Truth and utility in fuzzy logic
Abstract
The notion of degree of truth used in fuzzy logic can be interpreted in terms of partial truth or in terms of utility. By investigating how these interpretations fit in with Tarski's definition of truth, this paper explores some of their implications and their consequences for the foundations and credibility of fuzzy logic.
Full text
sYbs m 7BP ]B8}Z$ E
w
d
D
dMTd
qZY s I =$j$k $ 3Z99k NB${
V 7BA$ B
*} NB${ s I Bsj _Y$jBRB}Yk = $% 7s $sB I ]B8}BRjs
]s8}ZR = $%R$s$B R dx(E 7s $sB I ]B8}BRjs 7}s$
j4sj-oZR{R
VARs{
qY B$B BP I BP ZY ZRI $ PZ99k jB${ {s A $ }I $
8R BP }s$sj ZY B $ 8R BP Z$j$k k $ %R$s$ YBb YR
$ }s$B R h $ b$Y qsR,$:R Ih $$B BP ZY Y$R }s} -}jBR
RB8 BP Y$ $8}j${s$B R s I Y$ {B RJZ {R PB Y PBZ Is$B R s I
{I$A$j$k BP PZ99k jB${
kbBIRU
zsZ RR qZY =$j$k 3Z99k jB${
d y BIZ{$B
qY B$B BP ZY $R { sj B {jsRR${sj A$%sj jB${ bY${Y $R {B88B jk IT
R{$AI sR Y RZIk BP Y }B}ss$B BP ZY Ak %sj$I IIZ{$% }B{RRR
3Z99k jB${ $R BP IR{$AI sR s PB8sj$R8 PB sRB $ $ R$Zs$B R B bY${Y
Z {s$ k $R $ Y $ sRRB{$sR ABY }8$RR s I {B {jZR$B R b$Y
IR
BP ZY
T s {B {} sR PZ Is8 sj B PZ99k jB${ sR ZY $R B {jsRR${sj jB${ T
s I }B%$IR s {sj{ZjZR sjjBb$ sRB sAj %sjZs$B BP Y I BP {s$ k
b$Y bY${Y {B {jZR$B R {s A s{YI PB8 %sZ }8$RR s I $8}{$R jB${sj
js$B RY$}R
y $R bjj , Bb Ys IR BP ZY {s A $ }I $ R%sj I$&
bskR ! BP Y 8BR ZRZsj %$bR RR Y8 sR JZs $Pk$ ZY $RjP RB Ys
s I BP ZY jRR Ys d((0 $ I${sR s
}s$sj ZY
s BY RR Y8 sR
JZs $Pk$
ZRPZj ZY
>nH y }I sR 8sRZR BP }s$sj ZY Yk -}RR
s}}B-$8s$B R B s bYBj ZY Ys $R Z ss$ sAj A{sZR BP js{, BP Ps{Zsj
B $ P $sj $ PB8s$B PB -s8}j s IB{B s I$ s BsI s{{$I %${T
$8 b$YBZ I$s BR${ JZ$}8 8ZR Isb $ P {R B Y AsR$R BP $8}P{
, BbjI BP Y %${$8:R {B I$$B y }I sR 8sRZR BP XZRPZj" ZY
Yk -}RR s s :R RZA`{$% {B hI { $ Y ZY BP Y }B}BR$$B $
JZR$B PB -s8}j $ I$R$AZ$ Y$ RZIk $8 RZI R s, $ B s{{BZ
Y IR BP {B hI { Yk Ys% $ Y$ {Z sA$j$k B }sRR -s8$ s$B R
$ Y %s$BZR RZA`{R e$Y bsk sR -}RR$B R BP }s$sj ZY B ZRPZj ZY
IR BP ZY s js$% B s BA`{$% ZY Ys $R Z ss$ sAj A{sZR BP
{Z js{, BP $ PB8s$B
dM
d(
V 7BA$ B
y {jsRR${sj jB${ Y B$B BP BA`{$% ZY $R ZRZsjjk jsI B Ys BP T
sj ZY B s jsR B Y B$B BP s ZY b$Y s {s$ 8}Bsj RsA$j$k
y }s${Zjs Y %$h{s$B sj {$$s BP }YkR${R s I 8sY8s${R IBb Y$
}B}BR$$B R b$Y s {s$ RsA$j$k B $88ZsA$j$k y PZ99k jB${ Y {B {}
BP $8}{$R ZYR $R ZRZsjjk jsI $Y B Y I B {sk BZ sRB $
}B{RRR $ R$Zs$B R $ bY${Y $8 $R RYB s I }{$R $ PB8s$B {B { $
}8$RR s I $8}j${s$B R {s B A bs$I PB B R$Zs$B R $ bY${Y }{$R $ T
PB8s$B bBZjI A RB %BjZ8$ BZR sR B 8s, $R }B{RR$ $8}s{${sj B B
R$Zs$B R $ bY${Y Y s B s%s$jsAj 8{Ys $R8R PB }B{RR$ }{$R $ PBT
8s$B $ s bsk Ys Zss R {B {jZR$B R BP s j$sA$j$k Ys YBR Ys
{s A Isb B Y AsR$R BP $8}{$R $ PB8s$B
]jsRR${sj jB${ sR Y RZIk BP Y }B}ss$B BP ZY Ak %sj$I IIZ{$%
}B{RRR RR B s $Isj {$$B BP ZY i$BBZR Ih $$B R BP ZY Ys%
A }B}BRI Ak qsR,$
w
}$8s$jk b$Y PB8sj js ZsR $ 8$ I
D
s I $ %$b
BP Y }BAj8R s$R$ bY qsR,$:R Ih $$B $R s}}j$I B sZsj js ZsR
Ak R%sj BY sZYBR G$Y PZ99k jB${ $ 8$ I pBZ >EH YsR }B}BRI s
XRB{$sj" Ih $$B BP ZY b$Y PsZR $ Y$I PB8 R}{Y s{ YBk >dH s
RB{$sj {B {} BP ZY {B { R B Z R {R AZ Z Zs {R 8$I Ak
}s${Zjs s R b$Y }s${Zjs BsjR $ }s${Zjs R$Zs$B R V }BAj8 b$Y
RZ{Y s {B {} $R Ys Y js{, BP }j${sA$j$k BP Y {${Z8Rs {R s I$ s
Zs { YBb IBZAR B Y BA`{$%$k BP ZY sRR$ 8 R Ys s 8sI B
I} I B YR {${Z8Rs {R
]s$ jk PZ99k jB${ s}}sR B JZ$ RB8 ,$ I BP RB{$sj {B {} BP ZY
R$ { $ s8}R B 8BIj sjTj$P sRB $ {B Rs$ I Ak j$8$I $8 s I $ T
PB8s$B }B{RR$ }Bb V Y Rs8 $8 YBb% $ {js$8R B A BA`{$%
w
% YBZY PZ99k }B}BR$$B R 8sk A $ RB8 {B -TI} I R R BP j$8T
$I sY Ys Z $%Rsj R{B}
D
s I Y { B JZ$ s Ih $$B BP ZY Ys
$R BA`{$%jk s}}j${sAj $ s bsk Ys R8R AkB I Y s{Y BP RB{$sj {B {}R
BP ZY 3Z99k jB${ bBZjI YZR R8 B I s {B {} BP sII ZY Ys $R
%YjRR RZR{}$Aj B s Ih $$B BP Y ,$ I Ys qsR,$ }B}BRI PB Y
ZY BP {jsRR${sj jB${
y Y$R }s} y ZR qsR,$:R ZY {$$B B -s8$ {s$ j$8$s$B R s I
$8}j${s$B R BP Y B$B R BP ZY s I Z$j$k ZRI $ PZ99k jB${ y 7{$B 1
AjBb y s sjkR Y {B {}R BP $Isj ZY
w
1d
D
RB{$sj ZY
w
11
D
s I 8Zj$}jT
%sjZI ZY
w
1n
D
$ 7{$B ny{B R$IZY s I Z$j$k $ s PZ99k {B - s I
$ 7{$B ; y R,{Y RB8 {jBR$ 4-$B R
1 qY B$B BP ZY
1d yIsj ZY
]jsRR${sj jB${ $R {B { I b$Y Y PB8sj {B RZ{$B BP Y {B RJZ {R BP
R{$ $h{ js Zs T }ssI$8s${sjjk Y js ZsR BP }YkR${R s I 8sY8s${R
hjIR $ bY${Y Rs{Y $R {B88B jk Rs$I B sR}$ B BA`{$% ZY qY$R $ T
II BA`{$%$k jsIR B Y JZ$8 Ys s k Ih $$B BP ZY A $
D
BP
qZY s I =$j$k $ 3Z99k NB${
dd
sj s}}j${sA$j$k s I $$
D
B BjB${sjjk s I }$R8BjB${sjjk Zsj y $R ZRZT
sjjk {B R$II Ys ABY YR JZ$R$R s Rs$RhI Ak Y YBk BP ZY }Z
PBbsI Ak qsR,$ >d1H $ dnE bY${Y }B}BRR {B I$$B R Ys RYBZjI A 8 Ak
s k sIJZs ZY YBk s I }R R s Ih $$B BP ZY PB PB8sj js ZsR
Ys $R Rs$I B {B8}jk b$Y YR {B I$$B R
qsR,$ JZ$R BP s ZY YBk Ys $ A ABY X8s$sjjk sIJZs" s I
XPB8sjjk {B{" V YBk $R 8s$sjjk sIJZs bY $ $8}j$R sjj $ Rs {R
BP Y qT R{Y8s 7$RZ$&}
w
q
D
bY X7" $R s s8 $% B RB8 R { AjB $ B Y js Zs PB bY${Y
ZY $R A$ Ih I s I } $R s R { Ys sRRR bYs Y R { 7 sRRR
Y Rs IsI -s8}j BP s $ Rs { BP Y qTR{Y8s $R
X7 Bb $R bY$" $R Z $& R Bb $R bY$
V YBk $R PB8sjjk {B{ $P Y js Zs PB bY${Y ZY $R A$ Ih I s I
Y Ih $$B BP ZY $RjP Rs$RPk {s$ {B I$$B R
w
R qsR,$ >d1H PB }{$R
Is$jR
D
qsR,$:R YBk Rs$RhR Y JZ$8 BP B BjB${sj s I }$R8BjBT
${sj Zsj$k A{sZR s}}j${s$B BP Y qTR{Y8s IBR B $ $ R${sjjk $ %Bj%
Y s :R , BbjI B Aj$PR 7s$RPs{$B BP Y JZ$8 BP sj$k $R
jRR BA%$BZRU hR A{sZR Y $R B R$ j Ih $$B BP ZY s}}j${sAj B sjj
js ZsR AZ B jk }s${Zjs Ih $$B R PB }s${Zjs PB8sj js ZsR B s}T
}B}$sjk Zjs$9I sZsj js ZsR s I R{B Ijk A{sZR % sR sIR s
R$ j $% js Zs Y $R B Ih $$B BP ZY $ sj B jk BP Y ZY
BP }s${Zjs R {R 7
N ZR {B R$I Y 8s$sj sIJZs{k {B I$$B $ Y {B - BP sZsj js T
Zs $ {jZI$ Y js Zs BP 8}$${sj R{$ { WB Ys Rs$RPs{$B BP Y
qT R{Y8s IBR B Ak $RjP {B R$Z s Ih $$B BP ZY qsR,$ 8s,I Ys
$P s sZsj B R{$ $h{ js Zs YsI s h $ Z8A BP R {R s{Y BP bY${Y
bsR R8s ${sjjk {jBRI Y Ih $$B BP ZY bBZjI A $%$sj A{sZR $ bBZjI
A }BRR$Aj B j$R sjj R {R s I Ih sR Z `ZR YBR R {R 7 Ys s RT
jsI $ B Z R {R } <Bb% sZsj js ZsR Ys% s $ h $ Z8A BP
R {R qsR,$ 8 Y$R }BAj8 Ak Ih $ ZY $ 8R BP Y Rs$RPs{$B
BP s R $sj PZ {$B Ak $% BA`{R s I }B%$ Ys Y$R Ih $$B bsR 8sT
$sjjk sIJZs <Bb% Y$R RBjZ$B Ps$jR B s{,j s I$& ,$ I BP }BAj8
Ys s$RR PB sZsj js ZsRU Y -$R { BP %sZ }I${sR bY${Y 8s R
Ys $ Y qTR{Y8s 7 s I } 8sk $ {jZI bBIR BP $8}{$R 8s $ qY$R }BRR
Y JZR$B R BP bYY Y qTR{Y8s $R PB8sjjk {B8}s$Aj b$Y Y -$R {
BP %sZ }I${sR s I bYs Y $8}j${s$B R s PB s YBk BP ZY
11 7B{$sj ZY
y s RB{$sj s}}Bs{Y B ZY Y JZR$B BP bYs ZY $R $R }js{I Ak JZR$B R
sABZ YBb Y bBI XZ" $R ZRI $ YBb $ $R s}}j$I B R {R Ys s sRT
RI B A Z ! Y$R %$b sRR$B R sABZ ZY s %sjZsI $ Y {BZR
BP RB{$sj $ s{$B ZR$ BI$ sk js Zs sY Ys $ s $Isj XBA`{$%"
RkR8 IR$ I PB RB8 R}{$h{ }Z}BR RZ{Y sR Y PB8sj {B RZ{$B BP R{$T
{ V RB{$sj Ih $$B BP ZY IBR B Rs Ak JZ$$ Ys Z R {R
d1
V 7BA$ B
4{ Y bBjI AZ $ RsI Ys Yk IR{$A R$Zs$B R $ s bsk Ys RZjR $
RZ{{RRPZj {B88Z ${s$B Ab js Zs ZRR RB Ys Y js Zs ZR {$%T
$ Y8 Z IRs IR Y ZR Ak bYB8 Yk s 8$I _B}BR$$B R IB B Ys%
B
{B RZ{
sj$k sY Yk {B RZ{ s ZRPZj RZA`{$% Z IRs I$ BP
sj$k
y Y$R {B - s YBk BP ZY 8ZR s, $ B s{{BZ Ys Y ZYT%sjZ
BP s }B}BR$$B $R B $ I} I BP Y s R ZR$ $ B Y R$Zs$B $ bY${Y
$ $R ZRI Ys $ 8sk {Ys $ $8 Ys }B}BR$$B R 8ZR A %sjZsI `ZR sR
Yk s $ sj js Zs b$YBZ s k sjs$B BP Y$ j-${B s I Ys $ $R s
Ps{ Ys 8BR sZsj js Zs }B}BR$$B R $ {jZI bBIR BP $8}{$R 8s $
y BI$ sk {B88Z ${s$B Y s B $ I} I ZYR AZ Z R {
Zs {R }PB8I Ak }s${Zjs $ I$%$IZsjR y Ps{ $ Y RB{$sj {B - BP
{B88Z $$R BP R}{$sj$RR $ }s${Zjs RZA`{ 8sR Y s$AZ$B BP ZY
B s }B}BR$$B I} IR 8B B Y j$ Z$R${ {B88Z $k Ys B $R $ I$%$IZsj
88AR R$ { $ $R sjjk Y {B88Z $k Ys RsAj$RYR Ak $ R$Z$B sj
8{Ys $R8R bYs Y {B{ ZR BP s Rk8ABj B R$ BP Rk8ABjR $R s I bY${Y BP $R
88AR s {B8} T s I $ bYs I T B RsAj$RY ZY s RB8 }s${Zjs
$8 y %kIsk js Zs Zs {R ZRZsjjk P B R$Zs$B R Ys s B
}j${sAj {s B A -s8$ I Ak BYR s I {s B % A T-s8$ I Ak Y
R}s, R$ { Y $R B {s$ k Ys bB I$& -}$ {R s $ Rs {R BP
Y Rs8 R$Zs$B
y Y sAR { BP }j${sR sjj Ys {s A Rs$I $R Ys sRR$B R {s A 8sI
b$Y I$& IR BP RZ{{RR $ %s$BZR I$8 R$B R {s h Y Ps{R 8B B jRR
jBBRjk s I $ I$& bskR B I$& B{{sR$B R s I b$Y I$& $ R s I
}Z}BRR >EH qY Z $%R BP ZY %sjZR {s B A j$8$I B XZ" s I XPsjR"
VR BI sAB% PZ99k jB${ s}}sR B JZ$ s RB{$sj Ih $$B BP ZY 7$ {
$ $R {B { I b$Y sRB $ Ys $R $8}{$R j$, %kIsk sRB $ $ BI$ sk
js Zs $ BZY B s, $ B s{{BZ Y s R $ %Bj%I $8 {B - s I Y
-$R { BP %sZ }I${sR <Bb% {B $$B BP Y RB{$sj sZ BP ZY
}B%$IR B {$$B BP YBb B ZR Y$R {B {} sY $ s}}sR B $8}jk Ys
A{sZR BP Y %s$k s I s R$ { BP RB{$sj }Y B8 s B RZ{Y {$$B $R
}BRR$Aj qYZR sjYBZY $ $R B $88I$sjk {js YBb Y qTR{Y8s 8sk A
s}}j$I B sZsj B R{$ $h{ js Zs $Y $R $ {js Ys Y $R B I B
s}}jk $ V k R{$ $h{ hjI R,R BA`{$%$k $ {jZI$ Y s8}R b$Y$ Y
hjI BP PZ99k jB${ B RsAj$RY s PB8sj B $ PB8sj YBk BP %sZ RR PB s kB
b$RY$ B IBb Y jB${sj s sjkR$R BP $8}{$R js Zs b$Y BA`{$%$k Y
qTR{Y8s $R s $ RZ8 Ys {s B A B%jBB,I
1n yIsj ZY s I 8Zj$}jT%sjZI ZY
V{{BI$ B _Z s8 >d(H $ $R }BRR$Aj B PB8Zjs s qTR{Y8s PB js ZsR b$Y
%sZ }I${sR AZ B jk s s }${U Y $ BIZ{$B BP %sZ RR $ Y 8sT
js Zs qY$R $R $jjZRsI Ak Y PBjjBb$ ZY sAj $ bY${Y Xy" }R R
s k I BP ZY Ab q s I 3
qZY s I =$j$k $ 3Z99k NB${
dn
7 $R Z $&
w
D
}
q q q
3 q 3
y q y
y BY bBIR Y jB${ BP Y 8sjs Zs $R $ 4Z {I Ak Y jB${ BP
Y BA`{ js ZsU $P B bs R B }R% Y JZ$%sj { -}RRI $ Y qT
R{Y8s Y %sZ RR {s B A {B h I B Y BA`{ js Zs s I $ R}{I
PB8 Y %s s }B$ BP s {$R} 8sjs Zs T Y 8sjs Zs BB 8ZR sjjBb
%sZ RR 3ZY8B Y 8ZR % A 8sR {R }I${s$ ZY Ys
Ys% ZY %sjZR BY Ys q s I 3 RB Ys Y }I${s XZ" 8ZR {RRs$jk
A sR $8}{$R sR Y %sZ }I${sR BP Y BA`{ js ZsU $P Y qTR{Y8s
$R }R%I B s $8}{$R 7 Y 8ZR {BR}B I s $8}{$R } s I B Y
$8}{$R } s $8}{$R X7 $R Z" y RYB _Z s8:R sZ8 R RYBb Ys $P
Y 8sjs Zs $R B {B PB8 B {jsRR${sj jB${ Y Y BA`{ js Zs 8ZR
A Zjs$9I RB sR B j$8$ s %sZ RR bY$j $P %sZ }I${sR s B A
sI8$I $ Y BA`{ js Zs sR RZR{}$Aj BP jB${sj s sjkR$R Y {jsRR${sj
jB${ 8ZR A }js{I Ak s 8Zj$}jT%sjZI jB${ $ ABY Y BA`{ js Zs s I
Y 8sjs Zs
e% $P Y qTR{Y8s {s s s }${ A sj$9I PB8 }{$R B $8}{$R
js ZsR Y sAB% sj$9s$B bBZjI s}}s B JZ$ Ys bYs% I
BP ZY s R { 8sk Ys% Ys I BP ZY A Z $JZ I$R$ Z$RYsAj s I
$ I} I BP Y sZ BP s R s I R$Zs$B R yR Y$R RB $ js ZsR b$Y
%sZ }I${sR2 qY {B sk $R RZRI Ak Y }ssIB- BP 7B$RU $P RB8B
b$Y `ZR s Pb Ys$R B Y$ YsI
z
Rsk $R AsjI Y RB8B b$Y
z
Ld Ys$R $R
sjRB AsjI s I RB B RB %kB $R AsjI B 8s YBb 8s k Ys$R Yk Ys% B
Y$ YsI < s }s jk PsjR {B {jZR$B $R s$%I s YBZY Y sAR { BP s
YBj$R${ %$b BP Y }BAj8 s I Y ZR BP sRB $ Ys 8s$ s$ R Z sjI s
s{Y R} Y R Y b$Y bY${Y Y }I${s XAsjI" $R s}}j$I qY$R }ssIB-
YZR Y$Yj$YR bYs s}}sR B A s $ {B8}s$A$j$k Ab $BBZR s}}j${s$B
BP Y ZjR BP jB${ s I Y {B88B R R%sjZs$B BP ZY $ %kIsk R$Zs$B RU
$ $R sARZI B {B {jZI Ys % Y Ys$$R BP YsIR $R AsjI AZ $ $R B jRR
sARZI B k B $I $Pk s Ih $ Z8A BP Ys$R }BRRRR$B BP bY${Y {B R$ZR
Y ABIj$ Ab AsjI RR s I B TAsjI RR
GYs Y }ssIB- BP 7B$R sjjk Y$Yj$YR $R s I$& { Ab Y BAT
`{$%R BP XjB${BT8sY8s${sj" sRB $ s I Y BA`{$%R BP {B88B R R
sRB $ XNB${BT8sY8s${sj" sRB $ $R s}}B}$s s I &{$% $ }B%T
$ }B}BR$$B R b$Y $88ZsAj ZY %sjZR bYsR {B88B R R sRB $
{B { R Y sRR$ 8 BP ZY %sjZR PB R}{$h{ ZRPZj }Z}BRR $ R}{$h{ {B8T
8Z ${s$% R$Zs$B R
V Y$R }B$ j ZR {sjj Ys $ PZ99k jB${ XI BP ZY" $R ZRZsjjk $ T
}I $Y sR X}s$sj ZY" B sR XZRPZj ZY" 3B8 Y }B$ BP %$b BP
Z$j$k $ b$jj $ RB8 {sRR A $j%s bYY s $% R { $R sRR$ I sR
$R ZY %sjZ (ME( B (MEd YR bB %sjZR b$jj A $ I$R$ Z$RYsAj sR sIR
Y RZ{{RR BP Y {B88Z ${s$B $ bY${Y Yk s ZRI s I Y IR$sA$j$k B
BYb$R BP Y$ {B RJZ {R <Bb% $ }I sR 8sRZR BP }s$sj ZY
d;
V 7BA$ B
sR {BjsR BP sj$k
w
}Ys}R s %sZ BA`{
D
(ME( $R RR $sjjk I$R$ { PB8
(MEd $ II sRR$ 8 BP Y ZY %sjZ (ME( {BZjI A sI sR s$
sRR$ 8 BP Y %sjZ (MEd qYZR PB s }B}BR$$B IR$ s$ $R j$ Z$R${
{Bjs s8A$%sj jk Y qTR{Y8s $R B Rs$RhI s jsR PB B BP Y %sjZR
V}}j${s$B BP Y qTR{Y8s B R {R Ys {s B jk A 8BIjjI R8s $T
{sjjk ZR$ IR BP ZY YPB jsIR $ %$sAjk B Z IR$sAj {B {jZR$B R
yP Y $ }s$B BP Y B$B BP I BP ZY $R jB${sj Y BZY B
A s RYs} ABIj$ Ab s %sZ }I${s s I $R s$B RB sR B s%B$I
7B$RTk} }ssIB-R AZ Y $R B RYs} ABIj$ yP B Y BY Ys I Y
$ }s$B $R AsRI B Z$j$k Y Y s {$$s PB Isb$ Y ABIT
j$ AZ Y ABIj$ Isb $R Ys9k s I 8ZsAj I} I$ B {B -Zsj s I
-sj$ Z$R${ Ps{BR qY$R I$j88s Ab ZRjRR BA`{$%$k s I RZA`{$%
Z$j$k $R {Yss{$R${ BP Y RsZR BP Y B$B BP ZY $ PZ99k jB${ y bYs
PBjjBbR y I$R{ZRR RB8 sR}{R BP Y$R
n qZY s I Z$j$k $ PZ99k jB${
3Z99k jB${ $R s jB${ BP %sZ }I${sR V PJZ jk ZRI }ssI$8 BP s %sZ
}I${s $R Xsjj" y $R {B88B B Rsk Ys Y$R }I${s $R BAR%s$B sj $ $
AjB R B Ys {jsRR BP }I${sR Ys PB B}BR$$%$RR s RR $sj {B8}B R
BP Y }B}BR$$B R b$Y bY${Y R{$ { $R {B RZ{I y R}$ BP Y$R -sjI
PZ {$B b {s B AZ {B $9 Ys %sZ BAR%s$B sj }I${sR {s A ZRI
$ bskR Ys s {B sI${Bk
w
$ Y {jsRR${sj R R BP {B sI${$B
D
B s jsR
8ZZsjjk I$R$ { yP b bs I Y {B {} B Ys% s R$ j %sjZs$B b bBZjI
Ys% B -}RR $ b$Y s }{$R$B
V {B88B bsk BP RYs} $ Y 8s $ BP s %sZ }I${s $R Ak P {
B $ RZ8 R Ys s8}j$Pk B h BAR%s$B s&BI$ s 8B Is$jI %$b
BP Y BA`{R s I % R BAR%I Z $ RZ8 R Ys% Y$ j$8$R _s$,Y:R
YB8 TPB 8B Is$jR R >EHT RYBbR Ys PB
T{B {I R}s{R $ RZ8 R
BP BAR%s$B B 8sRZ8 {s B {js$Pk Y - R$B BP s %sZ }I${sU
sjj BAR%s$B R YBb% h Ys% Y$ b$j$Y 9B
V BY bsk BP RYs} $ s %sZ }I${s RZ{Y sR Xsjj" $R B s $ sR
-}RR$ s js$%$R${ {B {} {B8}s$ PB -s8}j Y Y$Y BP B $ I$T
%$IZsj b$Y Ys BP s BY y Y$R {sR Y R8s ${R BP Y %sZ }I${s $R
B }R I Ak s I BP ZY AZ Ak s BII R BP %sjZR Z R$ {
Y }I${s A$ %sZ sI8$R 8B Ys B $ Rs $s$B {s$ AsR BP
%sZ }I${sR b$Y I$& Y$YR {s B A 8ZZsjjk I$R{$8$ sI B I$R$ T
Z$RYI Ak 8s R BP Y }I${s Xsjj" y BY bBIR Yk s B 8ZZsjjk
{B8}ssAj
y %$b BP YR I$^{Zj$R b 8sk Pj 8}I B bB I bYs s sjj $ I$%$IZsj
sjjk $R y bBZjI A Yj}PZj B k B s Rb Y$R JZR$B $ 8R BP s }{$R
8sRZ PB -s8}j Ak s,$ s Zj s I ZR$ $ B 8sRZ s s}}B}$s
$ I$%$IZsj 7Z}}BR Ys Y RZj $R s Y$Y BP dM;( {8 yP Y $ I$%$IZsj
b Ys% 8sRZI s}}sR B A Zjk sjj b 8$Y Rsk Ys s sjj $ I$%$IZsj $R
RB8B bYB 8sRZR dM;( {8 Z Y$R IBR B s Rb Y B$$ sj JZR$B
qZY s I =$j$k $ 3Z99k NB${
dx
s 8BR $ s RbR Y JZR$B XGYs $R $ B 8sRZ dM;( {82" bY${Y $R JZ$
I$R$ { s jsR $ YBk PB8 Y JZR$B XGYs $R $ B 8sRZ dM;d {82" y
bBZjI YZR R8 I{$IIjk I$^{Zj B I8$ }{$Rjk bYs sjj RR $R $ R}$
BP BZ sjj , Bb$ YBb B 8}jBk Y bBI Xsjj" $ BZ RB{$sj Isj$ R
7B s R{$ $h{ Ih $$B BP Xsjj" IBR B {B$ {$I b$Y s }ZAj${ Ih $$B
s I
%${ %Rs
qB Rsk BP RB8B Ys Yk s sjj $R s {ZjZsj sRR$B AZ
R{$ { $R s j$8$I B R}{$sj PB8 BP {ZjZ $ %Bj%$ s R}{$h{ s}} ${RY$}
Z Is, $ R${I s{sI8${ JZsR s I }s${Zjs {B88Z $$R WsZsj
js Zs B Y BY Ys I $R Y PZ$ BP %BjZ$B s I }s BP BZ Bs ${
s I RB{$sj I%jB}8 V kB YBZY 8jk j$%$ $ {B88Z $k js R Y
8s $ BP Xsjj" sjYBZY s{Y $ I$%$IZsj $ }R $ $ Y$R B Y Bb 8R
VR +Z$ >ddH }B$ I BZ Y ZRZsj 8s R Ak bY${Y Y 8s $ BP BAR%s$B sj
}I${sR $R s{JZ$I $R BR R$B RB BABIk {s A RZ Ys bYs s bBI 8s R
PB Y8 {B$ {$IR -s{jk b$Y bYs $ 8s R PB RB8B jR % YBZY Yk
s
{B hI BP BRR {B$ {$I {
w
sR $R RYBb Ak Y Ps$jZ BP {B88Z ${s$B B
As, IBb bY % b ZR YR }I${sR
D
]BsR 8s $ $R YZR s {Yss{$R${ BP {s$ bBIR $ BI$ sk js Zs
VjYBZY dM;( {8 $R }P{jk I$R$ Z$RYsAj PB8 dM;d {8 b bBZjI sjj s
Ys $P RB8B Rs$I B 8sRZ dM;( {8 b {jsRR$hI sR sjj Y$R {jsRR$h{s$B
bBZjI B A sjI $P Yk Z I BZ B 8sRZ dM;d {8 e% $P %s$s$B BP
j$ Z$R${ {B % $B R PB8 B {B88Z $k B s BY s $ BI s $ I$%$IZsj:R
A$ sjj $R sR $ b B s }R s$% BP RB8Y$ Z $JZ AZ BP s {Bjj{T
$B BP $ Rs {R h$ Y IR{$}$B $% Ak Y }I${s qY {B % $B R
B% $ }I${s$B BP sjj RR s ZRPZj s I {s}Z Y bBjI AZ IB B I
B A $88ZsAj Yk {s {Ys $P Y$ ZRR RB b$RY qY$R $R B Y {sR BP
_kYsBsR: qYB8 s 8sY8s${sj }B}BR$$B {B R$II B A Z $%Rsj s I
$8jRR s jsR $ Y s}}B}$s YB${sj Ps8bB,
3B %sZ }I${sR Y {B R RZR BP Y {B88Z $k $R -8jk $8}Bs $
s$AZ$ 8s $ >H y BI B A sAj B , Bb Ys Y {s $ PB $R As,$
Y 8ZR A s8 Ys I $R I % YBZY Y 8sRZI bs%j YR
BP Y As,$ j$YR BP s k bB {sR Rj{I s s IB8 bBZjI IBZAjRR sj8BR
$ %s$sAjk A I$& GYs $R II $R s }s8s${ YBk BP Y ZR BP Y
bBI XI" B s $Isj YBk BP $
w
bY${Y $R sjsIk s%s$jsAj
D
_s$,Y >MH YsR I%$RI s %k s} $jjZRs$B BP Y Z$j$k BP s }s8s${ YBk
BP Y ZR BP BAR%s$B sj 8R y BR j$, Y$R V s I FBY s{Y $ Y Rs8
R{YBBj s I RYs s 4s ! Isk V }YB R FBY PB8 R{YBBj B Rsk Ys RY
YsR jP s YB8 s ABB, B jB${ RY IR PB Y - {jsRR s I {s Y }jsR
h I $ s I s, $ B Y 7$ { FBY IBR B , Bb bYs Y ABB, jBB,R j$, Y
sR,R Y bYs {BjBZ $ $R V }j$R b$Y s %sZ BAR%s$B sj }I${sU XI"
qY }BAj8 $R Ys V YsR d((( ABB,R BP bY${Y 1x( s I PB V
w
R
w
D
D
n(( I PB FBY
w
R
w
O
D
D
s I B jk 11x I PB ABY 1x s I PB V AZ B
PB FBY x I PB FBY AZ B PB V s I Ex I PB $Y BP Y8 qY$R
R$Zs$B $R }R I $ Y PBjjBb$ hZ
dE
V 7BA$ B
qY s d(( ABB,R B bY${Y V s I FBY sRR$ I$& {BjBZR AZ $ $R
sRRZ8I Ys $Y BP Y8 $R sbs BP Y$R bY V 8s,R Y JZR FBY
$R B h I Y ABB, V bs R b$Y Y RsI {BjBZ sR Y$R B jk - sj {jZ
w
Y YsR B jBB, s Y $j }s B 8s, RZ Y YsR Y $Y I ABB,
D
y$R
$ RZ{$% B {sj{Zjs Y s%s Z8A BP ABB,R Y YsR B B} $ I$&
{${Z8Rs {R
s
D
y Y sAR { BP s k $ PB8s$B s sjj sABZ Y - sj s}}ss { BP Y
ABB, $P Y $R jZ{,k $ b$jj A Y hR B Y B} R BYb$R $ b$jj A Y
jsR ! s%s Y Y b$jj Ys% B B} x((x ABB,R
A
D
yP FBY :R {B {} BP I {B$ {$IR b$Y Y Ak s sjBBZR sRB $ Y
b$jj Ys% B B} B s%s d1xx ABB,R R$ { Y$R Rs{Y b$jj A j$8$I B
1x( ABB,R
{
D
yP V :R s I FBY :R {B {}R BP I B%js} sR $R Y {sR j ZR RZ}}BR Ys
V Aj$%R Y ABB, B A $ b$Y }BAsA$j$k ( s I FBY Aj$%R $ B
A $ O b$Y Y Rs8 }BAsA$j$k FBY b$jj hR Rs{Y O s I Y $P Y
Rs{Y $R Z RZ{{RRPZj Y {B8}j8 BP O < b$jj YPB hR jBB, s
s s%s dx(x ABB,R b$Y }BAsA$j$k ( s I Y $P Y jBB,R s sjj n((
$ b$YBZ h I$ $ s s s%s nx( 8B b$Y }BAsA$j$k (d 8s,$
s B%sjj s%s BP (
dx( L (d
w
n(( L nx(
D
) 1(( ABB,R
qB RZ8 Z} FBY $R Yj}I B B R8sjj - Ak V :R jj$ Y$8 Y {BjBZ
B }BAsAj {BjBZ BP Y ABB, % YBZY Y$ {B {}R BP I IB B -s{jk
{B$ {$I y BY bBIR $P Y %sZ }I${s $R ZRI $ IBbR V :R 8RRs
b$Y s }BAsA$j$k BP RZ{{RR Ys $P $ $R B ZRIU Y Rs{Y $8 T s
}s8s${ 8sRZ j%s B Y Z$j$k BP Y 8RRs T $R R$ $h{s jk IZ{I
Ys ,R B Y $ PB8s$B {$%I
qY sAB% -s8}j RYBbR Ys Y RZ{{RR BP V :R 8RRs IBR B I} I
B Y s I FBY ABY , Bb$ }{$Rjk YBb Yk ZR Y bBI XI" B B Y$
ZRs A$ Y Rs8 $ I$& R$Zs$B R 3B h I$ Y JZRI BA`{ $ $R
RZ^{$ PB Y8 B RYs }s BP Y P $sj 8s $ BP Y bBI
qZY s I =$j$k $ 3Z99k NB${
d
qYZR $ R}$ BP %sZ }I${sR Ys%$ I$& %sjZR Y$ ZR IBR B jsI
B Y I$RsR PBBjI Ak Y {jsRR${sj {B sI${$B R
w
sjYBZY $ IBR jsI B I$^T
{Zj$R {B { $ Y }B}ss$B BP IR BP ZY YBZY sRB $ }B{RRR
y RYsjj B Ibjj B Y$R $8}Bs }B$
D
qY$ 8sRR$% ZR $ js Zs $R s
-s8}j BP %BjZ$B sk sIs}$% j$ Z$R${ AYs%$BZ $ PB{I Ak Y A hR
s&BII Ak Y s{Y$%8 BP Z IRs I$ s8B I$& }B}j bY Y
$R j$ Z$R${ {BB}s$B ]BB}s$B $ %Bj%R {B R RZR AZ {B R RZR }% R
Y Isb$ BP s RYs} Z sjsAj j$ Ab {sRR B bY${Y Y %sZ }I${s
$R s}}j${sAj s I {sRR B bY${Y $ $R B s}}j${sAj
7{$ { %YjRR sR}$R B }B%$I BA`{$% , BbjI s I RB BB IBR s
PB8sj YBk BP }B}BR$$B R b$Y %sZ 8s $ R RZ{Y sR PZ99k jB${ <Bb {s
s,I ZY bY${Y B&R BA`{$%$k A {B {$jI b$Y Z$j$k bY${Y RRRR Y
$8}Bs { BP %sZ RR $ {B88Z ${s$B 2 y RYsjj Bb s8} B {B88 Y$R
JZR$B
; 3$ sj 4-$B R
pB$ As{, B 7B$R bYs bBZjI `ZR$Pk s R { A$ sRR$ I B I BP
ZY s I B s BY sj8BR $ I$R$ Z$RYsAj PB8 Y hR2 VR BI sAB% $
{BZjI A sZI Ys Y {YB${ BP Y PB8 I BP ZY YsR }B%I ZRPZj PB
Y JZ$I }Z}BRR s I B IZ{$B $ Z$j$k bBZjI RZj PB8 }js{$ $ Ak
Y js
V s}}Bs{Y AsRI B Z$j$k sjjBbR Y %sjZ BP s R { B A }R I
$ 8Zj$}j bskR s Y s :R {B % $ { b$YBZ Y $ %$sAjk s$R$ s
{B sI${$B Ys sABR {B88Z ${s$B sR bBZjI B{{Z $P Y %sjZ b sI
sR Y s$B BP s 8$ $8sjjk I$& B V $ }s$B BP Y R8s ${R BP
PZ99k jB${ $ 8R BP Z$j$k YZR s&BIR Y YB$R RB8 PIB8 $ 8BIjj$
}BAj8R s I Y$R sIs}sA$j$k B R}{$h{ {B -R $R B BP Y ,k Ps{BR $
$R RZ{{RR >xH Z s Y Rs8 $8 $ 8sk A s -{ZR PB s%B$I$ }BRR$Aj
PZs$B R 7$ { s&s$R s Isj b$Y $ }s$sj RZA`{$% R{ s$BR $ 8s k
{sRR $ $R I$^{Zj B jj bYY s }B}BRsj $R Y AR RBjZ$B B % s BBI
B y RB8 {sRR Y }BAj8 8sk B Ys% A 8BIjjI sR bjj sR $ 8$Y
YBZY Y {B -Zsj$k 8s,R $ I$^{Zj B }B% Y {B sk
3j-$A$j$k $R Z IBZAIjk ZRPZj AZ s}}sR B A $ {B8}s$Aj b$Y Y $BZ
Ys PB8sj js ZsR s RZ}}BRI B }BRRRR y bBZjI YPB A IR$sAj B
R, s {s$ BA`{$%$k $ Y Z I $sAj Z$j$k B&I Ak PZ99k jB${ Z IRBBI
sR s jB${ BP sRR$B R qY$R BA`{$%$k $R ZRZsjjk }B%$II Ak s jB${sj {$$B
y Ys% sjsIk BI Ys $P Y ZR b$RYR B Ys% s jB${sj AsR$R PB Y ZR BP
IR BP ZY Y$ sRR$ 8 8ZR A Z $JZ s I {B { Z $JZ P R y
Y$R {sR
w
s I js%$ B B R$I Y I$^{Zjk BP {B RZ{$ s j$R BP R {R
D
$ bBZjI A }B} B {js$8 Y %sj$I$k BP Y qTR{Y8s PB s %sZ sZsj js T
Zs Z $P Ys b RB Y JZ$%sj { Ys Y qTR{Y8s JZ$R Ab
8sjs Zs s I BA`{ js Zs {BZjI B jk A RZARs $sI Ak {js$Pk$ Y
Rs BP Y$ R PI B Ak s R { {B s$ $ %sZ }I${sR $ Ak jZ{$T
Is$ Y B$B BP %sZ BA`{ yP Ys b s{Y$%I b bBZjI Ys% s }{$R