Documentary ethics in contemporary practices. Alternative participation, alternative ethics?
Abstract
Documentary scholars have presupposed a certain documentary practice, and have ethically evaluated this practice, with a focus on the need for protection for a vulnerable and ignorant participant. But times have changed. By researching the experience of ethical challenges by both documentary filmmakers and participants, through both a quantitative and a qualitative project, a practice surfaces in which the participant is committed to and involved in the project; conflict between filmmaker and participant is recurrent, but non-decisive, as communication, trust, and commitment act as a safety-net. Hence, questions about documentary ethics need to address this contemporary practice, rather than a past one.
Full text
! ! $/,B2)13+(=!)3:7,8!71!,/13)25/(+(=!5(+,37,)8C!! >63)(1+370)!5+(37,75+37/1K!+63)(1+370)!)3:7,8M! ! M@<<$G@$>!;&>S$#F1! ! ! >?83(+,3! 2='NG$>K&#R!F'O=<&#F!O&\$!Z#$FNZZ=F$S!&!'$#K&@>!S='NG$>K&#R!Z#&'K@'$6!&>S!O&\$! $KO@'&<<R!$\&<N&K$S!KO@F!Z#&'K@'$6!^@KO!&!%='NF!=>!KO$!>$$S!%=#!Z#=K$'K@=>!%=#!&! \N<>$#&[<$!&>S!@)>=#&>K!Z&#K@'@Z&>K(!?NK!K@G$F!O&\$!'O&>)$S(!?R!#$F$&#'O@>)!KO$! $VZ$#@$>'$!=%!$KO@'&<!'O&<<$>)$F![R![=KO!S='NG$>K&#R!%@<GG&A$#F!&>S!Z&#K@'@Z&>KF6! KO#=N)O![=KO!&!`N&>K@K&K@\$!&>S!&!`N&<@K&K@\$!Z#=b$'K6!&!Z#&'K@'$!FN#%&'$F!@>!^O@'O!KO$! Z&#K@'@Z&>K!@F!'=GG@KK$S!K=!&>S!@>\=<\$S!@>!KO$!Z#=b$'Kh!'=>%<@'K![$K^$$>!%@<GG&A$#! &>S!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!@F!#$'N##$>K6![NK!>=>BS$'@F@\$6!&F!'=GGN>@'&K@=>6!K#NFK6!&>S! '=GG@KG$>K!&'K!&F!&!F&%$KRB>$K(!7$>'$6!`N$FK@=>F!&[=NK!S='NG$>K&#R!$KO@'F!>$$S!K=! &SS#$FF!KO@F!'=>K$GZ=#&#R!Z#&'K@'$6!#&KO$#!KO&>!&!Z&FK!=>$(!! ! @)=9/(48A!2='NG$>K&#R6!Z#&'K@'$6!$KO@'F6!`N&<@K&K@\$!#$F$&#'O6!`N&>K@K&K@\$!#$F$&#'O6! Z&#K@'@Z&K@=>! ! ! 2='NG$>K&#R! KO$=#@FKF! O&\$6! F@>'$! KO$! G@SBWUIXF6! S@F'NFF$S! KO$! $KO@'F! =%! S='NG$>K&#R!%@<G!&>S!S='NG$>K&#R!%@<GG&A@>)!cF$$6!%=#!@>FK&>'$6!:#=FF6!]&KD6!&>S! ,N[R6! WUEE&h! /@'O=<F6! WUUWh! "#R<N'A6! WUIPh! ,=F$>KO&<6! WUEE&h! M@>FK=>6! HXXXd(! +! S$\$<=ZG$>K!KO&K!K#@))$#$S!F'O=<&#<R!'=>F@S$#&K@=>F!=%!$KO@'F!^&F!KO$!@>K#=SN'K@=>!=%! <@)OK^$@)OK!'&G$#&F!&>S!FR>'!F=N>S6!&>S!KONF!=%!-0('1+!10)'*,6!&>S!10)'*,!&`(0+`6! G&A@>)! @K! Z=FF@[<$! K=! %=<<=^! Z$=Z<$! &#=N>S! &>S! %@<G! KO$G! '=>K@>N=NF<R! &>S! FZ=>K&>$=NF<R! c"#R<N'A6! WUIPd(! 9>! KO@F! S@F'=N#F$6! F'O=<&#F! O&\$! Z#$FNZZ=F$S! &>S! $KO@'&<<R! $\&<N&K$S! &! '$#K&@>! S='NG$>K&#R! Z#&'K@'$(! -O@F! Z#&'K@'$! ^&F! )#=N>S$S! @>! ďŽƚŚZŽďĞƌƚ&ůĂŚĞƌƚLJƐŶĂƌƌĂƚŝǀĞĚŽĐƵŵĞŶƚĂƌŝĞƐƐƵĐŚĂƐV,)%%>!%4!+5'!V%(+5!cWUHHd! &>S! O,)! %4! F(,)! cWULJd6! &F! ^$<<! &F! @>! F='@&<! S='NG$>K&#@$F! Z#=SN'$S! [R! _=O>! :#@$#F=>!&>S!O@F!'=<<$&)N$F6!FN'O!&F!C(04+'(2!cWUJPd!&>S![%<20)$!@(%D/'*2!cWUL*d!&>S! @>! G=#$! #$'$>K! S@#$'K! '@>$G&! Z#=b$'KF6!G=FK! >=K&[<R! 80+01<+! J%//0'2!cWUPIh! F$$6! %=#! @>FK&>'$6!M@>FK=>6!HXXXd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b$'K(! 2@F&)#$$G$>K!&>S!'=>%<@'K![$K^$$>!%@<GG&A$#!&>S!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!@F!&!#$'N##$>K![NK!>=>B S$'@F@\$!$<$G$>K!=%!KO$!%@<GG&A$#BZ&#K@'@Z&>K!#$<&K@=>FO@Z(!;N'O!'=>%<@'K!@F!S@FZ$#F$S! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! W!"O26!&%%@<@&K$S!#$F$&#'O$#(!2$Z&#KG$>K!=%!3$S@&!&>S!4N<KN#$!;KNS@$F! ^(F&>S$#FiNN(><!
! ! ! ! ! &>S! <='&<6! &F! @F! KO$! $V'O&>)$! =%! @>%=#G&K@=>! &>S! )@\@>)! '=>F$>K(! 9>! KO@F! Z#&'K@'$6! '=GGN>@'&K@=>6!K#NFK6!&>S!'=GG@KG$>K!&'K!&F!&!F&%$KRB>$K!%=#!'=>%<@'K(! ! 9>!KO@F!Z&Z$#!9!^@<<!%@#FK!&SS#$FF!KO$!F'O=<&#<R!S@F'=N#F$!=>!S='NG$>K&#R!$KO@'F(!9!^@<<! KO$>! S@F'NFF! KO$! #$FN<KF! =%! K^=! $GZ@#@'&<! FKNS@$F!=%! S='NG$>K&#R! %@<GG&A@>)6! =>$! `N&>K@K&K@\$!&>S!=>$!`N&<@K&K@\$(!?R!'=G[@>@>)!KO$F$6!9!^@<<!Z#$F$>K!&>!&<K$#>&K@\$6! '=>K$GZ=#&#R! S='NG$>K&#R! Z#&'K@'$6! ^@KO! &! S@%%$#$>K! Z=F@K@=>! %=#! KO$! Z&#K@'@Z&>K(! -O@F!Z#&'K@'$!@>\@K$F!&<K$#>&K@\$!`N$FK@=>F!^@KO!#$FZ$'K!K=!$KO@'F(!! ! E,:/6+(6=!+14!5(/*)887/1+6!478,/B(8)A!2/(+6!788B)8K!83(+3).7)8K!+14!,7(,B283+1,)8! 9>!KO$!#$F$&#'O!S@F'NFF$S!O$#$6!KO$!S='NG$>K&#R!%@<GG&A@>)!Z#&'K@'$!N>S$#!F'#NK@>R! '&>![$!S$F'#@[$S!&F!&NKO=#!S='NG$>K&#R!%@<GG&A@>)(!9K!@F!&!Z#&'K@'$!KO&K!#$<@$F!=>! @>S@\@SN&<! %@<GG&A$#F! ^O=! '#$&K$! Z$#F=>&<! %@<GF6! &>S! KO&K! KONF! &<<=^F! %=#! &! ĨŝůŵŵĂŬĞƌƐƉĞƌƐŽŶĂůĂƌƚŝƐƚŝĐĞdžƉƌĞƐƐŝŽŶĨŽƌǁŚŝĐŚƐŚĞƵƐĞƐƚŚĞŵĞĂŶƐŽĨƉƌŽĚƵĐƚŝŽŶ! @>!&!^$<<B'=>F@S$#$S!^&R(!-O@F!Z#&'K@'$!@F!<$FF!S$G&>S@>)!KO&>!b=N#>&<@FG!Z#&'K@'$F! ^O$>! @K! '=G$F! K=! =[b$'K@\@KR! &>S! @GZ&#K@&<@KR(! 7$>'$6! 9! KN#>$S! K=! KO$! F'O=<&#<R! S='NG$>K&#R!S@F'=N#F$!#&KO$#!KO&>!K=!KO$!S@F'=N#F$!=>!G$S@&!=#!b=N#>&<@FG!$KO@'F(! ! -O$! F'O=<&#<R! S@F'=N#F$! =>! S='NG$>K&#R! $KO@'F! @F! G=FK<R! Z&#K! =%! KO$! [#=&S$#! KO$=#$K@'&<!S='NG$>K&#R!S@F'=N#F$(!;=G$K@G$F!$KO@'F!&#$!&SS#$FF$S!FZ$'@%@'&<<R!cF$$6! %=#! @>FK&>'$6! :#=FF6! ]&KD6! &>S! ,N[R6! WUEE&6! HXXLdh! G=#$! =%K$>! @K! @F! &SS#$FF$S! @GZ<@'@K<R!@>!&![#=&S$#!K$VK!cF$$6!%=#!@>FK&>'$6!M@>FK=>6!HXXXh!/@'O=<F6!HXXWd(!9>![=KO! @>FK&>'$F6!KO$!S@F'=N#F$!S=$F!>=K!@>'<NS$!$KO@'&<!KO$=#@$F!=#!`N$FK@=>F!&[=NK!^O@'O! =%!KO=F$!KO$=#@$F!G@)OK!=#!FO=N<S!)=\$#>!S='NG$>K&#R!%@<GG&A@>)(!+!S$[&K$!&[=NK! S$=>K=<=)@'&<6! K$<$=<=)@'&<6! =#! NK@<@K&#@&>! Z#@>'@Z<$F! &>Sj=#! KO$! #=<$! =%! \@#KN$F! @>! ĚŽĐƵŵĞŶƚĂƌLJ ĨŝůŵŵĂŬŝŶŐ ŝƐ ůĂĐŬŝŶŐ ƐĂǀĞ ŝŶ ƵƚĐŚĂƌƚƐ ;ϮϬϬϲͿ ĚŝƐĐƵƐƐŝŽŶ ŽĨ ǀŝƌƚƵĞ KO$=#R(!! ! dǁŽŐĞŶĞƌĂůĂƌĞĂƐĂƌĞĚŝƐƚŝŶŐƵŝƐŚĂďůĞŝŶƚŚĞĚŝƐĐƵƐƐŝŽŶŽĨĞƚŚŝĐƐŽŶĞĚĞĂůŝŶŐǁŝƚŚ `N$FK@=>F! =%! K#NKO! &>S! #$&<@KR6! [&F@'&<<R! &SS#$FF@>)! KO$! %@<GG&A$#B&NS@$>'$! #$<&K@=>FO@Zh! &>S! =>$! S$&<@>)! ^@KO! `N$FK@=>F! =%! #$Z#$F$>K&K@=>! &>S! '=>F$`N$>'$F6! [&F@'&<<R!S$&<@>)!^@KO!KO$!%@<GG&A$#BZ&#K@'@Z&>K!#$<&K@=>FO@Z(!-O$!<&KK$#!@F!KO$!%='NF!=%! KO@F!Z&Z$#(!M@KO!#$FZ$'K!K=!KO@F!#$<&K@=>FO@Z6!F'O=<&#F!S@F'NFF!@FFN$F6!Z#=[<$GF6!&>S! $\$>KF!^@KO!&!G=#&<!'=GZ=>$>K6!FN'O!&F!%@<G@>)!&!'=>%<@'Kh!KO$R!S@F'NFF!&!\&#@$KR!=%! @FFN$F!KO$R!#$<&K$!K=!$KO@'F6!FN'O!&F!#$Z#$F$>K&K@=>(!-O$R!&<F=!S@F'NFF!F=G$!FK#&K$)@$F! K=!S$&<!^@KO!FN'O!@FFN$F6!=#!K=!Z#$\$>K!KO$G(!9>!&SS@K@=>6!KO$R!S@F'NFF!'@#'NGFK&>'$F! KO&K!&%%$'K!KO$!$VZ$#@$>'$!=%!FN'O!@FFN$F(!9!^@<<!)=!@>K=!KO$F$!@>!KN#>![$<=^(!! ! 9>!KO$!S@F'NFF@=>!=%!KO$!$KO@'F!=%!KO$!%@<GG&A$#BZ&#K@'@Z&>K!#$<&K@=>FO@Z6!KO$!>=K@=>!=%! @>%=#G$S!'=>F$>K!Z<&LJƐĂĐĞŶƚƌĂůƌŽůĞDŽƐƚĂŶƐǁĞƌƐƚŽƐƵĐŚĂĐĐƵƐĂƚŝŽŶƐŽĨƚĂŬŝŶŐ &S\&>K&)$!=%!F=G$=>$!ʹ!t^ƌĞůLJŽŶƐŽŵĞŶŽƚŝŽŶŽĨĐŽŶƐĞŶƚ;ƵƐƵĂůůLJŝŶĨŽƌŵĞĚͿĂƐ ƚŚĞ ĞƚŚŝĐĂů ƚŽƵĐŚƐƚŽŶĞ ;ĞĐŬĞƌ ϭϵϴϴ Ɖ džŝŝͿ /Ŷ ĚŽĐƵŵĞŶƚĂƌLJ ĨŝůŵŵĂŬŝŶŐ ƚŚŝƐ '=>'$ZK6! ^O@'O! =#@)@>&K$S! @>! KO$! %@$<S! =%! G$S@'&<! $KO@'F6! #&@F$F! &! <=K! =%! `N$FK@=>F(! 3&>R!&)#$$!@K!@F! @GZ=FF@[<$!K=!@>%=#G!cZ=K$>K@&<d!Z&#K@'@Z&>KF!'=GZ<$K$<R!&[=NK!&<<! #@FAF!@>\=<\$S!@>!Z&#K@'@Z&K@>)!c?$'A$#6!WUEEh!:#=FF!$K!&<(6!WUEEh!]&KD!&>S!3@<FK$@>!]&KD6! WUEEh!/@'O=<F6!WUUWh!"#R<N'A6!WUIPh!,=F$>KO&<6!WUEE[h!M@>FK=>6!WUEE6!WUU*6!HXXXd(! +>S! &''=#S@>)! K=! M@>FK=>! cHXXXd6! @>%=#G$S! '=>F$>K! S=$F! >=K! G&K'O! %#$$S=G! =%! $VZ#$FF@=>(! 3=#$=\$#6! @>! S='NG$>K&#R! %@<GG&A@>)! KO$#$! F$$G! K=! [$! >=! N>@%=#G! Z#=K='=<F!%=#!@>%=#G$S!'=>F$>K(!7$>'$6!@K!G&A$F!G=#$!F$>F$!K=!S@F'NFF!@KF!'=>FK@KN$>K! Z&#KF1!KO$!$V'O&>)$!=%!@>%=#G&K@=>6!'=>F$>K!K=!Z&#K@'@Z&K$6!&>S!KO$!\=<N>K&#@>$FF!=%! KO&K!'=>F$>K!&>S!KONF!=%!KO$!Z&#K@'@Z&K@=>(!! !
tŚŝůĞ ŽŶĞ ĐĂŶ ĂƌŐƵĞ ĂďŽƵƚ ǁŚĞƚŚĞƌ ǁĞ ĐĂŶ ĞǀĞŶ ŬŶŽǁ ǁŚĂƚ ƌĞĂůůLJ ŚĂƉƉĞŶƐ @>$\@K&[<R! @>! %@<G@>)! &'KN&<@KR6! G=G$>KF! &#$! #$'=#S$S! KO&K! KO$! Z$=Z<$! [$@>)! ƉŚŽƚŽŐƌĂƉŚĞĚŵŝŐŚƚŶŽƚǁŝƐŚƚŽŵĂŬĞǁŝĚĞůLJƉƵďůŝĐƐĂŝĚ;WƌLJůƵĐŬϭϵϳϲƉϮϱϲͿ -O@F!`N=K$!FNGG&#@D$F!KO$!`N$FK@=>F!KO&K!FN##=N>S!'=>F$>K!&>S!\=<N>K&#@>$FF(!MO&K! O&ZZ$>F!@%!&!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!S$'@S$F!FO$!^&>KF!'$#K&@>!%==K&)$!$V'<NS$S!%#=G!KO$!%@<Gr! MO$#$!@F!KO$!<@>$![$K^$$>!'=>\@>'@>)!&!Z&#K@'@Z&>K6!Z#$FF@>)!O$#6!&>S!%=#'@>)!O$#r! -O$! S='NG$>K&#R! S@F'=N#F$! @>'<NS$F! >NG$#=NF! @FFN$F! F'O=<&#F! #$<&K$! K=! $KO@'F6! @>'<NS@>)6![NK!>=K!<@G@K$S!K=6!'=>F$`N$>'$F!=%!Z&#K@'@Z&K@=>!@>!&!S='NG$>K&#R!%@<G6! S@F'<=FN#$!cO=^!GN'O!@F!#$\$&<$Sd6!Z#@\&'R6!#$'@Z#='@KR6!#$Z#$F$>K&K@=>6!&>S!KO$!#@)OKF! =%!%@<GG&A$#F!K=!#$'=#S6!&>S!NF$!KO$!#$'=#S$S!G&K$#@&<(W! ! /ĨŽŶĞŝƐƐĞƌŝŽƵƐĂďŽƵƚƵƐŝŶŐĚŝƌĞĐƚĐŝŶĞŵĂƚŽŵĂŬĞǀĂůŝĚƐƚĂƚĞŵĞŶƚF!&[=NK!Z$=Z<$6! ƚŚĞŶĐŽůůĂďŽƌĂƚŝŽŶƐŚŽƵůĚďĞǁĞůĐŽŵĞ;WƌLJůƵĐŬϭϵϳϲƉϮϲϱͿ^ƵĐŚĐŽůůĂďŽƌĂƚŝŽŶŝŶ ^O@'O!KO$!%@<GG&A$#!%N>'K@=>F!<@A$!&!%&'@<@K&K=#!K=!KO$!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!&>S!O$#!FK=#R6!@F!=>$! FK#&K$)R!F'O=<&#F! S@F'NFF$S!K=! S$&<! ^@KO!G=#&<! @FFN$F(!7=^$\$#6! FN'O!'=<<&[=#&K@=>! ƌĂŝƐĞƐƋƵĞƐƚŝŽŶƐĂďŽƵƚƚŚĞĨŝůŵŵĂŬĞƌƐƉŽƐŝƚŝŽŶƚŽǁĂƌĚƐƚŚĞƚŽƉŝĐŽĨƚŚĞĨŝůŵĐĂŶƐŚĞ FK@<<!G&A$#!O$#!Z=@>K!c:#=FF6!WUEEh!M@>FK=>6!HXXXdr!! ! +>=KO$#!FK#&K$)R!S@F'NFF$S!@F!&FA@>)!Z#=\@F@=>&<!'=>F$>K!%=#!&!#=N)O!'NK![$%=#$!&FA@>)! %@>&<! '=>F$>K! %=#! KO$! %@>&<! 'NK! c"#R<N'A6! WUIPd(! +<F=6! F'O=<&#F! FN))$FK! K=! @>\@K$! Z&#K@'@Z&>KF!K=!\@$^!KO$!c$S@K$Sd!G&K$#@&<!&>S!@>S@'&K$!^O&K!KO$R!Z#$%$#!K=![$!<$%K!=NK! c:@<[$#K6!WUEWh!,=F$>KO&<6!WUEE[h!M@>FK=>!WUU*d(!! ! ,$%<$V@\@KR!@F!&<F=!&!F=<NK@=>!G$>K@=>$S(!,NďLJ;ϭϵϴϴͿĂĚǀŽĐĂƚĞĚĂŶŝŶƚĞůůŝŐĞŶƚůLJƵƐĞĚ ƌĞĨůĞdžŝǀŝƚLJĂƐĂŶĞƐƐĞŶƚŝĂůƉĂƌƚŽĨĂůůĞƚŚŝĐĂůůLJ ƉƌŽĚƵĐĞĚĚŽĐƵŵĞŶƚĂƌŝĞƐ;ƉϯϭϰͿ ?NK'O&#K!cHXXPd!&ZZ#=&'O$S!#$%<$V@\@KR!%#=G!KO$!Z$#FZ$'K@\$!=%!$KO@'F!&>S!S#&^F!=>! KO$!^=#A!=%!?&S@=N(!7$!Z#=Z=F$S!K=!&[&>S=>!ZO@<=F=ZO@'&<!@S$&F!&[=NK!cKO$!#@)OKF!=%d! ƚŚĞŽƚŚĞƌĂŶĚƚŽĨŽĐƵƐŽŶƚŚĞƐĂŵĞƚŚĞƐŝƚƵĂƚĞĚƐŚĂƌĞĚƚƌƵƚŚĂŶĚƚŽƐŚŽǁƚŚĂƚ K#NKO!KO#=N)O!\&#@=NF!%=#GF!=%!#$%<$V@\@KR(! ! 9>! &SS@K@=>! K=! G=#&<! @FFN$F! &>S! FK#&K$)@$F! K=! S$&<! ^@KO! KO$G! =#! Z#$\$>K! KO$G6! M@>FK=>!cHϬϬϬͿŵĞŶƚŝŽŶĞĚĨŽƵƌƉŽŝŶƚƐĨŽƌĞƚŚŝĐĂůƌŝƐŬƐǁŚĞƚŚĞƌƚŚĞĨŝůŵĞĚƉĞƌƐŽŶ @F! &! ZN[<@'! =#! Z#@\&K$! Z$#F=>h! KO$! S$)#$$! =%! F='@&<! [@&F! =%! KO$! &'K! [$@>)! %@<G$Sh! ^O$KO$#!KO$!Z<&'$!=%!%@<G@>)!@F!ZN[<@'!=#!Z#@\&K$h!&>S!^O$#$!&>S!%=#!^O@'O!&NS@$>'$! KO$! %@<G! ^@<<! [$! F'#$$>$S(! -O$F$! %=N#! &#$&F! =%! #@FA! &<<! #$%$#! K=! '@#'NGFK&>'$F1! KO$! Z$#F=>&<@KR!=%!KO$!Z&#K@'@Z&>K6!KO$!'=>K$>K!=%!KO$!%@<G6!KO$!%@<G@>)!'@#'NGFK&>'$F!cF$$! &<F=!:#=FF6!]&KD6!&>S!,N[R6!WUEE&d6!&>S!KO$!F'#$$>@>)!'@#'NGFK&>'$F!cF$$!&<F=!,N[R6! WUEEd(!+>S!KO$#$!&#$!G=#$1!'N<KN#&<!S@%%$#$>'$F![$K^$$>!%@<GG&A$#!&>S!Z&#K@'@Z&>K! c"#R<N'A6! WUIPdh! %@<G@>)! %&G@<R! G$G[$#F! ;<Ăƚnj ĂŶĚ DŝůƐƚĞŝŶ <Ăƚnj ϭϵϴϴͿ ƚŚĞ ĨŝůŵƐ &$FKO$K@'F!c]&KD!&>S!3@<FK$@>!]&KD6!WUEEh!/@'O=<F6!WUUWh!,N[R6!WUEEdh!K@G$!c,=F$>KO&<6! WUEE[d!&>S!G=>$R!cM@ŶƐƚŽŶϮϬϬϬͿĂŶĚƚŚĞĨŝůŵƐŐŽĂů;tŝŶƐƚŽŶϭϵϵϱϮϬϬϬZƵďLJ WUEEh! /@'O=<F6! WUUWd(! -O$! '@#'NGFK&>'$F6! =#! '=>K$VKF6! FNZZ=F$S<R! &%%$'K! KO$! $VZ$#@$>'$!=#!G=#&<!@FFN$F6!&F!^$<<!&F!O=^!KO$F$!&#$!S$&<K!^@KO(! ! 2='NG$>K&#R! F'O=<&#F! &<F=6! @GZ<@'@K<R! #&KO$#! KO&>! $VZ<@'@K<R6! \=@'$! @S$&F! &[=NK! KO$! S='NG$>K&#R! Z&#K@'@Z&>K(! ?#@$%<R6! F'O=<&#F! 'O&#&'K$#@D$S! O$#! &F! \N<>$#&[<$! ^@KO! #$FZ$'K! K=! KO$! '=>F$`N$>'$F! =%! S='NG$>K&#R! #$Z#$F$>K&K@=>! c"#R<N'A6! WUIPh! ,=F$>KO&<6!WUEE[d6!@)>=#&>K!&[=NK!KO$!S='NG$>K&#R!Z#&'K@'$!cM@>FK=>6!HXXXd6!&>S!&F! O&\@>)!>=KO@>)!K=!)&@>!%#=G!O$#!Z&#K@'@Z&K@=>!c:#=FF6!]&KD6!&>S!,N[R6!WUEE[h!"#R<N'A6! WUIPh!M@>FK=>6!HXXXd(!! !
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`N&>K@K&K@\$!=>$!=%!KO$!Z$#FZ$'K@\$!=%!%@<GG&A$#F6! &>S!&!`N&<@K&K@\$!=>$!=>!KO$!Z$#FZ$'K@\$!=%! Z&#K@'@Z&>KF(!?$<=^!9!S$F'#@[$!KO$G!@>! KN#>(!! ! <:)!5)(85),370)!/*!*7622+G)(8A!,/22B17,+37/1!+14!,/1*67,3H! Q@<GG&A$#F!#$)N<&#<R!S@F'NFF!KO$@#!@>S@\@SN&<!Z#&'K@'$F6!%=#!@>FK&>'$6!@>!@>K$#\@$^F!&>S! K&<AF!@>!G&)&D@>$F6!>$^FZ&Z$#F6!&>S!&K!%$FK@\&<F(!-=!N>S$#FK&>S!O=^!KO$!$VZ$#@$>'$F! =%!G=#&<!@FFN$F!&>S!FK#&K$)@$F!G@)OK![$!#$<&K$S6!9!S$'@S$S!K=!'=>SN'K!&!`N&>K@K&K@\$! FKNSR!&>S!@>'<NS$!$VZ$#@$>'$F!%#=G!&!<&#)$!>NG[$#!%@<GG&A$#F(!;=6!K=!G$&FN#$!KO$! $VK$>K!K=!^O@'O!%@<GG&A$#F!O&S!$VZ$#@$>'$S!KO$!G=#&<!@FFN$F!&>S!FK#&K$)@$F!S$#@\$S! %#=G!KO$!<@K$#&KN#$!&>S!KO$!@>@K@&<!@>K$#\@$^F6!&>S!@>!^O@'O!Z#=SN'K@=>!&>S!Z$#F=>&<! '=>K$VKF!KO@F!O&S!O&ZZ$>$S6!9!S$F@)>$S!&!`N$FK@=>>&@#$(!9!KN#>$S!KO$!\&#@=NF!>=K@=>F! KO&K!#$Z#$F$>K$S!G=#&<!@FFN$F!&>S!FK#&K$)@$F!@>K=!FK&K$G$>KF(!Q=#!$V&GZ<$6!KO$!@FFN$! ŽĨ ĚŝƐĐůŽƐƵƌĞ / ƚƵƌŶĞĚ ŝŶƚŽ ƚŚĞ ƐƚĂƚĞŵĞŶƚ dŚĞ ƉĂƌƚŝĐŝƉĂŶƚ ƌĞĨƵƐĞĚ ƚŽ ŚĂǀĞ ĐĞƌƚĂŝŶ ƐĐĞŶĞƐ Žƌ ĞǀĞŶƚƐ ĨŝůŵĞĚ ƚŚĞ ƐƚƌĂƚĞŐLJ ƚŽ ƉĂLJ Ă ƉĂƌƚŝĐŝƉĂŶƚ / ƚƵƌŶĞĚ ŝŶƚŽ ƚŚĞ ƐƚĂƚĞŵĞŶƚ/ŐĂǀĞ ƚŚĞƉĂƌƚŝĐŝƉĂŶƚƐŽŵĞŵŽŶĞLJŽƌ ĂŐŝĨƚ ;ĨŝůŵŵĂŬĞƌƐ ŚĂĚƚŽůĚŵĞ KO$R! F=G$K@G$F! [=N)OK! )@%KFd(! 9! G$&FN#$S! KO$! $VK$>K! K=! ^O@'O! %@<GG&A$#F! O&S! $VZ$#@$>'$S!KO$F$!=>!&!XBP!c>$\$#j>=K!&K!&<<!ʹ!&<<!KO$!K@G$j'=GZ<$K$<Rd!F'&<$(!9!&FA$S! KO$G! K=! &>F^$#! ^@KO! #$FZ$'K! K=! =>$! FZ$'@%@'! Z&#K@'@Z&>K! c=%! KO$@#! 'O=@'$d! @>! KO$@#! <&K$FK!Z#=b$'K(!9!&<F=!@>'<NS$S!'=>K$VKN&<!\&#@&[<$F!&[=NK!KO$!Z#=b$'K6!KO$!Z&#K@'@Z&>K6! &>S!KO$!%@<GG&A$#!@>!KO$!FN#\$R(!! ! 3R!F&GZ<$!'=>F@FK$S!=%!%@<GG&A$#!^O=!O&S!O&S!&!%@<G!F'#$$>$S!&K!=>$!=#!G=#$!=%! K^$<\$!@>K$#>&K@=>&<!S='NG$>K&#R!%@<G!%$FK@\&<F!^=#<S^@S$!@>!HXXP(!-O$F$!@>'<NS$S! S='NG$>K&#R! %$FK@\&<F! @>! +GFK$#S&G6! KO$! /$KO$#<&>SF6! 4&Z$! -=^>6! ;=NKO! +%#@'&6! -=#=>K=6!4&>&S&6!&>S!5&G&)&K&6!_&Z&>(!+%K$#!&!Z@<=K!FKNSR6!9!@>\@K$S!P*U!%@<GG&A$#F! K=! '=GZ<$K$! KO$! %@>&<! \$#F@=>! =%! KO$! `N$FK@=>>&@#$h! @>! KO$! $>S6! KO$! S&K&! =%! W*E! #$FZ=>S$>KF!^$#$!@>'<NS$S!@>!KO$!&>&<RF@F(! ! Q=#! KO$! &>&<RF@F! 9! #$<@$S! =>! &>! 0VZ<=#&K=#R! Q&'K=#! +>&<RF@F(! Q&'K=#! &>&<RF@F! @F! &! K$'O>@`N$!^O@'O!N>'=\$#F!Z&KK$#>F!c%&'K=#Fd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h!K=!@>K$#Z#$K!KO$!G=#$!)$>$#&<!ZO$>=G$>=>(L!! ! -O$!Z#$F$>K!&>&<RF@F!#$FN<K$S!@>!F$\$>!Z&KK$#>F(J6*!9K!KN#>$S!=NK!KO&K!&<<!Z&KK$#>F!&#$! '=##$<&K$S!G=S$FK<R![NK!F@)>@%@'&>K<R!^@KO!$&'O!=KO$#6!$V'$ZK!%=#!KO$!F$'=>S!Z&KK$#>6! 4=GGN>@'&K@=>!%=#!4==Z$#&K@=>6!^O@'O!=><R!'=##$<&K$F!&!<@KK<$![@K!^@KO!KO$!F$\$>KO! Z&KK$#>6!9GZ#=Z$#!,$'@Z#='@KR(!-O@F!G$&>F!KO&K!KO$!$VZ$#@$>'$!=%!4=GGN>@'&K@=>!%=#!
4==Z$#&K@=>! @F! @>S$Z$>S$>K! =%! KO$! $VZ$#@$>'$! =%! =KO$#! Z&KK$#>F(! 9K! FN))$FKF! KO&K! ĨŝůŵŵĂŬĞƌƐĞdžƉĞƌŝĞŶĐĞƐĂƌĞƐƉůŝƚďĞƚǁĞĞŶŚĂƌŵŽŶŝŽƵƐƌĞůĂƚŝŽŶƐŚŝƉƐĨƵůůŽĨƌĞĐŝƉƌŽĐĂů '=GGN>@'&K@=>!^@KO!KO$!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!=>!KO$!=>$!O&>S!cZ&KK$#>!Hd!&>S!G=#$!S@FKN#[$S! #$<&K@=>FO@ZF!^@KO!KO$!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!=>!KO$!=KO$#!cZ&KK$#>F!W!&>S!LB*d(!! ! -O@F! Z#=GZK$S! G$! K=! $VZ<=#$! KO$! Z&KK$#>F! %N#KO$#6! [R! '=>SN'K@>)! &! O@)O$#! =#S$#! %&'K=#!&>&<RF@F(!7@)O$#!=#S$#!Z&KK$#>F!&#$!G=#$!)$>$#&<!KO&>!<=^$#!=#S$#!Z&KK$#>F(! -O$!K$'O>@`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ƉĂƚƚĞƌŶƐŽĨĐŽŽƉĞƌĂƚŝŽŶĂŶĚĐŽŶĨůŝĐƚĚŽŵŝŶĂŶƚǁĞƌĞĨŝůŵŵĂŬĞƌƐĞĨĨŽƌƚƐƚŽĐŽŽƉĞƌĂƚĞ ^@KO! KO$! Z&#K@'@Z&>K! ^@KO! KO$! @>K$#$FKF! =%! KO$! %@<G! @>! G@>S6! ^O@<$! #$<R@>)! =>! KO$@#! Z#=%$FF@=>&<! Z=F@K@=>! &>S! &[@<@K@$F! K=! )$K! ^O&K! KO$R! >$$S$S! %=#! KO$! %@<G(! 4=>%<@'K! FN#%&'$S!@>!\&#@=NF!Z&KK$#>F!&>S!'&>![$!#$)&#S$S!&F!&!#$<$\&>K!Z&#K!=%!KO$!$VZ$#@$>'$6! &F!&!G&b=#@KR!=%!%@<GG&A$#F!@>S@'&K$S!$VZ$#@$>'@>)!FN'O!'=>%<@'K6!KO=N)O!K=!<@G@K$S! $VK$>KF! cZ$#'$>K&)$F! %=#! X(X! F'=#$F! #&>)$S! [$K^$$>! W(Ut! &>S! HP(Pt6! ^@KO! =>$! $VK#$G$!&K!JH(Jth!F=!G=FK!$VZ$#@$>'$S!F=G$!'=>%<@'K!&K!<$&FKd(! ! 9!NF$S!\&#@&[<$F!&[=NK!KO$!Z&#K@'@Z&>K6!KO$!%@<GG&A$#6!&>S!KO$!Z#=b$'K!K=!@>\$FK@)&K$! KO$! $VK$>K! K=! ^O@'O! FN'O! '=>K$VKN&<! \&#@&[<$F! '=N<S! Z#$S@'K! KO$! $VZ$#@$>'$! =%! '==Z$#&K@=>6!=ZZ=F@K@=>6!&>S!'=>%<@'K(!-=!S=!KO@F6!9!NF$S!3N<K@Z<$!,$)#$FF@=>(I!Q=#!KO$! Z&KK$#>F!#$<&K$S!K=!'=GGN>@'&K@=>!&>S!'==Z$#&K@=>6!KO$!G=FK!@GZ=#K&>K!Z#$S@'K@>)! \&#@&[<$F!^$#$!KO$!Z=F@K@=>!=%!KO$!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!@>!KO$!Z#=b$'K!c&F!&!F@>)<$!=#!=>$!=%!&! >NG[$#!=%!'$>K#&<!Z&#K@'@Z&>KFd6!KO$![NS)$K!=%!KO$!Z#=b$'K6!&>S!KO$!SNKR!K=!G&A$!KO$! [$FK!%@<G!Z=FF@[<$h!%=#!KO$!Z&KK$#>F!#$<&K$S!K=!'=>%<@'K!KO$F$!^$#$!'N<KN#&<!F@G@<&#@KR6! %@<G@>)!&>S!$S@K@>)!K@G$6!KO$!'=>K#=\$#FR!=%!KO$!'=>K$>K!=%!KO$!%@<G6!KO$!^@<<@>)>$FF!K=! ŵĞĞƚĨŝŶĂŶĐŝĞƌƐǁŝƐŚĞƐƚO$!^@<<@>)>$FF!K=!'=GZ#=G@F$!S$Z$>S@>)!=>!KO$!@>K$#$FKF!&K! FK&A$6! &>S!^O$KO$#!=#! >=K! KO$! %@<GG&A$#! O&S! O&S! F=G$! ZO@<=F=ZOR! &>Sj=#!$KO@'F! $SN'&K@=>(!7=^$\$#6!KO$!FK&K@FK@'&<!'&<'N<&K@=>F!@>S@'&K$S!KO&K!KO$!Z#$S@'K@\$!FK#$>)KO! =%! FN'O! \&#@&[<$F! @>! )$>$#&<! ^&F! \$#R! <@G@K$S1! KO$R! '=N<S! =><R! Z#$S@'K! FG&<<! S@%%$#$>'$F![$K^$$>!%@<GG&A$#F!&>S!KO$@#!#$<$\&>'$!^&F!KO$#$%=#$!<@G@K$S(! ! ! ! ! ! !
! ! ! ! ! -&[<$!W(!"&KK$#>!<&[$<F6!Z&KK$#>!S$%@>@K@=>F6!G$&>F!F'=#$F!&>S!FK&>S&#S!S$\@&K@=>F(! ! 9>@K@&<!Z&KK$#>F! ;$'=>S!=#S$#!Z&KK$#>F! -O@#S!=#S$#!Z&KK$#>F! 4=GGN>@'&K@=>!%=#!4==Z$#&K@=>!j! Q@<GG&A$#!&>S!Z&#K@'@Z&>K! $VZ$#@$>'$!! K#NFK!&>S!N>S$#FK&>S@>)!KO#=N)O! =>)=@>)!'=GGN>@'&K@=>(! 3$&>!J(HLh!;K&>S&#S!2$\@&K@=>! W(WU! 4=GGN>@'&K@=>!%=#!KO$! Q@<G!.>)=@>)!'=GGN>@'&K@=>! [$K^$$>!%@<GG&A$#!&>S! Z&#K@'@Z&>K!@F!&@G$S!&K! ĂĐŚŝĞǀŝŶŐƚŚĞĨŝůŵŵĂŬĞƌƐ )=&<F(! 3$&>!L(UWh!;K&>S&#S!2$\@&K@=>! W(JH! 4=GGN>@'&K@=>!%=#!Q@<G@>)! -O$#$!@F!&!Z&#K@'@Z&>K! =ZZ=F@K@=>!@FFN$!&>S!KO$! %@<GG&A$#!K#@$F!K=!F=<\$!@K(! 3$&>!H(P*h!;K&>S&#S!2$\@&K@=>! W(XE! Q@<GG&A$#!3&FK$#R! -O$!%@<GG&A$#!NF$F!&<<!G$&>F!&K! O$#jO@F!S@FZ=F&<!&F!&!%@<GG&A$#! K=!&'O@$\$!KO@>)F(! 3$&>!H(LPh!;K&>S&#S!2$\@&K@=>! W(HU! "&#K@'@Z&>K!.ZZ=F@K@=>! -O$!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!@F!N>^@<<@>)!K=!'=B =Z$#&K$!^@KO!KO$!%@<GG&A$#!&>S! &K!K@G$F!'=N>K$#Z#=SN'K@\$(! 3$&>!(EIh!;K&>S&#S!2$\@&K@=>! (EJ! .ZZ=F@K@=>!K=!2@F'<=FN#$! -O$!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!S=$F!>=K!^&>K! '$#K&@>!F'$>$F!=#!$\$>KF!K=![$! %@<G$S(! 3$&>!(EJh!;K&>S&#S!2$\@&K@=>! (EI! Q@<GG&A$#!.ZZ=F@K@=>! -O$!%@<GG&A$#![$O&\$F! N>'==Z$#&K@\$!K=^&#S!KO$! Z&#K@'@Z&>K!&>S!@F!>=K!&@G$S!&K! F=<NK@=>F(! 3$&>!(PUh!;K&>S&#S!2$\@&K@=>! (IE! "&FF@\$!4=>%<@'K! "&FF@\$>$FF!&>S!'=>%<@'K! S=G@>&K$!KO$!%@<GG&A$#B Z&#K@'@Z&>K!#$<&K@=>FO@Z(! 3$&>!(UUh!;K&>S&#S!2$\@&K@=>! (IE! -#@\@&<@D$S!7&#G! -O$#$!@F!&>!@FFN$!&>S!KO$! %@<GG&A$#!S=$F!>=K!K#R!K=!F=<\$! @K(! 3$&>!(IWh!;K&>S&#S!2$\@&K@=>! (UH! 4=>%<@'K!=>!,$Z#$F$>K&K@=>! Q@<GG&A$#!&>S!Z&#K@'@Z&>K![=KO! '&NF$!S&G&)$![R!S@%%$#$>'$F!@>! N>S$#FK&>S@>)!KO$!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!&F! \@'K@G(! 3$&>!W(XIh!;K&>S&#S!2$\@&K@=>! (UW! ! ! <:)!5)(85),370)!/*!5+(37,75+138A!J/=K!6)+(171.K!+14!8)6*-5()8)13+37/1! "&#K@'@Z&>KF! S=! >=K! #$)N<&#<R! )$K! KO$! =ZZ=#KN>@KR! K=! FO&#$! KO$@#! $VZ$#@$>'$F! =%! Z&#K@'@Z&K@>)!@>!&!S='NG$>K&#R!%@<G(!+<KO=N)O!G=#$!&>S!G=#$!=%K$>!KO$R!&#$!@>\@K$S! &F!)N$FKF!K=!%@<G!%$FK@\&<F!K=!K&<A!&[=NK!KO$@#!$VZ$#@$>'$F!&>S6!F=G$K@G$F!F$$A!KO$! G$S@&! K=! S@F'NFF! KO$@#! '=>K#@[NK@=>! =#! #$Z#$F$>K&K@=>! cF$$6! %=#! @>FK&>'$6! ?=^<$#6! ?#=^>$6! &>S! 7$#[$#K6! HXXU6! &>S! ?#&S%=#S! &>S! 7N<<6! HXWWd6! KO$R! &#$! >=K! '=GG=>! Z&#K@'@Z&>KF! =%! KO$! S@F'=N#F$! FN##=N>S@>)! S='NG$>K&#R! %@<G(! ;=6! K=! FKNSR! KO$! Z$#FZ$'K@\$! =%! S='NG$>K&#R! Z&#K@'@Z&>KF6! 9! 'O=F$! &! `N&<@K&K@\$! G$KO=S1! F$G@! FK#N'KN#$SB@>K$#\@$^F6! ^@KO! &GZ<$! =ZZ=#KN>@KR! %=#! KO$! #$FZ=>S$>KF! K=!K&<A!&F! KO$R! Z#$%$##$S(!! ! 9! @>K$#\@$^$S! %=N#! 2NK'O! S='NG$>K&#R! Z&#K@'@Z&>KF1! +<$V6! ?$>6! 4O#@F6! &>S! 2$[[R(E! -O$F$! #$FZ=>S$>KF! 9! %=N>S! &%K$#! '=>FN<K@>)! &! >NG[$#! =%! 2NK'O! S='NG$>K&#R! Z#=SN'$#F!&[=NK!FN@K&[<$!Z#=b$'KF!&>S!Z&#K@'@Z&>KF(!9!@>K$#\@$^$S!KO$G!K^@'$1!=>'$! [$%=#$!=#!\$#R!F==>!&%K$#!KO$!Z#$G@$#$!=%!KO$!S='NG$>K&#R!%@<G!KO$R!^$#$!@>6!&>S! &)&@>! [$K^$$>! %=N#! &>S! F@V! G=>KOF! <&K$#(! 9! &FA$S! KO$G! K=! %#$$<R! #$'=N>K! KO$@#!
$VZ$#@$>'$F!=%!Z&#K@'@Z&K@>)(!9!&>&<RF$S!KO$@#!@>K$#\@$^!&''=N>KF![R!@>\$FK@)&K@>)!^O&K! KO$F$! #$FZ=>S$>KF! F&@S! &[=NK! KO$@#! $VZ$#@$>'$F6! ^@KO! &! %='NF! =>! ^O&K! ^&F! G=FK! F&<@$>K! @>! KO$@#! &''=N>KF6! #&KO$#! KO&>! =>! &>F^$#F! K=! GR! `N$FK@=>F(! 9! &<F=! NF$S! '=>'$ZKF! F&<@$>K! @>! KO$! FN#\$R! #$FN<KF! &F! F$>F@K@D@>)! '=>'$ZKFh! $V&GZ<$F! @>'<NS$! '=GGN>@'&K@=>!cZ&KK$#>F!&K!KO$!K=Z!=%!-&[<$!Wd!&>S!S@F'<=FN#$!cZ&KK$#>F!@>!KO$!G@SS<$! =%!KO$!K&[<$d(U!! ! +<$V6!KO$!%@#FK!Z&#K@'@Z&>KF!@>K$#\@$^$S!%=#!KO@F!FKNSR6!@F!&!FO=ZA$$Z$#!&>S!&<F=!A$$ZF! ĂŶŝŵĂůƐdŚĞĚŽĐƵŵĞŶƚĂƌLJǁĂƐĂďŽƵƚŽŶĞŽĨƚŚĞƐĞĂŶŝŵĂůƐůĞdžƐĂĐĐŽƵŶƚƐĂďŽƵƚŚŝƐ S='NG$>K&#R!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!$VZ$#@$>'$!'$>K#$S!=>!KO$!%@<G@>)!&'K@\@K@$F6!O@F!^@FO!KO&K! F=G$!G=#$!%N>>R!F'$>$F!^$#$!@>'<NS$S!@>!KO$!%@<G6!&>S!O@F!#$<&V$S!&KK@KNS$!K=^&#S! G$S@&! Z&#K@'@Z&K@=>! @>! )$>$#&<6! [NK! G=FK<R! =>! O@GF$<%(! 7$! K&<A$S! G=#$! &[=NK! O@F! &>@G&<F!&>S!O@F!S&@<R!&'K@\@K@$F!KO&>!&[=NK!KO$!%@<G!O$!Z&#K@'@Z&K$S!@>6!^O@'O!#$%<$'KF! ůĞdžƐƉƌĞŽĐĐƵƉĂƚŝŽŶǁŝƚŚƚŚĞƉƌĞƐĞŶƚĂŶĚŚŝƐŽǁŶĚĂŝůLJĂĐƚŝǀŝƚ@$F(!7$!O&S!&ZZ$&#$S! @>!=KO$#!G$S@&![$%=#$!&>S!%=#!O@G6![$@>)!&!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!@>!KO$!S='NG$>K&#R!%@<G!^&F! =>$!$\$>K!@>!&!F$#@$F!=%!G$S@&!$VZ$#@$>'$F!O$!$>b=R$S!^@KO!O@F!Z#$\@=NF!&>S!'N##$>K! &>@G&<F(! +<$V! FZ=A$! \$#R! %$^! $\&<N&K@\$! ^=#SF! &[=NK! KO$! Z#=b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ǁŝƚŚƉĞŽƉůĞ/ŶƐŚŽƌƚůĞdžƐĂĐĐŽƵŶƚŽĨŚŝƐĞdžƉĞƌŝĞŶĐĞĂƐĚŽĐƵŵĞŶƚĂƌLJƉĂƌƚŝĐŝƉĂŶƚ FO=^F! KO&K! $\$>! KO=N)O! O$! ^=N<S! O&\$! Z#$%$##$S! &! %N>>@$#! %@<G! O$! <@A$S! KO$! $VZ$#@$>'$!&>S!$>b=R$S!@K(!7=^$\$#6!@K!^&F!=>$!G$S@&!$VZ$#@$>'$!&G=>)!=KO$#F(! ! ?$>6! KO$! F$'=>S! Z&#K@'@Z&>K6! @F! &! >N#F$(! 7$! Z&#K@'@Z&K$S! @>! &! %@<G! &[=NK! &! Z=<@K@'&<! Z&#KR! &>S! @KF! <$&S$#6! ^O=G! ?$>! FNZZ=#KF(! ĞŶƐ ĂĐĐŽƵŶƚƐ ĐĞŶƚƌĞĚ ĂƌŽƵŶĚ ŚŝƐ $\&<N&K@=>!=%!KO$!%@<G6!O@F!$\&<N&K@=>!=%!KO$!$VZ$#@$>'$6!KO$!%@<GG&A$#6!&>S!O@GF$<%(! Q=#!?$>!KO$!$VZ$#@$>'$!^&F!&!<$&#>@>)!$VZ$#@$>'$!&F!O$!<$&#>$S!&[=NK!%@<GG&A@>)!&F! ^$<<!&F!&[=NK!O@GF$<%(!?$>!#$'=N>K$S!O$!^=#A$S!^$<<!^@KO!KO$!%@<GG&A$#6!KO$#$!^&F!&! [&F@F!=%!K#NFK!&>S!&>RKO@>)!'=N<S![$!S@F'NFF$S6!S$FZ@K$!KO$@#!S@%%$#$>K!=Z@>@=>F(!?$>! ^&F! '#@K@'&<! &[=NK! KO$! %@<Gh! O$! %$<K! &! FZ$'@%@'! F'$>$! ^&F! >=K! K#NKO%N<6! &>S! O$! $VZ$#@$>'$S!&!<&'A!=%![&<&>'$!@>!KO$!%@<G6!^O@<$!KO$!%@<GG&A$#!O&S!K=<S!O@G!@K!^=N<S! [$![&<&>'$S(!7$!G$&>K!K=!S@F'NFF!KO$F$!@FFN$F!^@KO!KO$!%@<GG&A$#!<&K$#(!?$>!^&F!>=K! '#@K@'&<! &[=NK! KO$! %@<GG&A$#(! 2N#@>)! @>K$#\@$^F! %=#! KO$! %@<G6! ?$>! '=>K#=<<$S! O@F! '=>K#@[NK@=>![=KO![R!#$%NF@>)!'=>F$>K!%=#!%@<G@>)6!&>S![R!@>'<NS@>)!FZ$'@%@'!G&K$#@&<! &>S! NKK$#&>'$F(! 7$! &<F=! K#@$S! K=! '=>K#=<! O@F! '=>K#@[NK@=>! [R! K#R@>)! K=! $VK$>S! O@F! S@F'<=FN#$6![R!&FA@>)!KO$!%@<GG&A$#!K=!@>'<NS$!FZ$'@%@'!G&K$#@&<(!9>!&SS@K@=>6!O$!^&F! @>\=<\$S!@>!G&A@>)!&##&>)$G$>KF!%=#!%@<G@>)6!&>S!'=>K#@[NK$S!'=>K$>K!=%!O@F!=^>1!O$! &##&>)$S!%=#!&SS@K@=>&<!Z&#K@'@Z&>KF!K=!%@<G(!7@F!Z&#K@'@Z&K@=>!O&S!F=G$!'=>F$`N$>'$F! %=#!?$>!&K!^=#A6![NK!F$$GF!K=!O&\$!F$#\$S!&F!&!'&K&<RFK!%=#!$V@FK@>)!K$>F@=>F6!#&KO$#! ƚŚĂŶĂƉƌŽďůĞŵŝŶŝƚƐĞůĨĞŶƐƌĞůĂƚŝŽŶƐŚŝƉǁŝƚŚƚŚĞĨŝůŵŵĂŬĞƌĐŚĂŶŐĞĚĂĨƚĞƌƚŚĞĨŝůŵ ^&F! %@>@FO$S1! #&KO$#! KO&>! %@<GG&A$#! &>S! Z&#K@'@Z&>K! KO$R! [$'&G$! %#@$>SF6! &>S6! &''=#S@>)!K=!?$>6!KO$R![=KO![$>$%@K$S!%#=G!KO@F!%#@$>SFO@Z(!?$>!S@F#$)&#S$S!<@>)$#@>)! @FFN$F! O$! Z<&>>$S!K=! S@F'NFF! ^@KO! KO$! %@<GG&A$#! <&K$#6! Z#@=#@K@D@>)! KO$@#! %#@$>SFO@Z! =\$#!N>#$F=<\$S!@FFN$F!'=>'$#>@>)!KO$!%@<G(! ! -O$!KO@#S!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!^&F!4O#@F6!&>!&'&S$G@'!&>S!^#@K$#6!&>S!%#@$>S!=%!KO$!%@<GG&A$#! =%!KO$!%@<G!O$!^&F!@>(!4O#@F!$>b=R$S!Z&#K@'@Z&K@>)!@>!KO$!S='NG$>K&#R6!^O@'O!%=#!O@G! ^&F!@>!&!F$>F$!&!%#@$>S<R!KN#>(!7$!&ZZ#$'@&K$S!KO$!%@<G!\$#R!GN'O6!<@A$!O$!&ZZ#$'@&K$S!
! ! ! ! ! KO$! %@<GG&A$#ʹ%#@$>S! ^O=! G&S$! @K6! &>S! O$#! ^=#A! @>! )$>$#&<(! 2$FZ@K$! O@F! Z=F@K@\$! $\&<N&K@=>!=%!KO$!$VZ$#@$>'$6!KO$#$!^&F!=>$!F'$>$!O$!^&F!@>!O$!O&S!S=N[KF!&[=NK6! [NK! KO$! %@<GG&A$#! '=>\@>'$S! O@G! KO$#$! ^&F! >=! >$$S! K=! #$'=#S! @K! &)&@>(! +%K$#! ^&K'O@>)!&!#=N)O!'NK6!O$!Z#$%$##$S!K=!O&\$!&!FZ$'@%@'!F'$>$!&F!KO$!$>S@>)6![NK!KO$! %@<GG&A$#!S$'@S$S!&)&@>FK!@K(!4O#@F!&<@)>$S!O@GF$<%!^@KO! KO$!%@<GG&A$#6![=KO![$@>)! ĐƌĞĂƚŝǀĞ ƉƌĂĐƚŝƚŝŽŶĞƌƐ ĂŶĚ ƚŚŝƐ ĂůůŝĂŶĐĞ ŝŶĐůƵĚĞĚ ĂĐĐĞƉƚŝŶŐ ƚŚĞ ĨŝůŵŵĂŬĞƌƐ ĂƌƚŝƐƚŝĐ S$'@F@=>F(! 4O#@F! &<F=! G&S$! Z#&'K@'&<! &##&>)$G$>KF! %=#! KO$! %@<G1! O$! &##&>)$S! Z$#G@FF@=>!%=#!%@<G@>)!&K!K^=!<='&K@=>F(!! ! 2$[[R!^&F!KO$!<&FK!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!@>K$#\@$^$S!%=#!KO@F!FKNSR(!;O$!@F!&>!&'&S$G@'!K==6! ^O=6!&K!KO$!K@G$!=%!KO$!@>K$#\@$^6!O&S!#$'$>K<R!%@>@FO$S!O$#!"O2!KO$F@F6!&![@=)#&ZOR(! -O$! %@<G!^&F! &[=NK! KO$! F&G$! Z$#F=>! &F! KO$! [@=)#&ZOR(! 2$[[R! ^&F! &ZZ#=&'O$S!&F! '=>FN<K&>K!%=#!KO$!%@<G6![NK!<&K$#![$'&G$!KO$!G&@>!Z&#K@'@Z&>K(!ĞďďLJƐĂĐĐŽƵŶƚŽĨ O$#!$VZ$#@$>'$!&F!S='NG$>K&#R!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!FO=^F!KO&K!%=#!O$#6!KO$!$VZ$#@$>'$!^&F! >=K!N>'=GZ<@'&K$S(!;O$!^&F!@>\=<\$S!@>!KO$!Z#=b$'K!&F!#$F$&#'O$#!=%!&>S!KONF!$VZ$#K! =>!KO$!K=Z@'h!FO$!N>S$#FK&>SF!O$#!#=<$!@>!KO$!%@<G!&F!#$F$&#'O$#!&>S!&'&S$G@'(!;O$! #$'=N>K$S!S@%%$#$>'$F!=%!=Z@>@=>!^@KO!KO$!%@<GG&A$#!%#=G!KO$!FK&#K6!&F!^$<<!&F!F$\$#&<! @>K$##NZK@=>F!@>!O$#!'==Z$#&K@=>!^@KO!KO$!%@<GG&A$#!&>S!KO$!Z#=SN'K@=>!K$&G6!G=FK! >=K&[<R! ^O$>! FO$! #$%NF$S! K=! ZO#&F$! FZ$'@%@'! @>%=#G&K@=>! @>! &! ^&R! KO$! %@<GG&A$#! ĞŶĐŽƵƌĂŐĞĚŚĞƌƚŽďƵƚǁŚŝĐŚŝŶĞďďLJƐĞLJĞƐǁĂƐǁƌŽŶŐŝŶƚĞƌƌƵƉƚĞĚĨŝůŵŝŶŐĂŶĚ S$G&>S$S!K@G$!K=!'=>'$@\$!=%!&!Z#=Z$#!F$>K$>'$!=%!O$#!=^>6!^O@'O!FO$!^&F!)@\$>(! M=##@$S! &[=NK! O$#! #$Z#$F$>K&K@=>6! &>S! '=>F$`N$>K<R! O$#! @G&)$! &F! &'&S$G@'6! KO@F! ^&F! =>$! =%! F$\$#&<! $%%=#KF! K=! F&%$)N&#S! KO&K! @G&)$! FO$! #$'=N>K$S(! +%K$#! FO$! O&S! ^&K'O$S!KO$!%@>&<!&!%@<G6!FO$!^&F!Z=F@K@\$!&[=NK!O$#!#$Z#$F$>K&K@=>!&>S!KO$!%@<G!@>! )$>$#&<6!R$K!#$G&@>$S!'#@K@ĐĂůĂďŽƵƚƐŽŵĞŽĨƚŚĞĨŝůŵŵĂŬĞƌƐĐŚŽŝĐĞƐ^ŚĞƌĞĐĞŝǀĞĚ G&>R!Z=F@K@\$!#$FZ=>F$F!&F!^$<<(!! ! -O$! &>&<RF$F! =%! KO$! %=N#! &''=N>KF! Z#=\@S$S! &>! N>S$#FK&>S@>)! =%! KO$! \&#@=NF! $VZ$#@$>'$F6!^O@'O!&#$!'O&#&'K$#@F$S![R!b=R6!<$&#>@>)6!&>S!F$<%B#$Z#$F$>K&K@=>6!&F!^$<<! &F!ŽĨƉĂƌƚŝĐŝƉĂŶƚƐĂƚƚŝƚƵĚĞƚŽǁĂƌĚƚŚĞƉƌŽũĞĐƚĂŶĚƚŽǁĂƌĚƚŚĞŝŶƚĞƌǀŝĞǁ/ŶƌĞƐƉĞĐƚŽĨ KO$! \&#@=NF! '=>'$ZKF! #$<$\&>K! K=! S='NG$>K&#R! %@<GG&A@>)! &>S! $KO@'F6! KO$F$! '&F$! FKNS@$F! @>S@'&K$S! &! F@G@<&#! #$FN<K! K=! KO$! FN#\$R1! '==Z$#&K@=>6! '=GGN>@'&K@=>6! &>S! K#NFK!S=G@>&K$!KO$!$VZ$#@$>'$6!&>S!'=>%<@'K6!@>'<NS@>)!S@F&)#$$G$>K6!S@%%$#$>K!Z=@>KF! =%!\@$^6!&>S!'=>%<@'K!Z#=Z$#!@>!KO$!%=#G!=%!@>K$##NZK@=>F!K=!KO$!'==Z$#&K@=>![$K^$$>! %@<GG&A$#! &>S! Z&#K@'@Z&>K6! Z<&RF! &>! @GZ=#K&>K! FNZZ=#K@>)! #=<$(! +<<! #$FZ=>S$>KF! S@F&)#$$S!^@KO!KO$!%@<GG&A$#!&K!F=G$!Z=@>K!&>S!&<<!K#@$S!K=!&%%$'K!KO$!Z#=b$'K!&>S! ƐĂĨĞŐƵĂƌĚƚŚĞŝƌŝŶƚĞƌĞƐƚƐ/ŶĂĚĚŝƚŝŽŶƚŚĞƉĂƌƚŝĐŝƉĂŶƚƐĂĐĐŽƵŶƚƐƉŽŝŶƚĞĚƚŽĂǀĂƌŝĞƚLJ =%! '=>F$`N$>'$F! =%! Z&#K@'@Z&K@>)! @>! &! S='NG$>K&#R! Z#=b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b=R! &>S! <$&#>!%#=G!KO$@#!Z&#K@'@Z&K@=>6!&>S!&K!KO$!F&G$!K@G$![$!'#@K@'&<!&[=NK!KO$!#$FN<KF1!@K! G&KK$#F!K=!KO$G(!-O$R!G@)OK!&<F=!)$K!@>\=<\$S!@>!Z#=SN'K@=>!K&FAF!%=#!%@<G@>)(!?&F$S!
=>! KO$! $GZ@#@'&<! %@>S@>)F6! &! Z#&'K@'$! FN#%&'$F! @>! ^O@'O! KO$! Z&#K@'@Z&>K! @F! &'K@\$<R! @>\=<\$S! @>! &>S!'=GG@KK$S! K=! KO$! Z#=b$'Kh! @>! ^O@'O! '=>%<@'K! @>! &! [#=&S! F$>F$! @F! &! #$'N##$>K![NK!>=>BS$'@F@\$!$<$G$>K!=%!KO$!%@<GG&A$#BZ&#K@'@Z&>K!#$<&K@=>FO@Zh!&>S!@>! ^O@'O!'=>%<@'K!@F!S@FZ$#F$S!&>S!<='&<6!#$<&K$S!K=!@>S@\@SN&<!F'$>$F!&>S!NKK$#&>'$F(!9>! KO@F! Z#&'K@'$6! '=GGN>@'&K@=>6! K#NFK6! &>S! '=GG@KG$>K! &#$! KO$! [&F@F6!&>S! '=>%<@'K! @F! $VZ$#@$>'$S!=''&F@=>&<<R(!4=GGN>@'&K@=>6!K#NFK6!&>S!'=GG@KG$>K!KONF!%N>'K@=>!&F!&! F&%$KRB>$K!%=#!'=>%<@'K(!! ! 9>! FO=#K6! KO@F! &<K$#>&K@\$! Z#&'K@'$! G@)OK! [$! S$F'#@[$S! &F! %=<<=^F(! Q@<GG&A$#! &>S! Z&#K@'@Z&>K!'==Z$#&K$!@>!&!Z#=b$'K!@>!^O@'O![=KO!&#$!'=GG@KK$S!K=!G&A$!&!'=GZ$<<@>)! %@<G!&>S![=KO!^$@)O!KO$@#!@>K$#$FKF!&)&@>FK!KO$!@>K$#$FKF!=%!KO$!=KO$#6!&>S!=%!KO$!%@<G(! +<KO=N)O!KO$!%@<GG&A$#!@F!@>!'O&#)$!=%!KO$!'#$&K@\$!Z#='$FF6!KO$!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!'=>K#=<F! O$#! '=>K#@[NK@=>! [R! '=>K#=<<@>)! O$#! S@F'<=FN#$6! &>S! [R! #$'=>F@S$#@>)! O$#! '=>F$>K(! 3NKN&<! &>S! '=>K@>N=NF! $V'O&>)$! =%! @>%=#G&K@=>6! `N$FK@=>F6! &>S! '=>'$#>F6! G&A@>)! '=>%<@'K!$VZ<@'@K6!O$<ZF!'#$&K$!&>!$>\@#=>G$>K!=%!K#NFK!@>!^O@'O!FN'O!'=>%<@'K!'&>![$! >$)=K@&K$S!F&%$<R6!^@KO=NK!S$K#@G$>K&<!'=>F$`N$>'$F!%=#!KO$!Z#=b$'K(!! ! ;/1,6B87/1! -O$!#$FN<KF!=%!KO$!$GZ@#@'&<!#$F$&#'O!Z#=b$'KF!S@F'NFF$S!@>!KO@F!KO$F@F!G$#@K!&!#$\@F@=>! =%!KO$!F'O=<&#<R!S@F'NFF@=>!=%!S='NG$>K&#R!%@<GG&A@>)!$KO@'F(!3=#$!FZ$'@%@'&<<R6!KO$R! G$#@K!&!Z&#&S@)GBFO@%K(!-O$!#=<$!=%!KO$!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!'&>![$!'=>'$@\$S!&F!KO&K!=%!&!'=B '#$&K=#6! Z&#K@&<! KO=N)O! K=! O$#! '=>K#@[NK@=>h! FO$! '=>K#=<F! O$#! '=>K#@[NK@=>! &>S! @F! @>\=<\$S! @>! Z#=SN'K@=>! K&FAF(! -O$! S@F'NFF@=>! &[=NK! &>! $KO@'F! =%! S='NG$>K&#R! %@<GG&A@>)!GNFK!%@#FK!=%!&<<!@>'<NS$!&!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!&F!Z&#K@&<!'=B'#$&K=#6!'=GG@KK$S!&>S! @>\=<\$S! @>! KO$! Z#=b$'K(! 9K! GNFK! &<F=! @>'<NS$! '=GGN>@'&K@=>! &F! &! \$O@'<$! K=! '&##R! %@<GG&A$#! &>S! Z&#K@'@Z&>K! '=B'#$&K=#FO@Z6! @>'<NS@>)! %&'@<@K&K@>)! KO$! $V'O&>)$! =%! @>%=#G&K@=>6! `N$FK@=>F6! &>S!'=>'$#>F6! &>S! KO$! [N@<S@>)! &>S! %=FK$#@>)! =%! K#NFKh! &>S! '=>%<@'K!&F!&!G$&>F!K=!>$)=K@&K$!&>S!F&%$)N&#S!KO$@#!#$FZ$'K@\$!@>K$#$FKF(!! ! M@KO@>! KO$! S='NG$>K&#R!Z#=b$'K6! %=#! ^O@'O! '==Z$#&K@=>! @F! KO$! Z=@>K! =%! S$Z&#KN#$6! '=>%<@'K!$V@FKF!@>!@>FK&>'$F!@>!^O@'O!KO$!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!'O&<<$>)$F!KO$!&NKO=#@KR!=%!KO$! %@<GG&A$#!&>S!$V$#KF!@>%<N$>'$!=>!KO$!'=>K$>K!=%!KO$!%@<G![R!#$%NF@>)!=#!Z#=G=K@>)! FZ$'@%@'!'=>K$>K(!9>!KO@F!Z#&'K@'$6!S@%%$#$>K!$KO@'&<!`N$FK@=>F!FN#%&'$(!-O$F$!`N$FK@=>F! S=!>=K!Z#@G&#@<R!'=>'$#>!KO$!>$$S!%=#!KO$!%@<GG&A$#!K=!Z#=K$'K!KO$!Z&#K@'@Z&>K!%#=G! O&#G! $>FN@>)! %#=G! O$#! #$Z#$F$>K&K@=>! @>! &! S='NG$>K&#R! %@<G6! [NK! #&KO$#! KO$! >$)=K@&K@=>!=%!Z&#K@&<!'=B'#$&K=#FO@Z!&>S!=%!KO$!#$FZ$'K@\$!@>K$#$FKF!=%!%@<GG&A$#!&>S! Z&#K@'@Z&>K!@>!KO$!Z#='$FF!=%!G&A@>)!KO$!GNKN&<<R!S$F@#$S!'=GZ$<<@>)!%@<G(! ! $78,B887/1! -O$!`N$FK@=>>&@#$!^&F!S$F@)>$S!%=#!KO@F!FZ$'@%@'!FN#\$R!&>S!^@<<!FN#$<R![$!$<@)@[<$!%=#! S$\$<=ZG$>K!&>S!@GZ#=\$G$>K(!9K!^&F!@>!0>)<@FO!=><R6!^O@'O!O&F!S@F'=N#&)$S!F=G$! @>\@K$$F!%#=G!'=GZ<$K@>)!@K(!-O$!S&K&!@K!Z#=\@S$S!'&G$!%#=G!&!\$#R!O$K$#=)$>$=NF! )#=NZ!=%!%@<GG&A$#Fh!KO$!%&'K=#!&>&<RF@F!$VZ<&@>$S!=><R!JLt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b$'KF!K=![$!@>\$FK@)&K$S(!9!NF$S!F$G@BFK#N'KN#$S!@>K$#\@$^F6![NK!&F!S&K&!'=<<$'K@=>!