scieee Open visual document viewer

Circular Material Usage Strategies—Principles

Santos, Paulo; Byrne, Aimee; Karaca, Ferhat; Villoria, Paola; del Rio, Mercedes; Pineda-Martos, Rocío; Cervantes Puma, Genesis Camila

Abstract

The construction industry significantly contributes to global greenhouse gas emissions, raw material extraction, and waste production. Implementing circular economy (CE) principles in this sector could greatly reduce these impacts. However, adoption within the industry remains slow due to barriers such as limited knowledge and experience. This chapter aims to assess and help overcome these obstacles by providing a comprehensive analysis of circular material usage principles and strategies in construction. It also highlights opportunities and enablers of change, including innovations and emerging technologies in recycling, digitization, robotic systems, new materials, and processing techniques. Four case studies illustrate the application of circular theory through a Bio-Building, Urban Mining and Recycling (UMAR) Experimental Unit, Open-spaced apartment, and an “Escuela Politécnica Superior”. The conclusions emphasize the need for strong regulatory frameworks, awareness initiatives, and international cooperation. Integrating technological advancements like AI, robotics, and blockchain is crucial for optimizing waste management. Additionally, education on circular practices is vital. By fostering global collaboration, standardizing circular construction approaches can lead to a more sustainable and resilient building industry.

Full text

Chap e 7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples Paulo San os ,AimeeBy ne , Fe ha Ka aca , Paola Villo ia , Me cedes del Rio , Rocío Pineda-Ma os , and Genesis Camila Ce an es Puma Abs ac The cons uc ion indus y signi ican ly con ibu es o global g eenhouse gas emissions, aw ma e ial ex ac ion, and was e p oduc ion. Implemen ing ci cula economy (CE) p inciples in his sec o could g ea ly educe hese impac s. Howe e , adop ion wi hin he indus y emains slow due o ba ie s such as limi ed knowledge and expe ience. This chap e aims o assess and help o e come hese obs acles by p o iding a comp ehensi e analysis o ci cula ma e ial usage p inciples and s a e- giesincons uc ion.I alsohighligh soppo uni iesandenable so change,including inno a ions and eme ging echnologies in ecycling, digi iza ion, obo ic sys ems, new ma e ials, and p ocessing echniques. Fou case s udies illus a e he applica ion o ci cula heo y h ough a Bio-Building, U ban Mining and Recycling (UMAR) Expe imen al Uni , Open-spaced apa men , and an “Escuela Poli écnica Supe io ”. The conclusions emphasize he need o s ong egula o y amewo ks, awa eness ini ia i es, and in e na ional coope a ion. In eg a ing echnological ad ancemen s P. San os (B ) Ci il Enginee ing Depa men , ISISE, ARISE, Uni e si y o Coimb a, Coimb a, Po ugal e-mail: [email p o ec ed] A. By ne O ice o he Vice P esiden o Sus ainabili y, Technological Uni e si y Dublin, G angego man, I eland P. Villo ia ·M. del Rio Escuela Técnica Supe io de Edi icación, Uni e sidad Poli écnica de Mad id, Mad id, Spain F. Ka aca Depa men o Ci il and En i onmen al Enginee ing, School o Enginee ing and Digi al Sciences, Naza baye Uni e si y, As ana, Kazakhs an R. Pineda-Ma os Depa amen o de Ingenie ía Ae oespacial y Mecánica de Fluidos, Escuela Técnica Supe io de Ingenie ía Ag onómica, Uni e sidad de Se illa, Se illa, Spain G. C. Ce an es Puma ISISE, ARISE, Depa men o Ci il Enginee ing, Uni e si y o Minho, 4804-533 Guima ães, Po ugal © The Au ho (s) 2025 L. B agança e al. (eds.), Ci cula Economy Design and Managemen in he Buil En i onmen , Sp inge T ac s in Ci il Enginee ing, h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-031-73490-8_7 175 176 P. San os e al. like AI, obo ics, and blockchain is c ucial o op imizing was e managemen . Addi- ionally, educa ion on ci cula p ac ices is i al. By os e ing global collabo a ion, s anda dizing ci cula cons uc ion app oaches can lead o a mo e sus ainable and esilien building indus y. Keywo ds Ci cula economy ·Buildings ·Ci cula ma e ials ·S a egies · P inciples ·O e iew One o he main was e lows in he Eu opean Union (EU) is cons uc ion and demo- li ion was e (CDW), ep esen ing in 2018 a ound 36% o o al was e gene a ed [1]. Besides soils, conc e e, b icks, gypsum, wood, glass, me als, plas ic and sol en s a e he mos o en CDW ound in he EU-27 coun ies [2], exhibi ing no only a high esou ce alue, bu also a high po en ial o e-use and ecycling [1]. E en wi h high inancial penal ies, illegal ly- ipping o CDW con inues o ake place (Fig. 7.1). In his con ex , he EU has made he managemen o CDW a p io i y [3] and he Was e F amewo k Di ec i e (WFD) 2008/98/EC [4] imposed a manda o y eco e y a ge (70% eco e y a e o CDW in weigh by 2020). Included in hese eco e y ac i i ies a e “ he p epa a ion o non-haza dous CDW o e-use, ecycling and o he ma e ial eco e y, including back illing ope a ions” [1]. This chap e p esen s an upda ed e iew o ci cula ma e ial usage p inciples and s a egies wi hin he cons uc ion sec o . Fi s , some basic concep s abou ci cula economy and ma e ial usage a e p esen ed as an in oduc o y amewo k. Nex , he main p inciples o ci cula ma e ial usage a he design s age a e desc ibed. A e , he ci cula ma e ial usage s a egies and p inciples in cons uc ion ac i i ies a e p esen ed, including: ex ending li espan and end-o -li e s a egies, collabo a- i e app oaches and business models, echnological inno a ions, main ba ie s and enable s o ci cula ma e ial usage. Finally, o conclude his subsec ion, some bes Fig. 7.1 Cons uc ion and demo ion was e illegally disca ded in he middle o a o es 7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 177 p ac ices ela ed o he p e ious heo e ical concep s abou ci cula ma e ial usage in he building indus y, a e illus a ed using some selec ed case s udies. 7.1 Unde s anding Ci cula Economy and Ma e ial Usage Sec ion The ci cula economy (CE) is a model o p oduc ion and consump ion which ocuses on e aining exis ing ma e ials and p oduc s as long as possible and educing was e [5]. Ci cula i y aims o mo e away om he adi ional linea model o ‘ ake-make- dispose’ whe e ma e ials a e ex ac ed, manu ac u ed in o p oduc s, and ul ima ely disposed o . Ins ead, i ocuses on c ea ing a closed-loop sys em whe e ma e ials a e con inuously eused, ecycled, o egene a ed o minimize he need o new esou ces and educe he en i onmen al impac . In he buil en i onmen , he e is no clea and accep ed de ini ion o a CE [6]. Howe e , a ci cula buil en i onmen can be a sus ainable app oach which ca e s o he g owing needs o he sec o wi hou causing addi ional de imen al impac s on he en i onmen . The EU has ag eed o educe g eenhouse gas emissions by 55% by 2030 (o 1990 le els) and o become ca bon neu al by 2050 [7]. Al hough igu es luc ua e yea on yea , he Ci cula Economy Ac ion Plan [8] a ibu es 50% o ex ac ed ma e ial and 35% o he EU’s was e gene a ion o cons uc ion. The sec o accoun s o 5–12% o o al g eenhouse gas emissions h ough ma e ial ex ac ion, cons uc ion p oduc manu ac u e, and building wo k. This includes cemen , aluminium, s eel, b ick and glass p oduc ion which accoun o app oxima ely 9% o global ene gy ela ed CO2 emissions [9]. Con ounding his issue, 10–15% o building ma e ial is was ed du ing cons uc ion and he majo i y o demoli ion was e is cu en ly land illed in he EU [10]. Na ional cons uc ion and demoli ion was e (CDW) ecycling a es a y g ea ly ac oss Eu ope, om 10 o 90% [11]. A CE has he po en ial o educe global CO2 emissions om building ma e ials by 38% by 2050 [12,13]. Acco ding o he Ellen MacA hu Founda ion [14] he h ee p inciples o a CE a e: he elimina ion o was e and pollu ion, he use o ci cula p oduc s and ma e ials and hi dly, he egene a ion o na u e. Wi hin hese p inciples, he e a e se e al subca ego ies and concep s which will be discussed below. 7.1.1 Elimina ing Was e and Pollu ion The i s p inciple aims o mo e away om a linea sys em whe eby aw ma e- ials a e ex ac ed, consumed and e en ually h own la gely in o land ills and incin- e a o s. In ci cula design, aw ma e ials use is minimized, and ma e ials can be designed o emain in use o mul iple cycles by ollowing he R p inciples. The e a e many e sions o he R p inciples o a CE which a e based on he o iginal 3; 178 P. San os e al. Fig. 7.2 Ci cula i y hie a chy o p inciples in he p oduc chain wi h examples om cons uc ion. Based on a able by Po ing e al. [19] Reduce, Reuse, and Recycle. This can hen be subdi ided mul iple imes o make o up o 14 and e en 22 Rs [15,16]. Reike e al. [17] iden i ied 38 “ e-” wo ds, as lis ed nex by alphabe ic o de : “ e-assembly, ecap u e, econdi ioning, ecollec , eco e , ec ea e, ec i y, ecycle, edesign, edis ibu e, educe, e-en ision, e i , e u bish, e use, ema ke , emanu ac u e, eno a e, epai , eplacemen , ep ocess, ep oduce, epu pose, esale, esell, e-se ice, es o a ion, esyn hesize, e hink, e ie e, e o i , e og ade, e u n, euse, eu ilize, e enue, e e se and e i alize”. Ten o he mos common include: Re use/Rejec , Re hink, Reduce, Reuse, Repai , Re u bish,Remanu ac u e,Repu pose,RecycleandReco e .Figu e7.2indica es he hie a chy o hese, p io i ized om 1 o 10 based on maximizing esou ce e iciency, minimizing was e gene a ion, and highes alue c ea ion and e en ion. Recycling and eco e y a e anked lowes because o he loss o complex s a e and he need o highe ene gy inpu s [18]. 7.1.2 Use o Ci cula P oduc s and Ma e ials Ci cula Ma e ials used wi hin cons uc ion can be la gely di ided in o wo g oups; low o ze o-ca bon ma e ials such as wood and eused o eco e ed ma e ials wi h minimal ep ocessing o anspo - ela ed emissions [20]. The echnical cycle and he biological cycle suppo ci cula ma e ial use and a e illus a ed in Fig. 7.3. The echnical cycle on he igh in ol es ma e ials such as me als, conc e e, plas- ics, glass, o syn he ic composi es in building p oduc s. A he end o a s uc u e’s li e, o cons uc ion p oduc s’ li e, hese ma e ials a e eco e ed om he demoli- ion o decons uc ion p ocess, so ed and p ocessed be o e being ep ocessed o eused in cons uc ion o o he applica ions. The inne loops in he Fig. 7.3 bu e ly 7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 179 Fig. 7.3 Ci cula economy bu e ly diag am in e p e ed o he cons uc ion indus y by O enhaus [22] diag am applied o he cons uc ion indus y, e ain mos alue in he ma e ial o p oduc . This is based on he mo e gene al ci cula economy bu e ly diag am [21], in which he inne mos loop, ‘Main enance’, p olongs he li e o he ma e ial o p oduc . This is ollowed by ‘Reusing’ and ‘Redis ibu ing’ which keeps ma e ials in hei o iginal o m and displaces he need o manu ac u e new i ems o ex ac new ma e ials. ‘Re u bishing’ and ‘Remanu ac u ing’ hen include some p ocessing and he ou mos loop, ‘Recycling’, is a las eso when o he op ions a e no possible. The biological cycle, o bio-loop, only includes ma e ials ha can be sa ely egen- e a edin he biosphe e ia compos ing o anae obic diges ion suchas imbe , bamboo o s aw. Ma e ials om he echnical cycle can end up in he biological cycle, once hey can no longe make a p oduc . The inne loops o he le side o he bu e ly diag am shows he ‘cascading p inciple’ which is he cascading use o enewable esou ces, wi h se e al euse and ecycling cycles [23]. Fo he cons uc ion indus y, hisismos applicable o imbe ,whichcouldbegini s i s p oduc li eassolid imbe beams and end i s i h li e being incine a ed o ene gy eco e y [24]. Cascading ensu es ha biogenic ca bon emains in he sys em o a longe pe iod o ime, esul ing in lowe en i onmen al bu dens and can suppo o he indus ies such as a ming ia eeds ock o soil e ilize [25]. 180 P. San os e al. 7.1.3 Regene a e Na u e Ci cula cons uc ion can con ibu e o he egene a ion o na u e by inco po a ing s a egies ha suppo ecological es o a ion, biodi e si y enhancemen , and sus ain- able land managemen p ac ices. The a o emen ioned biological cycle con ibu es o biodi e si y and ecosys em heal h by p omo ing he use o enewable ma e ials ha can be eg own and eplenished. Main aining ma e ials in use also con ibu es o his p inciple as less land is equi ed o sou cing i gin aw ma e ials, which allows mo e land o be e u ned o na u e. While ci cula cons uc ion ma e ials hold g ea po en ial o sus ainable and esou ce-e icien building p ac ices, he e a e se e al challenges ha need o be add essed o acili a e widesp ead adop ion. The de ails o he challenges aced can be speci ic o each s akeholde ’s ole. Howe e , hey can be b oadly g ouped as economic, in o ma ional, ins i u ional, poli ical and echnical challenges [26] wi h commonly encoun e ed subca ego ies lis ed in Table 7.1. A key challenge in he sec o is he olume o exis ing buildings no designed o decons uc ion, con aining oxic ma e ials, and lacking de ailed documen a ion [28]. Reused ma e ials equi e addi ional ime and mo e quali ied labou , and he e is a lack o ma ke mechanisms o aid eco e y [6]. A sys em needs o be de eloped Table 7.1 Challenge a eas o a ci cula buil en i onmen compiled om e iew a icles [6,26, 27] Challenge subca ego ies Challenge Economic – Lack o g an s/unclea inancial case – Lack o inancial aid, incen i es o sho - e m bene i s – Low alue o ci cula ma e ials – Cos o up on in es men In o ma ional – Lack o esea ch, educa ion and in o ma ion – Lack o awa eness, in e es and knowledge – Lack o bes p ac ice case s udies and leade ship Ins i u ional/s uc u al – Lack o s a egic ision and collabo a i e pla o ms – F agmen ed supply chains – Lack o ma ke mechanisms o eco e y Poli ical – Lack o egula o y ins umen s/ egula o y p essu e – Lack o ax ac ions – Lack o ci cula ision Technological – Lack o in eg a ed p ocesses, ools, and p ac ices – Lack o an in o ma ion managemen sys em – Complexi y o buildings – Technology and in as uc u e eadiness 7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 181 which suppo s he use o ci cula ma e ials which includes quali y assu ance, s an- da diza ion, ce i ica ion and classi ica ion, mechanisms o anspo and s o age and access o he ma ke [26,29]. Finances, o lack o inancial case, we e iden i ied as a leading ba ie o s ake- holde s [6,10,27]. Fo ci cula cons uc ion ma e ials, his includes he high a ail- abili y and low cos [27] o i gin aw ma e ial, he cos o decons uc ion, he wo k in ol ed in p o iding he ma e ial o euse, he cos o ecycled/ eused ma e ials, and he lack o ewa d o penal y [26]. Ins i u ional o in o ma ional challenges include he lack o guidance and ools, and lack o knowledge [26]. S akeholde s h oughou cons uc ion alue chains in Eu ope a e un amilia wi h how CE p inciples do o could ope a e in he buil en i- onmen , wi h many unable o iden i y i s s eps in ini ia ing he ansi ion o a CE [10]. Add essing hese challenges equi es collabo a i e e o s om a ious s ake- holde s, including policymake s, indus y p o essionals, esea che s, and end use s. O e coming hese ba ie s will pa e he way o a mo e widesp ead adop ion o ci cula cons uc ion ma e ials, howe e he e is a need ini ially o p o ide e idence, compile bes p ac ice examples and de elop guidance. 7.2 Design P inciples o Ci cula Ma e ial Usage 7.2.1 Designing o Ci cula i y The e a e se e al p inciples wi hin he design s age o p omo e ci cula i y in building cons uc ions. These p inciples can be clus e ed in o he ollowing poin s [30,31]: – Design s anda dized p oduc s and ma e ials, using egula and simple modula shapes o a oid was e. – Design o dec ease he need o ex ac and p oduce i gin ma e ials. – Design using eco e ed ma e ials: by de ec ing unused ma e ials om echnical o na u al lows and ans o ming hem in o ci cula ma e ials which can be inco po- a ed wi hin he p oduc ion o new ma e ials and p oduc s, p omo ing he design o ma e ials wi h high ecycled con en . – Design du able ma e ials so ha hey can p olong hei use in he building and he e o e inc ease li e ime and delay he end-o -use cycle. – Design conside ing he se ing p ocedu e o he ma e ials, so ha he ma e ials can be easily disassembled: Ma e ials should be designed hinking ha , when placed in a cons uc ion p ojec , hey should allow decons uc ion and p omo e euse and ecycling. Fo example, using mechanical join s o a oid he use o binde s and adhesi es. 182 P. San os e al. 7.2.2 Ma e ial Selec ion and Managemen The cons uc ion sec o , in pa icula , plays a pi o al ole in ansi ioning owa ds a less esou ce-in ensi e economy by maximizing he use and eco e y o esou ces in building design and cons uc ion. Sus ainable ma e ial sou cing and e icien ecycling echniques a e c ucial o achie ing a ci cula economy. 1. C i e ia o Selec ing Ci cula Ma e ials The EU emphasizes he signi icance o applying ci cula economy (CE) p inciples ac ossall economic sec o s, wi h a pa icula ocuson wa e and ene gyconse a ion, was e p e en ion, ma e ial ecycling, p omo ion o euse and epai , and u iliza ion o seconda y aw ma e ials [32]. CE in he cons uc ion sec o aims o maximize he use and eco e y o esou ces and buildings, educing he en i onmen al impac . Thus, i is o impo ance ha designs aim o ex end he use ul li e o buildings h ough ehabili a ion, using ecy- clable ma e ials; and he usage o new indus ialized long-li e ma e ials based on eco e ed and alued esou ces. Addi ionally, adop ing new indus ialized long-li e ma e ials de i ed om eco e ed and alued esou ces can con ibu e o sus ainable p ac ices [33]. By implemen ing hese ecommenda ions, he cons uc ion sec o can play a pi o al ole in ansi ioning owa ds a less esou ce-in ensi e economy and os e ing ci cula i y. This app oach aligns wi h he b oade objec i es o he CE, such as educing was e gene a ion, conse ing esou ces, and p omo ing sus ainable ma e ial use. 2. Sus ainable Ma e ial Sou cing Rega ding he a ailabili y o aw ma e ials, c i ical aw ma e ials a e o pa icula impo ance as hei g ea economic impo ance o he Eu opean Union (EU); e y sensi i e o supply in e up ion; and being hei ex ac ion o a signi ican impac on he en i onmen . C i ical aw ma e ials—e.g., li hium, a e o en p esen in elec onic de ices. The cu en low ecycling a e o hese ma e ials means ha signi ican economic oppo uni ies a e being los . Thus, he undamen al di ec ions ha he ci cula i y s a egy mus ake a he Eu opean le el a e hose ha conside he need o inco po a e hese ma e ials in o educ ion, euse and ecycling p ac ices. To achie e au onomywi h espec o hesema e ials, heEUp oposes di e si iedand undis o ed access o global aw ma e ials ma ke s, while seeking o educe ex e nal dependence on hese ma e ials as well as he en i onmen al p essu es associa ed wi h hei impo [32]. 3. Ma e ial E iciency and Recycling Techniques TheEUinsis son heimpo anceo incen i es o headop iono e iciencymeasu es in he use o esou ces and o inc easing ecycling, eco-inno a i e pe o mance, and in es men s in g een p oduc s and se ices [32]. To mo e owa ds an economic model o ma e ial e iciency, economic p io i ies and li es yles mus be in line wi h educing excessi e economic ma e ial dependence by applying he p inciples o ci cula i y—i.e., educe and euse be o e ecycling [32]. Fundamen al aspec s o CE 7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 183 Fig. 7.4 Impo an ecycle poin s (Sou ce au ho s, based on Si uación y e olución de la economía ci cula en by Mo a ó e al. [32]) ela ed o ecycling a e: (i) design o ien ed owa ds economy o ma e ials and ene gy, use o ecyclable and enewable ma e ials, and easy disassembly and eplacemen o ma e ials and componen s; and, (ii) ecycling and eco e y o non- eusable ma e ials [33]. Was e p e en ion con inues o pose a majo challenge in all Membe S a es o he EU, including hose wi h high ecycling a es [32]. The use o ecycled ma e ials can con ibu e o pa ially co e ing he o al demand o ma e ials, hus educing he ex ac ion o aw ma e ials. C ea ing e icien seconda y ma e ials ma ke s enables highe alue ecycling cycles since mos ma e ials a e ecycled a e disassembly. The p inciples a e ou lined in Fig. 7.4. 4. Li ecycle Assessmen and Ma e ial Managemen P oduc ion sys ems conce ning e icien use o ma e ials—gi en p io i y o ac i i- ies allowing he de elopmen o CE p inciples om he beginning o he p oduc ion p ocess phases, and no only in i s inal dimensions; i.e., ecycling and econ e - sion o was e—would se e as ecommenda ions aimed a he change o economic models and he ansi ion owa ds a less esou ce-in ensi e economy. E icien use o ma e ials in p oduc ion sys ems is a c i ical aspec o he CE. I is essen ial o p io i ize ac i i ies ha p omo e CE p inciples om he beginning o he p oduc ion p ocess phases, a he han only ocusing on ecycling and econ e sion o was e in i s inal dimensions. 190 P. San os e al. 7.3.2 Collabo a i e App oaches and Business Models In his sec ion, some o he inno a ions in business models ha a e a ec ing he cons uc ion sec o in a ou o CE applied o i s p oduc s a e collec ed. 1. Ci cula Supply Chains and Ne wo ks Cu en ly, he con e sion o adi ional linea supply chains in o ci cula ones o imp o e he managemen o na u al esou ces and educe he olume o was e p oduced is included as one o he goals o he ansi ion o he cons uc ion sec o owa ds CE [82]. The amoun o ma e ial los in demoli ion p ocesses is equi alen o 40% o he o al mass o aw ma e ials ex ac ed in p oduc ion, making he cons uc- ion indus y one o he mos pollu ing indus ies globally [9]. In his sense, one o he mos ambi ious a ge s included in CE is “closing he loop” in he lows o aw ma e ials and esou ces used h oughou he li e cycle o cons uc ion p oduc s [42, 49,83]. Figu e 7.7 p o ides a schema ic o e iew o he ela ionship be ween he s ages wi hin he supply chain and he s akeholde s. In his gene al o e iew, a ansi ion owa ds CE in he building ma e ials supply chain equi es a join e o o all pa icipan s included in he ne wo k [84]. The e- o e, i is necessa y o inc ease anspa ency, a oiding possible weaknesses in he chain and gaps in he ag eemen s. This would gene a e oppo uni ies o indus- ial symbiosis and he in eg a ion o e e se logis ics in manu ac u ing p ocesses, mo ing owa ds a edesign o cu en indus ial p ocesses and imp o ing coo dina- ion be ween esou ces/in en o ies [49]. On he o he hand, he c ea ion o a well- de ined ma ke o CDW would make i possible o inc ease consume demand o hese ecycledp oduc s, mo ing owa dsag eensupplychain ha in eg a es he en i- onmen al cos s de i ed om he p oduc dis ibu ion p ocess [26]. In addi ion, o a ansi ion owa ds ci cula i y in he cons uc ion sec o , i is necessa y o eco e he seconda y aw ma e ials gene a ed in demolished buildings a he end o hei use ul li e and, in u n, o analyse hei iabili y o ecycling, eco e y o einco po a ion Fig. 7.7 Fullsupplychaincycleands akeholde sin ol ed(Sou ce ownelabo a ionbasedon Cheng e al. [82]) 7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 191 in he p oduc ion o new p oduc s [85]. A his poin , se e al au ho s ag ee on he impo ance o educing and sepa a ing CDW a sou ce o imp o e i s managemen p ocess [86]. Wi h his sepa a ion a he s a ing poin , he logis ical cos s and en i- onmen al impac in e ms o CO2equi alen emissions de i ed om anspo o he p ocessing plan would be educed, so ha bo h anspo jou neys and anspo ed mass would be educed. 2. Sha ing Economy and P oduc -as-a-Se ice Models Indus ial s a egies o alue c ea ion ha e changed adically in ecen yea s as a consequence o globalisa ion and p og essi e echnological de elopmen [87]. This e olu ion has a ec ed he cons uc ion indus y, which is e ol ing om p oduc p ocu emen -cen ed hinking owa ds p oduc -se ice sys ems (PSS) [88]. In his way, building p oduc manu ac u e s a e o ced o edesign hei manu ac u ing p ocesses and complexi y inc eases in he ea ly s ages o de elopmen o accom- moda e his new business model [89]. By o e ing p oduc -associa ed unc ionali y, manu ac u e s a e obliged o ha e a deep unde s anding o how hei p oduc s beha e a e con inuous use, which p o ides addi ional mo i a ion o imp o e he skills associa ed wi h he enginee ing and p oduc design s ages h ough expe ience [90]. Howe e , as in o he indus ial sec o s, he e mus be a ecep i eness on he pa o consume s when i comes o accep ing his p oduc and se ice model. In his ega d, Fig. 7.8 schema ically shows he ex e nal and in e nal ac o s ound in he li e a u e ha o a ce ain ex en condi ion he accep ance o his business model in cons uc ion. Se e al au ho s ha e wo ked wi h his business model ying o adap di e en p oduc s o his “se i isa ion” p ocess. Examples a e linked o cons uc ion equip- men [87], cons uc ion machine y [90], p e ab ica ed building componen s [91] o building componen s [92]. Impo an ly, he p oduc -as-a-se ice model b ings Fig. 7.8 In e nalandex e nalde e minan so p oduc -as-a-se icemodels(Sou ce ownelabo a ion based on Cook e al. [89]) 192 P. San os e al. ad an ages om an en i onmen al poin o iew, conside ing he ull li e cycle o he p oduc and i s subsequen eco e y possibili ies [93], as well as con inuous imp o emen based on in o ma ion sha ing ha boos s he sus ainabili y o building p oduc s [88]. Finally, and in ela ion o he p oduc -as-a-se ice business model, i is wo h highligh ing how in ecen decades he collabo a i e economy has been encou aged o p omo e sus ainabili y. This concep add esses he possibili y o using high-p iced physical asse s wi hou he need o buy hem, educing was e due o obsolescence o disuse [91]. Fu he mo e, hanks o he ad ancemen o in o ma ion and commu- nica ion echnologies, i is possible o p omo e a mo e democ a ic o ganiza ion and educe in o ma ion asymme ies in a ou o a CE in cons uc ion [94]. 3. Ex ended P oduc Responsibili y Ex ended p oduc esponsibili y (EPR) was i s de ined a he beginning o he cen u y by Lindhq is as a s a egy o p o ec he en i onmen and is in ended o ensu e ha any p oduc manu ac u e akes esponsibili y o i s en i e li e cycle, inco po a ing he s ages o eco e y, ecycling, collec ion and disposal [95]. This app oach would change he cu en p oduc ion model a ec ing he cons uc ion indus y by egula izing and se ing he ules o he p ope managemen o cons uc- ion and demoli ion was e in line wi h he Eu opean G een Deal guidelines [1]. This app oachisal eadybeingadap ed o ce ainp oduc sa ound hewo ld,suchasEu o- pean legisla ion o plas ic p oduc s [96], o ai condi ione s and washing machines in Japan [97]. Howe e , inal cons uc ion p oduc s, unde s ood as ci il in as uc u es o build- ings, a e complex and ailo -made en i ies in each design, which makes i di icul o s anda dize and ace he p o o ypes p oduced o he ma ke [98]. In his sense, i is possible o hink o an EPR localized o he main aw ma e ials used in he elabo a ion o cons uc ion sys ems. Howe e , he use ul li e o hese is a ely less han 50 yea s and i is di icul o manage he inal managemen o hese p oduc s [98]. The e o e,as a as EPR isconce ned,i isnecessa y o examinecu en ini ia i es, egula ions and p ac ices in he cons uc ion sec o o unde s and hei sui abili y and abili y o add ess he issue o end-o -li e managemen o CDW [99]. Only in his way, i will be possible o build a legisla i e amewo k o building and ci il wo ks, buil on he “pollu e pays” p inciple, encou aging p oduce s o inco po a e CE c i e ia in hei manu ac u ing p ocesses, p omo ing eco-design and suppo ing he ecycling, eco e y and inal euse o cons uc ion p oduc s [100,101]. 4. Public–P i a e Pa ne ships and Policy Implica ions Public–p i a e pa ne ships (PPPs) a e a use ul ool in he cons uc ion sec o o le e age public esou ces and p i a e managemen expe ise in mo ing owa ds a ci cula and sus ainable economy [102]. These pa ne ships a e es ablished based on a long- e m ela ionship o us , whe e esou ces, knowledge, skills and sha ed 7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 193 Table 7.3 Ad an ages and disad an ages o public–p i a e pa ne ships in he cons uc ion sec o (Sou ce Bao e al. [109]) Ad an ages Disad an ages ✓Public sec o s can alle ia e esponsibili y ✓Long nego ia ion pe iods ✓P i a e sec o s can mode a e in es men ✓Lack o lexibili y ✓Public sec o s can d aw on p i a e sec o expe ise ✓Inequali y o isk and e u n ✓Public–p i a e pa ne ship is s eng hened in he long e m ✓Lack o anspa ency in Ag eemen s esponsibili y o decision-making a e exchanged [103,104]. Howe e , hese pa - ne ships a e no always a ou able and ha e se e al ad an ages and disad an ages ha can be seen in Table 7.3. While i is ue ha PPPs a e commonly accep ed in he de elopmen o acili ies, including design, inancing and implemen a ion [105], such as he supply o d inking wa e in la ge ci ies [106], in was e managemen o a CE he e is s ill a long way o go. In he EU, p og ess is being made owa ds a policy amewo k o p omo e such an ag eemen o educe he en i onmen al impac o he cons uc ion sec o [107]. Howe e , his ansi ion is slow and o en no as e icien as desi ed and making in as uc u e esilien will equi e a change o mindse on he pa o p i a e managemen and las ing suppo om go e nmen s [108]. 7.3.3 Technological Inno a ions o Ci cula Ma e ial Usage CE cons i u es an impulse o imp o ing he p oduc i i y o he cons uc ion sec o wi h a need o in es men in echnology and digi alisa ion. Acco ding o Fe e e al. [33], he scale and e iciency o ne wo ks o ecycled, alued and eco e ed cons uc ion ma e ials a e undamen al o he ollowing poin s ou lined in Fig. 7.9. Inno a ion ecosys ems o boos e-indus ializa ion and sus ainabili y in he cons uc ion sec o ad oca e he p omo ion and suppo o R +D+I (Resea ch, De elopmen and Inno a ion) and knowledge ans e ins umen s on: echnologies 4.0; ecycling and eco e y o ma e ials and componen s which a e mo e complex o ecycle (plas ics, composi es, was e); p oduc i i y imp o emen s in componen manu ac u ing and eco e y (3D, obo ics, A i icial In elligence (AI), In e ne o Things (IoT); new long-las ing ma e ials; and ma e ials aceabili y echnologies (blockchain) [33]. 1. Ad anced Recycling Technologies Resou ce eco e y as business model and d i e o CE ocuses p ima ily on eco e y o used ma e ials o ene gy om was e—e.g., ecycled s eel and ib es, and ecycled agg ega es o hei use in cons uc ion o in o he sec o s; being indus ial and 194 P. San os e al. Fig. 7.9 Fundamen als in ci cula ma e ial usage (Sou ce own elabo a ion based on Fe e e al. [33]) ene gy symbiosis among complemen a y sec o s essen ial o he adop ion o he CE p inciples [33]. In he con ex o cons uc ion, disassembly and ecycling bes p ac ices a e employed o e alue he use o cons uc ion was e, which is o en conside ed “low alue” ma e ial. Tes ing me hods o disassembly, ea men , and ecycling would help o op imize he eco e y and euse o ma e ials, con ibu ing o he e icien use o esou ces in he p oduc ion p ocess [33]. By implemen ing hese ad anced ecycling echnologies, he cons uc ion indus y can educe was e, minimize he ex ac ion o i gin esou ces, and p omo e a mo e sus ainable app oach o ma e ials managemen . Fu he mo e, hese echnologies enable he ans o ma ion o was e in o aluable esou ces, p omo ing he de elopmen o a CE. Recycled s eel, ib es, and agg ega es can be u ilized in a ious sec o s, including cons uc ion; c ea ing a closed-loop sys em whe e ma e ials a e con inuously eused and ecycled. This no only educes he en i onmen al impac o esou ce ex ac ion bu also con ibu es o he de elopmen o a mo e esou ce-e icien and less was e ul economy [110]. O e all, ad anced ecycling echnologies and esou ce eco e y play a c ucial ole in d i ing he ansi ion owa ds a CE by maximizing he alue o was e ma e ials and minimizing esou ce consump ion. By adop ing hese echnologies and p inciples, indus ies can con ibu e o a mo e sus ainable and esou ce-e icien u u e. 7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 195 2. In elligen So ing and Sepa a ion Sys ems In elligen so ing and sepa a ion sys ems a e pi o al in ad ancing he p inciples o he CE by enhancing he e iciency and e ec i eness o was e managemen and esou ce eco e y p ocesses. These sys ems le e age cu ing-edge echnologies such as AI, machine lea ning, compu e ision, and obo ics o accu a ely iden i y, so , and seg ega e di e se ma e ials. This enables hei app op ia e ecycling, euse, o eco e y, he ebyp omo ingsus ainablep ac ices.Byau oma ing heso ingp ocess, hese sys ems enhance he pu i y and quali y o eco e ed ma e ials, augmen ing hei alue o subsequen euse o ecycling. Mo eo e , hey op imize esou ce allo- ca ion by dynamically adjus ing pa ame e s, such as con eyo speed and senso se ings, he eby maximizing e iciency while minimizing was e. These sys ems also play a c i ical ole in de ec ing and elimina ing con aminan s, he eby imp o ing he quali y o eco e ed ma e ials and mi iga ing he isk o c oss-con amina ion. Wi h hei excep ional accu acy and speed in so ing, hey educe manual labou equi e- men s, inc ease h oughpu capaci y, and enable he p ocessing o la ge olumes o was e. Fu he mo e, in elligen so ing sys ems gene a e aluable da a pe aining o was e composi ion, quan i y, and quali y [33]. This da a-d i en app oach acili a es in o med decision-making, p ocess op imiza ion, and he de elopmen o no el ecy- cling echnologies. By in eg a ing in o ci cula supply chains, hese sys ems acili- a e he e icien eco e y and ein oduc ion o ecycled ma e ials, he eby closing he loop in he CE. As echnology con inues o ad ance, hese sys ems a e poised o makesigni ican con ibu ions o esou cee iciency,was e educ ion,andsus ainable ma e ial u iliza ion. 3. Digi alisa ion and Blockchain Applica ions The p omo ion o he gua an eed sys em o componen s and spa e pa s, digi al aceabili y (Eu opean passpo ) and associa ed documen a ion a e equi emen s o he deli e y o sus ainable and ci cula buil en i onmen [33]. Complemen a ily, inancial aid o in es men s by indus ialized and sus ainable cons uc ion compa- nies—e.g., modula design, BIM (Building In o ma ion Modelling), IoT digi aliza- ion, 3D p in ing, cu ing obo ics, …—, and suppo o componen s’ banks and ma e ial passpo s, a e p oposed as d i e s o o e s in public–p i a e collabo a ion [33]. Rega ding ci cula i y o ma e ials, blockchain solu ion o ma e ials passpo emb aces echnology agains he low anspa ency and aceabili y o he ma e ials used—e.g., ib e pla es, s eels, coa ings, acades. Collabo a i e design and manu ac- u ing (BIM, IoT, …) bene i by he a ailabili y o new echnologies which in eg a e design, wi h p oduc ion and deli e y sys ems—JIT (Jus -In-Time) deli e y—a he cons uc ion si e. 4. Robo ic Decons uc ion Technological inno a ions in decons uc ion include ad anced ools and echniques used o disman le and epu pose buildings and s uc u es in a mo e e icien , sus ain- able, and p o i able manne . These inno a ions aim o educe was e, minimize en i- onmen al impac , and imp o e sa e y du ing he decons uc ion p ocess. The use 196 P. San os e al. o obo s o decons uc ion is a p omising app oach ha can imp o e e iciency and sus ainabili y in he cons uc ion indus y. T adi ional demoli ion me hods ha e signi ican isks and en i onmen al impac s, especially in conges ed u ban a eas [111].In Japan, al e na i eme hods using Single-Task Cons uc ion Robo s (STCRs) andsemi-au oma edon-si e ac o iesha ebeende eloped oadd esslegal,economic, and ecological needs. Howe e , implemen ing adi ional indus ial obo s in a decons uc ion en i onmen poses challenges, pa icula ly in e ms o human– obo in e ac ion and collabo a ion. To o e come hese challenges, e icien human– obo collabo a ion is conside ed in he design o decons uc ion STCRs. Addi ionally, he applica ion o he Robo -O ien ed Design me hod can make he ope a ion o he decons uc ion sys em mo e e icien . Building componen s should be compa ible wi h obo ic applica ions, and connec o s and join s be ween componen s should p o ide easy access o equipmen du ing he disassembly phase. The use o obo s o decons uc ion can sa e ene gy, money, and ime while minimizing casual ies and dis u bance o he economic en i onmen [111]. A amewo k o he e alua ion o obo -assis ed, sys emized decons uc ion has been p oposed, which includes pe o - mance indica o s ha can be adjus ed based on s akeholde pe spec i es. O e all, he use o obo s in decons uc ion o e s a scalable and sus ainable solu ion o he indus y. 5. Eme ging Ma e ials and Sus ainable Manu ac u ing P ocesses Inno a ion in ma e ials, sus ainable design, and he de elopmen o al e na i e ech- nologies ha equi e di e en ma e ials can help mi iga e supply isk. Solu ions o educe he ecological oo p in and inc ease ma e ial eco e y o imp o e he sa e y and compe i i eness o p oduc ion p ocesses a e wi hin each. Howe e , global scena ios con inue o p esen g ea e complexi y and compe i ion o na u al esou ces [32]. The du a ion and oo p in s o ca bon dioxide (CO2), wa e and ma e ial consump ion a e lowe in indus ialized sys ems, being he en i onmen al impac o ci cula and sus ainable indus ialized cons uc ion suscep ible o di e en modelling scena ios o ecycling pe cen age [33]. 7.3.4 Ba ie s and Enable s o Ci cula Ma e ial Usage Ex ensi e li e a u e has iden i ied ba ie s and enable s o de eloping a ci cula economy in he cons uc ion sec o . Howe e , i is impo an o no e ha a ci cula economy is a mul idimensional concep , and a close inspec ion o exis ing li e - a u e e eals ha ba ie s and enable s ha e p ima ily ocused on he echnical aspec s o ma e ials and p oduc s. Acco ding o a ecen s udy by Cha e e al. [112], ba ie s o he de elopmen o a ci cula economy in he cons uc ion sec o can be ca ego ized in o six dis inc ypes: economic ( e e ing o ma ke ba ie s), socio- logical (pe aining o cul u al o psychological obs acles), poli ical, o ganiza ional (in ol ing s akeholde s), echnological, and en i onmen al (conce ning ecological impac ). Simila ly, Ababio and Lu [113] iden i ied i e ca ego ies o ba ie s: social 7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 197 and cul u al, poli ical and legisla i e, inancial and economic, echnological, and amewo k and heo y ela ed. While esea ch on ba ie s o ci cula economy de elopmen has been ex ensi e, s udies on enable s o he ci cula economy ha e ye o be conduc ed o he same ex en .AbabioandLu [113]ha edepa ed om classi yingandlis ingenable sunde speci ic ca ego ies and ins ead discussed hem unde b oade hemes. Gene ally, enable s a e ela ed o echnology and inno a ion, policy, educa ion and awa eness, as well as inancing and ma ke c ea ion. I is impo an o no e ha a comp ehensi e unde s anding o bo h ba ie s and enable s is c i ical o p omo ing a success ul ansi ion o a ci cula economy in he cons uc ion sec o . This pa o he epo ocuses on he ma e ial usage- ela ed ba ie s o enable s add essed in he li e a u e. They a e discussed unde ou ca ego ies. 1. Economic and Regula o y Ba ie s Nume ous s udies ha e iden i ied insu icien and imma u e ma ke s, as well as a lack o demand o eused and ecycled ma e ials, as he p ima y economic ba ie s o he implemen a ion o ci cula economy p ac ices in he cons uc ion sec o [114–116]. These s udies also sugges ha he cons uc ion indus y is o en c i icized o i s poo lexibili y in adop ing inno a i e p ac ices due o he pe cei ed isk o losing p o i s [112,115]. In he cons uc ion sec o , adop ing CE p ac ices is me wi h a majo challenge— he highe esou ce cos associa ed wi h decons uc ion compa ed o demoli ion. Mo eo e , i gin ma e ials end o be less expensi e han ecycled ma e ials, while ecycling cos s mo e han he disposal o CDW. Un o una ely, he ecen COVID- 19 pandemic has only wo sened hese challenges by s alling economic de elopmen and inc easing he use o single-use ma e ials. The implemen a ion o CE p ac ices in he cons uc ion indus y equi es signi ican in es men s, such as he enewal o equipmen [116]. Mo eo e , ou da ed legisla ion and he lack o s anda dized guides ega ding design and p ocu emen p ocedu es a e majo egula o y ba ie s o CE de elopmen [112,117]. Addi ionally, a lack o go e nmen suppo and he absence o suppo om public ins i u ions ha e been highligh ed as c i ical ba ie s o CE adop ion [112,118]. In o de o p omo e he in eg a ion o ci cula economy p ac ices in he cons uc- ion indus y, i is necessa y o adop new business models and me hods o e alu- a ing asse s ha p io i ize ma e ial alue. Fo ins ance, long- e m in es men s can be made o suppo he ci cula economy business case by u ilizing whole-li e cos ing. Ano he oppo uni y p esen ed by he implemen a ion o ci cula economy p ac ices is he abili y o ans o m he business model in o a p oduc -as-a-se ice con ac (PSS), as no ed by Rizos e al. [119]. Enable s ha ha e been commonly iden i- ied include design-build-ope a e-main ain con ac s and hei a ia ions, acco ding o Ababio and Lu [113]. Fu he mo e, s akeholde s in he cons uc ion indus y ha e epo ed ha implemen ing ci cula economy p ac ices can o e mo e lexible wo king a angemen s, as To gau o e al. [117] epo ed. 198 P. San os e al. 2. Cul u al and Beha iou al Challenges Cul u al and beha iou al changes can p esen signi ican obs acles o he adop ion o inno a i e p ac ices in he cons uc ion indus y. This sec o is known o i s conse a i e na u e and esis ance o new ideas ha challenge exis ing a i udes, cus oms, and belie s. Some o he cul u al issues ha hinde he adop ion o ci cula economy (CE) and sus ainabili y p ac ices among cons uc ion s akeholde s include a lack o awa eness, eluc ance, and isk a e sion. Mo eo e , he e is a p e e ence o i gin cons uc ion ma e ials o e eused and ecycled p oduc s, which is ein o ced by ing ained belie s ha ci cula economy p ac ices a e no easible [112,118]. Se e al s udies ha e in es iga ed s akeholde s’ pe cep ions o he adop ion o CE p ac ices in he cons uc ion indus y. The li e a u e e iewed in his sec ion highligh s ha con ac o s a e hesi an o use e u bished and ecycled ma e ials in hei cons uc ion due o conce ns abou a po en ial dec ease in he quali y o hei p oduc s [27,112,118]. Cus ome s, on he o he hand, may no p e e buildings cons uc ed using old ma e ials. Addi ionally, he quali y o eco e ed ma e ials is o en pe cei ed as in e io o i gin ma e ials, u he uelling scep icism abou he easibili y o CE p ac ices [117]. 3. S akeholde Engagemen and Awa eness In o de o acili a e he widesp ead adop ion o ci cula economy (CE) p ac ices in he cons uc ion indus y, i is impo an o add ess he exis ing cul u al and beha iou al ba ie s. This can be achie ed h ough a a ie y o means, such as educa- ion,awa eness- aising, and cul u al change ini ia i es. By doing so, s akeholde s can wo k owa ds c ea ing a mo e sus ainable and ci cula economy, which would no only bene i he indus y bu also he en i onmen . One e ec i e enabling ool o inc easing awa eness, changing a i udes, and a ec ing beha iou s is dialogue [113]. This can in ol e open and hones commu- nica ion be ween di e en g oups o s akeholde s, including indus y p o essionals, academics, and go e nmen o icials. Th ough dialogue, s akeholde s can gain a be e unde s anding o each o he ’s pe spec i es and wo k collabo a i ely owa ds inding solu ions o indus y challenges. Academic cu icula and p o essional wo kshops a e also impo an enable s o cap u ing CE and i s ange o sus ainable p ac ices [113]. These educa ional oppo u- ni iesp o ides akeholde swi h he equisi eideas and knowledge oadd essindus y challenges. Addi ionally, hey help o ensu e ha indus y p o essionals a e equipped wi h he skills and expe ise needed o implemen sus ainable p ac ices in hei wo k. By in es ing in educa ion and aining oppo uni ies, s akeholde s can wo k owa ds a mo e sus ainable and ci cula economy in he cons uc ion indus y. 4. Go e nmen al Suppo and Incen i es The global cons uc ion indus y is acing a signi ican challenge in emb acing ci cula p ac ices and business models due o he absence o adequa e policies, laws, and amewo ks. The lack o go e nmen suppo , such as inancial aid o ax incen i es, is making i less economically easible o in es in ci cula models, 7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 199 and as a esul , discou aging hei adop ion. The absence o egula o y p essu e and s ic laws also ails o es ablish he necessa y u gency o ci cula i y, and he equi ed beha iou al changes in he cons uc ion indus y a e no aking place. This is a p essing issue ha needs o be add essed so ha he cons uc ion indus y can mo e owa ds a mo e sus ainable and ci cula u u e [27]. Sus ainable de elopmen is becoming inc easingly essen ial, and as a esul , ci cula buildings a e gaining popula i y. The main objec i e o ci cula buildings is o os e he idea o “building as a ma e ial bank” [115], whe e he ma e ials used in he cons uc ion a e s o ed and eused when he building’s li e comes o an end. Howe e , his can only be achie ed i he e is a inancial incen i e o design buildings ha can be easily decons uc ed and econs uc ed. I is wo h no ing ha ci cula buildings a e gene ally mo e cos ly han adi ional buildings. The ci cula economy in he cons uc ion indus y is a complex issue ha equi es he in ol emen o all s akeholde s, including go e nmen s, in es o s, designe s, cons uc o s, and use s. The ansi ion owa ds ci cula p ac ices equi es a signi i- can change in mindse and app oach, as well as he adop ion o new echnologies and sys ems. None heless, he bene i s o ci cula i y in he cons uc ion indus y a e a - eaching, including educed was e and ca bon emissions, inc eased esou ce e i- ciency, and imp o ed social and economic ou comes. The e o e, i is essen ial o all s akeholde s o collabo a e and wo k owa ds a mo e sus ainable u u e o he cons uc ion indus y. 7.4 Case S udies and Bes P ac ices 7.4.1 Case S udy 1—Gonsi Sóc a es Bio-building (Ba celona, Spain) Figu e 7.10 shows he Gonsi Sóc a es Bio-Building which was buil by Cons ucía Company. They ollowed he Lean2C adle®ci cula cons uc ion me hodology [120]. Almos all he building ma e ials (99%) we e cha ac e ized and i s compo- nen s we e e iewed, and up o 50 ypes o ma e ials we e in en o ied. Among hese ma e ials, 89% (8,400 ons) will no become was e a hei end-o -li e bu ha e a ci cula way o be ein oduced in o he p oduc ion p ocess. Thus, when he use ul li e o he building ends, hey can be eused, epai ed o ecycled in he way ha is mos con enien a ha ime, allowing hem o p ese e g ea e alue o he nex use [121]. 206 P. San os e al. conse ing esou ces, and os e ing inno a ion. Fu he mo e, in eg a ing hese p in- ciples suppo s he b oade global sus ainabili y agenda, signi ican ly ad ancing CE p ac ices beyond he cons uc ion sec o . This chap e ela ed o implemen ing CE p inciples in he cons uc ion indus y has e ealed c ucial insigh s o enhancing sus ainabili y and educing en i on- men al impac . Howe e , he slow adop ion o hese p inciples is due o indus y- speci ic ba ie s such as limi ed knowledge and expe ience. The e o e, a collec- i e e o o educa e and dissemina e in o ma ion is essen ial o o e come hese obs acles. Emb acing inno a ion o e s a p omising pa h o p omo ing ci cula i y. Success ul case s udies o ci cula p ac ices can p o ide aluable insigh s o wide indus y adop ion. De eloping obus egula o y amewo ks can incen i ize sus ain- able p ac ices, and in eg a ing ad anced echnologies can op imize was e manage- men p ocesses. Educa ion on ci cula p ac ices is i al, and global collabo a ion is essen ial o s anda dizing uni e sally accep ed app oaches. Re e ences 1. Moschen-Schimek J, Kaspe T, Hube -Hume M (2023) C i ical e iew o he eco e y a es o cons uc ion and demoli ion was e in he Eu opean Union—an analysis o in luencing ac o s in selec ed EU coun ies. Was e Manag Else ie L d 167(Decembe 2022):150–164. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.wasman.2023.05.020 2. Gio gi S, La agna M, Campioli A (2018) Guidelines o e ec i e and sus ainable ecycling o cons uc ion and demoli ion was e. In: Bene o E, Ge icke K, Gui on M (eds) Designing sus ainable echnologies, p oduc s and policies. Sp inge In e na ional Publishing, pp 211– 221. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-319-66981-6 3. Eu opean Commission (2019) Cons uc ion and demoli ion was e—en i onmen . h ps://en i onmen .ec.eu opa.eu/ opics/was e-and- ecycling/cons uc ion-and-demoli ion-was e_en. Accessed 14 July 2023 4. Eu opean Pa liamen and o Council (2008) Di ec i e 2008/98/EC o he Eu opean Pa liamen and o he Council o 19 No embe 2008 on was e, known as “Was e F amewo k Di ec i e” (WFD), consolida ed ( e ised 7-5-2018). O J Eu Union 5. Eu opean Pa liamen (2023) Ci cula economy: de ini ion, impo ance and bene i s. h ps://www.eu opa l.eu opa.eu/news/en/headlines/economy/20151201STO05603/ci cula - economy-de ini ion-impo ance-and-bene i s?&a _campaign=20234-Economy&a _med ium=Google_Ads&a _pla o m=Sea ch&a _c ea ion=RSA&a _goal=TR_G&a _audience= impo ance%20o %20ci cula %20economy&a _ opic=Ci cula _Economy&a _loca ion= IE&gclid=EAIaIQobChMI -6j yVgAMV 4poCR1L QBdEAAYASAAEgLUT_D_BwE. Accessed 9 July 2023 6. Adams KT, Osmani M, Tho pe T, Tho nback J (2017) Ci cula economy in cons uc- ion: cu en awa eness, challenges and enable s. P oc Ins Ci Eng Was e Resou Manag 170(1):15–24 7. Eu opean Commission (2019) COM/2019/640 The Eu opean g een deal. B ussels 8. Eu opeanCommission(2020)COM/2020/98Anewci cula economyac ionplan o acleane and mo e compe i i e Eu ope. B ussels 9. Uni ed Na ions En i onmen al P og amme (2022) 2022 Global s a us epo o buildings and cons uc ion: owa ds a ze o-emission, e icien and esilien buildings and cons uc ion sec o , Nai obi 10. Acha ya D, Boyd R, Finch O (2018) F om p inciples o p ac ice: i s s eps owa ds a ci cula buil en i onmen 7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 207 11. Eu opean Commission (2020) Cons uc ion and demoli ion was e. h ps://en i onmen .ec. eu opa.eu/ opics/was e-and- ecycling/cons uc ion-and-demoli ion-was e_en#publica ions. Accessed 9 July 2023 12. Ellen MacA hu Founda ion (2022) Reimagining ou buildings and spaces o a ci cula economy. h ps://ellenmaca hu ounda ion.o g/ opics/buil -en i onmen /o e iew. Accessed 8 July 2023 13. Мa e ial Economics (2019) Indus ial ans o ma ion 2050: pa hways o ne -ze o emissions om EU hea y indus y. Uni e si y o Camb idge Ins i u e o Sus ainabili y Leade ship (CISL), Camb idge 14. Ellen MacA hu Founda ion (2018) Wha is a ci cula economy? h ps://ellenmaca hu oun da ion.o g/ opics/ci cula -economy-in oduc ion/o e iew. Accessed 9 July 2023 15. Çimen Ö (2023) De elopmen o a ci cula building li ecycle amewo k: incep ion o ci cula ion. Resul s Eng 17:100861 16. Çimen Ö (2021) Cons uc ion and buil en i onmen in ci cula economy: a comp ehensi e li e a u e e iew. J Clean P od 305:127180 17. Reike D, Ve meulen WJV, Wi jes S (2018) The ci cula economy: new o Re u bished as CE 3.0?—Explo ing con o e sies in he concep ualiza ion o he ci cula economy h ough a ocus on his o y and esou ce alue e en ion op ions. Resou Conse Recycl Else ie 135(No embe 2017):246–264. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j. escon ec.2017.08.027 18. Mesa JA, Espa agoza I (2021) Towa ds he implemen a ion o ci cula economy in engi- nee ing educa ion: a sys ema ic e iew. In: 2021 IEEE on ie s in educa ion con e ence (FIE), 13–16 Oc 2021, pp 1–8 19. Po ing J, Hekke M, Wo elland E, Hanemaaije A (2017) Ci cula economy: measu ing inno a ion in he p oduc chain. PBL 20. Ga g R (2022) He e’s how o c ea e a ci cula sys em o he buil en i onmen . In: Uni ed Na ions clima e change con e ence COP27: wo ld economic o um 21. Ellen MacA hu Founda ion (2019) Ci cula economy bu e ly diag am. h ps://ellenmaca hu ounda ion.o g/ci cula -economy-diag am. Accessed 9 July 2023 22. O enhaus LM (2022) Bu e ly diag am o ci cula buildings ( e sion 1). igsha e. h ps:// doi.o g/10.6084/m9. igsha e.21249573. 1 23. Eu opean Commission (2019) A sus ainable bioeconomy o Eu ope: s eng hening he connec ion be ween economy, socie y and he en i onmen : upda ed bioeconomy s a egy. Publica ions O ice o he Eu opean Union, B ussels 24. Technical Uni e si y Munich (2017) Cascading use o wood o ensu e sus ainabili y. h ps:// phys.o g/news/2017-12-cascading-wood-sus ainabili y.h ml 25. Ellen MacA hu Founda ion (2022) The biological cycle o he bu e ly diag am. h ps://ell enmaca hu ounda ion.o g/a icles/ he-biological-cycle-o - he-bu e ly-diag am. Accessed 9 July 2023 26. Muna o MR, Ta a es SF (2023) A e iew on ba ie s, d i e s, and s akeholde s owa ds he ci cula economy: he cons uc ion sec o pe spec i e. Clean Respons Consump 8:100107. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.cl c.2023.100107 27. Wuni IY (2022) Mapping he ba ie s o ci cula economy adop ion in he cons uc ion indus y: a sys ema ic e iew, Pa e o analysis, and mi iga ion s a egy map. Build En i on 223:109453 28. Spa anda a L, We ne M, Kaminsky A, Finch L, Douglas K (2020) Accele a ing he ci cula economy h ough comme cial decons uc ion and euse 29. Akinade O, Oyedele L, Oyedele A, Da ila Delgado JM, Bilal M, Akanbi L, Ajayi A, Owolabi H (2020) Design o decons uc ion using a ci cula economy app oach: ba ie s and s a egies o imp o emen . P od Plan Con ol 31(10):829–840 30. B own M, Hasels eine E, Ap ó D, Kope a D, Luca E, Pulkkinen K, Vula Riz anolli B (2018) Sus ainabili y, es o a i e o egene a i e. Publica ions COST ac ion RESTORE CA16114, wo king g oup one epo . h ps://www.eu es o e.eu/wp-con en /uploads/2018/04/Sus ainab ili y-Res o a i e- o-Regene a i e.pd . Accessed 14 July 2023 208 P. San os e al. 31. Dumée LF (2022) Ci cula ma e ials and ci cula design— e iew on challenges owa ds sus ainable manu ac u ing and ecycling. Ci c Econ Sus ain 2:9–23. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/ s43615-021-00085-2. Accessed 14 July 2023 32. Mo a ó J, Jiménez LM, Calle os-Islas A, De la C uz JL, Díaz LD, Ma ínez J, P-Lagüela E, Penagos G, Pe nas JJ, Ro i a S, Sanz FJ, Tollin N, Villanue a B, Woischnik A (2021) In o me COTEC – Si uación y E olución de la Economía Ci cula en España. Mad id: Fundación Co ec pa a la inno ación. h ps://co ec.es/obse acion/economia-ci cula / 62c16db-5823- deb4-7986-a786e5c3401c. Accessed 18 Aug 2023 33. Fe e J, He e ía N, Remón A, A mas R, Díez de Ri e a T, Ramos I, Sa o i T, Isla M, Mo a ó J, Villanue a B, Ba alla J, Villa M (2022) P oyec o Economía Ci cula España – Acele ando la T ansición en el Sec o de Cons ucción. h ps://www.accen u e.com/con en /dam/acc en u e/ inal/accen u e-com/documen /Accen u e-EC-Espana-In o me-Sec o -Cons uccion. pd . Accessed 19 Aug 2023 34. Ellen Maca hu Founda ion (2023) h ps://ellenmaca hu ounda ion.o g/. Accessed 8 July 2023 35. Cha e R, Lu W, Hall D (2022) The ansi ion o he ci cula economy o he cons uc ion indus y: insigh s in o sus ainable app oaches o imp o e he unde s anding. J Clean P od Else ie L d 364(June):132421. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2022.132421 36. Nußholz J e al (2023) F om ci cula s a egies o ac ions: 65 Eu opean ci cula building cases and hei deca bonisa ion po en ial. Resou Conse Recycl Ad 17(Janua y). h ps://doi.o g/ 10.1016/j. c ad .2023.200130 37. Se aki F, an Timme en A (2022) Dis up i e echnologies o a ci cula building indus y. Build En i on Else ie L d 223(July):109394. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.builden . 2022.109394 38. Ta a es TM e al (2023) The bene i s and ba ie s o addi i e manu ac u ing o ci cula economy: a amewo k p oposal. Sus ain P od Consump Else ie L d 37:369–388. h ps:// doi.o g/10.1016/j.spc.2023.03.006 39. Oluleye BI, Chan DWM, An wi-A a i P (2023) Adop ing A i icial In elligence o enhancing he implemen a ion o sys emic ci cula i y in he cons uc ion indus y: a c i ical e iew. Sus ainP odConsumpIns ChemEng 35:509–524.h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.spc.2022.12.002 40. Ma sh ATM, Velen u APM, Be nal SA (2022) Ci cula economy s a egies o conc e e: implemen a ionand in eg a ion.JClean P od Else ie L d362(Oc obe 2021):132486. h ps:// doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2022.132486 41. Figge F e al (2018) Longe i y and ci cula i y as indica o s o eco-e icien esou ce use in he ci cula economy. Ecol Econ Else ie 150(No embe 2017):297–306. h ps://doi.o g/10. 1016/j.ecolecon.2018.04.030 42. Ki chhe J, Reike D, Hekke M (2017) Concep ualizing he ci cula economy: an analysis o 114 de ini ions. Resou Conse Recycl 127:221–232. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j. escon ec. 2017.09.005 43. Mollaei A, Bachmann C, Haas C (2023) Es ima ing he eco e able alue o in-si u building ma e ials. Sus ain Ci ies Soc 91:104455. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.scs.2023.104455.66 44. Zhuang GL, Shih SG, Wagi i F (2023) Ci cula economy and sus ainable de elopmen goals: explo ing he po en ials o eusable modula componen s in ci cula economy business model. J Clean P od Else ie L d 414:137503. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2023.137503 45. Haines-Gadd M, Cha nley F, Encinas-O opesa A (2021) Sel -healing ma e ials: a pa hway o immo al p oduc s o a isk o ci cula economy sys ems? J Clean P od Else ie L d 315(May 2020):128193. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2021.128193 46. A a N (2023) Remanu ac u ing owa ds ci cula i y in he cons uc ion sec o : he ole o digi al echnologies. In:Technologicalimagina ion in he g eenand digi al ansi ion. Sp inge In e na ional Publishing, pp 493–503. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/978-3-031-29515-7_45 47. Van S ijn A, G uis V (2020) Towa ds a ci cula buil en i onmen : an in eg al design ool o ci cula building componen s. Sma Sus ain Buil En i on 9(4):635–653. h ps://doi.o g/10. 1108/SASBE-05-2019-0063 7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 209 48. Hosseini MR e al (2015) Re e se logis ics in he cons uc ion indus y. Was e Manag Res 33(6):499–514. h ps://doi.o g/10.1177/0734242X15584842 49. Ding L, Wang T, Chan PW (2023) Fo wa d and e e se logis ics o ci cula economy in cons uc ion: a sys ema ic li e a u e e iew. J Clean P od 388:135891. h ps://doi.o g/10. 1016/j.jclep o.2023.135981 50. An wi-A a i P, Ng ST, Hossain MU (2021) A e iew o he ci cula i y gap in he cons uc ion indus y h ough scien ome ic analysis. J Clean P od Else ie L d 298:126870. h ps://doi. o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2021.126870 51. Ha J e al (2019) Ba ie s and d i e s in a ci cula economy: he case o he buil en i- onmen . P ocedia CIRP Else ie B.V. 80(Ma ch):619–624. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.p oci . 2018.12.015 52. ebuydeal.com (2023) h ps://www. ebuydeal.com/en/buy-sell-second-hand/115/building- ma e ials. Accessed 15 July 2023 53. seconduse.com (2023) h ps://www.seconduse.com/in en o y/ca ego ies/lumbe /. Accessed 15 July 2023 54. o o dc.com (2023) Ro o DC—decons uc ion and consul ing. h ps:// o o dc.com/shop/ca ego y/doo -32. Accessed 15 July 2023 55. Oluleye BI e al (2022) Ci cula economy esea ch on building cons uc ion and demoli ion was e: a e iew o cu en ends and u u e esea ch di ec ions. J Clean P od Else ie L d 357(Decembe 2021):131927. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2022.131927 56. Ghobadi M, Sepasgoza SME (2023) Ci cula economy s a egies in mode n imbe cons uc- ion as a po en ial esponse o clima e change. J Build Eng Else ie L d 107229. h ps://doi. o g/10.1016/j.jobe.2023.107229 57. Ahn N e al (2022) Ci cula economy in mass imbe cons uc ion: s a e-o - he-a , gaps and p essing esea ch needs. J Build Eng Else ie L d 53(May):104562. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/ j.jobe.2022.104562 58. Llana DF e al (2022) C oss Lamina ed Timbe (CLT) manu ac u ed wi h Eu opean oak eco e ed om demoli ion: s uc u al p ope ies and non-des uc i e e alua ion. Cons Build Ma e 339(No embe 2021). h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.conbuildma .2022.127635 59. Cobî zan N e al (2020) Mic oscopical and mac oscopical analysis o eco e ed b icks o assessing hei eusabili y in mason y buildings. P ocedia Manu Else ie B.V. 46:144–149. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.p om g.2020.03.022 60. Ramos M e al (2023) Local scale dynamics o p omo e he sus ainable managemen o cons uc ion and demoli ion was e. Resou Conse Recycl Ad 17(Feb ua y). h ps://doi. o g/10.1016/j. c ad .2023.200135 61. dos Reis GS e al (2021) Cu en applica ions o ecycled agg ega es om cons uc ion and demoli ion: a e iew. Ma e ials 14(7). h ps://doi.o g/10.3390/ma14071700 62. Sahoo P e al (2023) Seques a ion and u iliza ion o ca bon dioxide o imp o e enginee ing p ope ies o cemen -based cons uc ion ma e ials wi h ecycled b ick powde : a pa hway o cleane cons uc ion. Cons Build Ma e Else ie L d 395(June):132268. h ps://doi.o g/10. 1016/j.conbuildma .2023.132268 63. Be gonzoni M, Melloni R, Bo i L (2023) Analysis o sus ainable conc e e ob ained om he by-p oduc so anindus ial p ocess and ecycledagg ega es om cons uc ionand demoli ion was e. P ocedia Compu Sci Else ie B.V. 217(2022):41–51. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.p ocs. 2022.12.200 64. Fe ández D e al (2023) Towa ds a mo e sus ainable en i onmen ally p oduc ion sys em o he ea men o ecycled agg ega es in he cons uc ion indus y: an expe imen al s udy. Heliyon 9(6). h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e16641 65. Za agoza-Benzal A, Fe ández D, San os P e al (2023) Reco e y o end-o -li e y es and mine alwool was e:a case s udy wi h gypsumcomposi e ma e ials applying ci cula economy c i e ia. Ma e ials 16(1):243. h ps://doi.o g/10.3390/ma16010243 66. Za agoza-Benzal A, Fe ández D, A anes-Sánchez E e al (2023) New ligh ened plas e ma e- ial wi h dissol ed ecycled expanded polys y ene and end-o -li e y es ib es o building p e ab ica ed indus y. Case S ud Cons Ma e 18(Oc obe 2022):e02178. h ps://doi.o g/10. 1016/j.cscm.2023.e02178 210 P. San os e al. 67. So munen P e al (2021) An e alua ion o he moplas ic composi e ille s de i ed om cons uc ion and demoli ion was e based on hei economic and en i onmen al cha ac e is ics. J Clean P od 280. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2020.125198 68. Ahmed N (2023) U ilizing plas ic was e in he building and cons uc ion indus y: a pa hway owa ds he ci cula economy. Cons Build Ma e Else ie L d 383(Decembe 2022):131311. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.conbuildma .2023.131311 69. Özçelikci E e al (2023) Eco-hyb id cemen -based building insula ion ma e ials as a ci cula economysolu ion ocons uc ionand demoli ionwas e.Cemen Conc Compos141(Janua y). h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.cemconcomp.2023.105149 70. Seco A e al (2018) Sus ainable un i ed b icks manu ac u ing om cons uc ion and demoli- ion was es. Cons Build Ma e Else ie L d 167:154–165. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.conbui ldma .2018.02.026 71. dos Reis GS e al (2020) Fab ica ion, mic os uc u e, and p ope ies o i ed clay b icks using cons uc ion and demoli ion was e sludge as he main addi i e. J Clean P od 258. h ps://doi. o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2020.120733 72. Islam S, Islam J, Robiul Hoque NM (2022) Imp o emen o consolida ion p ope ies o clay soil using ine-g ained cons uc ion and demoli ion was e. Heliyon The Au ho (s) 8(10):e11029. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e11029 73. GiannopoulouIe al(2023)High empe a u epe o manceo geopolyme sbasedon cons uc- ion and demoli ion was e. J Build Eng Else ie L d 72(Feb ua y):106575. h ps://doi.o g/10. 1016/j.jobe.2023.106575 74. He X e al (2022) Recycling o plas ic was e conc e e o p epa e an e ec i e addi i e o ea ly s eng h and la e pe meabili y imp o emen o cemen pas e. Cons Build Ma e Else ie L d 347(June):128581. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.conbuildma .2022.128581 75. Thwe Win T e al (2023) Use o polyp opylene ibe s ex ac ed om ecycled su gical ace masks in cemen mo a . Cons Build Ma e Else ie L d 391(Ma ch):131845. h ps://doi. o g/10.1016/j.conbuildma .2023.131845 76. Ál a ez M e al (2022) ‘Pe o mance cha ac e isa ion o a new plas e composi e ligh ened wi h end-o -li e y es’ ecycled ma e ials o alse ceiling pla es. Ma e ials 5660. h ps://doi. o g/10.3390/ma15165660 77. San os P, Ma eus D (2020) Expe imen al assessmen o he mal b eak s ips pe o mance in load-bea ing and non-load-bea ing LSF walls. J Build Eng Else ie L d 32:101693. h ps:// doi.o g/10.1016/j.jobe.2020.101693 78. San os P e al (2022) Nume ical simula ion and expe imen al alida ion o he mal b eak s ips’ Imp o emen in Facade LSF Walls. Ene gies 15(21):8169. h ps://doi.o g/10.3390/en1 5218169 79. Paih e PL, Lalngaihawma AC, Saini G (2019) Recycled agg ega e illed was e plas ic bo les as a eplacemen o b icks. Ma e Today P oc Else ie L d. 15:663–668. h ps://doi.o g/10. 1016/j.ma p .2019.04.135 80. Lamy-mendes A e al (2022) Ae ogel composi es p oduced om silica and ecycled ubbe sols o he mal insula ion. Ma e ials 15(22):7897. h ps://doi.o g/10.3390/ma15227897 81. Rod igues Pon inha AD e al (2023) The momechanical pe o mance assessmen o sus ain- able buildings’ insula ing ma e ials unde accele a ed ageing condi ions. Gels 9(3):241. h ps://doi.o g/10.3390/gels9030241 82. Cheng Q, Feng H, Ga cia de So o B (2022) Re amping cons uc ion supply chain p ocesses wi h ci cula economy s a egies: a sys ema ic li e a u e e iew. J Clean P od 335:130240. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2021.130240 83. Bocken NMP, Oli e i EA, Cullen JM, Po ing J, Li se R (2017) Taking he ci cula i y o he nex le el: a special issue on he ci cula economy: aking ci cula i y o he nex le el. J Ind Ecol 21:476–482 84. Rabnawaz R, Zhang X (2021) Mul i-s age ne wo k-based wo- ype cos minimiza ion o he e e se logis ics managemen o ine cons uc ion was e. Was e Manag 120:805–819. h ps:// doi.o g/10.1016/j.wasman.2020.11.004 7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 211 85. Komko a A, Kabe G (2023) Op imal supply chain ne wo ks o was e ma e ials used in alkali-ac i a ed conc e e os e ing ci cula economy. Resou Conse Recycl 193:106949. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j. escon ec.2023.106949 86. Pallewa S, Wee asoo iyageda a M, Bo doloi S, Sa mah AK, Vi hanage M (2023) Rep o- cessed cons uc ion and demoli ion was e as an adso ben : an app aisal. Sci To En i on 882:163340. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.sci o en .2023.163340 87. Ru ald R, Be oni A, Johansson C (2019) A ole o physical p o o yping in p oduc -se ice sys em design: case s udy in cons uc ion equipmen . P ocedia 83:358–362. h ps://doi.o g/ 10.1016/j.p oci .2019.03.099 88. Tseng ML, Lin S, Chen CC, Calaho ano LS, Tan CL (2019) A causal sus ainable p oduc - se ice sys em using hie a chical s uc u e wi h linguis ic p e e ences in he Ecuado ian cons uc ion indus y. J Clean P od 230:477–487. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2019. 05.140 89. Cook M, Go be g A, Angus A, Longhu s P (2012) Recep i i y o he p oduc ion o p oduc se ice sys ems in he UK cons uc ion and manu ac u ing sec o s: a compa a i e analysis. J Clean P od 32:61–70. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2012.03.018 90. DongminZ,DachaoH,YuchunX,HongZ(2012)A amewo k o designknowledgemanage- men and euse o p oduc -se ice sys ems in cons uc ion machine y indus y. Compu Ind 63:328–337. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.compind.2012.02.008 91. Li CZ, Chen Z, Xue F, Kong X, Xiao B, Lai X, Zhao Y (2019) A blockchain- and IoT-based sma p oduc -se ice sys em o he sus ainabili y o p e ab ica ed housing cons uc ion. J Clean P od 286:125391. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2020.125391 92. Ness D, Xing K, Kim K, Jenkins A (2019) An ICT-enabled p oduc se ice sys em o euse o building componen s. IFAC 52:761–766. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.i acol.2019.11.207 93. K is ensen HS, Remmen A (2019) A amewo k o sus ainable alue p oposi ions in p oduc - se ice sys ems. J Clean P od 223:25–35. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2019.03.074 94. Thie e A, Koopman C, Hobson A, Kuipe C (2016) How he In e ne , he sha ing economy, and epu a ional eedback mechanisms sol e he “Lemons P oblem”. Law Re 830. h ps:// eposi o y.law.miami.edu/uml / ol70/iss3/6 95. Lindhq is T (2000) Ex ended p oduce esponsibili y in cleane p oduc ion: policy p inciple o p omo e en i onmen al imp o emen s o p oduc sys ems. Lund Uni e si y 96. Filho WL, Saa i U, Fedo uk M, Ii al A, Moo a H, Klöga M, Vo ono a V (2019) An o e iew o he p oblems posed by plas ic p oduc s and he ole o ex ended p oduce esponsibili y in Eu ope. J Clean P od 214:550–558. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2018.12.256 97. Jang YC (2010) Was e elec ical and elec onic equipmen (WEEE) managemen in Ko ea: gene a ion, collec ion, and ecycling sys ems. J Ma e Cycles Was e Manag 12:283–294. h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s10163-010-0298-5 98. Xu J, Ye M, Lu W, Bao Z, Webs e C (2021) A ou -quad an concep ual amewo k o analyzing ex ended p oduce esponsibili y in o sho e p e ab ica ion cons uc ion. J Clean P od 282:124540. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2020.124540 99. Campbell-JhonsonK, Calis oM, ThapaK, Lake eld D,Ve meulen WJV(2020) Howci cula is you y e: Expe iences wi h ex ended p oduce esponsibili y om a ci cula economy pe spec i e. J Clean P od 279:122042. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2020.122042 100. Fe ão P, Ribei o P, Sil a P (2008) A managemen sys em o end-o -li e y es: a Po uguese case s udy. Was e Manage 28(3):604–614. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.wasman.2007.02.033 101. Deu z P (2009) P oduce esponsibili y in a sus ainable de elopmen con ex : ecological mode nisa iono indus ialecology?Geog J175(4):274–285.h ps://doi.o g/10.1111/j.1475- 4959.2009.00330.x 102. ZhangX,UllahYousa HMA(2020)G eensupplychaincoo dina ionconside inggo e nmen in e en ion, g een in es men , and cus ome g een p e e ences in he pe oleum indus y. J Clean P od 246:118984. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2019.118984 103. Glasbe gen P (2011) Mechanisms o p i a e me a-go e nance: an analysis o global p i a e go e nance o sus ainable de elopmen . In J S a Bus Alliances 2(3):19–206. h ps://doi. o g/10.1504/IJSBA.2011.040886 212 P. San os e al. 104. Xie Y, Zhao Y, Chen Y, Allen C (2022) G een cons uc ion supply chain managemen : in eg a ing go e nmen al in e en ion and public–p i a e pa ne ships h ough ecological mode nisa ion. J Clean P od 331:129986. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jclep o.2021.129986 105. Tang L,Shen Q,Cheng EWL (2009)A e iew o s udieson Public-P i a e pa ne shipp ojec s in he cons uc ion indus y. In J P oj Manag 28:683–694. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.ijp oman. 2009.11.009 106. Munoz-Jo e J, Hinojosa S, Mascle-Allemand AL, Temp ano J (2023) A selec i i y index o public-p i a e pa ne ship p ojec s in he u ban wa e and sani a ion sec o in La in Ame ica and he Ca ibbean. J En i on Manage 335:117564. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.jen man.2023. 117564 107. Aza ian M, Tadege A, Laed e O, Wondimu P, K is ian T (2023) P ojec owne ship in public- p i a e pa ne ship (PPP) p ojec s o No way. P ocedia Compu Sci 219:1838–1846. h ps:// doi.o g/10.1016/j.p ocs.2023.01.481 108. Amp a wum G, Osei R, Tam VWY (2022) Explo ing he concep o public-p i a e pa ne ship in building c i ical in as uc u e esilience agains unexpec ed e en s: a sys ema ic e iew. In J C i In as uc P o 39:100556. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.ijcip.2022.100556 109. Bao Z, Lu W, Chi B, Yuan H, Hao J (2019) P ocu emen inno a ion o a ci cula economy o cons uc ion and demoli ion was e: lessons lea n om Suzhou, China. Was e Manag 99:12– 21. ISSN 0956-053X. h ps://doi.o g/10.1016/j.wasman.2019.08.031 110. Eu opean En i onmen Agency (2023) Cons uc ion and demoli ion was e: challenges and oppo uni ies in a ci cula economy. h ps://www.eea.eu opa.eu/publica ions/cons uc ion- and-demoli ion-was e-challenges. Accessed 24 Sep embe 2023 111. Lee S, Pan W, Linne T, Bock T (2015) A amewo k o obo assis ed decons uc ion: p ocess, sub-sys ems and modelling. In: P oceedings o he 32nd ISARC, Oulu, Finland, pp 1–8. h ps://doi.o g/10.22260/ISARC2015/0093 112. Cha e R, Mo el CJ, Rakhshan K (2021) Ba ie s o implemen ing he ci cula economy in he cons uc ion indus y: a c i ical e iew. Sus ainabili y 13(23):12989 113. Ababio BK, Lu W (2023) Ba ie s and enable s o ci cula economy in cons uc ion: a mul i- sys em pe spec i e owa ds he de elopmen o a p ac ical amewo k. Cons Manag Econ 41(1):3–21 114. Hosseini MR, Chileshe N, Rameezdeen R, Lehmann S (2014) Re e se logis ics o he cons uc ion indus y: lessons om he manu ac u ing con ex . In J Cons Eng Manag 3:75–90 115. Kan e s J (2020) Ci cula building design: an analysis o ba ie s and d i e s o a ci cula building sec o . Buildings 10:77 116. Tleuken A, Tokazhano G, Jemal KM, Shaimakhano R, So e bek M, Ka aca F (2022) Legisla i e, ins i u ional, indus ial and go e nmen al in ol emen in ci cula economy in Cen al Asia: a sys ema ic e iew. Sus ainabili y 14:8064 117. To gau o B, Zhanabaye A, Tleuken A, Tu kyilmaz A, Bo ucki C, Ka aca F (2022) Pe o - mance assessmen o cons uc ion companies o he ci cula economy: a balanced sco eca d app oach. Sus ain P od Consump 33:991–1004 118. Bilal M, Khan KIA, Thaheem MJ, Nasi AR (2020) Cu en s a e and ba ie s o he ci cula economy in he building sec o : owa ds a mi iga ion amewo k. J Clean P od 123250 119. Rizos V e al (2016) Implemen a ion o ci cula economy business models by small and medium-sized en e p ises (SMEs): ba ie s and enable s. Sus ainabili y 8(11):1212 120. Ve a Co nejo SE (2018) P opues a de indicado es lean2c adle® en ases de uso y decons ucción. Mas e hesis. Escuela de Caminos. Uni e sidad Poli écnica de Ca aluña. h ps://upcommons.upc.edu/bi s eam/handle/2117/341616/TFM_SOLANGE_V ERA.pd ?sequence=1&isAllowed=y. Accessed 14 July 2023 121. Cons ucía(2020)LaCons ucciónCi cula conLean2C adle®.h ps://www.cons ucia.com/ cons uccion-ci cula -lean2c adle/. Accessed 14 July 2023 122. Cons ucía (2020) Edi icio Sóc a es. h ps://www.cons ucia.com/edi icio-soc a es. Accessed 14 July 2023 7 Ci cula Ma e ial Usage S a egies—P inciples 213 123. KPMG (2019) T ue Value de edi icios Lean2C adle®. Economía ci cula en el diseño a qui- ec ónico, Cons ucía and eco in elligen g ow h, 2. h ps://www.picha chi ec s.com/2020/05/ 20/economia-ci cula -en-el-disenoa qui ec onico-p -2/. Accessed 14 July 2023 124. Heisel F, Hebel DE, Sobek W (2019) Resou ce- espec ul cons uc ion— he case o he U ban Mining and Recycling uni (UMAR). In: P oceedings o IOP con e ence se ies: ea h and en i onmen al science (EES), ol 225, p 012049. h ps://iopscience.iop.o g/a icle/10.1088/ 1755-1315/225/1/012049/pd . Accessed 14 July 2023 125. Heisel F, Hebel DE, Sobek W (2018) U ban mining and ecycling. h ps://www.nes -uma .ne . Accessed 14 July 2023 126. Heisel F, Hebel DE, Sobek W (2018) U ban Mining and Recycling (UMAR) expe imen al uni . Ma e ials. h ps://nes -uma .ne /#ma e ials. Accessed 14 July 2023 127. S oneCycling (2023) h ps://www.s onecycling.com/. Accessed 14 July 2023 128. Magna Glaske amik (2023) h ps://magna-glaske amik.com/. Accessed 14 July 2023 129. ReWall (2023) h ps://elemen al.g een/ ewall- ecycled-high-pe o mance- oo -and-wall-ma e ials/. Accessed 14 July 2023 130. Robe sonGL(2021)Recyclingo asep icbe e ageca ons:a e iew.Recycling6(20).h ps:// doi.o g/10.3390/ ecycling6010020 131. Ul a ouch (2023). Denim insula ion. h ps://www.bondedlogic.com/ul a ouch-denim-insula ion/. Accessed 14 July 2023 132. Di isa e (2023) h ps://di isa e.com/au ho s/2144897897-alex-shoo s-buildings. Accessed 14 July 2023 133. Packwall (2023) Boa ds. h ps://www.packwall.a /en/homepage/. Accessed 14 July 2023 134. RECOMA (2023) h ps://www. ecoma.com/p oduc /design-boa d. Accessed 14 July 2023 135. Repolyuse (2018) EU unded p ojec . Li e +.h ps://li e- epolyuse.com/.Accessed14July 2023 136. Yesy o ma (2023) SKY echos ecosos enibles. h ps://www.yesy o ma.es/sky- echos-ecoso enibles/. Accessed 14 July 2023 137. Rod igo-B a o A, Cuenca-Rome o LA, Calde ón V, Rod íguez Á, Gu ié ez-González S (2022) Compa a i e Li e Cycle Assessmen (LCA) be ween s anda d gypsum ceiling ile and polyu e hane gypsum ceiling ile. Ene gy Build 259. h ps://www.sciencedi ec .com/science/ a icle/pii/S037877882200038X? ia%3Dihub. Accessed 14 July 2023 Open Access This chap e is licensed unde he e ms o he C ea i e Commons A ibu ion 4.0 In e na ional License (h p://c ea i ecommons.o g/licenses/by/4.0/), which pe mi s use, sha ing, adap a ion, dis ibu ion and ep oduc ion in any medium o o ma , as long as you gi e app op ia e c edi o he o iginal au ho (s) and he sou ce, p o ide a link o he C ea i e Commons license and indica e i changes we e made. The images o o he hi d pa y ma e ial in his chap e a e included in he chap e ’s C ea i e Commons license, unless indica ed o he wise in a c edi line o he ma e ial. I ma e ial is no included in he chap e ’s C ea i e Commons license and you in ended use is no pe mi ed by s a u o y egula ion o exceeds he pe mi ed use, you will need o ob ain pe mission di ec ly om he copy igh holde .