganic ca bon (C), wi h an
accumula ion g ea e han ha accumula ed by he a mosphe e and
plan s combined, and an es ima ed igu e amoun o 1580 G C (Jobb´
agy
and Jackson, 2000; Co u o e al., 2019). The e o e, C seques a ion in
soils plays a c ucial ole om an en i onmen al pe spec i e, by
seques e ing CO
2
om he a mosphe e, and om a soil e ili y
pe spec i e by imp o ing he physical, chemical, and biological p op-
e ies o he soil (Sainju e al., 2011). The d i e s o soil o ganic ca bon
(SOC) changes can be g ouped in o h ee main ca ego ies: 1) clima ic
a iables such as p ecipi a ion and empe a u e; 2) soil condi ions such
as physical and chemical p ope ies; 3) bio ic p ope ies such as he
quan i y and quali y o C inpu s o he soil o soil mic oo ganism
Abb e ia ions: CT, con en ional illage; DC, double-c opping; MC, monoc opping; Min-C, mine al-associa ed ca bon; NT, no- illage; NO−
3, ni a e; NH+
4, ammo-
nium; PNP, p-ni ophenol; POM-C, pa icula e o ganic ca bon; POxC, pe mangana e-oxidizable o ganic C; SOC, soil o ganic ca bon; SOM, soil o ganic ma e ; TPF,
iphenyl o mazan.
* Co esponding au ho .
E-mail add ess: [email p o ec ed] (J. Fe n´
andez-O ega).
Con en s lis s a ailable a ScienceDi ec
Soil & Tillage Resea ch
jou nal homepage: www.else ie .com/loca e/s ill
h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.s ill.2025.106496
Recei ed 18 Janua y 2024; Recei ed in e ised o m 29 Janua y 2025; Accep ed 12 Feb ua y 2025
Soil & Tillage Resea ch 249 (2025) 106496
A ailable online 15 Feb ua y 2025
0167-1987/© 2025 The Au ho s. Published by Else ie B.V. This is an open access a icle unde he CC BY license ( h p://c ea i ecommons.o g/licenses/by/4.0/ ).
biodi e si y (Luo e al., 2017). These d i e s c ea e an annually
balanced sys em as he losses o C o he a mosphe e h ough au o o-
phic and he e o ophic espi a ion a e compensa ed by he C gain ob-
ained in he soil h ough pho osyn hesis. Howe e , he changes o land
use owa ds ag icul u al sys ems and he in ensi ica ion o ag icul u e
a e accele a ing he losses o SOC o he a mosphe e (McLauchlan, 2006;
Lal, 2007; Ga cía-Palacios e al., 2021). Addi ionally, he cu en a i-
abili y in empe a u es and p ecipi a ion u he complica es he si ua-
ion. Inc eases in empe a u e can con ibu e o an escala ion in SOC
losses h ough accele a ed mic obial decomposi ion and oo espi a ion
p ocesses (Rich e e al., 2007; S ewa e al., 2007; Sen hilkuma ,
2009). On he o he hand, soil d ying and we ing p ocesses ha e also
been shown o inc ease o ganic ma e decomposi ion by p omo ing
mic obial ac i i y (Ma eau e al., 2021). This phenomenon has ga ne ed
subs an ial a en ion om he scien i ic communi y in ecen decades,
e iden in he comp ehensi e models o he clima e cycle p esen ed by
he In e go e nmen al Panel on Clima e Change (IPCC, 2014).
Wi hin he ag icul u al domain, a p oposed solu ion o main aining
SOC in ol es inc easing o ganic ma e o he soil h ough c op esidues.
A p omising echnique is he in ensi ica ion o c ops by employing wo
cul i a ion cycles pe yea , also known as double- c opping (Zhao e al.,
2018). The e ec s o hese in ensi ied sys ems on SOC a y depending
on he c op species and esidue managemen p ac ices. Double-c opping
wi h legume-ce eal combina ions and e aining esidues on he ield has
been shown o po en ially inc ease SOC (S agna i e al., 2017; Jian e al.,
2020). Howe e , i c op esidues a e emo ed o insu icien e iliza ion
is applied, i may lead o a educ ion in SOC (Heggens alle e al., 2008;
Ma esma e al., 2019). None heless, he e is limi ed esea ch a ailable
indica ing he ad an age o double-c opping in inc easing SOC con en .
Conse a ion illage and op imized ni ogen (N) e iliza ion a e also
wo in e es ing p ac ices ha ha e been ex ensi ely s udied, showing a
signi ican impac on SOC dynamics. Se e al s udies pe o med in he
Medi e anean egion ha e demons a ed ha he implemen a ion o
conse a ion illage may esul in a di ec inc ease in SOC, wi h an
a e age o 0.40–0.50 Mg C ha
−1
yea
−1
obse ed in he op 30 cm o he
soil p o ile (Plaza-Bonilla e al., 2010; ´
Al a o-Fuen es e al., 2012;
Mazzoncini e al., 2016). Howe e , he SOC seques a ion p ocess has
limi s, and hey a e closely ela ed o soil p ope ies, clima e condi ions,
and c op complexi y. A e a change in he illage sys em, i akes abou
15–50 yea s o each an equilib ium le el (s eady-s a e) (Folle , 2001;
Wes and Pos , 2002; Smi h and Chalk, 2020). This equilib ium le el
also depends on he wa e egime o he expe imen . ´
Al a o-Fuen es and
Paus ian (2011) obse ed ha o he same clima e condi ions, he
Cen u y model p edic ed a SOC seques a ion du a ion o 90 yea s in
i iga ed sys ems, and 70 yea s in ain ed sys ems. Such dispa i ies un-
de sco e he impo ance o in es iga ing each speci ic c opping sys em
wi hin i s espec i e c opping a ea. N e iliza ion also has a di ec e ec
on he soil C balance due o i s e ec on inc easing biomass p oduc ion
(Sainju e al., 2002; Bolinde e al., 2020). Howe e , excessi e N
e iliza ion may also lead o inc eased o ganic ma e mine aliza ion
and he elease o C in o he a mosphe e, as well as po en ial N loss
h ough leaching (Mazzoncini e al., 2011).
The biological quali y o soils is in ica ely ied o hei capaci y o
o ganic ma e mine aliza ion and, consequen ly, SOC seques a ion.
Enzyma ic ac i i ies, commonly u ilized in s udies, se e as aluable
indica o s o soil biological quali y, displaying co ela ions wi h
di e en SOC ac ions and a es o o ganic ma e mine aliza ion.
(Moeskops e al., 2010; Zhang e al., 2021). Dehyd ogenase ac i i y,
being exclusi ely measu ed wi hin he cells o li ing o ganisms, se es
as a eal- ime indica o o soil biological ac i i y and espi a ion (Li
e al., 2019). Con e sely, β-glucosidase ac i i y is an ex acellula
enzyme wi h a cen al ole in cellulose deg ada ion. Since i s subs a e is
a ely limi ed, luc ua ions in his enzyma ic ac i i y a e asc ibed o
al e a ions in soil physical and chemical p ope ies (Ei azi and Taba-
abai, 1988; Tan e al., 2021). Thus, s udying enzyme ac i i ies in
conjunc ion wi h SOC can gi e a deepe unde s anding o he impac s o
ag icul u al managemen on SOC changes.
I is impe a i e o in es iga e cul i a ion echniques ha no only
main ain SOC bu also sus ain c op yields, as highligh ed by se e al
au ho s (Blanco-Canqui, 2022; an de Pol e al., 2022). Due o he
mul i ude o ac o s in ol ed in he cu en p ocess o SOC loss, con-
duc ing s udies ac oss di e se geog aphical a eas becomes necessa y
(Na a o-Ped e˜
no e al., 2021). These s udies should encompass
comp ehensi e c op managemen , including di e en cul i a ion sys-
ems, soil p ac ices, and e ilize a es.
The e o e, he objec i es o his s udy we e: i) o assess he impac o
legume-maize double-c opping, in conjunc ion wi h di e en illage
sys ems and mine al N e iliza ion a es, on SOC con en ; ii) o analyze
how he main SOC ac ions a e a ec ed by hese changes in c opping
managemen ; and iii) o de e mine he ac i i ies o dehyd ogenase and
β-glucosidase enzymes and hei ela ionships wi h he obse ed SOC
changes. The ini ial hypo hesis sugges s ha he use o double-c opping,
conse a ion illage, and educed ni ogen a es would esul in he
highes ca bon accumula ion, leading o he mos signi ican inc eases in
SOC le els. Mo eo e , he soil condi ions c ea ed by hese combined
managemen s a egies would os e an en i onmen conduci e o
highe enzyme ac i i ies, he eby e lec ing imp o ed soil quali y.
2. Ma e ial and me hods
2.1. Expe imen al design and managemen p ac ices
The s udy was conduc ed in no heas e Spain, in he Ag amun
municipali y (41◦48
′
N, 1◦07
′
E, 330 m asl). The egion is ypical o a
semia id Medi e anean d yland wi h a con inen al end. In he las 30
yea s, he a e age annual p ecipi a ion has been 442 mm, he a e age
annual empe a u e has been 14.6 ◦C, and he annual po en ial e apo-
anspi a ion (PET) is 855 mm. The a e age annual empe a u e du ing
he h ee-yea du a ion o he expe imen was 15.9 ⁰C, whe eas i had
been 14.3 ⁰C du ing he 3 yea s p io o he expe imen (Fig. 1a). The
a e age soil mois u e (0–10 cm dep h) o bo h he expe imen al pe iod
and he pe iod be o e he expe imen was 25.3 and 18.3 % espec i ely
(Fig. 1b). Acco ding o he Soil Su ey S a (2014), he soil is classi ied
as Typic Xe o lu en s. The main physiochemical p ope ies a e p esen ed
in Table 2.
The expe imen al ield was es ablished in 1996 o compa e h ee
a es o mine al N (0, 60 and 120 kg N ha
−1
) and h ee illage sys ems
(con en ional illage, CT; minimum illage, MT; no- illage, NT) unde
ain ed ba ley monoc opping condi ions (Ang´
as e al., 2006) (Table 1).
In 2015, he expe imen was ans o med o i iga ed condi ion using
Fig. 1. Daily ai empe a u e (a) and soil olume ic mois u e (b) o pe iod
0 (2015–2017) and pe iod 1 (2019–2021).
J. Fe n´
andez-O ega e al.
Soil & Tillage Resea ch 249 (2025) 106496
2
solid se sp inkle s spaced a 18 ×18 m, and he c op was changed o
maize (Zea mays L.) monoc opping (Pa eja-S´
anchez e al., 2017). The
illage ea men s we e main ained, and mine al N e iliza ion a es
we e adap ed o maize c op (0, 200, 400 kg N ha
−1
) wi h he same
expe imen al layou as he p e ious ain ed expe imen . In 2018, o
enhance he s udy o c op di e si ica ion and i s in e ac ion wi h illage
and N e iliza ion, he plo s we e di ided in o a spli -plo design
measu ing 3 m wide and 48 m long. This allowed o a compa ison be-
ween wo c opping sys ems (Cs): monoc opping maize (MC) and
double-c opping legume-maize (DC). Soil illage ea men s (Till) we e
he same as hose used p e iously, al hough only he wo mos di e en
ea men s (CT and NT) we e used o his s udy. The N e iliza ion a es
(Fe ) we e ze o (0 kg N ha
−1
), medium (200 kg N ha
−1
), and high
(400 kg N ha
−1
) o MC while assuming he biological ixa ion o he
legume, he a es we e adjus ed o ze o (0 kg N ha
−1
), medium
(150 kg N ha
−1
), and high (300 kg N ha
−1
) o DC. Consequen ly, he
c op di e si ica ion ea men spanned 3 yea s, whe eas he illage and
N e iliza ion ea men s ex ended o e 25 yea s by he conclusion o
he cu en expe imen .
Fo MC maize, a long-cycle maize cul i a (FAO 700, Pionee ’s
P1570 hyb id) was used. Fo DC a sho -cycle maize cul i a (FAO 400,
Pionee ’s P0312 hyb id) was plan ed as summe c op and a legume as
win e c op. The legumes we e: pea used o g ain (Pisum sa i um L., a .
Fu ious) du ing he 2018–2019 season; and e ch (Vicia sa i a L., a .
P on i esa) employed as g een manu e du ing 2019–2020 and o age
du ing 2020–2021. Th oughou he h ee-yea s udy pe iod, MC maize
was sown in Ap il; DC maize in ea ly June; and he legume om
Decembe o Janua y. The sowing a e in maize (MC and DC) was
90,000 seeds ha
−1
wi h a sepa a ion be ween lines o 73 cm. In he case
o legumes, a densi y o 100 plan s m
−2
was used o pea and 267 plan s
m
−2
o e ch.
The CT ea men consis ed o subsoile (35 cm dep h) ollowed by
one pass o o o ille (15 cm dep h) and one pass o olle be o e
plan ing, wi h almos 100 % o he c op esidues inco po a ed in o he
soil. NT plo s we e sp ayed wi h he bicide, 1.5 L ha
−1
o 36 % glypho-
sa e [N-(phosphonome hyl)-glycine] wi hou dis u bing he soil.
Plan ing was done wi h a pneuma ic ow di ec seeding machine
equipped wi h double disc u ow opene s (model P osem K, Sol`a,
Cala , Spain).
N e ilize was manually applied, and exclusi ely o he maize c op.
In MC, p e-sowing u ea (46 % N) e iliza ion ook place in Ap il-May.
The u ea was b oadcas ed on he soil su ace and inco po a ed
h ough illage in CT, while i was le on he g ound in NT. The p e-
sowing e iliza ion a e was 50 and 100 kg N ha
−1
o he medium
and high a es, espec i ely. Fu he mo e, bo h in MC and DC, wo op-
d essing e iliza ions we e pe o med in s ages V3-V5 (May in MC, and
la e June in DC) and V7-V8 (June in MC, and July in DC). These op-
d essing applica ions in ol ed ammonium ni a e (34.5 % N) a 75
and 150 kg N ha
−1
o he medium and high a es, espec i ely. A he
onse o each g owing season, mine al P and K e ilize s we e applied o
ul ill he nu i ional demands o maize and legumes, in acco dance wi h
he s anda d yields obse ed in he egion. I iga ion was conduc ed
om Ma ch o Oc obe based on he c op’s wa e equi emen s. The
i iga ion schedule was de e mined by he c op wi h he highes wa e
demand, which was es ima ed weekly by sub ac ing he e ec i e p e-
cipi a ion (75 % o he o al weekly p ecipi a ion) om he c op
e apo anspi a ion (ETc) (Das ane, 1978). The ETc was de e mined
using he FAO Penman-Mon ei h me hodology wi h me eo ological da a
ob ained om a nea by wea he s a ion in he icini y o he ield
expe imen . This da a was hen mul iplied by he c op coe icien (Kc)
speci ic o he c op, de i ed as a unc ion o he mal ime (Allen e al.,
1998).
Table 1
Managemen his o y o he expe imen al ield.
Sys em: Rain ed
S a ing yea 1996
C op: Ba ley
T ea men s
Ni ogen (Kg N ha
−1
)
Ze o - 0
Medium - 60
High - 120
Tillage Con en ional illage
No illage
Sys em: Sp inkle i iga ion
S a ing yea
2015
C op: Maize
T ea men s
Ni ogen (Kg N ha
−1
)
Ze o - 0
Medium - 200
High - 400
Tillage Con en ional illage
No illage
2019 T ea men s
C op: Maize Legume-Maze
Ni ogen (Kg N ha
−1
)
Ze o 0 0
Medium 200 150
High 400 300
Tillage Con en ional illage
No illage
C opping di e si ica ion Monnoc opping maize
Legume-Maize Double-c opping
Table 2
Soil p ope ies o he Ap ho izon (0–28 cm dep h) in 1996. Ini ial soil o ganic
ca bon con en (SOC
i
) (1996) and soil o ganic ca bon con en (SOC) (0–30 cm)
in h ee illage sys ems (con en ional illage, CT; no- illage, NT) in 2017.
Soil p ope ies
Soil classi ica ion*Typic Xe o lu en
pH (H
2
O, 1:2.5) 8.5
EC 1:5 (dS m
−1
) 0.15
P Olsen (mg kg
−1
) 35
K Amm. Ac. (mg kg
−1
) 194
Wa e e en ion (g g
−1
)
−33 kPa 0.16
−1500 kPa 0.05
Soil Tex u e (g kg
−1
)
Sand (2–0.05 mm) 308
Sil (0.05–0.002 mm) 573
Clay (<0.002 mm) 119
SOC (g kg
−1
)
1996
2017
7.6
CT 8.6
NT 12.2
*
Acco ding o he USDA classi ica ion (Soil Su ey S a , 2014)
J. Fe n´
andez-O ega e al.
Soil & Tillage Resea ch 249 (2025) 106496
3
2.2. Soil sampling and analysis
The ini ial soil sampling was conduc ed in No embe 2018 p io o
he s a o he expe imen . The inal soil sampling was conduc ed in
No embe 2021, ollowing he ha es o maize. Soil samples we e aken
in wo obse a ions pe plo a : 0–5, 5–10, 10–20, 20–30, 30–40 cm o
dep h. To al soil o ganic ca bon (SOC), pe mangana e-oxidizable
o ganic C (POxC), pa icula e o ganic ma e ca bon (POM-C) and
mine al-associa ed o ganic ca bon (Min-C) we e analysed. These spe-
ci ic ac ions we e chosen due o hei a ying sensi i i y o changes
esul ing om di e en ag icul u al managemen p ac ices
(´
Al a o-Fuen es e al., 2014). SOC de e mina ion was pe o med
ollowing he me hodology o Walkley and Black (1934), using a 1 g soil
subsample, p e iously d ied and sie ed a 2 mm. POM-C and Min-C
ac ions we e analysed acco ding o Camba della and Ellio (1992)
wi h a modi ica ion de eloped o ou condi ions by Pa eja S´
anchez
e al. (2020). B ie ly, wen y-g am subsamples o soil om each dep h
and plo we e dispe sed in 100 mL o 5 g L
−1
sodium hexame aphos-
pha e o 15 h on a ecip ocal shake . Then he samples we e passed
h ough a 50
μ
m sie e o sepa a e he POM and Min-C. The ma e ial
passing h ough he sie e (Min-C) was collec ed in aluminium pans and
o en d ied a 50 ◦C. The we oxida ion me hod o Walkley and Black
(1934) was hen used o measu e he C concen a ion in he Min-C
ac ion. The POM-C con en was de e mined as he di e ence be-
ween o al SOC con en and Min-C con en . POxC was de e mined ac-
co ding o Weil e al. (2003). SOC con en s we e de e mined based on
mass pe uni a ea, calcula ed by mul iplying he ca bon concen a ion
alues ob ained h ough he oxida ion me hod by he co esponding soil
bulk densi y alues. Addi ionally, SOC s ock (kg C ha
−1
) was adjus ed
o equi alen soil mass acco ding o he p ocedu e ou lined by Elle
and Be any (1995) o he 0–40 cm soil dep h in e al. The annual SOC
seques a ion a e (ΔSOC a e) (kg C ha
−1
y
−1
) (0–40 cm soil dep h)
was compu ed o each ea men om 2018 o 2021. The objec i e
conce ning his pa ame e was o assess he con inued use o i iga ed
maize e sus he p ac ice o legumes-maize double-c opping.
Soil sampling o enzyma ic ac i i ies was pe o med in wo obse -
a ions pe plo a 0–5, 5–10, 10–20, 20–30 cm soil dep hs, exclusi ely
in he CT and NT plo s. Soil o wo obse a ions we e mixed and passed
h ough a 2 mm sie e o ob ain a ep esen a i e and unique sample a
di e en dep hs. Dehyd ogenase ac i i y was de e mined om 3 g o
esh soil ollowing he me hod o Casida e al. (1964) based on he
de e mina ion o iphenyl o mazan (TPF) p oduced om 2,3,5- i-
phenyl e azolium chlo ide a e 24 h incuba ion a 37 ◦C in he da k.
β-glucosidase ac i i y was analysed om 1 g o esh soil ollowing he
me hod o Ei azi and Taba abai (1988) based on he de e mina ion o
p-ni ophenol (pNP) a e incuba ion wi h p-ni ophenyl-β -D-glucoside
o 1 h.
2.3. Ca bon inpu s
C op esidue samples we e aken jus a e ha es ing. The me hod o
sampling a ied depending on he ype o c op. Fo bo h MC and DC
maize, plan samples om 2-m-long cen al ows we e aken in h ee
obse a ions pe plo . Fo pea, 0.5-m-long o wo adjacen ows we e
sampled a wo obse a ions pe plo . Fo e ch 0.36 m
2
o plan s we e
cu a he soil su ace le el in wo a eas o each plo .
Only he abo e-g ound biomass o he c op was conside ed o he C
inpu s, as he g ain was ha es ed o sale and he oo s we e no
sampled. Simila ly, he e ch c op in 2021 was no conside ed in he
calcula ions as i was expo ed as o age. The biomass o all c ops was
d ied in an o en a 60 ⁰C o 48 h, h eshed and weighed excluding he
g ain, he ea e e e ed as c op esidues. The C con en was de e mined
by d y combus ion (model T uspec CN, LECO, S Joseph, MI, USA). C
inpu s we e calcula ed by mul iplying he biomass o he ag icul u al
esidues by hei C con en .
2.4. S a is ical analysis
Da a we e checked o no mali y, homoscedas ici y and se ial inde-
pendence by Shapi o-Wilk, Ba le , and Du bin-Wa son es espec-
i ely. Ou lie s we e checked using he G ubbs es wi h a s a is ical
con idence le el o 95 %. Any da a no passing ei he es equi ed
addi ional ans o ma ion. Fo C inpu s and enzyma ic ac i i ies da a
analysis, a epea ed measu es analysis o a iance (ANOVA) was ca ied
ou wi h he c opping sys em, illage and N e iliza ion, yea , and hei
in e ac ions as e ec s. Fo SOC and i s ac ions, and o SOC seques-
a ion a e, ANOVA was conduc ed wi h he ea men s o c opping
sys em, illage and N e iliza ion, dep h, and hei in e ac ions as e -
ec s. S a is ical analyses we e pe o med wi h he s a is ical package
JMP p o 16 (SAS Ins i u e Inc., 2021) and S a g aphics Cen u ion 18
(S a g aphics Technologies Inc., 2018).
3. Resul s
3.1. Ca bon inpu s and SOC
The esul s o his expe imen co espond o he pe iod 2019–2021
(P1). To explain he obse ed changes in SOC du ing his ime, da a on C
inpu s om he p e ious s udy pe iod (P0, 2015–2017) by Pa eja
S´
anchez e al. (2020) a e also p esen ed (Fig. 2, P0).
Du ing P1, he h ee ea men s s udied had a signi ican impac on C
inpu s (Table 3). Among he c opping sys ems, DC p oduced he highes
C inpu alues, pa icula ly when combined wi h NT and medium o
high N e iliza ion a es. The a e age C inpu s o hese combina ions
anged be ween 7086 and 8257 kg C ha⁻¹ (Fig. 2). In con as , he lowes
C inpu s we e consis en ly obse ed in he MC-CT combina ion,
ega dless o he N e iliza ion a e, wi h an a e age o 3323 kg C
ha⁻¹ ac oss all a es.
When compa ing C inpu s ac oss pe iods, he inpu s om P0 we e
simila o hose o he MC ea men du ing P1, wi h a e ages o
3100 kg C ha⁻¹ (P0) and 3650 kg C ha⁻¹ (P1), espec i ely.
By he conclusion o he expe imen in No embe 2021, SOC le els
we e signi ican ly in luenced by all h ee ea men s (Table 3). The DC
sys em showed he highes SOC concen a ion (9.4 g C kg⁻¹ soil).
Rega ding illage managemen , NT esul ed in he highes SOC le els
(9.8 g C kg⁻¹ soil). Fo N e iliza ion, signi ican di e ences we e
obse ed be ween he e ilized ea men s and he un e ilized con ol,
wi h a mean SOC concen a ion o 8.7 g C kg⁻¹ soil ac oss e ilized
ea men s. Howe e , no signi ican di e ences we e ound be ween
medium and high N e iliza ion a es.
Fig. 2. Tillage (CT, con en ional illage; NT, no- illage) and a e o N e il-
iza ion (Ze o, Med and High: 0, 200, and 400 kg N ha
−1
o MC; 0, 150, and
300 kg N ha
−1
o DC), e ec s on C inpu s (pe iod 0); and c opping sys em (MC,
monoc opping sys em; DC double-c opping sys em), illage and a e o N
e iliza ion e ec s on C inpu s (pe iod 1). Fo pe iod 0, he e a e no signi ican
di e ences among ea men s; o pe iod 1, he a ious lowe case le e s indi-
ca e signi ican di e ences among ea men s a p<0.05. The e ical ba s
indica e he s anda d e o .
J. Fe n´
andez-O ega e al.
Soil & Tillage Resea ch 249 (2025) 106496
4
When compa ing SOC le els a he beginning and he end o he
expe imen , he ΔSOC a e was also signi ican ly in luenced by all h ee
ea men s s udied (Table 4). Unde he DC sys em, he C s ock emained
s able compa ed o 2018, while he MC sys em expe ienced a decline in
C s ock a a a e o 178 kg C ha⁻¹ yea ⁻¹ . In e ms o illage managemen ,
NT e ec i ely p ese ed soil C s ock, whe eas CT led o a educ ion o
199 kg C ha⁻¹ yea ⁻¹ . Rega ding ni ogen e iliza ion, he applica ion
o N, especially a high a es, caused a educ ion in C s ock, wi h de-
c eases o 90 and 157 kg C ha⁻¹ yea ⁻¹ o medium and high N a es,
espec i ely. In con as , he un e ilized ea men main ained C s ock
le els.
SOC ac ions e ealed signi ican changes associa ed wi h he
c opping sys em. Speci ically, he use o DC esul ed in a 19.5 % inc ease
in POM-C and a 12.7 % inc ease in POxC compa ed o MC. The illage
ea men also impac ed he POM-C and Min-C ac ions, wi h NT
showing POM-C alues 44.4 % highe han CT.
N e iliza ion in luenced all s udied SOC ac ions. As wi h o al SOC
con en , signi ican di e ences we e obse ed only be ween e ilized
ea men s and he un e ilized con ol, wi h no no able di e ences
be ween medium and high e iliza ion a es. On a e age, e ilized
ea men s showed inc eases o 13.8 % in POM-C, 11.0 % in Min-C, and
12.5 % in POxC compa ed o he un e ilized ea men (Table 4).
A signi ican in e ac ion be ween he illage sys em and sampling
dep h was also obse ed o bo h o al SOC and i s ac ions (Table 4). In
he opsoil laye (0–5 cm), NT had he highes SOC concen a ion
(18.5 g C kg⁻¹ in NT s. 11.0 g C kg⁻¹ in CT) (Fig. 3a). A 5–10 cm dep h,
NT also main ained signi ican ly highe alues han CT. Howe e , a
deepe laye s (10–40 cm), no signi ican di e ences we e ound be-
ween illage ea men s, wi h an a e age SOC concen a ion o 4.5 g C
kg⁻¹ .
Fo POM-C, he highes alues we e obse ed in he su ace laye
(0–10 cm) unde NT, wi h concen a ions o 11.5 and 6.4 g C kg⁻¹ a
0–5 cm and 5–10 cm dep hs, espec i ely. No signi ican di e ences
we e ound be ween illage ea men s a in e media e o deepe laye s
(Fig. 3b).
Min-C alues we e also highe unde NT in he 0–10 cm ange, while
simila alues we e eco ded a g ea e dep hs ac oss all illage ea -
men s (Fig. 3c). Fo POxC, signi ican di e ences be ween ea men s
we e obse ed only in he mos supe icial laye (0–5 cm), whe e NT
eco ded a mean alue o 760.5 mg C kg⁻¹ , signi ican ly highe han CT
a 572 mg C kg⁻¹ (Fig. 3d).
3.2. Soil enzyma ic ac i i ies
The e ec o c opping on dehyd ogenase ac i i y was ound o
depend on illage ea men s ac i i y as e ealed by he signi ican
in e ac ion be ween ac o s. Dehyd ogenase ac i i y was no ably highe
in he NT sys em, especially when combined wi h DC, eaching 5.5
μ
g
TPF g
−1
d y soil h
−1
(Fig. 4a). The signi ican di e ences ound in
β-glucosidase ac i i y we e a ibu ed o indi idual ac o s o c opping
and illage sys ems (Table 3). β-Glucosidase ac i i y in he DC sys em
was 23 % highe compa ed o MC (Fig. 4b). Addi ionally, NT esul ed in
a 53 % inc ease in β-glucosidase ac i i y (Fig. 4c).
4. Discussion
4.1. Legume-maize double-c opping e ec s
The indings o his s udy demons a e ha eplacing win e allow in
monoc opping maize sys ems wi h a legume signi ican ly inc eases SOC
le els. I is well-es ablished ha highe C inpu s consis en ly ac as he
p ima y d i e o SOC accumula ion ac oss di e se en i onmen s (Kong
e al., 2005; Liu e al., 2014). In his expe imen , he highes C inpu s
we e obse ed in he DC sys em, p ima ily due o he p esence o wo
c op phases pe yea and he imp o emen s in DC maize yields p o ided
by he p eceding legume phase (Talukde e al., 2022; Fe n´
andez-O ega
e al., 2023b). This inding was u he suppo ed by a s a is ically sig-
ni ican co ela ion be ween SOC le els and soil inpu s, modeled
h ough a wo-deg ee polynomial eg ession (p <0.001, ² =0.22).
The analysis o C ac ions e ealed ha he p ima y ac ion a ec ed
by he use o DC was POM-C. This ac ion is composed o
Table 3
Analysis o a iance (p- alues) o ca bon inpu s (C-inpu ), soil dehyd ogenase
ac i i y (DHA) and soil β-Glucosidase ac i i y (β-Glu) as a ec ed by c opping
sys em, illage, a e o N e iliza ion, yea and hei in e ac ions.
Sou ce o a ia ion C inpu s DHA β-Glu
C opping sys em (Cs) <0.001 NS <0.01
Tillage (Till) <0.001 NS <0.001
N e iliza ion (Fe ) <0.001 NS NS
Cs ⋅ Till NS NS NS
Cs ⋅ Fe NS <0.05 NS
Till ⋅ Fe NS <0.001 <0.001
Cs ⋅ Till ⋅ Fe <0.05 NS NS
Yea <0.001 NS NS
Yea ⋅ Cs <0.001 NS NS
Yea ⋅ Till NS <0.001 NS
Yea ⋅ Fe <0.001 NS NS
Yea ⋅ Cs ⋅ Till NS NS NS
Yea ⋅ Cs ⋅ Fe <0.05 NS NS
Yea ⋅ Till ⋅ Fe NS NS NS
Yea ⋅ Cs ⋅ Till ⋅ Fe NS NS NS
NS, no signi ican
Table 4
Analysis o a iance a he end o he expe imen (No embe 2021) o soil
o ganic ca bon (SOC), pa icula e o ganic ma e ca bon (POM-C), mine al-
associa ed ca bon (Min-C), pe mangana e-oxidizable o ganic C (POxC) con-
cen a ion and soil o ganic ca bon seques a ion a e (ΔSOC a e) as a ec ed by
c opping sys em (MC, monoc opping sys em; DC, double-c opping sys em),
illage (CT, con en ional illage; NT, no- illage), a e o N e iliza ion (Ze o,
Med and High: 0, 200, and 400 kg N ha
−1
o MC; 0, 150, and 300 kg N ha
−1
o
DC), dep h, and hei in e ac ions. Nega i e alues o ΔSOC a e imply a dec ease
in soil ca bon s ock compa ed o he yea 2018.
Sou ce o
a ia ion SOC POM-C Min-C POxC ΔSOC a e
g C kg
soil
−1
mg C kg
soil
−1
kg C ha
−1
y
−1
MC 8.5 b 4.1 b 4.4 426.8 b −178.1 b
DC 9.4 a 4.9 a 4.5 480.0 a 19.1 a
CT 7.7 b 3.6 b 4.1 b 448.6 −199.4 b
NT 9.8 a 5.2 a 4.6 a 463.0 6.9 a
Ze o 8.1 b 4.0 b 4.1 b 418.4 b −13.3 a
Med 8.9 a 4.4 a 4.5 a 467.3 a −89.5 ab
High 9.1 a 4.5 a 4.6 a 474.5 a −156.9 b
ANOVA
C opping
sys em (Cs) <0.01 <0.001 NS <0.05 <0.001
Tillage (Till) <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 NS <0.001
N e iliza ion
(Fe ) <0.05 NS <0.05 NS <0.05
Cs ⋅ Till NS NS NS NS NS
Cs ⋅ Fe NS NS NS NS NS
Till ⋅ Fe NS NS NS NS NS
Cs ⋅ Till ⋅ Fe NS NS NS NS NS
Dep h <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.001
Dep h ⋅ Cs NS NS NS NS NS
Dep h ⋅ Till <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 <0.05 NS
Dep h ⋅ Fe NS NS NS NS NS
Dep h ⋅ Cs ⋅ Till NS NS NS NS NS
Dep h ⋅ Cs ⋅ Fe NS NS NS NS NS
Dep h ⋅ Till ⋅
Fe NS NS NS NS NS
Dep h⋅ Cs ⋅ Till ⋅
Fe NS NS NS NS NS
NS, no signi ican .
Di e en lowe case le e s indica e signi ican di e ences among ea men s a
p<0.05.
J. Fe n´
andez-O ega e al.
Soil & Tillage Resea ch 249 (2025) 106496
5
undecomposed o pa ially decomposed ma e ials, including mic obial
biomass, plan esidues, and oo emnan s (Six e al., 2001; Von Lü zow
e al., 2008). I exhibi s he mos apid changes in esponse o a ia ions
in C inpu s, ypically wi hin weeks o yea s (Culman e al., 2012;
Plaza-Bonilla e al., 2014; Wooli e and Jagadamma, 2023). Mo eo e ,
i has been iden i ied as a eliable p edic o o changes in he con en
and quali y o soil o ganic ma e , as well as a signi ican sou ce o
po en ially mine alizable o ganic ma e in he soil (Semeno e al.,
2019). In his s udy, POM-C le els we e signi ican ly highe in he DC
sys em, u he ein o cing he idea ha changes in SOC a e p ima ily
d i en by di e ences in C inpu s. In con as , he use o DC did no lead
o signi ican di e ences compa ed o MC in he Min-C ac ion. Min-C
consis s o single molecules o mic oscopic agmen s o o ganic ma e-
ial leached om plan ma e ial o ans o med by soil bio a (La allee
e al., 2020; Rocci e al., 2020). Due o he long mean esidence ime o
c op esidues, no iceable inc eases in his ac ion ypically ake decades
o cen u ies (Camba della and Ellio , 1992; S i as a a e al., 2016).
Min-C is also p o ec ed om decomposi ion by associa ions wi h soil
mine als, such as chemical bonds wi h mine al su aces and occlusion
wi hin mic opo es o small agg ega es (<50–63 µm), limi ing i s
accessibili y o decompose s and enzymes. As a esul , c op managemen
changes ha e a slow impac on Min-C le els (To sche e al., 2018;
Co u o e al., 2019). In his s udy, he h ee-yea DC implemen a ion
was insu icien o p oduce signi ican di e ences in Min-C compa ed o
MC sys ems.
The use o DC inc eased he con en o POxC compa ed o MC. POxC
ep esen s he ea ly decomposi ion p oduc s o plan and aunal
biomass, oo exuda es, and mic obial biomass (Bolan e al., 2011;
Mo ow e al., 2016). I s apid o ma ion makes POxC he mos ac i e
SOC componen (Zhang e al., 2021), o en used as an e ec i e indica o
o sho - e m changes in SOC ac ions (Plaza-Bonilla e al., 2014;
Gaba ´
on-Galeo e e al., 2015). The inco po a ion o easily deg adable
legumes in luences he deg ada ion o o ganic ma e , con e ing s able
C pools in o mo e labile C o ms (Li e al., 2019).
Fu he mo e, he DC sys em exhibi ed highe dehyd ogenase and
β-glucosidase ac i i ies. Dehyd ogenase ac i i y, which exis s only in
in ac cells, e lec s he le el o ac i e mic obial ac i i y a a gi en ime
(Veum e al., 2014). I is associa ed wi h mic oo ganisms esponsible o
b eaking down o ganic ma e ials (Ross, 1971; Bol on e al., 1985; Pio-
owska-Długosz e al., 2022), leading o apid inc eases in soil POxC
(Leno e al., 2021) and explaining he highe POxC alues obse ed
unde DC. Simila ly, β-glucosidase ac i i y inc eases wi h he addi ion o
easily deg adable legume esidues (Ei azi and Taba abai, 1990; Na as
e al., 2011). This enzyme plays a key ole in he inal b eakdown o
plan deb is ich in cellulose (Tu ne e al., 2002). Highe β-glucosidase
ac i i y has been linked o inc eased le els o Min-C and POxC in a ious
s udies (Ajwa and Taba abai, 1994; Whi b ead e al., 2000; Haynes,
2005). Combined, hese enzyma ic ac i i ies sugges ha legumes in he
Fig. 3. Soil o ganic ca bon (SOC) (a), pa icula e o ganic ma e ca bon (POM-C) (b), mine al-associa ed ca bon (Min-C) (c) and pe mangana e-oxidizable o ganic C
(POxC) (d) as a ec ed by illage (CT, con en ional illage; NT, no- illage) a di e en soil dep hs a he end o he s udy (2021). Wi hin a soil laye Di e en lowe
case le e s indica e signi ican di e ences among ea men s a p<0.05.
J. Fe n´
andez-O ega e al.
Soil & Tillage Resea ch 249 (2025) 106496
6
DC sys em enhance mic obial ac i i y and, consequen ly, imp o e C
dynamics and ixa ion in he soil (Visse and Pa kinson, 1992; de la Paz
Jimenez e al., 2002).
The con inuous use o MC unde i iga ed condi ions led o a loss o
SOC compa ed o he s a o he expe imen in 2019. Al hough he C
inpu s om MC du ing his pe iod (P1, 2019–2021) we e compa able o
hose epo ed in he p e ious s udy by Pa eja-S´
anchez e al. (2020) (P0,
2015–2017), conduc ed in he same expe imen al ield unde iden ical
illage and N ea men s, hey we e insu icien o main ain SOC le els.
I has been demons a ed ha sus ained i iga ion can inc ease
enzyma ic ac i i y and accele a e he mine aliza ion o o ganic ma e ,
leading o SOC educ ions, pa icula ly unde equen cycles o soil
we ing and d ying (Nunes e al., 2007; Ma eau e al., 2021). Fu he -
mo e, nume ous global s udies ha e consis en ly iden i ied a s ong
co ela ion be ween declining SOC and inc eases in empe a u e and
humidi y (Sen hilkuma , 2009; Mo ug´
an-Co onado e al., 2020;
Ma iappan e al., 2022). This decline is p ima ily d i en by accele a ed
decomposi ion a es (Da idson e al., 2000; Conan e al., 2008) and
inc eased esidue mine aliza ion (Rus ad e al., 2001; Ga cía-Palacios
e al., 2021). In his pa icula s udy, he annual mean empe a u e and
maximum empe a u e we e 1.6 ◦C and 3.5 ◦C highe , espec i ely,
compa ed o he p e ious pe iod. Addi ionally, soil mois u e was, on
a e age, 7 % highe . Thus, he con inued use o in ensi e i iga ion
sys ems, combined wi h inc eased empe a u e and soil mois u e, has
been iden i ied as he p ima y ac o s con ibu ing o he obse ed
educ ion in SOC wi hin he MC sys em.
In con as , using legumes be o e maize cul i a ion helped main ain
SOC le els. Resea ch has shown ha inco po a ing legumes in o o a-
ions can help p ese e SOC, especially when esidues added o he soil
ha e a low C/N a io (Paus ian e al., 2019; an de Pol e al., 2022). DC
no only inc eases C inpu s bu also enhances soil agg ega e o ma ion
(Talukde e al., 2023). This imp o ed s uc u e physically p o ec s C
inpu s om mic obial decomposi ion (Negassa e al., 2015; Vi k e al.,
2022). Addi ionally, legumes al e he soil mic obiome’s composi ion
and s a egies, enabling e icien decomposi ion and u iliza ion o
plan -de i ed C sou ces a he han elying solely on exis ing o ganic C
(Malik e al., 2020). These e ec s p omo e e icien ans o ma ions
among SOC ac ions, leading o s able o ganic C seques a ion h ough
mic obial p ocesses (Li e al., 2023). Howe e , despi e he highe
decomposi ion a es obse ed in his s udy, he inc eased C inpu s unde
DC we e insu icien o augmen C s ocks compa ed o he expe imen ’s
beginning, sugges ing ha he DC sys em has eached a s eady-s a e
(Powlson e al., 2011; Nicoloso e al., 2016; an de Pol e al., 2022).
4.2. Tillage sys ems e ec s
In line wi h he ini ially p oposed hypo hesis, he NT sys em showed
an inc ease in SOC and i s ac ions, POM-C and Min-C, compa ed o CT.
Simila o he c opping sys em ea men , he highe le els o POM-C in
he NT sys em a e p ima ily a ibu ed o he inc eased C inpu s
obse ed in NT, ela i e o CT. Nume ous s udies unde compa able
condi ions ha e shown ha NT sys ems imp o e soil physical p ope ies,
including he o ma ion o soil mac oagg ega es, enhanced soil s uc-
u e, and inc eased soil wa e con en (Lampu lan´
es and Can e -
o-Ma ínez, 2003; Pa eja-S´
anchez e al., 2017; Talukde e al., 2022),
which in u n suppo s highe biomass yields. Fu he mo e, he inc ease
in POM-C is pa icula ly associa ed wi h he NT sys em, mainly due o
he be e p o ec ion p o ided by soil agg ega es in his illage sys em
and he educed bu ial o c op esidues compa ed o CT (Zube and
Villamil, 2016; Kan e al., 2020; Vilakazi e al., 2022). These di e ences
a e especially no iceable in he uppe soil laye s, whe e he highes
concen a ion o esidues accumula es and whe e his ac ion is mo e
sensi i e o illage ope a ions (Wande and Bida , 2000; Li e al., 2022).
In he case o Min-C, he e ha e been limi ed s udies on illage ha
Fig. 4. Dehyd ogenase ac i i y as e ec s o he in e ac ion o c opping sys em (MC, monoc opping sys em; DC, double-c opping sys em) and illage (CT, con en-
ional illage; NT, no- illage) (a), and β-glucosidase ac i i y as a ec ed by he c opping sys em (b) and illage (c). The a ious lowe case le e s indica e signi ican
di e ences among ea men s a p <0.05. The e ical ba s indica e he s anda d de ia ion.
J. Fe n´
andez-O ega e al.
Soil & Tillage Resea ch 249 (2025) 106496
7
epo ed signi ican esul s (Poeplau and Don, 2015; Wooli e and
Jagadamma, 2023). This is due o he ecalci an na u e o his ac ion
o C, as well as he ypically la ge pool size in mine al soils, which leads
o e y slow changes (Rocci e al., 2021). In ou s udy, al hough he
p esen expe imen las ed 3 yea s, he 25 yea s o main aining he same
illage p ac ices in he o al du a ion o he long- e m expe imen ha e
allowed us o obse e he highes le els o Min-C in he NT. The main
jus i ica ions o he inc ease in Min-C a e he imp o ed condi ions o
he es ablishmen and p oli e a ion o mic obio a esponsible o he
ans o ma ion and s abiliza ion o SOC p o ided by NT (La allee e al.,
2020; Nunes e al., 2020). One o he ac o s ha s ongly in luences
enzyme ac i i y is soil mois u e (Ade unji e al., 2017). Speci ically, in
his ial, signi ican ly highe soil mois u e le els we e ound wi h he
use o NT (Fe n´
andez-O ega e al., 2023a). The combina ion o highe
mois u e le els and educed soil dis u bance in NT led o inc eased
dehyd ogenase and β-glucosidase ac i i ies, which in u n implied
g ea e SOC s abiliza ion (´
Al a o-Fuen es e al., 2013; Chen e al.,
2019). Howe e , he di e ences ound ega ding Min-C we e limi ed o
he su ace laye s o he soil. Min-C is ela ed wi h mine al associa ions,
including chemical bonds be ween soil o ganic ma e (SOM) and min-
e al su aces and occlusion wi hin mic opo es o small agg ega es
(<50–63 µm) (La allee e al., 2020). I has been p o en ha NT p o-
mo es he o ma ion o mic opo es and mic oagg ega es, pa icula ly in
he 0–10 cm laye (G ego ich e al., 1993; Mondal and Chak abo y,
2022). On he o he hand, CT p omo es he o ma ion o mac oagg e-
ga es (Talukde e al., 2023), jus i ying he lowe alues o Min-C. In
deepe soil laye s, di e ences in agg ega ion a e less p onounced. I is
well es ablished ha he p ima y mechanism o s abilizing ca bon in
he Min-C ac ion a hese dep hs is chemical a he han physical. As a
esul , he di e ences in his ac ion be ween illage sys ems end o
diminish wi h inc easing soil dep h (Ti e e al., 2013).
Rega ding POxC, di e ences we e only obse ed in he op 5 cm o
soil due o i s g ea e mobili y (Shen e al., 2021). The highe mic obial
popula ions and inc eased espi a ion ac i i y nea he soil su ace
accele a e he oxida ion o compounds comp ising POxC o hei
ans o ma ion in o mo e s able and p o ec ed SOC, compa ed o deepe
soil laye s (Wang e al., 2017). These p ocesses a e pa icula ly obse ed
when he e is an abundance o o ganic ma e inpu s (Plaza-Bonilla
e al., 2014; Jagadamma e al., 2019).
When analyzing he e ec s o illage a di e en dep hs on o al SOC
con en , i was ound ha NT sys ems only inc eased SOC in he op
10 cm o soil. Simila ly, expe imen s conduc ed in he Medi e anean
egion showed ha a e 15 yea s o expe imen a ion, NT did no
signi ican ly inc ease SOC h oughou he en i e soil p o ile, bu only in
he op 10 cm. In con as , CT exhibi ed he highes SOC le els when
conside ing dep hs up o 40 cm (Huggins e al., 2007; ´
Al a o-Fuen es
e al., 2008; Meu e e al., 2018). In ou case, a dep hs anging om
10–40 cm, NT sys ems showed simila SOC alues o CT. S udies such as
hose by Blanco-Canqui and Lal (2008) ha e demons a ed ha al hough
C mobili y is highe in CT sys ems han in NT, long- e m main enance o
NT p omo es he ans e o ca bon o deepe soil laye s, hus elimi-
na ing he di e ences be ween NT and CT o e ime (Huggins e al.,
2007; Meu e e al., 2018; Zhang e al., 2018).
The analysis o SOC e olu ion wi h he main enance o illage sys-
ems e ealed ha while CT esul ed in a dec ease in SOC, NT allowed
o he main enance o achie ed C le els. In CT sys ems, moldboa d
plowing accele a es he decomposi ion o SOC and loss o C o he a -
mosphe e as CO
2
. The mixing o esidues and soil h ough plowing en-
hances physical con ac be ween soil mic oo ganisms and c op esidues,
c ea ing mo e a o able soil mic oclima ic condi ions o esidue
decomposi ion (B uce e al., 1999; Nunes e al., 2020). In con as , NT
p ac ices ha e he po en ial o inc ease SOC seques a ion by educing
SOC deg ada ion, lowe ing SOC mine aliza ion a es, and inc easing C
inpu s (Aguile a e al., 2013; Blanco-Mou e e al., 2013; Mazzoncini
e al., 2016). I is gene ally accep ed ha a e 14–15 yea s o NT
p ac ices, a s a e o SOC equilib ium is achie ed, whe e no signi ican
gains o losses a e obse ed in he s udied ho izons (´
Al a o-Fuen es
e al., 2008; Cai e al., 2022). In ou s udy, a e 25 yea s o NT, only
minimal changes in SOC we e obse ed, indica ing ha he NT ea -
men ha e eached a s eady-s a e.
Conside ing ha he mos signi ican losses o SOC a e obse ed in
su ace ho izons (Wang e al., 2022), he adop ion o NT, which
encou age C accumula ion in he su ace laye s, has p o en o be an
e ec i e app oach in p ese ing SOC le els.
4.3. Ni ogen e ilize e ec s
The applica ion o N e iliza ion, ega dless o he a e, inc eased
SOC le els compa ed o un e ilized ea men s. This e ec ex ended o
SOC ac ions, including POM-C, Min-C, and POxC. Howe e , consis en
wi h indings om o he s udies conduc ed in he Medi e anean egion,
highe N e iliza ion a es did no lead o addi ional inc eases in SOC
le els o any o he s udied SOC ac ions (L´
opez-Bellido e al., 2010;
´
Al a o-Fuen es e al., 2013). These esul s unde sco e he bene i s o
mode a e N e iliza ion a es, which enhance sys em e iciency by
educing he need o excessi e mine al e ilize s.
Simila o he o he ea men s examined in his expe imen , he
inc eased C inpu s esul ing om e iliza ion ea men s jus i y he
obse ed highe le els o POM-C (Salinas-Ga cia e al., 1997; Sainju
e al., 2003; Russell e al., 2005). These indings a e consis en wi h he
esul s o o he e iliza ion expe imen s (Lou e al., 2011; Lu e al.,
2011; Pa eja-S´
anchez e al., 2020) and suppo he no ion p oposed by
Plaza-Bonilla e al. (2014) ha POM-C is a highly esponsi e ac ion o
N e iliza ion.
Simila s udies ha e demons a ed ha applying app op ia e a es o
N e iliza ion enhances soil mic obial communi ies (Thie elde e al.,
2018; Ramí ez e al., 2020; Zhang e al., 2021). This mic obial s imu-
la ion acili a es he decomposi ion o high-quali y plan li e , leading
o he p oduc ion o oo exuda es and mic obial compounds (Kno
e al., 2005; Co u o e al., 2013; Rocci e al., 2021). These p ocesses no
only di ec ly inc ease POxC le els (Bolan e al., 2011; Ramí ez e al.,
2020) bu also con ibu e o he o ma ion o Min-C h ough mecha-
nisms such as di ec so p ion and he subsequen physicochemical s a-
biliza ion o ca bon (Panchal e al., 2022; Lei e al., 2023).
None heless, unde he condi ions o his expe imen , high a es o N
e iliza ion led o an accele a ed decomposi ion o SOC, esul ing in
educed SOC con en . This phenomenon is o en linked o a dec eased C:
N a io, which shi s mic obial communi ies om ungal- o bac e ial-
domina ed sys ems, he eby inc easing he a e o SOC decomposi ion
(Six e al., 2006; Yuxin e al., 2011; Spohn e al., 2016). These indings
highligh he impo ance o op imizing e iliza ion p ac ices o s ike a
balance be ween main aining c op p oduc i i y and minimizing soil C
losses.
5. Conclusion
In Medi e anean soils, i iga ed maize monoc opping unde con-
en ional illage has been shown o dec ease SOC le els due o in en-
si ied o ganic ma e decomposi ion and insu icien ca bon inpu s.
T ansi ioning o legume-maize double-c opping sys ems has p o en o
be use ul in main aining SOC le els by inc easing C inpu s and
imp o ing SOC cycling. Simila ly, adop ing no- illage p ac ices im-
p o es SOC seques a ion in su ace laye s h ough educed dis u bance
and enhanced biological ac i i y linked o ca bon s abiliza ion. While
ni ogen e iliza ion suppo s c op p oduc i i y and con ibu es o
ca bon inpu s, excessi e a es accele a e SOC decomposi ion, high-
ligh ing he need o op imized applica ion a es o balance ca bon
e en ion and sys em e iciency.
In he ace o ising empe a u es and clima ic challenges in Medi-
e anean egions, in eg a ing legume-maize double-c opping, no-
illage, and mode a e ni ogen e iliza ion eme ges as a sus ainable
s a egy o main ain SOC le els, enhance mic obial unc ion, and
J. Fe n´
andez-O ega e al.
Soil & Tillage Resea ch 249 (2025) 106496
8
imp o e soil esilience.
CRediT au ho ship con ibu ion s a emen
Delgado An onio: Me hodology, In es iga ion. Ga cía-L´
opez Ana:
Me hodology, In es iga ion. Fe n´
andez-O ega Jesús: W i ing – o ig-
inal d a , Visualiza ion, So wa e, Me hodology, In es iga ion, Fo mal
analysis, Da a cu a ion. Can e o-Ma ínez Ca los: Supe ision, In es-
iga ion, Funding acquisi ion. ´
Al a o-Fuen es Jo ge: W i ing – e iew
& edi ing, Supe ision, Funding acquisi ion.
Decla a ion o Compe ing In e es
The au ho s decla e ha hey ha e no known compe ing inancial
in e es s o pe sonal ela ionships ha could ha e appea ed o in luence
he wo k epo ed in his pape .
Acknowledgemen s
The au ho s would like o hank Ca los Co ´
es and Sil ia Ma í o
labo a o y and ield assis ance. This esea ch wo k was inancially
suppo ed by he Minis e io de Ciencia e Inno aci´
on o Spain (p ojec
AGL2017–84529-C3–3-R;; PhD ellowship PRE2018–084610).
Da a a ailabili y
Da a will be made a ailable on eques .
Re e ences
Ade unji, A.T., Lewu, F.B., Mulidzi, R., Ncube, B., 2017. The biological ac i i ies o
β-glucosidase, phospha ase and u ease as soil quali y indica o s: a e iew. J. Soil Sci.
Plan Nu . 17, 794–807.
Aguile a, E., Lassale a, L., Ga inge , A., Gimeno, B.S., 2013. Managing soil ca bon o
clima e change mi iga ion and adap a ion in Medi e anean c opping sys ems: a
me a-analysis. Ag ic. Ecosys . En i on. 168, 25–36.
Ajwa, H.A., Taba abai, M.A., 1994. Decomposi ion o di e en o ganic ma e ials in soils.
Biol. Fe il. Soils 18, 175–182.
Allen, R.G., Pe ei a, L.S., Raes, D., & Smi h, M., 1998. C op e apo anspi a ion-
Guidelines o compu ing c op wa e equi emen s-FAO I iga ion and d ainage
pape 56. Fao, Rome, 300, D05109.
´
Al a o-Fuen es, J., Paus ian, K., 2011. Po en ial soil ca bon seques a ion in a semia id
Medi e anean ag oecosys em unde clima e change: quan i ying managemen and
clima e e ec s. Plan Soil 338, 261–272.
´
Al a o-Fuen es, J., L´
opez, M.V., Can e o-Ma inez, C., A úe, J.L., 2008. Tillage e ec s
on soil o ganic ca bon ac ions in medi e anean d yland ag oecosys ems. Soil Sci.
Soc. Am. J. 72, 541–547.
´
Al a o-Fuen es, J., Mo ell, F.J., Plaza-Bonilla, D., A úe, J.L., Can e o-Ma ínez, C., 2012.
Modelling illage and ni ogen e iliza ion e ec s on soil o ganic ca bon dynamics.
Soil Tillage Res. 120, 32–39.
´
Al a o-Fuen es, J., Mo ell, F.J., Madej´
on, E., Lampu lan´
es, J., A úe, J.L., Can e o-
Ma ínez, C., 2013. Soil biochemical p ope ies in a semia id Medi e anean
ag oecosys em as a ec ed by long- e m illage and N e iliza ion. Soil Tillage Res.
129, 69–74.
´
Al a o-Fuen es, J., Plaza-Bonilla, D., A úe, J.L., Lampu lan´
es, J., Can e o-Ma ínez, C.,
2014. Soil o ganic ca bon s o age in a no- illage ch onosequence unde
Medi e anean condi ions. Plan Soil 376, 31–41.
Blanco-Canqui, H., 2022. Co e c ops and ca bon seques a ion: lessons om U.S.
s udies. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 86, 501–519.
Blanco-Canqui, H., Lal, R., 2008. No- illage and soil-p o ile ca bon seques a ion: an on-
a m assessmen . Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 72, 693–701.
Blanco-Mou e, N., G acia, R., Bielsa, A.C., L´
opez, M.V., 2013. Long- e m no- illage e ec s
on pa icula e and mine al-associa ed soil o ganic ma e unde ain ed
Medi e anean condi ions. Soil Use Manag. 29, 250–259.
Bolan, N.S., Ad iano, D.C., Kunhik ishnan, A., James, T., Mcdowell, R., Senesi, N., 2011.
Dissol ed O ganic Ma e : Biogeochemis y, Dynamics, and En i onmen al
Signi icance in Soils In: Ad ances in Ag onomy, 1s ed., 110. Else ie Inc.
Bolinde , M.A., C o y, F., Elsen, A., F ac, M., Kism´
anyoky, T., Lipiec, J., Ti s, M.,
T´
o h, Z., K¨
a e e , T., 2020. The e ec o c op esidues, co e c ops, manu es and
ni ogen e iliza ion on soil o ganic ca bon changes in ag oecosys ems: a syn hesis
o e iews. Mi ig. Adap . S a eg. Glob. Chang. 25, 929–952.
Bol on, H., Ellio , L.F., Papendick, R.I., Bezdicek, D.F., 1985. Soil mic obial biomass and
selec ed soil enzyme ac i i ies: E ec o e iliza ion and c opping p ac ices. Soil
Biol. Biochem. 17, 297–302.
B uce, J.P., F ome, M., Hai es, E., Janzen, H., Lal, R., Paus ian, K., 1999. Ca bon
seques a ion in soils. J. Soil Wa e Conse . 54, 382–389.
Cai, A., Han, T., Ren, T., Sande man, J., Rui, Y., Wang, B., Smi h, P., Xu, M., Li, Y., 2022.
Declines in soil ca bon s o age unde no illage can be alle ia ed in he long un.
Geode ma 425, 16–18.
Camba della, C.A., Ellio , E.T., 1992. Pa icula e soil o ganic-ma e changes ac oss a
g assland cul i a ion sequence. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 56, 777–783.
Casida, L.E., Klein, D.A., San o o, T., 1964. Soil dehyd ogenase ac i i y. Soil Sci. 98,
371–376.
Chen, H., Liang, Q., Gong, Y., Kuzyako , Y., Fan, M., Plan e, A.F., 2019. Reduced illage
and inc eased esidue e en ion inc ease enzyme ac i i y and ca bon and ni ogen
concen a ions in soil pa icle size ac ions in a long- e m ield expe imen on Loess
Pla eau in China. Soil Tillage Res 194, 104296.
Conan , R.T., D ijbe , R.A., Haddix, M.L., Pa on, W.J., Paul, E.A., Plan e, A.F., Six, J.,
S einweg, M.J., 2008. Sensi i i y o o ganic ma e decomposi ion o wa ming a ies
wi h i s quali y. Glob. Chang. Biol. 14, 868–877.
Co u o, M.F., Ranalli, M.G., Haddix, M.L., Six, J., Luga o, E., 2019. Soil ca bon s o age
in o med by pa icula e and mine al-associa ed o ganic ma e . Na . Geosci. 12,
989–994.
Co u o, M.F., Wallens ein, M.D., Boo , C.M., Dene , K., Paul, E., 2013. The Mic obial
E iciency-Ma ix S abiliza ion (MEMS) amewo k in eg a es plan li e
decomposi ion wi h soil o ganic ma e s abiliza ion: Do labile plan inpu s o m
s able soil o ganic ma e ? Glob. Chang. Biol. 19, 988–995. h ps://doi.o g/
10.1111/gcb.12113.
Culman, S.W., Snapp, S.S., F eeman, M.A., Schipanski, M.E., Benis on, J., Lal, R.,
D inkwa e , L.E., F anzluebbe s, A.J., Glo e , J.D., G andy, A.S., Lee, J., Six, J.,
Maul, J.E., Mi sky, S.B., Spa go, J.T., Wande , M.M., 2012. Pe mangana e oxidizable
ca bon e lec s a p ocessed soil ac ion ha is sensi i e o managemen . Soil Sci.
Soc. Am. J. 76, 494–504.
Das ane, N.G., 1978. E ec i e ain all in i iga ed ag icul u e. In: I iga ion and D ainage
Pape , 25. FAO, Rome.
Da idson, E.A., T umbo e, S.E., Amundson, R., 2000. Soil wa ming and o ganic ca bon
con en . Na u e 408, 789–790.
an de Pol, L.K., Robe son, A., Schipanski, M., Calde on, F.J., Wallens ein, M.D.,
Co u o, M.F., 2022. Add essing he soil ca bon dilemma: legumes in in ensi ied
o a ions egene a e soil ca bon while main aining yields in semi-a id d yland whea
a ms. Ag ic. Ecosys . En i on. 330, 107906.
Ei azi, F., Taba abai, M.A., 1988. Glucosidases and galac osidases in soils. Soil Biol.
Biochem. 20, 601–606.
Ei azi, F., Taba abai, M.A., 1990. Fac o s a ec ing glucosidase and galac osidase
ac i i ies in soils. Soil Biol. Biochem. 22, 891–897.
Elle , B.H., & Be any, J.R., 1995. Calcula ion o o ganic ma e and nu ien s s o ed in
soils unde con as ing managemen egimes. 75, 529–538.
Fe n´
andez-O ega, J., ´
Al a o-Fuen es, J., Can e o-Ma ínez, C., 2023a. The use o
double-c opping in combina ion wi h no- illage and op imized ni ogen e iliza ion
educes soil N
2
O emissions unde i iga ion. Sci. To al En i on. 857, 109017.
Fe n´
andez-O ega, J., ´
Al a o-Fuen es, J., Talukde , R., Lampu lan´
es, J., Can e o-
Ma ínez, C., 2023b. The use o double-c opping in combina ion wi h no- illage and
op imized ni ogen e iliza ion imp o e c op yield and wa e use e iciency unde
i iga ed condi ions. F. C op. Res. 301, 109017.
Folle , R., 2001. Soil managemen concep s and ca bon seques a ion in c opland soils.
Soil Tillage Res 61, 77–92.
Gaba ´
on-Galeo e, M.A., T igale , S., an Wesemael, B., 2015. E ec o land
abandonmen on soil o ganic ca bon ac ions along a Medi e anean p ecipi a ion
g adien . Geode ma 249–250, 69–78.
Ga cía-Palacios, P., C ow he , T.W., Dacal, M., Ha ley, I.P., Reinsch, S., Rinnan, R.,
Rousk, J., an den Hoogen, J., Ye, J.-S., B ad o d, M.A., 2021. E idence o la ge
mic obial-media ed losses o soil ca bon unde an h opogenic wa ming. Na . Re .
Ea h En i on. 2, 507–517.
G ego ich, E.G., Reynolds, W.D., Culley, J.L.B., McGo e n, M.A., Cu noe, W.E., 1993.
Changes in soil physical p ope ies wi h dep h in a con en ionally illed soil a e no-
illage. Soil Tillage Res 26, 289–299.
Haynes, R.J., 2005. Labile o ganic ma e ac ions as cen al componen s o he quali y
o ag icul u al soils: an o e iew. Ad . Ag on. 85, 221–268.
Heggens alle , A.H., Anex, R.P., Liebman, M., Sundbe g, D.N., Gibson, L.R., 2008.
P oduc i i y and nu ien dynamics in bioene gy double-c opping sys ems. Ag on. J.
100, 1740–1748.
Huggins, D.R., Allma as, R.R., Clapp, C.E., Lamb, J.A., Randall, G.W., 2007. Co n-
soybean sequence and illage e ec s on soil ca bon dynamics and s o age. Soil Sci.
Soc. Am. J. 71, 145–154.
In e go e nmen al Panel on Clima e Change, 2014. Clima e Change 2013 – The Physical
Science Basis: Wo king G oup I Con ibu ion o he Fi h Assessmen Repo o he
In e go e nmen al Panel on Clima e Change. Camb idge Uni e si y P ess,
Camb idge.
Jagadamma, S., Essing on, M.E., Xu, S., Yin, X., 2019. To al and ac i e soil o ganic
ca bon om long- e m ag icul u al managemen p ac ices in Wes Tennessee. Ag ic.
En i on. Le . 4, 180062.
Jian, J., Du, X., Rei e , M.S., S ewa , R.D., 2020. A me a-analysis o global c opland soil
ca bon changes due o co e c opping. Soil Biol. Biochem. 143, 107735.
Jobb´
agy, E.G., Jackson, R.B., 2000. The e ical dis ibu ion o soil o ganic ca bon and
i s ela ion o clima e and ege a ion. Ecol. Appl. 10, 423–436.
Kan, Z.R., Vi k, A.L., He, C., Liu, Q.Y., Qi, J.Y., Dang, Y.P., Zhao, X., Zhang, H.L., 2020.
Cha ac e is ics o ca bon mine aliza ion and accumula ion unde long- e m
conse a ion illage. Ca ena 193, 104636.
Kong, A.Y.Y., Six, J., B yan , D.C., Denison, R.F., an Kessel, C., 2005. The ela ionship
be ween ca bon inpu , agg ega ion, and soil o ganic ca bon s abiliza ion in
sus ainable c opping sys ems. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. J. 69, 1078–1085.
J. Fe n´
andez-O ega e al.
Soil & Tillage Resea ch 249 (2025) 106496
9