Full text
Vol.:(0123456789)
SN Applied Sciences (2021) 3:114 | h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s42452-020-04066-2
Resea ch A icle
De ail in es iga ion o he moelec ic pe o mance andmagne ic
p ope ies o Cs-doped Bi2S 2Co2Oy ce amic ma e ials
B.Özçelik1 · M.Gü sul1· G.Çe in1· C.Özçelik2· M.A.To es3· M.A.Mad e3· A.So elo3
Recei ed: 8 Sep embe 2020 / Accep ed: 22 Decembe 2020
© The Au ho (s) 2021 OPEN
Abs ac
Bi2S 2−xCsxCo2Oy ma e ials wi h 0 ≤ x ≤ 0.15, ha e been ab ica ed ia he classical ce amic echnique. XRD esul s ha e
indica ed ha undoped and Cs-subs i u ed samples a e composed o Bi2S 2Co2Oy phase as he majo one. Mic os uc u al
s udies ha e demons a ed he o ma ion o a liquid phase, which allows a d as ic g ain g ow h. This ac o is esponsible
o a d as ic imp o emen o ela i e densi y, eaching abou 95% o he heo e ical one o 0.125 Cs con en . On he
o he hand, elec ical esis i i y has been educed up o 14 mΩ cm a 650°C o 0.125 Cs con en , a ound 40% lowe han
he ob ained in undoped samples. As a consequence, Seebeck coe icien has been dec eased due o he aise in cha ge
ca ie concen a ion. The highes powe ac o a 650°C (0.21 mW/K2 m) has been ound o 0.125 Cs subs i u ed sample,
abou 40% la ge han he ob ained in undoped samples, and e y simila o he no i ied in single c ys als (0.26 mW/K2
m). Magne isa ion wi h espec o empe a u e esul s ha e demons a ed ha measu ed samples ha e a pa amagne ic
p ope y abo e 50K, excep 0.10 Cs. Magne ic hys e esis cu es ha e shown ha he slopes and he magni udes ha e
inc eased wi h dec easing empe a u e.
Keywo ds Bi2S 2Co2Oy· Elec ical p ope ies· Seebeck coe icien · Powe ac o · Laye ed cobal i es
1 In oduc ion
Since he es ablishmen o undamen al equa ions o
explain he moelec ic (TE) phenomena [1, 2], many di -
e en amilies o TE ma e ials ha e been disco e ed [3–5].
Nowadays, he mos a ac ing cha ac e is ic o hese
ma e ials is hei abili y o di ec ly ans o m, wi hou
he need o mo ing pa s, hea in o elec ic powe [6].
The ma e ial e iciency o pe o m his p ocess can be
e alua ed h ough he dimensionless ZT (Figu e o Me i )
ob ained om [7]: (ZT = S2σT/κ), whe e S, σ, T, and κ, a e
Seebeck coe icien , elec ical conduc i i y, absolu e em-
pe a u e, and he mal conduc i i y, espec i ely. Mo eo-
e , he S2σ ac o , ep esen ing he elec ical pa in his
exp ession is known as he TE Powe Fac o , PF.
Usually, i is conside ed ha TE ma e ials o p ac ical
applica ions should p esen ZT ≥ 1. Recen ly, he la ges
ZT alues ha e been ob ained in in e me allic ma e ials,
as PbTeSe [3]. On he o he hand, hese ma e ials show
limi ed wo king empe a u es due o oxida ion a high
empe a u e unde ai , e y expensi e cos s [6], and less
plen y in he ea h c us [8]. Howe e , in spi e o he majo
abundance o silicon in he ea h c us [8], he bes pe o -
mances a e ob ained in high cos s ma e ials [6]. The dis-
co e y o high TE p ope ies in oxide ma e ials [5], which
combine high wo king empe a u es, low cos s and ela-
i ely high abundance in he ea h c us [6, 8], opened a
b oad esea ch ield. Following his disco e y, and p o-
ided by he impo an ad an ages o oxides, new ma e-
ials wi h a ac i e TE p ope ies, such as Bi2S 2Co1.8Ox [9],
* B. Özçelik, oz[email p o ec ed] | 1Depa men o Physics, Facul y o Sciences andLe e s, Çuku o a Uni e si y, 01330Adana,
Tu key. 2Ins i u e o Enginee ing andSciences, Iskende un Technical Uni e si y, Ha ay, Tu key. 3Dp o. de Ciencia de Ma e iales, ICMA
(CSIC-Uni e sidad de Za agoza), C/Ma ía de Luna 3, 50018Sa agossa, Spain.
Vol:.(1234567890)
Resea ch A icle SN Applied Sciences (2021) 3:114 | h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s42452-020-04066-2
we e also ound. Mo eo e , he in e es in hese ma e i-
als g ew when ZT o 1.2 in Bi2S 2Co1.8Ox whiske s was
achie ed [10]. Howe e , in spi e o he many wo ks pub-
lished on TE oxides, bulk polyc ys alline ma e ials canno
each hese ZT alues, being usually much lowe han 1. As
a consequence, one o he main objec i es o esea che s
is enhancing hei TE pe o mances o be used in p ac i-
cal applica ions. Among he la ge numbe o app oaches
pe o med o enhance he TE p ope ies o hese oxides, i
can be highligh ed he use o we -syn hesis me hods [11,
12], ex u ing [13, 14], and doping [15, 16].
The s udies pe o med on TE oxides o he CoO amily
ha e allowed o de e mine ha he subs i u ion o any ca -
ion o he Rock Sal laye by a lowe oxida ion one, leads o
an inc ease o cha ge ca ie concen a ion due o he pa -
ial p omo ion o Co3+ ca ions o Co4+ in he conduc ing
laye [17], which induces a dec ease o Seebeck coe icien
[18]. This e ec can be p oduced by alkaline ea h sub-
s i u ion in he s uc u e by an alkaline elemen , leading
o impo an mic os uc u al and elec ical modi ica ions,
as demons a ed in p e ious wo ks [19, 20]. The e o e,
we aim o de e mine he e ec o a la ge alkaline ca ion
(Cs) pa ial subs i u ion in he alkaline ea h posi ion o
Bi2S 2Co2Oy he moelec ic compound. The s uc u al and
mic os uc u al changes induced by his subs i u ion will
be de e mined and linked o he modi ica ions o elec ical
p ope ies in classically sin e ed ma e ials.
2 Expe imen al
Cs-doped Bi2S 2−xCsxCo2Oy p ecu so s, wi h 0 ≤ x ≤ 0.15,
ha e been p epa ed, h ough he classical ce amic
me hod, using comme cial Bi2O3 (98+ %, Pan eac), S CO3
(98.5%, Pan eac), CoO (99.99%, Sigma-Ald ich), and
Cs2CO3 (99.8%, Pan eac) powde s as s a ing ma e ials.
A e weighing hem in he app op ia e p opo ions, hey
we e well mixed and subjec ed o ball milling, using wa e
media, a 300 pm o 30min. The p oduced slip was sub-
sequen ly d ied and hea ed o decompose he ca bon-
a es using a wo-s ep p ocess: 750°C o 12h, and 800°C
o 12h, wi h an in e media e manual milling. Finally, he
powde s we e uniaxially p essed in o pelle s (2 × 2 × 14
mm3) unde 400MPa applied p essu e, and sin e ed a
810°C o 24h and u nace cooled.
Powde X- ay di ac ion (XRD) pa e ns we e ob ained
in a Rigaku D/max-B X- ay powde di ac ome e wo k-
ing wi h Cu Kα adia ion, and ixing 2θ be ween 10 and
40 deg ees, in o de o iden i y he phases in he ex u ed
ma e ials. Mic os uc u al cha ac e iza ion has been
made in a Zeiss–Me lin ield emission scanning elec on
mic oscope (FESEM) associa ed o an ene gy-dispe si e
spec oscopy (EDS) sys em used o quali a i e elemen al
analysis. Samples we e analysed h ough su ace mic o-
g aphs o de e mine mic os uc u al modi ica ions
induced by Cs doping. Mo eo e , densi y o ma e ials has
been ob ained by A chimedes’ me hod in se e al speci-
mens o each composi ion o minimize e o s.
Elec ical p ope ies o he di e en samples we e
de e mined h ough simul aneous measu emen o
Seebeck coe icien and elec ical esis i i y using he
well-known di ec cu en ou -p obe con igu a ion in a
LSR-3 sys em (Linseis GmbH). These p ope ies ha e been
ob ained unde s eady-s a e condi ions be ween 50 and
650°C using He a mosphe e. Elec ical pe o mance o
samples, PF, was calcula ed using hese da a. Finally, he
magne ic p ope ies we e measu ed by using a PPMS sys-
em (Dynecool PPMS, Quan um Design). The magne ic
hys e esis da a we e aken in be ween—5 o 5T, and he
magne iza ion measu emen s we e ob ained in ZFC mode
unde a DC- ield o 20 Oe, om 300K down o 5K.
3 Resul s anddiscussion
Rep esen a i e XRD pa e ns ob ained on g inded
Bi2S 2−xCsxCo2Oy ma e ials a e p esen ed in Fig.1. In his
g aph, i may be easily deduced ha mos o he peaks
(indica ed by hei di ac ion planes) can be associa ed
o he Bi2S 2Co2Oy phase, being he majo one, which is
Fig. 1 Rep esen a i e powde X- ay di ac ion pa e ns o
Bi2S 2−xCsxCo2Oy samples; o x = (a) 0; (b) 0.025; (c) 0.075; and
(d) 0.125. Di ac ion planes show he peaks associa ed o he TE
phase, while * iden i ies he co esponding o he Bi–S –O phase
Vol.:(0123456789)
SN Applied Sciences (2021) 3:114 | h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s42452-020-04066-2 Resea ch A icle
consis en wi h li e a u e [21]. Mo eo e , he * shows he
Co- ee seconda y phase [22], which is p esen in e y
small p opo ions. Consequen ly, i can be easily deduced
ha all samples a e o med by nea ly single Bi2S 2Co2Oy
phase. On he o he hand, in compa ison o undoped sam-
ples, e y small shi in he di ac ion peaks o Cs-doped
samples has been ound, esul ing om highe ionic adius
o Cs. In addi ion, no Cs-based seconda y phases ha e
been obse ed.
Figu e2 displays ep esen a i e SEM mic og aphs pe -
o med on he su ace o Bi2S 2−xCsxCo2Oy samples. F om
hese mic og aphs, i is easy o obse e a d as ic g ain
g ow h and dec ease o po osi y when he amoun o Cs
is inc eased. This e olu ion can be associa ed o he o ma-
ion o a liquid phase induced by he alkaline ca ion, which
can be due o he low mel ing poin o Cs2CO3 (793°C
[23]), in ag eemen wi h p e ious s udies on simila com-
pounds [24]. Up o 0.05 Cs subs i u ion (Fig.2b), he g ain
sizes a e only sligh ly la ge han in pu e samples (Fig.2a).
On he o he hand, highe Cs addi ions lead o much la ge
g ains, indica ing he p esence o a la ge amoun o liq-
uid phase along he g ain bounda ies, which enhances
ca ions mobili y. This e ec , and he sys em endency o
dec ease su ace ene gy, a e he esponsible pa ame e s
o inc easing g ain sizes. On he o he hand, ano he
impo an mic os uc u al modi ica ion is he appea -
ance, besides he g ey con as (#1, associa ed h ough
EDS o he he moelec ic Bi2S 2Co2Oy phase), o a ligh
g ey one (#2, co esponding o he Bi–S –O phase) when
Cs is added o he samples. Finally, o he highes Cs con-
aining samples, a black con as can be ound (#3), wi h
Co-oxide composi ion. On he o he hand, Cs doping leads
o a sligh Ca2+ by Cs+ subs i u ion, ound by EDS analysis
o he he moelec ic phase in se e al samples o each Cs
subs i u ion. The EDS esul s ha e shown ha he subs i-
u ing Cs amoun co esponds o, app oxima ely, one hal
o he nominal one in he inne pa o he samples, while
i is ha dly de ec ed in he su ace o samples. Mo eo e ,
no Cs has been iden i ied in any o he seconda y phases.
These da a clea ly ag ee wi h p e ious obse a ions in
simila compounds [24].
In o de o de e mine he e ec o his liquid phase in
he sin e ing p ocess, densi y measu emen s ha e been
pe o med using A chimedes’ me hod and he esul s a e
p esen ed, as a unc ion o nominal Cs con en , in Fig.3. As
i can be obse ed in he g aph, undoped samples display
he lowes densi ies, 5.45g/cm3, which a e abou 80% o
he heo e ical one ( aking heo e ical densi y as 6.8g/cm3
[25]). When Cs is added, ela i e densi y mono onically
inc eases wi h Cs con en up o a ound 95% o 0.125 Cs
Fig. 2 Rep esen a i e SEM mic og aphs pe o med on su aces o Bi2S 2−xCsxCo2Oy samples, wi h x = a 0; b 0.05; c 0.1; and d 0.15. G ey con-
as (#1) co esponds o he he moelec ic phase, ligh g ey (#2) o he Co- ee one (Bi–S –O), and black one (#3) o Co-oxide
Vol:.(1234567890)
Resea ch A icle SN Applied Sciences (2021) 3:114 | h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s42452-020-04066-2
samples, sligh ly dec easing o highe Cs amoun s. These
da a clea ly con i m he d as ic dec ease o po osi y when
Cs is added, eaching alues compa able o he epo ed
o ho -p essed o mel -g own ma e ials (96, and 97%,
espec i ely) [25, 26], and only lowe han he epo ed
in pa ially mel ed ma e ials wi h subsequen ho -p ess-
ing p ocess (a ound 99%) [25]. Fu he mo e, i should be
highligh ed ha hese e y high densi y alues ha e been
ob ained h ough a e y simple and sho p ocess, when
compa ed o hose p e iously men ioned in li e a u e.
Elec ical esis i i y a ia ions o all samples wi h em-
pe a u e, as a unc ion o Cs con en , a e shown in Fig.4.
As can be seen in he plo , he gene al sample’s beha -
iou is signi ican ly changed by Cs subs i u ion; i is semi-
conduc ing (dρ/dT < 0) o he pu e and 0.025 Cs samples
(much less e iden o hese las samples), while highe
Cs subs i u ion leads o me allic (dρ/dT > 0) one. Mo eo-
e , he inc ease o Cs subs i u ion leads o lowe elec i-
cal esis i i y alues han he measu ed in undoped ones.
This e olu ion is in ag eemen wi h he S 2+ subs i u ion
by Cs+, which dec eases he oxida ion s a e o he ock
sal s uc u e, p omo ing he Co3+ in he conduc ing laye
o Co4+. Consequen ly, he cha ge ca ie concen a ion
(holes), a e inc eased, dec easing elec ical esis i i y. On
he o he hand, he inc ease de e mined in he 0.15 Cs
subs i u ed samples can be associa ed o he aise in he
numbe o de ec s, which is esponsible o hei highe
elec ical esis i i y alues. O he a ou able e ec s o
his dec ease in elec ical esis i i y a e he aise in den-
si y, and he impo an g ain g ow h, which dec eases
he numbe o g ain bounda ies in he bulk ma e ial. The
lowes esis i i y alues a 650°C (14 mΩ cm) ha e been
de e mined in 0.125 Cs subs i u ed samples, abou 40%
lowe han hose ob ained in undoped samples in his
wo k. Mo eo e , hey a e much lowe han he epo ed
in ex u ed ma e ials ia ho p essing (40 mΩ cm [27]), o
lase p ocessing (20 mΩ cm [13]), while hey a e close o
hose ob ained in sin e ed ma e ials unde oxygen (15
mΩ cm [28]), o in single c ys als (18 mΩ cm a oom em-
pe a u e [29], and 10 mΩ cm a 600°C [16]). These esul s
clea ly ag ee wi h he d as ic enhancemen o g ain sizes,
dec ease o po osi y and, p obably, he imp o emen o
g ains elec ical connec i i y, p oduced by Cs subs i u ion.
The endency obse ed in elec ical esis i i y wi h Cs
subs i u ion may be due o he modi ica ion o mic o-
s uc u e and elec onic pa ame e s. Howe e , mo e in o -
ma ion and expe imen al wo k is necessa y o p ecisely
de e mine and explain his e olu ion. The e o e, in o de
o be e unde s and he mechanism o esis i i y, he
small pola on hopping model [30] has been used hough
he ollowing ela ion:
whe e A, n, e, x, Ea, kB, and T a e he p e-exponen ial
e m ela ed o he sca e ing mechanism, ca ie concen-
a ion, elemen a y cha ge, in e si e hopping dis ance,
(2)
𝜌(T)=(T
Anex2)exp (Ea
kBT)
Fig. 3 E olu ion o Bi2S 2−xCsxCo2Oy samples densi y, oge he wi h
i s s anda d e o , as a unc ion o nominal Cs con en Fig. 4 Elec ical esis i i y e olu ion wi h empe a u e o
Bi2S 2−xCsxCo2Oy samples. The inse shows he linea i s o ln(ρ/T)
e sus 1000/T o all samples
Vol.:(0123456789)
SN Applied Sciences (2021) 3:114 | h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s42452-020-04066-2 Resea ch A icle
pola on ac i a ion ene gy, Bol zmann cons an and abso-
lu e empe a u e, espec i ely. As i is shown in he inse o
Fig.4, he linea ela ionship o ln(ρ/T) wi h espec o 1/T
abo e 500K i s well wi h he pola on hopping model o
elec ical esis i i ies o all samples. In o de o calcula e
he ac i a ion ene gies o samples, he slopes o s aigh
lines ha e been used, and he calcula ed alues o he
pu e, 0.025, 0.050, 0.075, 0.10, 0.125, and 0.15 samples a e
165.62, 59.21, 33.20, 25.80, 27.21, 26.60, and 25.72meV,
espec i ely. Acco ding o hese alues, he Ea alues o
undoped samples a e much highe han he de e mined in
Cs doped ones. Ini ially, he alues d as ically dec ease up
o 0.05 Cs, emaining p ac ically cons an o highe dop-
ing. The hopping o cha ge ca ie s akes place be ween
Co3+ and Co4+ in he CoO2 laye o BiS CoO sys em. The e-
o e, he a io be ween Co3+ and Co4+ di ec ly in luences
he hopping dis ance, x. The dec ease o his a io sugges s
an inc emen o Co4+ concen a ion due o Cs subs i u-
ion, educing he hopping dis ance. This ac also leads
o he dec ease o hopping ac i a ion ene gy. This esul
suppo s he a gumen ha he Co3+ is p omo ed o Co4+
in he conduc ing laye , as discussed abo e.
Figu e5 illus a es Seebeck coe icien a ia ion wi h
empe a u e, and Cs subs i u ion. In he g aph, i can be
obse ed ha all alues a e posi i e in he whole meas-
u ed empe a u e ange, which is cha ac e is ic o hole-
domina ing anspo mechanism. A oom empe a u e,
he Seebeck coe icien is dec eased in Cs subs i u ed
samples, when compa ed o he undoped ones. This is
in ag eemen wi h Koshibae’s exp ession [18], which
indica es ha he inc ease o Co4+ p opo ion in he
conduc ion band leads o a educ ion o Seebeck coe -
icien . Howe e , oom empe a u e Seebeck coe icien
alues a e only sligh ly modi ied in he Cs doped samples,
which could be in e p e ed as a close Cs con en in all
doped samples, when compa ed o he nominal compo-
si ion. This ac could also explain he ac ha lowe Cs
con en han he nominal one has been ound by EDS in
he samples, as obse ed in p e ious wo ks [24]. The high-
es S alues a 650°C (195μV/K) ha e been measu ed in
undoped samples, a ound 10% highe han hose meas-
u ed in Cs subs i u ed samples in his s udy. These alues
a e la ge han hose in o med in ho -p essed samples
(~150μV/K) [27], o single c ys als (160μV/K) [16], and
close o hose de e mined in sin e ed samples ob ained
by so chemis y ou es (205μV/K) [31].
Using elec ical esis i i y and Seebeck coe icien al-
ues p e iously p esen ed, PF e olu ion wi h empe a u e,
and Cs subs i u ion, has been calcula ed and p esen ed in
Fig.6. As i can be seen in he plo , in spi e o hei lowe
Seebeck coe icien alues, Cs subs i u ed samples display
highe PF alues han he undoped ones. Mo eo e , PF is
inc eased wi h empe a u e in he whole measu ed em-
pe a u e ange, and wi h Cs con en up o 0.125, sligh ly
dec easing o highe con en . The highes PF alues a
650°C (~0.20 mW/K2 m) ha e been ob ained in 0.125
Cs subs i u ed samples, which a e a ound 40% highe
han hose de e mined in undoped samples in his wo k.
Mo eo e , hey a e much la ge han he p esen ed in
ho -p essed samples (0.06 mW/K2 m) [27], and simila o
he ob ained in ce amics p epa ed h ough so chemis-
y ou es (0.20 mW/K2 m) [31], a he same empe a u e.
Fig. 5 Seebeck coe icien e olu ion wi h empe a u e o
Bi2S 2−xCsxCo2Oy samples
Fig. 6 Powe ac o e olu ion wi h empe a u e o
Bi2S 2−xCsxCo2Oy samples
Vol:.(1234567890)
Resea ch A icle SN Applied Sciences (2021) 3:114 | h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s42452-020-04066-2
Howe e , hey a e s ill sligh ly lowe han he bes epo ed
esul s in single c ys als (0.26 mW/K2 m) [16], due o he
absence o g ain bounda ies.
The moelec ic appa a us di ec ly con e s a empe a-
u e g adien in o elec ici y called as he Seebeck e ec ,
while he e e se coun e pa is he he moelec ic cooling
phenomenon named as Pel ie e ec . As i is known, he
magne ic cooling is based on he Magne o Calo ic E ec
(MCE) and i is p omisingly applicable on e ige a ion sys-
ems. Hence, o he po en ial payo , i is necessa y o p o-
duce and op imize new he moelec ic ma e ials, which
can be sui able o ope a ion o e wide low empe a u e
anges. Since he he moelec ic pa ame e s like Seebeck
coe icien , powe ac o and o he s a e e y sensi i e o
he small a ia ion o he ex e nal applied magne ic ield,
he magne ic cha ac e iza ion can be e y impo an issue
o p esen new candida e samples o he moelec ic-
cooling applica ions. The e o e, he samples we e in es-
iga ed om he magne ic poin o iew. Fo his pu pose,
he empe a u e and ield dependen magne iza ion, and
hys e esis cu es o all samples ha e been de e mined.
In Fig.7 he magne iza ion o all samples wi h espec
o empe a u e down o 10K, measu ed in ze o- ield
cooled mode, unde 20 Oe ex e nal applied magne ic
ield, a e p esen ed. As i can be seen in his igu e, e y
simila magne ic p ope ies ha e been de e mined in all
samples, i.e. magne iza ion o samples sha ply dec eases
om 5K up o 25K, and hen slowly dec eases, excep o
0.1 Cs ones. Acco ding o he Cu ie–Weiss law, in he high
empe a u e egion, he da a o each sample should be i -
ed o a s aigh line by plo ing in e se suscep ibili y (1/χ)
wi h espec o empe a u e, T, as gi en in inse o Fig.7,
o he 0.05 Cs samples. By ex apola ing he high-T pa o
he cu es (1/χ ĺ 0), nega i e pa amagne ic empe a u es,
θ, we e ob ained o he pu e (≈−60K), 0.05 (≈−50K), and
0.075 (≈−15K), samples. Consequen ly, an i e omagne ic
luc ua ions a e p e ailing in hese samples. Howe e , o
Cs subs i u ion ≥ 0.10, he (T) cu es exhibi a shallow
maximum a a ound 150 K. This e ec may be a ibu ed
o an an i e omagne ic s a e p omo ed by his highe
Cs-con en .
The Cu ie cons an s o all samples ha e been calcula ed
om he slope o he 1/ e sus T cu es, being a ound
≈3 × 10–3 emu K/g. The e ec i e magne ic momen s, μe ,
o undoped, 0.05 Cs, 0.075 Cs and 0.1 Cs samples ha e
been calcula ed by using he equa ion gi en in [32], as
2.40μB, 2.35μB, 1.25μB, and 3.83μB, espec i ely.
The M–H cu es, measu ed a 15K o he undoped and
Cs-doped samples ha e been plo ed in Fig.8. No hys e -
esis beha io can be obse ed in hese cu es, demon-
s a ing ha he pa amagne ic phase is s ill dominan a
empe a u es ≥15K. In addi ion, he slopes a e inc eased
when he Cs-con en is highe . I is necessa y o highligh
ha he linea ield dependence o magne iza ion poin s
o a no mal canonical pa amagne ic o de in connec ion
wi h he applied magne ic ield.
The empe a u e dependence o magne ic hys e esis
has been also in es iga ed, and he esul s a e p esen ed
in Fig.9. Since he gene al beha io o undoped and Cs-
doped samples is he same o Cs con en up o 0.10, o
he sake o cla i y, only he esul s ob ained in 0.05 Cs and
0.10 Cs samples a e shown. In he igu e, i can be seen
ha he slopes and he magni ude o magne iza ion is
dec eased when he empe a u e is inc eased o samples
wi h Cs con en ≤ 0.10. I can be a gued ha when empe -
a u e dec eases, he magne ic momen s in andom di ec-
ions a e a ec ed by inc easing ex e nal applied magne ic
Fig. 7 DC-magne iza ion o pu e and 0.05 Cs, 0.075 Cs, and 0.10 Cs.
The inse shows he in e se DC-magne ic suscep ibili y cu es o
he 0.05 Cs doped samples measu ed a 20 Oe
Fig. 8 Hys e esis cu es o he pu e and 0.05 Cs, 0.075 Cs, and 0.10
Cs samples a measu ed 15K
Vol.:(0123456789)
SN Applied Sciences (2021) 3:114 | h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s42452-020-04066-2 Resea ch A icle
ield. Then, all he spins in andom di ec ions a e o ien ed
he di ec ion o ex e nal applied magne ic ield. Hence,
he magne iza ion alues s a o inc ease wi h dec easing
empe a u e alues.
As a esul , when conside ing all hese esul s, i may
be concluded ha Cs-doping is e y use ul o imp o ing
he he moelec ic p ope ies o Bi2S 2Co2Oy ma e ials. An
impo an inc ease in powe ac o , PF, ob ained in his
wo k using a simple p epa a ion p ocess, leads o conside
hese ce amic ma e ials as e y p omising candida es o
hei in eg a ion in p ac ical he moelec ic de ices.
4 Conclusions
Bulk sin e ed Bi2S 2−xCsxCo2Oy (0 ≤ x ≤ 0.15) he moelec ic
ce amics ha e been success ully ab ica ed ia he clas-
sical ce amic p epa a ion echnique. I has been ound
ha Cs subs i u ion has led o he o ma ion o a liquid
phase du ing sin e ing p ocedu e, d as ically enhancing
g ain g ow h and dec easing po osi y. On he o he hand,
his g ain g ow h is accompanied by he o ma ion o a Co
poo egion close o he g ain bounda ies. These mic o-
s uc u al modi ica ions ha e been e lec ed in a d as ic
inc ease o ela i e densi y, eaching alues o abou 95%
o he heo e ical one. Mo eo e , elec ical esis i i y is
dec eased wi h Cs doping, due o he inc ease in cha ge
ca ie concen a ion, which has been con i med by he
dec ease o Seebeck coe icien when compa ed o he
undoped samples. Fu he mo e, he inc ease o elec ical
esis i i y in 0.125 Cs samples is associa ed o he aise o
de ec s which ac as elec onic sca e ing cen e s. All hese
cha ac e is ics led o high powe ac o alues in Cs sub-
s i u ed samples, which makes hem p omising ce amic
ma e ials o p ac ical applica ions.
On he o he hand, magne ic p ope ies do no e lec
hese imp o emen s since Cs-addi ion is andomly in lu-
encing hem.
Acknowledgemen s This s udy was ca ied ou wi hin he scope o
Cuku o a Uni e si y Scien i ic Resea ch P ojec s Uni FBA-2020-
13007 and FBA-2020-12784. The au ho s wish o hank he Spanish
MINECO-FEDER (MAT2017-82183-C3-1-R), and Gobie no de A agón
(Resea ch G oup T 54-17 R) o unding. The au ho s wish o acknowl-
edge he use o Se icio Gene al de Apoyo a la In es igación-SAI,
Uni e sidad de Za agoza.
Compliance wi h e hical s anda ds
Con lic o in e es The au ho s decla e ha hey ha e no con lic o
in e es .
Open Access This a icle is licensed unde a C ea i e Commons A i-
bu ion 4.0 In e na ional License, which pe mi s use, sha ing, adap-
a ion, dis ibu ion and ep oduc ion in any medium o o ma , as
long as you gi e app op ia e c edi o he o iginal au ho (s) and he
sou ce, p o ide a link o he C ea i e Commons licence, and indica e
i changes we e made. The images o o he hi d pa y ma e ial in his
a icle a e included in he a icle’s C ea i e Commons licence, unless
indica ed o he wise in a c edi line o he ma e ial. I ma e ial is no
included in he a icle’s C ea i e Commons licence and you in ended
use is no pe mi ed by s a u o y egula ion o exceeds he pe mi ed
use, you will need o ob ain pe mission di ec ly om he copy igh
holde . To iew a copy o his licence, isi h p://c ea i eco mmons
.o g/licen ses/by/4.0/.
Re e ences
1. Al enki ch E (1909) Ube den Nu ze eck de The mosaule. Phys
Z 10(16):560–568
2. Al enki ch E (1911) Elec o he mische Kal ee zeugung und
e e sible elec ische Heizung. Phys Z 12:920–924
3. Fu T, Yue X, Wu H, Fu C, Zhu T, Liu X, Hu L, Ying P, He J, Zhao
X (2016) Enhanced he moelec ic pe o mance o PbTe bulk
ma e ials wi h igu e o me i zT > 2 by mul i- unc ional alloying.
J Ma e iomics 2:141–149
Fig. 9 Hys e esis cu es o he a 0.05 Cs, b 0.10 Cs doped samples
measu ed a 15, 30, and 45K
Vol:.(1234567890)
Resea ch A icle SN Applied Sciences (2021) 3:114 | h ps://doi.o g/10.1007/s42452-020-04066-2
4. Niki in E (1958) In es iga ion on empe a u e dependencies o
elec ical conduc i i y and he mopowe o silicides. Zhu nal
Tekhnicheskoj Fiziki 28:23–25
5. Te asaki I, Sasago Y, Uchinoku a K (1997) La ge he moelec ic
powe in NaCo2O4 single c ys als. Phys Re B 56:12685–12687
6. LeBlanc S (2014) The moelec ic gene a o s: linking ma e ial
p ope ies and sys ems enginee ing o was e hea eco e y
applica ions. Sus Ma e Technol 1–2:26–35
7. Rowe DM (eds) (2006) The moelec ics handbook: mac o o
nano, 1s edn. CRC P ess, Boca Ra on
8. He J, Liu Y, Funahashi R (2011) Oxide he moelec ics: he chal-
lenges, p og ess, and ou look. J Ma e Res 26:1762–1772
9. Funahashi R, Ma suba a I, Sodeoka S (2000) The moelec ic
p ope ies o Bi2S 2Co2Ox polyc ys alline ma e ials. Appl Phys
Le 76:2385–2387
10. Funahashi R, Shikano M (2002) Bi2S 2Co2Oy whiske s wi h high
he moelec ic igu e o me i . Appl Phys Le 81:1459
11. So elo A, Rasekh Sh, To es MA, Bosque P, Mad e MA, Diez JC
(2015) E ec o syn hesis me hods on he Ca3Co4O9 he mo-
elec ic ce amic pe o mances. J Solid S a e Chem 221:247–254
12. Wu NY, Holga e TC, Nong NV, P yds N, Linde o h S (2014) High
empe a u e he moelec ic p ope ies o Ca3Co4O9+δ by au o-
combus ion syn hesis and spa k plasma sin e ing. J Eu Ce am
Soc 34:925–931
13. Rasekh Sh, Cos a FM, Fe ei a NM, To es MA, Mad e MA, Diez JC,
So elo A (2015) Use o lase echnology o p oduce high he -
moelec ic pe o mances in Bi2S 2Co1.8Ox. Ma e Des 75:143–148
14. Wang H, Sun X, Yan X, Huo D, Li X, Li J-G, Ding X (2014) Fab-
ica ion and he moelec ic p ope ies o highly ex u ed
Ca9Co12O28 ce amic. J Alloy Compd 582:294–298
15. Xu GJ, Funahashi R, Shikano M, Ma suba a I, Zhou YQ (2002)
The moelec ic p ope ies o Bi2.2−xPbxS 2Co2Oy sys em. J Appl
Phys 91:4344–4347
16. Sun N, Dong ST, Zhang BB, Chen YB, Zhou J, Zhang ST, Gu ZB, Yao
SH, Chen YF (2013) In insically modi ied he moelec ic pe -
o mance o alkaline-ea h iso alen ly subs i u ed [Bi2AE2O4]
[CoO2]y single c ys als. J Appl Phys 114:043705
17. Maignan A, Pelloquin D, Hebe S, Klein Y, He ieu M (2006) The -
moelec ic powe in mis i cobal i es ce amics: op imiza ion by
chemical subs i u ions. Bol Soc Esp Ce am 45:122–125
18. Koshibae W, Tsu sui K, Maekawa S (2000) The mopowe in cobal
oxides. Phys Re B 62:6869–6872
19. Çe in Ka akaya G, Ozcelik B, Nane O, So elo A, Rasekh Sh, To es
MA, Mad e MA (2018) Imp o emen o Bi2S 2Co2Oy he moelec-
ic pe o mances by Na doping. J Elec oce am 40:11–15
20. Li Y-N, Wu P, Zhang S-P, Chen S, Yan D, Yang J-G, Wang L, Huai
X-L (2018) The moelec ic p ope ies o lowe concen a ion
K-doped Ca3Co4O9 ce amics. Chin Phys B 27:057201
21. So elo A, Rasekh Sh, Cons an inescu G, To es MA, Mad e MA,
Diez JC (2013) Imp o emen o ex u ed Bi1.6Pb0.4S 2Co1.8Ox
he moelec ic pe o mances by me allic Ag addi ions. Ce am
In 39:1597–1602
22. Me cu io D, Champa naud-Mesja d JC, F i B, Con lan P, Boi in
JC, Vog T (1994) The mal e olu ion o he c ys al-s uc u e
o he hombohed al Bi0.75S 0.25O1.375 phase—a single-c ys al
neu on-di ac ion s udy. J Solid S a e Chem 112:1–8
23. Hammond CR (2009) Handbook o physics and chemis y, 90 h
edn. CRC P ess, Boca Ra on, FL
24. So elo A, Cos a FM, Fe ei a NM, Ko ale sky A, Fe o MC, Ama al
VS, Ama al JS, Rasekh Sh, To es MA, Mad e MA, Diez JC (2016)
Tailo ing Ca3Co4O9 mic os uc u e and pe o mances using
a ansien liquid phase sin e ing addi i e. J Eu Ce am Soc
36:1025–1032
25. Combe E, Funahashi R, Ba bie T, Azough F, F ee R (2016)
Dec eased he mal conduc i i y in Bi2S 2Co2Ox bulk ma e ials
p epa ed by pa ial mel ing. J Ma e Res 31:1296–1305
26. Çe in G, Özçelik B, Gu sul M, To es MA, Mad e MA, So elo A
(2020) E ec o annealing and po assium subs i u ion on he
he moelec ic and magne ic p ope ies o di ec ionally g own
Bi2S 2Co2Oy ce amics. Bol Soc Esp Ce am Vid 59:121–128
27. Shin W, Mu ayama N (2000) The moelec ic p ope ies o (Bi,
Pb)–S –Co–O oxide. J Ma e Res 15:382–386
28. I aha a H, Xia C, Sugiyama J, Tani T (2004) Fab ica ion o ex u ed
he moelec ic laye ed cobal i es wi h a ious ock sal - ype lay-
e s by using β-Co(OH)2 pla ele s as eac i e empla es. J Ma e
Chem 14:61–66
29. I oh T, Te asaki I (2000) The moelec ic p ope ies o
Bi2.3−xPbxS 2.6Co2Oy single c ys als. Jpn J Appl Phys
39:6658–6660
30. Bosman AJ, Daal HJV (1970) Small-pola on e sus band conduc-
ion in some ansi ion-me al oxides. Ad Phys 19:1
31. Mad e MA, Rasekh Sh, Diez JC, So elo A (2010) New solu ion
me hod o p oduce high pe o mance he moelec ic ce amics:
a case s udy o Bi–S –Co–O. Ma e Le 64:2566–2568
32. Çe in Ka akaya G, Özçelik B, To es MA, Mad e MA, So elo A
(2018) E ec o Na-doping on he moelec ic and magne ic
pe o mances o ex u ed Bi2S 2Co2Oy ce amics. J Eu Ce am
Soc 38:515–520
Publishe ’s No e Sp inge Na u e emains neu al wi h ega d o
ju isdic ional claims in published maps and ins i u ional a ilia ions.